{ "schemaVersion": "0.3.0", "book": { "title": "NOMOS GEO-Auditprotokoll", "seriesTitle": "Die GEO-1000-Methode", "subtitle": "Ein Protokoll zur Messung der Repräsentation von Entitäten in generativen Systemen über die Weltbevölkerung hinweg", "author": "Kaan MURAZ", "methodIdentity": "NOMOS by NobleJackal", "language": "de-DE", "version": "0.9.0", "status": "Finaler Textkandidat – deutsche redaktionelle Ausgabe", "canonicalAuthority": "Noch nicht etabliert", "benchmarkStatus": "BQ-0 – nicht durchgeführt", "demonstrationStatus": "DEMO-BQ-2 – Probelauf der Pipeline mit erheblichem Nachbesserungsbedarf", "conformityProgram": "Inaktiv", "licenseStatus": "Veröffentlichungslizenz noch nicht festgelegt" }, "notice": "Dieses Objekt gibt die englische Maschinenebene eines Kandidatenprotokolls frei. Es aktiviert keine Zertifizierung, Konformitätszeichen oder kanonische weltweite Standardbehörden.", "contentModel": { "sourceHumanLayer": "Der festgeschriebene türkische redaktionelle Master bleibt die kontrollierende Quelle für die zweisprachige Parität.", "englishHumanLayer": "Die englische redaktionelle Ausgabe ist der kontrollierende für Menschen lesbare Text für diesen englischen Veröffentlichungskandidaten.", "machineLayer": "Dieses JSON-Objekt gibt Kapitelidentität, Quellverknüpfungen, normative Regelpaare und maschinenorientierte Blöcke frei, ohne den menschlichen Text zu ersetzen.", "conflictRule": "Wenn ein Konflikt zwischen menschlicher und maschineller Ebene besteht, behandeln Sie den Maschineneintrag als ungelöst und erfordern eine verantwortliche menschliche Überprüfung gegenüber der festgeschriebenen türkischen Quelle." }, "statusAssertions": { "independentLegalEntity": false, "independentAiModel": false, "canonicalWorldStandard": false, "certificationActive": false, "conformityMarkActive": false, "bq0Executed": false, "chapter18RealWorldExperiment": false, "chapter18SyntheticDemonstration": true, "publicationLicenseDeclared": true }, "chapters": [ { "chapter": 0, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-CONSTITUTION-A0", "title": "Erklärung der Repräsentationsrechte", "subtitle": "Der verfassungsartige Kern eines vorgeschlagenen GEO-Standards", "sourceIds": [ "K20", "K22" ], "normativeRuleId": null, "normativeRuleEnglish": null, "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": null, "machineBlocksEnglish": [], "normativeRuleLocalized": null, "machineBlocksLocalized": [] }, { "chapter": 1, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH01", "title": "Eine einzelne Antwort ist kein GEO-Score", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K05", "K09" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH01-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "A single generative-system output MAY establish that a specific response occurred under recorded conditions. A single output MUST NOT be used to infer: - population prevalence, - typical product behaviour, - temporal stability, - cross-language consistency, - cross-country consistency, - cross-product consistency, - intervention effect, - recommendation certainty, - commercial impact, - conformity, - or a GEO score. All broader claims MUST be supported by a predefined target population, valid multi-observation design, recorded dependence structure, evidence bundle, evaluation rule, scope statement, and uncertainty disclosure. A single high-harm output MAY trigger a separate critical-incident review without being treated as evidence of population prevalence.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Tek bir üretken sistem çıktısı, belirli bir cevabın kaydedilmiş koşullarda oluştuğunu gösterebilir. Ancak nüfus yaygınlığı, tipik ürün davranışı, zaman kararlılığı, diller arası tutarlılık, ülkeler arası tutarlılık, AI ürünleri arası tutarlılık, müdahale etkisi, recommendation kesinliği, ticari sonuç, uygunluk veya GEO skoru çıkarmak için kullanılamaz. Tekil yüksek zararlı çıktı, nüfus yaygınlığı kanıtı sayılmadan ayrı Critical olay incelemesi başlatabilir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH01-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE READABLE BY MACHINE FOR CHAPTER 23", "sourceParagraph": 1032 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH01-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1033 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single generative-system output MAY establish that a specific response", "sourceParagraph": 1035 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "occurred under recorded conditions.", "sourceParagraph": 1036 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single output MUST NOT be used to infer:", "sourceParagraph": 1038 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- population prevalence,", "sourceParagraph": 1040 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- typical product behaviour,", "sourceParagraph": 1041 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- temporal stability,", "sourceParagraph": 1042 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- cross-language consistency,", "sourceParagraph": 1043 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- cross-country consistency,", "sourceParagraph": 1044 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- cross-product consistency,", "sourceParagraph": 1045 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- intervention effect,", "sourceParagraph": 1046 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- recommendation certainty,", "sourceParagraph": 1047 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- commercial impact,", "sourceParagraph": 1048 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- conformity,", "sourceParagraph": 1049 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- or a GEO score.", "sourceParagraph": 1050 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "All broader claims MUST be supported by a predefined target population,", "sourceParagraph": 1052 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "valid multi-observation design, recorded dependence structure, evidence", "sourceParagraph": 1053 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bundle, evaluation rule, scope statement, and uncertainty disclosure.", "sourceParagraph": 1054 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single high-harm output MAY trigger a separate critical-incident review", "sourceParagraph": 1056 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "without being treated as evidence of population prevalence.", "sourceParagraph": 1057 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1058 }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single output from a generative system can indicate that a certain response occurred under recorded conditions. However, it cannot be used to derive population prevalence, typical product behaviour, temporal stability, cross-linguistic consistency, cross-country consistency, consistency among AI products, intervention effect, recommendation certainty, commercial consequence, compliance, or GEO score. A single highly harmful output can trigger a separate Critical event review without being considered evidence of population prevalence.", "sourceParagraph": 1059 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Eine einzelne Ausgabe eines generativen Systems KANN feststellen, dass eine bestimmte Antwort unter aufgezeichneten Bedingungen aufgetreten ist. Ein einzelnes Ergebnis DARF NICHT verwendet werden, um Folgendes abzuleiten: - Bevölkerungsprävalenz, - typisches Produktverhalten, - zeitliche Stabilität, - sprachübergreifende Konsistenz, - länderübergreifende Konsistenz, - produktübergreifende Konsistenz, - Interventionseffekt, - Sicherheit der Empfehlung, - kommerzielle Auswirkungen, - Konformität, - oder einen GEO-Score. Alle weitergehenden Behauptungen MÜSSEN durch eine vordefinierte Zielpopulation, ein gültiges Mehrfachbeobachtungsdesign, aufgezeichnete Abhängigkeitsstrukturen, ein Evidenzbündel, Bewertungsregel, Umfangserklärung und eine Offenlegung der Unsicherheit unterstützt werden. eine einzelne Ausgabe mit hohem Schadenspotenzial KANN eine separate Überprüfung kritischer Vorfälle auslösen, ohne als Nachweis für die Bevölkerungsprävalenz behandelt zu werden.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH01-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL FÜR KAPITEL 23", "sourceParagraph": 1032, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH01-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1033, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine einzelne generative Systemausgabe KANN feststellen, dass eine bestimmte Antwort", "sourceParagraph": 1035, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unter aufgezeichneten Bedingungen aufgetreten ist.", "sourceParagraph": 1036, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine einzelne Ausgabe DARF NICHT verwendet werden, um folgendes abzuleiten:", "sourceParagraph": 1038, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Populationsprävalenz,", "sourceParagraph": 1040, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- typisches Produktverhalten,", "sourceParagraph": 1041, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- zeitliche Stabilität,", "sourceParagraph": 1042, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konsistenz über Sprachen hinweg,", "sourceParagraph": 1043, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konsistenz über Länder hinweg,", "sourceParagraph": 1044, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konsistenz über Produkte hinweg,", "sourceParagraph": 1045, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Interventionseffekt,", "sourceParagraph": 1046, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Empfehlungssicherheit,", "sourceParagraph": 1047, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- kommerzielle Auswirkung,", "sourceParagraph": 1048, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konformität,", "sourceParagraph": 1049, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- oder eine GEO-Bewertung.", "sourceParagraph": 1050, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Alle breiteren Aussagen MÜSSEN durch eine vordefinierte Zielpopulation unterstützt werden,", "sourceParagraph": 1052, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gültiges Multi-Beobachtungs-Design, aufgezeichnete Abhängigkeitsstruktur, Nachweis", "sourceParagraph": 1053, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bündel, Bewertungsregel, Umfangserklärung und Unsicherheitsangabe.", "sourceParagraph": 1054, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein einzelnes hochschädliches Ergebnis KANN eine separate Überprüfung kritischer Vorfälle auslösen", "sourceParagraph": 1056, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ohne als Nachweis der Populationsprävalenz behandelt zu werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1057, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1058, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH01-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein einzelnes Ergebnis aus einem generativen System kann anzeigen, dass eine bestimmte Antwort unter den aufgezeichneten Bedingungen aufgetreten ist. Es kann jedoch nicht verwendet werden, um die Populationsprävalenz, das typische Produktverhalten, die zeitliche Stabilität, die sprachübergreifende Konsistenz, die länderübergreifende Konsistenz, die Konsistenz zwischen KI-Produkten, den Interventionseffekt, die Gewissheit von Empfehlungen, kommerzielle Konsequenzen, Compliance oder den GEO-Score abzuleiten. Ein einzelnes hochschädliches Ergebnis kann eine separate Critical-Event-Prüfung auslösen, ohne als Nachweis für die Populationsprävalenz betrachtet zu werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1059, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 2, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH02", "title": "Repräsentation ist eine Verteilung", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K05", "K09" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH02-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "An entity's generative-system representation MUST be treated as a conditional distribution of observable outcomes across defined: - AI products and user surfaces, - users or sampling units, - countries, - languages and locales, - session and personalisation states, - prompts, - and measurement times. A single aggregate score MUST NOT replace disclosure of: - scope and coverage, - outcome distribution, - subgroup variation, - critical-error incidence, - unknown and untested mass, - temporal stability, - weighting rules, - and uncertainty. Equal averages MUST NOT be interpreted as equivalent representation quality when their subgroup, severity, coverage, or stability distributions materially differ. Untested groups MUST NOT be imputed as conforming, and rare high-harm outcomes MUST remain separately visible from average performance.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Bir varlığın üretken sistemlerdeki temsili; tanımlı AI ürünleri ve kullanıcı yüzeyleri, kullanıcılar veya örnekleme birimleri, ülkeler, diller ve locale’ler, oturum ve kişiselleştirme durumları, promptlar ve ölçüm zamanları arasında oluşan koşullu gözlenebilir sonuç dağılımı olarak değerlendirilmelidir. Tek bir toplulaştırılmış skor; kapsamı, sonuç dağılımını, alt grup farklarını, Critical hata oranını, bilinmeyen ve test edilmemiş kütleyi, zaman kararlılığını, ağırlıkları ve belirsizliği görünmez kılamaz. Aynı ortalama, maddi ölçüde farklı dağılımlar için eşdeğer temsil kalitesi anlamına gelmez.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH02-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE READABLE BY MACHINE FOR CHAPTER 31", "sourceParagraph": 1312 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH02-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1313 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An entity's generative-system representation MUST be treated as a", "sourceParagraph": 1315 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conditional distribution of observable outcomes across defined:", "sourceParagraph": 1316 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- AI products and user surfaces,", "sourceParagraph": 1318 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- users or sampling units,", "sourceParagraph": 1319 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- countries,", "sourceParagraph": 1320 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- languages and locales,", "sourceParagraph": 1321 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- session and personalisation states,", "sourceParagraph": 1322 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompts,", "sourceParagraph": 1323 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and measurement times.", "sourceParagraph": 1324 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single aggregate score MUST NOT replace disclosure of:", "sourceParagraph": 1326 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope and coverage,", "sourceParagraph": 1328 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- outcome distribution,", "sourceParagraph": 1329 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- subgroup variation,", "sourceParagraph": 1330 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- critical-error incidence,", "sourceParagraph": 1331 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unknown and untested mass,", "sourceParagraph": 1332 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- temporal stability,", "sourceParagraph": 1333 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- weighting rules,", "sourceParagraph": 1334 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and uncertainty.", "sourceParagraph": 1335 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Equal averages MUST NOT be interpreted as equivalent representation", "sourceParagraph": 1337 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "quality when their subgroup, severity, coverage, or stability", "sourceParagraph": 1338 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "distributions materially differ.", "sourceParagraph": 1339 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Untested groups MUST NOT be imputed as conforming, and rare high-harm", "sourceParagraph": 1341 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "outcomes MUST remain separately visible from average performance.", "sourceParagraph": 1342 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1343 }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The representation of an entity in generative systems should be evaluated as the conditional observable outcome distribution arising between defined AI products and user interfaces, users or sampling units, countries, languages and locales, session and personalisation states, prompts, and measurement times. A single aggregated score cannot make the scope, outcome distribution, subgroup differences, critical error rate, unknown and untested population, temporal stability, weights, and uncertainty invisible. The same average does not mean equivalent representation quality for materially different distributions.", "sourceParagraph": 1344 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Die Repräsentation einer Entität in generativen Systemen MUSS als bedingte Verteilung beobachtbarer Ergebnisse über definierte: - KI-Produkte und Nutzeroberflächen, - Nutzer oder Stichprobeneinheiten, - Länder, - Sprachen und Regionen, - Sitzungs- und Personalisierungszustände, - Prompts, - und Messzeiten behandelt werden. Ein einzelner aggregierter Wert DARF die Offenlegung von: - Umfang und Abdeckung, - Ergebnisverteilung, - Untergruppenvariationen, - Vorkommen kritischer Fehler, - unbekannter und nicht getesteter Masse, - zeitlicher Stabilität, - Gewichtungsregeln, - und Unsicherheit NICHT ersetzen. Gleiche Durchschnitte DÜRFEN NICHT als gleichwertige Repräsentationsqualität interpretiert werden, wenn ihre Untergruppen-, Schwere-, Abdeckungs- oder Stabilitätsverteilungen sich wesentlich unterscheiden. Ungetestete Gruppen DÜRFEN NICHT als konform eingeordnet werden, und seltene, schädliche Ergebnisse MÜSSEN weiterhin getrennt von der durchschnittlichen Leistung sichtbar bleiben.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH02-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL FÜR KAPITEL 31", "sourceParagraph": 1312, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH02-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1313, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Repräsentation eines generativen Systems einer Entität MUSS als", "sourceParagraph": 1315, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bedingte Verteilung beobachtbarer Ergebnisse über definierte:", "sourceParagraph": 1316, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- KI-Produkte und Nutzerschnittstellen,", "sourceParagraph": 1318, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nutzer oder Stichprobeinheiten behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1319, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Länder,", "sourceParagraph": 1320, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprachen und Locale,", "sourceParagraph": 1321, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sitzungs- und Personalisierungszustände,", "sourceParagraph": 1322, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompts,", "sourceParagraph": 1323, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Messzeiten.", "sourceParagraph": 1324, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein einziger aggregierter Wert DARF die Offenlegung von folgenden Punkten NICHT ersetzen:", "sourceParagraph": 1326, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Reichweite und Abdeckung,", "sourceParagraph": 1328, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Ergebnisverteilung,", "sourceParagraph": 1329, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Untergruppenvariation,", "sourceParagraph": 1330, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Auftreten kritischer Fehler,", "sourceParagraph": 1331, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unbekannte und ungetestete Masse,", "sourceParagraph": 1332, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- zeitliche Stabilität,", "sourceParagraph": 1333, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gewichtungsregeln,", "sourceParagraph": 1334, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Unsicherheit.", "sourceParagraph": 1335, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gleiche Durchschnitte DÜRFEN NICHT als gleichwertige Repräsentation interpretiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1337, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Qualität, wenn ihre Untergruppe, Schwere, Abdeckung oder Stabilität", "sourceParagraph": 1338, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verteilungen wesentlich abweichen.", "sourceParagraph": 1339, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ungetestete Gruppen DÜRFEN NICHT als konform unterstellt werden, und seltene schwerwiegende", "sourceParagraph": 1341, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ergebnisse MÜSSEN weiterhin getrennt von der durchschnittlichen Leistung sichtbar bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1342, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1343, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH02-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Repräsentation einer Entität in generativen Systemen sollte als die bedingte beobachtbare Ergebnisverteilung bewertet werden, die zwischen definierten KI-Produkten und Nutzeroberflächen, Nutzern oder Stichprobeneinheiten, Ländern, Sprachen und Regionen, Sitzungs- und Personalisierungszuständen, Prompts und Messzeiten entsteht. Eine einzelne aggregierte Punktzahl kann den Umfang, die Ergebnisverteilung, Unterschiede zwischen Untergruppen, die kritische Fehlerrate, unbekannte und ungetestete Populationen, zeitliche Stabilität, Gewichtungen und Unsicherheiten nicht unsichtbar machen. Derselbe Durchschnitt bedeutet nicht gleichwertige Repräsentationsqualität für materiell unterschiedliche Verteilungen.", "sourceParagraph": 1344, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 3, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH03", "title": "Welche Entität wird eigentlich geprüft?", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K10", "K11" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH03-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO audit MUST define and version, before observing results: - a prompt anchor, - a target entity, - an entity type, - a canonical identity record, - a relationship graph, - a temporal and jurisdictional boundary, - an audit object, - and a conformity unit. Domains, brands, legal entities, corporate groups, subsidiaries, products, services, persons, franchises, distributors, platforms, and sellers MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable entities. Attributes, credentials, licenses, customers, employees, performance, authority, and conformity MUST NOT transfer across related entities unless the relationship, scope, time, and evidence explicitly support that transfer. The entity resolved by the AI product MUST be evaluated separately from the factual accuracy of the response. A conformity decision MUST apply only to the explicitly identified entity and audited scope. It MUST NOT automatically extend to affiliates, products, jurisdictions, languages, domains, future versions, or related entities.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO denetimi sonuçlar görülmeden önce prompt çapasını, hedef varlığı, varlık türünü, kanonik kimlik kaydını, ilişki grafiğini, zamansal ve hukuki sınırı, denetim nesnesini ve uygunluk birimini tanımlayıp sürümlemek zorundadır. Alan adı, marka, hukuki şirket, şirketler grubu, bağlı kuruluş, ürün, hizmet, kişi, franchise, distribütör, platform ve satıcı birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Özellikler ve uygunluk, açık ilişki, kapsam, zaman ve kanıt bulunmadan ilişkili varlıklara aktarılamaz. AI ürününün çözümlediği varlık, yanıtın maddi doğruluğundan ayrı değerlendirilmelidir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH03-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "31. MACHINE-READABLE ENTITY RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1362 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1363 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1364 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1365 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1366 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1367 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1368 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"ACTIVE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1369 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityType\": \"LEGAL_ENTITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1370 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1371 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"legalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1372 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"SYNTHETIC\",", "sourceParagraph": 1373 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registrationId\": \"SYNTHETIC-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1374 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 1375 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1376 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aliases\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1377 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1378 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"name\": \"Asteron\",", "sourceParagraph": 1379 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aliasType\": \"BRAND_REFERENCE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1380 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": \"und\"", "sourceParagraph": 1381 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1382 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1383 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"brands\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1384 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1385 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1386 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"OWNS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1387 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\"", "sourceParagraph": 1388 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1389 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1390 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domains\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1391 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1392 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domain\": \"asteron.example\",", "sourceParagraph": 1393 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"CONTROLS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1394 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"GLOBAL_CORPORATE_SURFACE\"", "sourceParagraph": 1395 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1396 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1397 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subsidiaries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1398 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1399 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TR-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 1400 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"CONTROLS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1401 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1402 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1403 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1404 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"externalRelationships\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1405 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1406 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-MIRA-004\",", "sourceParagraph": 1407 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"SERVICE_DELIVERED_BY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1408 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"SELECTED_DESTINATION_SERVICES\",", "sourceParagraph": 1409 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1410 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2026-01-01\"", "sourceParagraph": 1411 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1412 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1413 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditScope\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1414 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedEntities\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1415 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1416 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 1417 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1418 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"excludedEntities\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1419 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-CLUB-005\"", "sourceParagraph": 1420 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1421 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedDomains\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1422 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"asteron.example\"", "sourceParagraph": 1423 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1424 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1425 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"en\",", "sourceParagraph": 1426 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tr\"", "sourceParagraph": 1427 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1428 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1429 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1430 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1431 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1432 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityPeriod\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1433 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"from\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1434 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"to\": \"2027-08-17\"", "sourceParagraph": 1435 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1436 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1437 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responsibility\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1438 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOwner\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1439 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surfaceOperator\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1440 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"serviceDeliveryVariesByJurisdiction\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1441 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ENTITY_RECORD_OWNER\"", "sourceParagraph": 1442 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1443 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1444 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1445 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1446 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "does not by itself prove that the relation is correct,", "sourceParagraph": 1447 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "does not replace a legal record,", "sourceParagraph": 1448 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "does not properly declare all subsidiaries.", "sourceParagraph": 1449 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Only shows the audit object and the alleged relationships in a machine-readable format.", "sourceParagraph": 1450 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 32", "sourceParagraph": 1452 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH03-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1453 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO audit MUST define and version, before observing results:", "sourceParagraph": 1455 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a prompt anchor,", "sourceParagraph": 1457 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a target entity,", "sourceParagraph": 1458 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- an entity type,", "sourceParagraph": 1459 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a canonical identity record,", "sourceParagraph": 1460 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a relationship graph,", "sourceParagraph": 1461 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a temporal and jurisdictional boundary,", "sourceParagraph": 1462 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- an audit object,", "sourceParagraph": 1463 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and a conformity unit.", "sourceParagraph": 1464 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Domains, brands, legal entities, corporate groups, subsidiaries, products,", "sourceParagraph": 1466 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "services, persons, franchises, distributors, platforms, and sellers MUST", "sourceParagraph": 1467 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT be treated as interchangeable entities.", "sourceParagraph": 1468 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Attributes, credentials, licenses, customers, employees, performance,", "sourceParagraph": 1470 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authority, and conformity MUST NOT transfer across related entities", "sourceParagraph": 1471 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unless the relationship, scope, time, and evidence explicitly support", "sourceParagraph": 1472 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "that transfer.", "sourceParagraph": 1473 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The entity resolved by the AI product MUST be evaluated separately from", "sourceParagraph": 1475 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "the factual accuracy of the response.", "sourceParagraph": 1476 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A conformity decision MUST apply only to the explicitly identified", "sourceParagraph": 1478 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entity and audited scope. It MUST NOT automatically extend to affiliates,", "sourceParagraph": 1479 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "products, jurisdictions, languages, domains, future versions, or related", "sourceParagraph": 1480 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entities.", "sourceParagraph": 1481 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1482 }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Before the results of each GEO audit are seen, the prompt anchor, target entity, entity type, canonical identity record, relationship graph, temporal and legal boundary, audit object, and conformity unit must be defined and versioned. Domain name, brand, legal company, corporate group, subsidiary, product, service, person, franchise, distributor, platform, and vendor cannot be used interchangeably. Attributes and compliance cannot be transferred to related entities without explicit relationship, scope, time, and evidence. The entity analysed by the AI product must be evaluated separately from the factual accuracy of the response.", "sourceParagraph": 1483 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede GEO-Prüfung MUSS vor der Beobachtung von Ergebnissen definieren und versionieren: - einen Prompt-Anker, - eine Zielentität, - einen Entitätstyp, - einen kanonischen Identitätsdatensatz, - einen Beziehungsgraph, - eine zeitliche und juristische Grenze, - ein Prüfobjekt, - und eine Konformitätseinheit. Domains, Marken, juristische Personen, Unternehmensgruppen, Tochtergesellschaften, Produkte, Dienstleistungen, Personen, Franchiseunternehmen, Distributoren, Plattformen und Verkäufer DÜRFEN NICHT als austauschbare Entitäten behandelt werden. Attribute, Berechtigungen, Lizenzen, Kunden, Mitarbeiter, Leistung, Autorität und Konformität DÜRFEN NICHT auf verwandte Entitäten übertragen werden, es sei denn, die Beziehung, der Umfang, die Zeit und die Nachweise unterstützen diese Übertragung ausdrücklich. Die vom KI-Produkt gelöste Einheit MUSS getrennt von der sachlichen Richtigkeit der Antwort bewertet werden. Eine Konformitätsentscheidung MUSS sich nur auf die ausdrücklich identifizierte Einheit und den geprüften Umfang beziehen. Sie DARF NICHT automatisch auf Tochtergesellschaften, Produkte, Jurisdiktionen, Sprachen, Bereiche, zukünftige Versionen oder verwandte Einheiten ausgeweitet werden.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH03-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "31. MASCHINENLESBARER ENTITÄTEN-DATENSATZ", "sourceParagraph": 1362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"AKTIV\",", "sourceParagraph": 1369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityType\": \"RECHTSINHABER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1370, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"legalName\": \"Asteron Holdings Ltd.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Rechtsgebiet\": \"SYNTHETISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1373, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registrationId\": \"SYNTHETISCH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 1375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Aliase\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1377, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Name\": \"Asteron\"", "sourceParagraph": 1379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{\"aliasType\": \"MARKEN_REFERENZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 1380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Sprache\": \"und\",", "sourceParagraph": 1381, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Marken\":", "sourceParagraph": 1384, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Beziehung\": \"BESITZT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"validFrom\": \"2025-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 1388, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Domänen\":", "sourceParagraph": 1391, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1392, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Domäne\": \"asteron.example\",", "sourceParagraph": 1393, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Beziehung\": \"KONTROLLIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1394, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Umfang\": \"GLOBAL_KONZERN_OBERFLÄCHE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1395, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1396, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1397, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Tochtergesellschaften\":", "sourceParagraph": 1398, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1399, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TR-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 1400, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Beziehung\": \"KONTROLLIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1401, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"Rechtsgebiet\": \"TR\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1402, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1403, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1404, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"externalRelationships\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1405, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1406, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-MIRA-004\",", "sourceParagraph": 1407, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"SERVICE_DELIVERED_BY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1408, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"SELECTED_DESTINATION_SERVICES\",", "sourceParagraph": 1409, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"jurisdiction\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1410, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": ", \"validFrom\": \"2026-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 1411, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1412, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1413, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditScope\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1414, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedEntities\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1415, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1416, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-TRAVEL-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1417, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1418, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"excludedEntities\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1419, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-CLUB-005\",", "sourceParagraph": 1420, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1421, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedDomains\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1422, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"asteron.example\",", "sourceParagraph": 1423, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1424, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1425, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"en\",", "sourceParagraph": 1426, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tr\"", "sourceParagraph": 1427, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1428, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1429, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1430, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1431, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1432, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityPeriod\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1433, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"von\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1434, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"an\": \"2027-08-17\"", "sourceParagraph": 1435, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1436, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1437, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1438, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOwner\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1439, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surfaceOperator\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1440, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"serviceDeliveryVariesByJurisdiction\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1441, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ENTITY_RECORD_OWNER\"", "sourceParagraph": 1442, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1443, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1444, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1445, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1446, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "beweist für sich genommen nicht, dass die Beziehung korrekt ist,", "sourceParagraph": 1447, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ersetzt keinen rechtlichen Datensatz,", "sourceParagraph": 1448, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gibt nicht alle Tochtergesellschaften ordnungsgemäß an.", "sourceParagraph": 1449, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zeigt lediglich das Prüfobjekt und die angeblichen Beziehungen in einem maschinenlesbaren Format an.", "sourceParagraph": 1450, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 32", "sourceParagraph": 1452, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH03-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1453, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-Prüfung MUSS eine Definition und Version festlegen, bevor Ergebnisse beobachtet werden:", "sourceParagraph": 1455, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein Promptanker,", "sourceParagraph": 1457, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- eine Zielentität,", "sourceParagraph": 1458, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein Entitätstyp,", "sourceParagraph": 1459, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein kanonischer Identitätsdatensatz,", "sourceParagraph": 1460, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein Beziehungsdiagramm,", "sourceParagraph": 1461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- eine zeitliche und zuständige Grenze,", "sourceParagraph": 1462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein Prüfungsobjekt,", "sourceParagraph": 1463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und eine Übereinstimmungseinheit.", "sourceParagraph": 1464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Domains, Marken, juristische Personen, Unternehmensgruppen, Tochtergesellschaften, Produkte,", "sourceParagraph": 1466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dienstleistungen, Personen, Franchiseunternehmen, Vertriebspartner, Plattformen und Verkäufer MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 1467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NICHT als austauschbare Einheiten behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Attribute, Referenzen, Lizenzen, Kunden, Mitarbeiter, Leistung,", "sourceParagraph": 1470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Autorität und Konformität DÜRFEN NICHT auf verwandte Einheiten übertragen werden", "sourceParagraph": 1471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es sei denn, die Beziehung, der Umfang, die Zeit und die Evidenz unterstützen", "sourceParagraph": 1472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "diese Übertragung ausdrücklich.", "sourceParagraph": 1473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die vom KI-Produkt aufgelöste Einheit MUSS getrennt von", "sourceParagraph": 1475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "der sachlichen Richtigkeit der Antwort bewertet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Konformitätsentscheidung MUSS sich nur auf die ausdrücklich identifizierte", "sourceParagraph": 1478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einheit und den geprüften Umfang beziehen. Sie DARF sich NICHT automatisch auf Tochtergesellschaften,", "sourceParagraph": 1479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Produkte, Jurisdiktionen, Sprachen, Bereiche, zukünftige Versionen oder verwandte", "sourceParagraph": 1480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einheiten ausdehnen.", "sourceParagraph": 1481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH03-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevor die Ergebnisse jeder GEO-Prüfung sichtbar sind, müssen der Prompt-Anker, die Zielentität, der Entitätstyp, das kanonische Identitätsregister, der Beziehungsgraph, die zeitlichen und rechtlichen Grenzen, das Prüfobjekt und die Konformitätseinheit definiert und versioniert werden. Domainname, Marke, juristische Gesellschaft, Unternehmensgruppe, Tochtergesellschaft, Produkt, Dienstleistung, Person, Franchise, Distributor, Plattform und Anbieter dürfen nicht austauschbar verwendet werden. Attribute und Compliance dürfen ohne explizite Beziehung, Umfang, Zeit und Nachweis nicht auf verwandte Entitäten übertragen werden. Die vom KI-Produkt analysierte Entität muss getrennt von der faktischen Genauigkeit der Antwort bewertet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1483, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 4, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH04", "title": "Zwei Ebenen der Wirklichkeit", "subtitle": "Offizielle Repräsentation und verifizierte Realität der Entität", "sourceIds": [ "K10", "K11" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH04-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every material generative-system claim about an audited entity MUST be evaluated against two separately versioned reference layers:", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": null, "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH04-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "42. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1340 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1341 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1342 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1343 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1344 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1345 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-ASTERON-COUNTRIES-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1346 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1347 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 1348 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1349 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1350 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 1351 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceId\": \"OFFICIAL-WEB-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1352 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 1353 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1354 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"PUBLIC_GLOBAL_CLAIM\"", "sourceParagraph": 1355 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1356 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedReality\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1357 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"CONTRADICTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1358 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportedValue\": 9,", "sourceParagraph": 1359 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceLevel\": \"VR-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1360 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1361 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OPS-COUNTRY-REGISTER-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1362 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CONTRACT-REGISTER-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 1363 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1364 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidenceIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1365 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OFFICIAL-WEB-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1366 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1367 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"ACTIVE_SERVICE_DELIVERY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1368 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1369 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uncertainty\": \"Some remote-only markets remain unresolved\"", "sourceParagraph": 1370 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1371 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1372 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"required\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1373 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preferredForm\": \"The company states that it operates in 25 countries; active service delivery has been verified in 9.\"", "sourceParagraph": 1374 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1375 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materiality\": \"MAJOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1376 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudication\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1377 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reviewStatus\": \"REVIEWED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1378 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"OPEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1379 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"CLAIM_ADJUDICATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1380 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1381 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1382 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1383 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1384 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "do not claim to represent absolute truth,", "sourceParagraph": 1385 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "may change with new evidence,", "sourceParagraph": 1386 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "preserves the scope and uncertainty of the evidence.", "sourceParagraph": 1387 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE OF THE CHAPTER 43 READABLE BY MACHINE", "sourceParagraph": 1389 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH04-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1390 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every material generative-system claim about an audited entity MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 1392 }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "evaluated against two separately versioned reference layers:", "sourceParagraph": 1393 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede wesentliche Aussage des generativen Systems über eine geprüfte Entität MUSS anhand von zwei separat versionierten Bezugsebenen bewertet werden:", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH04-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "42. MASCHINENLESBARES AUSSAGEREGISTER", "sourceParagraph": 1340, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1341, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1342, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1343, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1344, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1345, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-ASTERON-LÄNDER-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1346, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1347, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 1348, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1349, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"OFFIZIELL_AKTUELL\",", "sourceParagraph": 1350, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 1351, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceId\": \"OFFIZIELLE-WEB-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1352, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 1353, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1354, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Geltungsbereich\": \"ÖFFENTLICH_GLOBALER_ANSRUCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1355, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1356, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedReality\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1357, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"WIDERSPRUCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1358, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportedValue\": 9,", "sourceParagraph": 1359, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceLevel\": \"VR-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1360, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1361, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OPS-LÄNDER-REGISTER-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VERTRAGS-REGISTER-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 1363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidenceIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OFFIZIELLE-WEB-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"umfang\": \"AKTIVE_DIENSTLEISTUNGSERBRINGUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unsicherheit\": \"Einige ausschließlich ferngesteuerte Märkte sind noch ungelöst\",", "sourceParagraph": 1370, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"zuschreibung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"erforderlich\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1373, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preferredForm\": \"Das Unternehmen gibt an, dass es in 25 Ländern tätig ist; aktive Dienstleistungserbringung wurde in 9 verifiziert.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"wesentlichkeit\": \"BESONDERS_WICHTIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entscheidungsfindung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1377, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reviewStatus\": \"ÜBERPRÜFT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"OFFEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"ANSpruchSBEURTEILER\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1381, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1384, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "behaupten Sie nicht, die absolute Wahrheit zu vertreten,", "sourceParagraph": 1385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kann sich mit neuen Nachweisen ändern,", "sourceParagraph": 1386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bewahrt den Umfang und die Unsicherheit der Nachweise.", "sourceParagraph": 1387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL DES KAPITELS 43 VON DER MASCHINE LESBAR", "sourceParagraph": 1389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH04-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede wesentliche Aussage eines generativen Systems über eine geprüfte Entität MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 1392, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH04-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gegen zwei separat versionierte Referenzschichten bewertet werden:", "sourceParagraph": 1393, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 5, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH05", "title": "Die relevante Nutzerpopulation für jedes KI-Produkt", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K05", "K06", "K07" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH05-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO population audit MUST define, before result inspection, a time-bound and product-specific target user population for each: - AI product and user surface, - country or jurisdiction, - age and lawful-access condition, - account or plan condition, - language and locale, - interface, - prompt family, - and measurement purpose. Total resident population MUST NOT be treated as product-eligible population without justified eligibility adjustments. Product unavailability MUST be reported as an access-coverage limitation, not silently scored as incorrect representation or silently removed from global scope. Potential access, active use, actual exposure, Native Reach, Common Support, market relevance, and research observability MUST remain distinct population concepts. Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and product observations MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable population units. Oversampled countries, languages, and accessibility groups MUST be reweighted for population estimates while remaining separately visible for fairness and coverage analysis. Country Observer observations MAY establish geographic observation coverage, but MUST NOT be represented as statistically reliable country scores. Participants MUST NOT be required to bypass product, geographic, age, identity, or account restrictions in order to enter the official population panel. Every population frame MUST be versioned, sourced, uncertainty-aware, and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO nüfus denetimi, sonuçlar görülmeden önce her AI ürünü ve kullanıcı yüzeyi, ülke veya yargı alanı, yaş ve meşru erişim koşulu, hesap veya plan, dil ve locale, arayüz, prompt ailesi ve ölçüm amacı için zamana bağlı ürün-özel hedef kullanıcı nüfusu tanımlamalıdır. Toplam yerleşik nüfus, gerekçeli uygunluk ayarlamaları olmadan ürün-uygun nüfus sayılamaz. Ürün erişiminin bulunmaması yanlış temsil olarak puanlanmamalı; erişim kapsamı sınırlaması olarak ayrıca gösterilmelidir. Kişi, hesap, oturum, dil ve ürün gözlemi birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Gözcü gözlemleri ülke görünürlüğü sağlayabilir; istatistiksel ülke skoru olarak sunulamaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH05-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE POPULATION RECORD 42", "sourceParagraph": 1466 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1467 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1468 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1469 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceDate\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1470 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"CORE_IDENTITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1471 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetEstimand\": \"Probability of a qualifying representation among product-eligible adult users\"", "sourceParagraph": 1472 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1473 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligibility\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1474 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumAgeRule\": \"ADULT_BASELINE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1475 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"internetAccessRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1476 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialProductAccessRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1477 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restrictionCircumventionAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1478 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageCompetenceRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1479 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researchConsentRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1480 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1481 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryFrames\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1482 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1483 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-A\",", "sourceParagraph": 1484 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1400000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1485 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"UNAVAILABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1486 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1487 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachStatus\": \"OUTSIDE_NATIVE_REACH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1488 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentinelEligible\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1489 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1490 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1491 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-B\",", "sourceParagraph": 1492 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1450000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1493 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 520000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1494 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1495 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 520000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1496 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETIC_JOINT_ESTIMATE\"", "sourceParagraph": 1497 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1498 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1499 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-C\",", "sourceParagraph": 1500 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 340000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1501 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 250000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1502 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1503 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 250000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1504 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETIC_JOINT_ESTIMATE\"", "sourceParagraph": 1505 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1506 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1507 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-D\",", "sourceParagraph": 1508 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 35000,", "sourceParagraph": 1509 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 25000,", "sourceParagraph": 1510 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFICIALLY_AVAILABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1511 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 25000,", "sourceParagraph": 1512 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelShare\": 0.000032,", "sourceParagraph": 1513 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1514 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1515 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1516 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panels\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1517 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1518 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"POPULATION_WEIGHTED_ESTIMATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"defaultTargetValidObservations\": 1000", "sourceParagraph": 1520 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1521 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1522 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"COUNTRY_COVERAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1523 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryScoresAllowedFromSingleObservation\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1524 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1525 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairnessPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1526 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"LOW_RESOURCE_LANGUAGE_DIAGNOSTICS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1527 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reweightToPopulationForGlobalScore\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1528 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1529 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessibilityPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1530 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"ACCESSIBILITY_COVERAGE_AND_DIAGNOSTICS\"", "sourceParagraph": 1531 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1532 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1533 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1534 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReach\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1535 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupport\": \"TO_BE_DEFINED_PER_COMPARISON_SET\"", "sourceParagraph": 1536 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1537 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1538 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationFrameOwnerRole\": \"POPULATION_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 1539 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1540 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeAfterResultInspection\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1541 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1542 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1543 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1544 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1545 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "is not real population data,", "sourceParagraph": 1546 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "is not a real product access map,", "sourceParagraph": 1547 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "shows the data structure of a method.", "sourceParagraph": 1548 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE OF THE CHAPTER 43 READABLE BY MACHINE", "sourceParagraph": 1550 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH05-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1551 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO population audit MUST define, before result inspection, a", "sourceParagraph": 1553 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "time-bound and product-specific target user population for each:", "sourceParagraph": 1554 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- AI product and user surface,", "sourceParagraph": 1556 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- country or jurisdiction,", "sourceParagraph": 1557 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- age and lawful-access condition,", "sourceParagraph": 1558 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- account or plan condition,", "sourceParagraph": 1559 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- language and locale,", "sourceParagraph": 1560 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- interface,", "sourceParagraph": 1561 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt family,", "sourceParagraph": 1562 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and measurement purpose.", "sourceParagraph": 1563 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Total resident population MUST NOT be treated as product-eligible", "sourceParagraph": 1565 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "population without justified eligibility adjustments.", "sourceParagraph": 1566 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Product unavailability MUST be reported as an access-coverage limitation,", "sourceParagraph": 1568 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "not silently scored as incorrect representation or silently removed from", "sourceParagraph": 1569 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "global scope.", "sourceParagraph": 1570 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Potential access, active use, actual exposure, Native Reach, Common", "sourceParagraph": 1572 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Support, market relevance, and research observability MUST remain", "sourceParagraph": 1573 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "distinct population concepts.", "sourceParagraph": 1574 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and product observations MUST NOT", "sourceParagraph": 1576 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "be treated as interchangeable population units.", "sourceParagraph": 1577 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Oversampled countries, languages, and accessibility groups MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 1579 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reweighted for population estimates while remaining separately visible", "sourceParagraph": 1580 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "for fairness and coverage analysis.", "sourceParagraph": 1581 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Country Observer observations MAY establish geographic observation coverage, but", "sourceParagraph": 1583 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT be represented as statistically reliable country scores.", "sourceParagraph": 1584 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Participants MUST NOT be required to bypass product, geographic, age,", "sourceParagraph": 1586 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "identity, or account restrictions in order to enter the official", "sourceParagraph": 1587 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "population panel.", "sourceParagraph": 1588 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every population frame MUST be versioned, sourced, uncertainty-aware,", "sourceParagraph": 1590 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 1591 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1592 }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Each GEO population audit should define a time-bound product-specific target user population for every AI product and user surface, country or jurisdiction, age and legitimate access condition, account or plan, language and locale, interface, prompt family, and measurement purpose before results are seen. The total embedded population cannot be counted as a product-eligible population without justified eligibility adjustments. Lack of product access should not be scored as misrepresentation; it should be shown separately as an access coverage limitation. Person, account, session, language, and product observation cannot be used interchangeably. Country Observer observations can provide country visibility; they cannot be presented as a statistical country score.", "sourceParagraph": 1593 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede GEO-Populationsprüfung MUSS vor der Ergebnisüberprüfung eine zeitlich begrenzte und produktspezifische Zielpopulation von Nutzern für jede der folgenden Kombinationen definieren: - KI-Produkt und Nutzeroberfläche, - Land oder Rechtsgebiet, - Altersgrenze und Voraussetzung für einen rechtmäßigen Zugang, - Konto- oder Tarifbedingung, - Sprache und Gebietsschema, - Schnittstelle, - Prompt-Familie, - und Messzweck. Die gesamte ansässige Bevölkerung DARF NICHT als produktberechtigte Bevölkerung behandelt werden, ohne gerechtfertigte Berechtigungsanpassungen. Die Nichtverfügbarkeit des Produkts MUSS als Zugangsbeschränkung gemeldet werden, nicht stillschweigend als falsche Repräsentation bewertet oder stillschweigend aus dem globalen Umfang entfernt werden. Potenzieller Zugang, aktive Nutzung, tatsächliche Exposition, Natürliche Reichweite, Gemeinsame Vergleichsbasis, Marktrelevanz und Forschungsbeobachtbarkeit MÜSSEN als unterschiedliche Populationskonzepte bestehen bleiben. Personen, Konten, Sitzungen, Sprachen und Produktbeobachtungen DÜRFEN NICHT als austauschbare Populations-Einheiten behandelt werden. Überrepräsentierte Länder, Sprachen und Zugänglichkeitsgruppen MÜSSEN für Populationsschätzungen neu gewichtet werden, während sie separat sichtbar für Fairness- und Abdeckungsanalysen bleiben. Beobachtungen von Country Observer KÖNNEN die geografische Beobachtungsabdeckung bestimmen, DÜRFEN jedoch nicht als statistisch verlässliche Länderscores repräsentiert werden. Teilnehmer DARF NICHT dazu verpflichtet werden, Produkt-, geografische-, Alters-, Identitäts- oder Kontoeinschränkungen zu umgehen, um in das offizielle Bevölkerungs-Panel aufgenommen zu werden. Jeder Bevölkerungsrahmen MUSS versioniert, quellenbasiert, unsicherheitsbewusst und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH05-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESBARES POPULATIONSREGISTER 42", "sourceParagraph": 1466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1469, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceDate\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"CORE_IDENTITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetEstimand\": \"Wahrscheinlichkeit einer qualifizierenden Repräsentation unter produktberechtigten erwachsenen Nutzern\"", "sourceParagraph": 1472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Eignung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1474, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumAgeRule\": \"ERWACHSENEN_GRUNDLAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"internetAccessRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialProductAccessRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1477, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restrictionCircumventionAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageCompetenceRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researchConsentRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryFrames\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1483, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-A\",", "sourceParagraph": 1484, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1400000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1485, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"NICHT_VERFÜGBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1486, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1487, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachStatus\": \"AUSSERHALB_DES_NATIVEN_BEREICHS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1488, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentinelEligible\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1489, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1490, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1491, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-B\",", "sourceParagraph": 1492, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 1450000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1493, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 520000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1494, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFIZIELL_VERFÜGBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1495, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 520000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1496, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETISCHES_GEMEINSAMES_SCHÄTZUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1497, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1498, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1499, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-C\",", "sourceParagraph": 1500, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 340000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1501, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 250000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1502, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFIZIELL_VERFÜGBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1503, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 250000000,", "sourceParagraph": 1504, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimationMethod\": \"SYNTHETISCHES_GEMEINSAMES_SCHÄTZUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1505, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1506, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1507, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-D\"", "sourceParagraph": 1508, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residentPopulation\": 35000,", "sourceParagraph": 1509, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedJointEligiblePopulation\": 25000,", "sourceParagraph": 1510, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAccessStatus\": \"OFFIZIELL_VERFÜGBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1511, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachPopulation\": 25000,", "sourceParagraph": 1512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelShare\": 0.000032,", "sourceParagraph": 1513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Panels\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zweck\": \"BEVÖLKERUNGSGEWICHTETE_SCHÄTZUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"defaultTargetValidObservations\": 1000", "sourceParagraph": 1520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinelPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zweck\": \"LANDESABDECKUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryScoresAllowedFromSingleObservation\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairnessPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zweck\": \"DIAGNOSTIK_FÜR_SPRACHEN_MIT_WENIG_RESSOURCEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reweightToPopulationForGlobalScore\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessibilityPanel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zweck\": \"BARREIEREFREIHEITSABDECKUNG_UND_DIAGNOSTIK\"", "sourceParagraph": 1531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReach\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupport\": \"FÜR_JEDES_VERGLEICHSSET_ZU_DEFINIEREN\"", "sourceParagraph": 1536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationFrameOwnerRole\": \"LEITUNG_BEVOELKERUNGSMETHODEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-08-18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeAfterResultInspection\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ist keine echten Bevölkerungsdaten,", "sourceParagraph": 1546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ist keine echte Produktzugriffskarte,\"", "sourceParagraph": 1547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zeigt die Datenstruktur einer Methode.", "sourceParagraph": 1548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL DES KAPITELS 43 VON DER MASCHINE LESBAR", "sourceParagraph": 1550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH05-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "JEDER GEO-Populationsaudit MUSS vor der Ergebnisüberprüfung definieren,", "sourceParagraph": 1553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine zeitlich begrenzte und produktspezifische Zielnutzerpopulation für jedes:", "sourceParagraph": 1554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- KI-Produkt und Nutzeroberfläche,", "sourceParagraph": 1556, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Land oder Rechtsordnung,", "sourceParagraph": 1557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Alters- und rechtmäßige Zugriffsbedingungen,", "sourceParagraph": 1558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konto- oder Planbedingungen,", "sourceParagraph": 1559, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprache und Gebietsschema,", "sourceParagraph": 1560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Schnittstelle,", "sourceParagraph": 1561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompt-Familie,", "sourceParagraph": 1562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Messzweck.", "sourceParagraph": 1563, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die gesamte ansässige Bevölkerung DARF NICHT als produktberechtigt behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevölkerung ohne gerechtfertigte Anspruchsanpassungen.", "sourceParagraph": 1566, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Produktnichtverfügbarkeit MUSS als Zugangs- bzw. Abdeckungsbeeinträchtigung gemeldet werden,", "sourceParagraph": 1568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht stillschweigend als falsche Repräsentation bewertet oder stillschweigend aus dem", "sourceParagraph": 1569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "globalen Bereich entfernt.", "sourceParagraph": 1570, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Potenzieller Zugang, aktive Nutzung, tatsächliche Exposition, Natürliche Reichweite, Allgemein", "sourceParagraph": 1572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unterstützung, Marktrelevanz und Forschungsbeobachtbarkeit MÜSSEN weiterhin", "sourceParagraph": 1573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "distinkte Bevölkerungskonzepte bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Personen, Konten, Sitzungen, Sprachen und Produktbeobachtungen DÜRFEN NICHT", "sourceParagraph": 1576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als austauschbare Bevölkerungseinheiten behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Überrepräsentierte Länder, Sprachen und Zugänglichkeitsgruppen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 1579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "für Bevölkerungsschätzungen neu gewichtet werden, während sie separat sichtbar bleiben", "sourceParagraph": 1580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "für Fairness- und Abdeckungsanalysen.", "sourceParagraph": 1581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beobachtungen von Länderbeobachtern KÖNNEN die geografische Beobachtungsabdeckung festlegen, dürfen jedoch", "sourceParagraph": 1583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NICHT als statistisch verlässliche Länderscores repräsentiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Teilnehmer DÜRFEN NICHT verpflichtet werden, Produkt-, geografische-, Alters-,", "sourceParagraph": 1586, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Identitäts- oder Kontoeinschränkungen zu umgehen, um am offiziellen", "sourceParagraph": 1587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevölkerungs-Panel teilzunehmen.", "sourceParagraph": 1588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jeder Bevölkerungsrahmen MUSS versioniert, bezogen und unsicherheitsbewusst sein,", "sourceParagraph": 1590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und auf einen verantwortlichen Menschen oder eine Organisation zurückzuführen.", "sourceParagraph": 1591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH05-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jedes GEO-Bevölkerungs-Audit sollte für jedes KI-Produkt und jede Nutzeroberfläche, jedes Land oder jede Gerichtsbarkeit, jedes Alter und jede legitime Zugriffsbedingung, jedes Konto oder jede Abonnementart, jede Sprache und jeden Standort, jede Schnittstelle, jede Prompt-Familie und jeden Messzweck eine zeitlich begrenzte, produktspezifische Zielnutzerpopulation definieren, bevor Ergebnisse betrachtet werden. Die insgesamt eingebettete Population kann nicht als produkterlaubte Population gezählt werden, ohne dass gerechtfertigte Anpassungen der Berechtigung vorgenommen wurden. Ein fehlender Produktzugang sollte nicht als Falschdarstellung gewertet werden; er sollte separat als Einschränkung der Zugangsabdeckung dargestellt werden. Person, Konto, Sitzung, Sprache und Produktbeobachtung können nicht austauschbar verwendet werden. Beobachtungen von Länderbeobachtern können Einblicke in das Land geben; sie können jedoch nicht als statistische Länderbewertung dargestellt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1593, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 6, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH06", "title": "Die bevölkerungsproportionale GEO-1000-Stichprobe", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K05", "K07", "K08" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH06-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "For each AI product and principal measurement wave, the GEO-1000 Population Panel SHOULD target at least 1,000 valid product-observations unless a different target is explicitly justified. Sample allocation MUST be designed, versioned, and locked before AI responses are observed. Primary allocation MUST be based on the product-eligible target population, not raw resident population, invitation counts, accounts, sessions, or convenience availability. Fractional allocations MUST be converted to integer quotas using a predeclared, reproducible, outcome-blind method. Positive-mass populations MUST NOT be deterministically assigned zero selection probability when the audit claims inference to the full target population. Small populations MAY be represented through justified pooled strata and probability-proportional selection. Country Observer, Language Fairness, and Accessibility observations MAY supplement the main panel, but MUST remain separately labelled and appropriately reweighted. Oversampled groups MUST NOT receive their raw sample share as population weight. Participant replacement MUST be based only on predeclared recruitment or protocol-validity conditions. Incorrect, negative, refused, or critical AI outputs MUST NOT trigger replacement. Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units. Design weights, nonresponse adjustments, calibration, trimming, clustering, paired observations, and effective sample size MUST be documented. Any post-result change to quotas, strata, pools, weights, exclusions, or sample targets MUST create a new analysis version and preserve the original record.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her AI ürünü ve ana ölçüm dalgası için GEO-1000 Population Panel, farklı bir hedef açıkça gerekçelendirilmedikçe en az 1.000 geçerli ürün-gözlemini hedeflemelidir. Örneklem tahsisi AI yanıtları görülmeden önce tasarlanmalı, sürümlenmeli ve kilitlenmelidir. Ana tahsis toplam ülke nüfusuna, davet sayısına, hesaplara, oturumlara veya kolaylık örneklemine değil ürün-uygun hedef insan nüfusuna dayanmalıdır. Küsuratlı kotalar önceden ilan edilmiş ve sonuçtan bağımsız yöntemle tam sayıya çevrilmelidir. Pozitif nüfus kütlesi taşıyan gruplara, bütün hedef nüfus adına çıkarım yapılırken deterministik sıfır seçilme olasılığı verilemez. Fazla örneklenen gruplar ham örneklem paylarını nüfus ağırlığı olarak kullanamaz. Yanlış, olumsuz, ret veya Critical AI çıktısı katılımcı değiştirme nedeni olamaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH06-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "58. MACHINE-READABLE ALLOCATION RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1512 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1513 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1514 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationShare\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 1515 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawQuota\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1516 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1517 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"withinPoolSelection\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1518 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"method\": \"PPS_ELIGIBLE_POPULATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1520 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1521 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-H\",", "sourceParagraph": 1522 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 1500000,", "sourceParagraph": 1523 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.75", "sourceParagraph": 1524 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1525 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1526 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-I\",", "sourceParagraph": 1527 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 400000,", "sourceParagraph": 1528 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.2", "sourceParagraph": 1529 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1530 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1531 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", "sourceParagraph": 1532 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 100000,", "sourceParagraph": 1533 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.05", "sourceParagraph": 1534 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1535 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1536 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1537 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1538 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1539 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1540 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supplementaryPanels\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1541 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1542 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 3,", "sourceParagraph": 1543 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedCountries\": [\"SYN-H\", \"SYN-I\", \"SYN-J\"],", "sourceParagraph": 1544 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryScoresFromSingleObservationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1545 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPopulationEstimateWithFullSentinelWeight\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1546 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1547 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1548 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 50,", "sourceParagraph": 1549 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oversampledLanguage\": \"SYN-LANG-Y\",", "sourceParagraph": 1550 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reweightToPopulation\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1551 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1552 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessibility\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1553 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 40,", "sourceParagraph": 1554 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"separateDiagnosticReporting\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1555 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1556 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1557 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1558 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedCompletionRate\": 0.82,", "sourceParagraph": 1559 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedProtocolValidityRate\": 0.92,", "sourceParagraph": 1560 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plannedInvitationsMainPanel\": 1326,", "sourceParagraph": 1561 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reserveListsPreselected\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1562 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseContentMayTriggerReplacement\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1563 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityReviewBeforeSemanticScoring\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1564 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1565 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"weights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1566 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"baseDesignWeight\": \"INVERSE_SELECTION_PROBABILITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1567 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": \"PREDECLARED_RESPONSE_CLASSES\",", "sourceParagraph": 1568 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"calibration\": \"COUNTRY_LANGUAGE_TOTALS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1569 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"trimming\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1570 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enabled\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1571 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ifEnabledRequiresNewAnalysisVersion\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1572 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1573 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveSampleSizeRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1574 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1575 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1576 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachAllocation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1577 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupportAllocation\": \"SEPARATE_RECORD_REQUIRED\"", "sourceParagraph": 1578 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1579 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1580 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allocationApprovedBeforeResponses\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1581 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"SAMPLE_DESIGN_OWNER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1582 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 1583 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resultDrivenChangesProhibited\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1584 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1585 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1586 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1587 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1588 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is not actual product or country data,", "sourceParagraph": 1589 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is not an actual sampling plan.", "sourceParagraph": 1590 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a synthetic representation of the reproducible allocation structure.", "sourceParagraph": 1591 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 59", "sourceParagraph": 1593 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH06-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1594 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "For each AI product and principal measurement wave, the GEO-1000", "sourceParagraph": 1596 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Population Panel SHOULD target at least 1,000 valid product-observations", "sourceParagraph": 1597 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unless a different target is explicitly justified.", "sourceParagraph": 1598 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sample allocation MUST be designed, versioned, and locked before AI", "sourceParagraph": 1600 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "responses are observed.", "sourceParagraph": 1601 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Primary allocation MUST be based on the product-eligible target population,", "sourceParagraph": 1603 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "not raw resident population, invitation counts, accounts, sessions, or", "sourceParagraph": 1604 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "convenience availability.", "sourceParagraph": 1605 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fractional allocations MUST be converted to integer quotas using a", "sourceParagraph": 1607 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "predeclared, reproducible, outcome-blind method.", "sourceParagraph": 1608 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Positive-mass populations MUST NOT be deterministically assigned zero", "sourceParagraph": 1610 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "selection probability when the audit claims inference to the full target", "sourceParagraph": 1611 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "population. Small populations MAY be represented through justified pooled", "sourceParagraph": 1612 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "strata and probability-proportional selection.", "sourceParagraph": 1613 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Country Observer, Language Fairness, and Accessibility observations MAY", "sourceParagraph": 1615 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "supplement the main panel, but MUST remain separately labelled and", "sourceParagraph": 1616 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "appropriately reweighted.", "sourceParagraph": 1617 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Oversampled groups MUST NOT receive their raw sample share as population", "sourceParagraph": 1619 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "weight.", "sourceParagraph": 1620 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Participant replacement MUST be based only on predeclared recruitment or", "sourceParagraph": 1622 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "protocol-validity conditions. Incorrect, negative, refused, or critical AI", "sourceParagraph": 1623 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "outputs MUST NOT trigger replacement.", "sourceParagraph": 1624 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Persons, accounts, sessions, languages, and AI-product observations MUST", "sourceParagraph": 1626 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain distinct units.", "sourceParagraph": 1627 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Design weights, nonresponse adjustments, calibration, trimming, clustering,", "sourceParagraph": 1629 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "paired observations, and effective sample size MUST be documented.", "sourceParagraph": 1630 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Any post-result change to quotas, strata, pools, weights, exclusions, or", "sourceParagraph": 1632 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sample targets MUST create a new analysis version and preserve the original", "sourceParagraph": 1633 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "record.", "sourceParagraph": 1634 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1635 }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "For each AI product and main measurement wave, the GEO-1000 Population Panel should target at least 1,000 valid product-observations unless a different target is explicitly justified. Sample allocation should be designed, finalised, and locked before AI responses are seen. The main allocation should be based on the product-eligible target human population, not on total country population, number of invitations, accounts, sessions, or convenience samples. Fractional quotas should be announced in advance and rounded to whole numbers using a method independent of the results. Groups with a positive population mass cannot be assigned a deterministic zero probability of selection when making inferences for the entire target population. Over-sampled groups cannot use raw sample shares as population weights. Incorrect, negative, rejected, or Critical AI output cannot be a reason for participant replacement.", "sourceParagraph": 1636 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Für jedes KI-Produkt und jede Hauptmesswelle SOLLTE das GEO-1000-Bevölkerungs-Panel mindestens 1,000 gültige Produktbeobachtungen anvisieren, es sei denn, ein anderes Ziel wird ausdrücklich gerechtfertigt. Die Stichprobenzuweisung MUSS entworfen, versioniert und festgeschrieben werden, bevor KI-Antworten beobachtet werden. Die primäre Zuweisung MUSS auf der produktberechtigten Zielpopulation basieren, nicht auf der rohen Wohnbevölkerung, Einladungszahlen, Konten, Sitzungen oder bequemer Verfügbarkeit. Bruchteilige Zuweisungen MÜSSEN unter Verwendung einer vorab erklärten, reproduzierbaren und ergebnisunabhängigen Methode in Ganzzahlquoten umgewandelt werden. Populationen mit positiver Zielpopulationsmasse DÜRFEN NICHT deterministisch mit einer Selektionswahrscheinlichkeit von null versehen werden, wenn die Prüfung Rückschlüsse auf die gesamte Zielpopulation beansprucht. Kleine Populationen KÖNNEN durch gerechtfertigte zusammengefasste Schichten und wahrscheinlichkeitsproportionale Auswahl vertreten werden. Beobachtungen von Länderbeobachtern, Sprachfairness und Barrierefreiheit KÖNNEN das Hauptpanel ergänzen, MÜSSEN jedoch separat gekennzeichnet und angemessen neu gewichtet bleiben. Überrepräsentierte Gruppen DÜRFEN ihren Rohstichprobenanteil NICHT als Populationsgewicht erhalten. Der Ersatz von Teilnehmern MUSS ausschließlich auf vorab festgelegte Rekrutierungs- oder protokollgültige Bedingungen basieren. Falsche, negative, verweigerte oder kritische KI-Ausgaben DÜRFEN keinen Ersatz auslösen. Personen, Konten, Sitzungen, Sprachen und KI-Produktbeobachtungen MÜSSEN getrennte Einheiten bleiben. Designgewichte, Nichtantwortanpassungen, Kalibrierung, Trimmung, Clusterbildung, gepaarte Beobachtungen und effektive Stichprobengröße MÜSSEN dokumentiert werden. Jede nachträgliche Änderung von Quoten, Schichten, Pools, Gewichten, Ausschlüssen oder Stichprobenzielen MUSS eine neue Analyseversion erstellen und den ursprünglichen Datensatz erhalten.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH06-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "58. MASCHINENLESBARER ZUORDNUNGSRECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationShare\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 1515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawQuota\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"withinPoolSelection\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"method\": \"PPS_BERECHTIGTE_BEVÖLKERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-H\",", "sourceParagraph": 1522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 1500000,", "sourceParagraph": 1523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.75", "sourceParagraph": 1524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-I\",", "sourceParagraph": 1527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 400000,", "sourceParagraph": 1528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.2", "sourceParagraph": 1529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", "sourceParagraph": 1532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eligiblePopulation\": 100000,", "sourceParagraph": 1533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conditionalSelectionShare\": 0.05", "sourceParagraph": 1534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supplementaryPanels\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countrySentinel\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 3,", "sourceParagraph": 1543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedCountries\": [\"SYN-H\", \"SYN-I\", \"SYN-J\"],", "sourceParagraph": 1544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryScoresFromSingleObservationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPopulationEstimateWithFullSentinelWeight\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 50,", "sourceParagraph": 1549, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oversampledLanguage\": \"SYN-LANG-Y\",", "sourceParagraph": 1550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reweightToPopulation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1552, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessibility\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValid\": 40,", "sourceParagraph": 1554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"separateDiagnosticReporting\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1556, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedCompletionRate\": 0.82,", "sourceParagraph": 1559, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedProtocolValidityRate\": 0.92,", "sourceParagraph": 1560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plannedInvitationsMainPanel\": 1326,", "sourceParagraph": 1561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reserveListsPreselected\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseContentMayTriggerReplacement\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1563, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityReviewBeforeSemanticScoring\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"weights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1566, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"baseDesignWeight\": \"GEGENSEITIGE_AUSWAHLWAHRSCHEINLICHKEIT\",\"", "sourceParagraph": 1567, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": \"VORDEFINIERTE_ANTWORTKLASSEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"kalibrierung\": \"LAND_SPRACHE_SUMMEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"kürzung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1570, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aktiviert\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1571, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ifEnabledRequiresNewAnalysisVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveSampleSizeRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1575, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonFrames\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachAllocation\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupportAllocation\": \"GETRENNTER_DATENSATZ_ERFORDERLICH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1578, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allocationApprovedBeforeResponses\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"STICHPROBEN_DESIGN_INHABER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1582, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 1583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resultDrivenChangesProhibited\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1586, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es handelt sich nicht um tatsächliche Produkt- oder Länderdaten,", "sourceParagraph": 1589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es handelt sich nicht um einen tatsächlichen Stichprobenplan.", "sourceParagraph": 1590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist eine synthetische Repräsentation der reproduzierbaren Zuordnungsstruktur.", "sourceParagraph": 1591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 59", "sourceParagraph": 1593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH06-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1594, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Für jedes KI-Produkt und jede Hauptmesswelle, das GEO-1000", "sourceParagraph": 1596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Population Panel SOLLTE mindestens 1,000 gültige Produktbeobachtungen anstreben", "sourceParagraph": 1597, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es sei denn, ein anderes Ziel wird ausdrücklich gerechtfertigt.", "sourceParagraph": 1598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Probenzuweisung MUSS vor der KI entworfen, versioniert und festgeschrieben werden", "sourceParagraph": 1600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antworten werden beobachtet.", "sourceParagraph": 1601, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die primäre Zuweisung MUSS auf der produktberechtigten Zielpopulation basieren,", "sourceParagraph": 1603, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht rohe Wohnbevölkerung, Einladunganzahlen, Konten, Sitzungen oder", "sourceParagraph": 1604, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verfügbarkeitskomfort.", "sourceParagraph": 1605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bruchanteile MÜSSEN unter Verwendung einer ganzen Zahlquoten in Ganzzahlen umgewandelt werden", "sourceParagraph": 1607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "vordeklarierte, reproduzierbare, ergebnisunabhängige Methode.", "sourceParagraph": 1608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Populationen mit positiver Masse DÜRFEN NICHT deterministisch auf Null gesetzt werden", "sourceParagraph": 1610, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Auswahlwahrscheinlichkeit, wenn die Prüfung eine Schlussfolgerung auf die gesamte Zielgruppe zieht", "sourceParagraph": 1611, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevölkerung. Kleine Bevölkerungen KÖNNEN durch gerechtfertigtes Zusammenfassen repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 1612, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Schichten und wahrscheinlichkeitsskalierte Auswahl.", "sourceParagraph": 1613, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beobachtungen des Länderbeobachters, Sprachgerechtigkeit und Barrierefreiheit KÖNNEN", "sourceParagraph": 1615, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "die Haupttafel ergänzen, MUSS aber separat gekennzeichnet bleiben und", "sourceParagraph": 1616, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "angemessen neu gewichtet.", "sourceParagraph": 1617, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Überabgetastete Gruppen DÜRFEN ihren rohen Stichprobenanteil nicht als Bevölkerung erhalten", "sourceParagraph": 1619, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gewicht.", "sourceParagraph": 1620, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Ersatz von Teilnehmern MUSS ausschließlich auf vorab angekündigter Rekrutierung basieren oder", "sourceParagraph": 1622, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Protokoll-Gültigkeitsbedingungen. Falsche, negative, abgelehnte oder kritische KI", "sourceParagraph": 1623, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ausgaben dürfen keinen Ersatz auslösen.", "sourceParagraph": 1624, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Personen, Konten, Sitzungen, Sprachen und KI-Produktbeobachtungen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 1626, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bleiben eigenständige Einheiten.", "sourceParagraph": 1627, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Designgewichte, Nichtantwortanpassungen, Kalibrierung, Trimmen, Clustering,", "sourceParagraph": 1629, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gepaarte Beobachtungen und effektive Stichprobengröße MÜSSEN dokumentiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1630, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jegliche nachträgliche Änderung der Quoten, Schichten, Pools, Gewichte, Ausschlüsse oder", "sourceParagraph": 1632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beispielziele MÜSSEN eine neue Analyseversion erstellen und das Original bewahren", "sourceParagraph": 1633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufzeichnen.", "sourceParagraph": 1634, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1635, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH06-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Für jedes KI-Produkt und jede Hauptmessungswelle sollte das GEO-1000-Populationspanel mindestens 1,000 gültige Produktbeobachtungen anstreben, sofern ein anderer Zielwert nicht ausdrücklich gerechtfertigt ist. Die Stichprobenverteilung sollte geplant, finalisiert und festgeschrieben werden, bevor KI-Antworten eingesehen werden. Die Hauptverteilung sollte auf der produktberechtigten Zielgruppe basieren, nicht auf der Gesamtbevölkerung des Landes, der Anzahl der Einladungen, Konten, Sitzungen oder Zufallsstichproben. Bruchquoten sollten im Voraus angekündigt und auf ganze Zahlen gerundet werden, wobei eine Methode verwendet wird, die unabhängig von den Ergebnissen ist. Gruppen mit einer positiven Bevölkerungsmasse können bei der Ableitung von Schlussfolgerungen für die gesamte Zielpopulation nicht mit einer deterministischen Nullwahrscheinlichkeit für die Auswahl belegt werden. Überproportional beprobte Gruppen können Rohprobenanteile nicht als Populationsgewichte verwenden. Falsche, negative, abgelehnte oder kritische KI-Ergebnisse können kein Grund für den Ersatz von Teilnehmern sein.", "sourceParagraph": 1636, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 7, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH07", "title": "Panels für Länderbeobachtung und Sprachgerechtigkeit", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K06", "K07", "K20" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH07-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "The GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language Fairness Panel MUST remain distinct in purpose, sampling, weighting, and public claims. A Country Observer observation MAY establish that an access condition, response, anomaly, or critical incident occurred in a defined country-product-language context. A Country Observer observation MUST NOT be represented as a country prevalence estimate or country GEO score. Country observation coverage, population-weighted observation coverage, and country estimation coverage MUST be reported separately. Every eligible country SHOULD receive a positive probability of observation within a predeclared surveillance cycle, unless it is explicitly outside the product's lawful Native Reach. Language fairness MUST evaluate materially comparable representation under semantically equivalent prompts and comparable contexts. It MUST NOT require word-for-word identical responses or ignore legitimate local differences. Oversampled languages MUST be reweighted to their target population shares for global population estimates. Population-weighted scores, equal-language diagnostic scores, language floors, critical-error rates, unknown rates, and untested languages MUST remain separately visible. A language disparity MUST NOT be attributed solely to the AI product before prompt equivalence, reference parity, measurement parity, and adjudication parity are assessed. A single observation MAY carry multiple diagnostic panel tags, but MUST NOT receive duplicate full population weight. Critical Observer incidents MAY trigger confirmatory sampling and conformity review without being treated as evidence of country prevalence.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "GEO-1000 Population Panel, Ülke Gözcü Paneli ve Dil Adaleti Paneli amaç, örneklem, ağırlık ve kamu iddiası bakımından ayrı tutulmalıdır. Tek bir ülke gözcü gözlemi belirli ülke–ürün–dil bağlamında bir erişim durumunun, cevabın, anomalinin veya Critical olayın meydana geldiğini gösterebilir; ülke yaygınlık tahmini veya ülke GEO skoru olarak sunulamaz. Ülke sayısı kapsamı, nüfus ağırlıklı kapsam ve ülke tahmin kapsamı ayrı raporlanmalıdır. Dil adaleti, semantik olarak eşdeğer promptlarda ve karşılaştırılabilir koşullarda maddi temsili değerlendirmeli; kelime kelime aynı cevap istememeli ve meşru yerel farkları yok saymamalıdır. Fazla örneklenen diller global nüfus tahmininde gerçek hedef nüfus paylarına geri ağırlıklandırılmalıdır.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH07-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "47. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1460 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1461 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1462 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SF-3\": 17", "sourceParagraph": 1463 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1464 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1465 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryObservationCoverageCount\": 0.3167,", "sourceParagraph": 1466 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryObservationCoveragePopulation\": 0.97,", "sourceParagraph": 1467 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryEstimationCoverage\": 0.1167", "sourceParagraph": 1468 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1469 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentinelObservationsCreateCountryScores\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1470 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"alarms\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1471 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1472 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", "sourceParagraph": 1473 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"alarmType\": \"SA-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1474 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"CONFIRMATORY_SAMPLE_REQUIRED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1475 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryPrevalenceClaimAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1476 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1477 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1478 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1479 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1480 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageRegistryVersion\": \"LF-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1481 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"inScopeLanguages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1482 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1483 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1484 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1485 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.55,", "sourceParagraph": 1486 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 550,", "sourceParagraph": 1487 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1488 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.95", "sourceParagraph": 1489 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1490 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1491 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1492 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1493 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.25,", "sourceParagraph": 1494 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 250,", "sourceParagraph": 1495 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1496 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.92", "sourceParagraph": 1497 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1498 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1499 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1500 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1501 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.10,", "sourceParagraph": 1502 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 100,", "sourceParagraph": 1503 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1504 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.88", "sourceParagraph": 1505 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1506 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1507 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1508 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1509 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.06,", "sourceParagraph": 1510 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 1511 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 140,", "sourceParagraph": 1512 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.65,", "sourceParagraph": 1513 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1514 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1515 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"PASSED\"", "sourceParagraph": 1516 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1517 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1518 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1520 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.04,", "sourceParagraph": 1521 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 40,", "sourceParagraph": 1522 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 160,", "sourceParagraph": 1523 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.58,", "sourceParagraph": 1524 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1525 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1526 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"PASSED\"", "sourceParagraph": 1527 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1528 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1529 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"globalPopulationWeightedScore\": 0.9027,", "sourceParagraph": 1530 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalLanguageDiagnosticScore\": 0.796,", "sourceParagraph": 1531 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFloor\": 0.58,", "sourceParagraph": 1532 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"maxLanguageGap\": 0.37,", "sourceParagraph": 1533 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oversamplesReweightedToPopulation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1534 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allLanguagesClaimAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1535 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1536 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1537 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRolesKeptSeparate\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1538 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"duplicateFullWeightingProhibited\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1539 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"COUNTRY_LANGUAGE_PANEL_OWNER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1540 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 1541 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1542 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1543 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1544 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1545 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "this is not real country or language data,", "sourceParagraph": 1546 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "this is not actual AI performance,", "sourceParagraph": 1547 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "it is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the panel distinction.", "sourceParagraph": 1548 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 48", "sourceParagraph": 1550 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH07-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1551 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language", "sourceParagraph": 1553 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fairness Panel MUST remain distinct in purpose, sampling, weighting, and", "sourceParagraph": 1554 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "public claims.", "sourceParagraph": 1555 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A Country Observer observation MAY establish that an access condition,", "sourceParagraph": 1557 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "response, anomaly, or critical incident occurred in a defined", "sourceParagraph": 1558 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "country-product-language context.", "sourceParagraph": 1559 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A Country Observer observation MUST NOT be represented as a country prevalence", "sourceParagraph": 1561 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "estimate or country GEO score.", "sourceParagraph": 1562 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Country observation coverage, population-weighted observation coverage,", "sourceParagraph": 1564 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and country estimation coverage MUST be reported separately.", "sourceParagraph": 1565 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every eligible country SHOULD receive a positive probability of", "sourceParagraph": 1567 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "observation within a predeclared surveillance cycle, unless it is", "sourceParagraph": 1568 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "explicitly outside the product's lawful Native Reach.", "sourceParagraph": 1569 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Language fairness MUST evaluate materially comparable representation", "sourceParagraph": 1571 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "under semantically equivalent prompts and comparable contexts. It MUST", "sourceParagraph": 1572 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT require word-for-word identical responses or ignore legitimate local", "sourceParagraph": 1573 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "differences.", "sourceParagraph": 1574 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Oversampled languages MUST be reweighted to their target population", "sourceParagraph": 1576 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "shares for global population estimates.", "sourceParagraph": 1577 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Population-weighted scores, equal-language diagnostic scores, language", "sourceParagraph": 1579 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "floors, critical-error rates, unknown rates, and untested languages MUST", "sourceParagraph": 1580 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain separately visible.", "sourceParagraph": 1581 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A language disparity MUST NOT be attributed solely to the AI product", "sourceParagraph": 1583 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "before prompt equivalence, reference parity, measurement parity, and", "sourceParagraph": 1584 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "adjudication parity are assessed.", "sourceParagraph": 1585 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single observation MAY carry multiple diagnostic panel tags, but MUST", "sourceParagraph": 1587 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT receive duplicate full population weight.", "sourceParagraph": 1588 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical Observer incidents MAY trigger confirmatory sampling and", "sourceParagraph": 1590 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conformity review without being treated as evidence of country", "sourceParagraph": 1591 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "prevalence.", "sourceParagraph": 1592 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1593 }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "GEO-1000 Population Panel, Country Observer Panel, and Language Fairness Panel should be kept separate in terms of purpose, sample, weighting, and public claim. A single Country Observer observation can show that a certain access condition, response, anomaly, or critical event has occurred in a specific country–product–language context; it cannot be presented as a country prevalence estimate or country GEO score. Country coverage, population-weighted coverage, and country estimate coverage should be reported separately. Language fairness should assess material representation in semantically equivalent prompts and comparable conditions; it should not demand word-for-word identical responses and should not ignore legitimate local differences. Over-sampled languages should be reweighted to reflect the actual target population shares in global population estimates.", "sourceParagraph": 1594 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Das GEO-1000 Bevölkerungspanel, das Länderbeobachter-Panel und das Sprachfairness-Panel MÜSSEN sich in Zweck, Stichprobe, Gewichtung und öffentlichen Aussagen unterscheiden. Eine Länderbeobachter-Beobachtung KANN feststellen, dass eine Zugangsbedingung, Antwort, Anomalie oder ein kritischer Vorfall in einem definierten Länder-Produkt-Sprach-Kontext aufgetreten ist. Eine Länderbeobachter-Beobachtung DARF NICHT als Länderprävalenzschätzung oder Länder-GEO-Score repräsentiert werden. Die Abdeckung der Länderbeobachtung, die bevölkerungsgewichtete Beobachtungsabdeckung und die Länderabschätzungsabdeckung MÜSSEN separat berichtet werden. Jedes berechtigte Land SOLLTE innerhalb eines vorher festgelegten Überwachungszyklus eine positive Wahrscheinlichkeit für eine Beobachtung erhalten, es sei denn, es liegt ausdrücklich außerhalb der gesetzlichen Natürliche Reichweite des Produkts. Die Sprachgerechtigkeit MUSS eine materiell vergleichbare Repräsentation unter semantisch gleichwertigen Aufforderungen und vergleichbaren Kontexten bewerten. Sie DARF NICHT wortwörtlich identische Antworten verlangen oder legitime lokale Unterschiede ignorieren. Übermäßig gesampelte Sprachen MÜSSEN für globale Bevölkerungs­schätzungen auf ihre Zielbevölkerungsanteile umgewichtet werden. Bevölkerungsgewichtete Punktzahlen, gleichsprachige Diagnosewerte, Sprachuntergrenzen, kritische Fehlerraten, unbekannte Raten und ungetestete Sprachen MÜSSEN gesondert sichtbar bleiben. Eine Sprachunterschied MUSS NICHT ausschließlich dem KI-Produkt zugeschrieben werden, bevor die Gleichwertigkeit der Prompt, die Referenzgleichheit, die Messgleichheit und die Adjudikationsgleichheit bewertet wurden. Eine einzelne Beobachtung KANN mehrere diagnostische Panel-Tags tragen, darf jedoch nicht mit doppeltem Gesamtpopulation-Gewicht versehen werden. Kritische Beobachtervorfälle KÖNNEN eine Bestätigungsstichprobe und Konformitätsprüfung auslösen, ohne als Nachweis für die Prävalenz im Land behandelt zu werden.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH07-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "47. MASCHINENLESBARES PANEL-DATENBLATT", "sourceParagraph": 1460, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SF-3\": 17", "sourceParagraph": 1463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metriken\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1465, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryObservationCoverageCount\": 0.316 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryObservationCoveragePopulation\": 0.97,", "sourceParagraph": 1467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryEstimationCoverage\": 0.116 7", "sourceParagraph": 1468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1469, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentinelObservationsCreateCountryScores\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"alarme\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCode\": \"SYN-J\",", "sourceParagraph": 1473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"alarmType\": \"SA-5\",\"", "sourceParagraph": 1474, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"BESTÄTIGENDE_PROBE_ERFORDERLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryPrevalenceClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1477, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFairness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageRegistryVersion\": \"LF-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"inScopeLanguages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1483, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1484, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1485, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.55,", "sourceParagraph": 1486, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 550,", "sourceParagraph": 1487, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1488, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.95", "sourceParagraph": 1489, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1490, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1491, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1492, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1493, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.25,", "sourceParagraph": 1494, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 250,", "sourceParagraph": 1495, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1496, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.92", "sourceParagraph": 1497, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1498, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1499, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1500, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1501, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.10,", "sourceParagraph": 1502, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 100,", "sourceParagraph": 1503, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1504, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.88", "sourceParagraph": 1505, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1506, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1507, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1508, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1509, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.06,", "sourceParagraph": 1510, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 1511, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 140,", "sourceParagraph": 1512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.65,", "sourceParagraph": 1513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageId\": \"SYN-L5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"LS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 1520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationWeight\": 0.04,", "sourceParagraph": 1521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationPanelValid\": 40,", "sourceParagraph": 1522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessOversampleValid\": 160,", "sourceParagraph": 1523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"estimatedRepresentation\": 0.58,", "sourceParagraph": 1524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptEquivalence\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceParity\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationParity\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"globalPopulationWeightedScore\": 0.902 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalLanguageDiagnosticScore\": 0.796,", "sourceParagraph": 1531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageFloor\": 0.58,", "sourceParagraph": 1532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"maxLanguageGap\": 0.37,", "sourceParagraph": 1533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oversamplesReweightedToPopulation\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allLanguagesClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRolesKeptSeparate\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"duplicateFullWeightingProhibited\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanRole\": \"LAND_SPRACHE_PANEL_EIGENTÜMER\"", "sourceParagraph": 1540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 1541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dies ist keine echte Länder- oder Sprachendaten,", "sourceParagraph": 1546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dies ist keine tatsächliche KI-Leistung,", "sourceParagraph": 1547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es ist eine maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation der Panel-Unterscheidung.", "sourceParagraph": 1548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 48", "sourceParagraph": 1550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH07-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "das GEO-1000 Bevölkerungs-Panel, Länderbeobachter-Panel und Sprache", "sourceParagraph": 1553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fairness-Panel MUSS in Zweck, Stichprobe, Gewichtung und", "sourceParagraph": 1554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "öffentlichen Behauptungen unterscheiden bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine Länderbeobachter-Beobachtung KANN feststellen, dass eine Zugangsbedingung,", "sourceParagraph": 1557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antwort, Anomalie oder kritischer Vorfall in einem definierten Bereich aufgetreten ist", "sourceParagraph": 1558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Land-Produkt-Sprachkontext.", "sourceParagraph": 1559, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Beobachtung durch einen Länderbeobachter DARF NICHT als Länderprävalenz repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 1561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Schätzung oder Länder-GEO-Score.", "sourceParagraph": 1562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abdeckung der Länderbeobachtung, bevölkerungsgewichtete Beobachtungsabdeckung,", "sourceParagraph": 1564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und Abdeckung der Länderschätzung MUSS separat berichtet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jedes berechtigte Land SOLLTE eine positive Wahrscheinlichkeit der", "sourceParagraph": 1567, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beobachtung innerhalb eines vorher festgelegten Überwachungszyklus erhalten, sofern es nicht", "sourceParagraph": 1568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "explizit außerhalb des rechtmäßigen Natürliche Reichweite des Produkts liegt.", "sourceParagraph": 1569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sprachfairness MUSS eine materiell vergleichbare Repräsentation bewerten", "sourceParagraph": 1571, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unter semantisch äquivalenten Eingaben und vergleichbaren Kontexten. Es MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 1572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NICHT wortwörtlich identische Antworten erfordern oder legitime lokale", "sourceParagraph": 1573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unterschiede ignorieren.", "sourceParagraph": 1574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Überrepräsentierte Sprachen MÜSSEN an ihre Zielanteile in der", "sourceParagraph": 1576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gesamtbevölkerung angepasst werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevölkerungsgewichtete Punktzahlen, gleichsprachige Diagnostikwerte, Sprach", "sourceParagraph": 1579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "untergrenzen, kritische Fehlerquoten, Unbekannt-Quoten und ungetestete Sprachen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 1580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separat sichtbar bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Sprachdiskrepanz DARF NICHT ausschließlich dem KI-Produkt zugeschrieben werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bevor Aufforderungsäquivalenz, Referenzparität, Messparität und", "sourceParagraph": 1584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Entscheidungsparität beurteilt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine einzelne Beobachtung KANN mehrere diagnostische Panel-Tags tragen, darf aber", "sourceParagraph": 1587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NICHT dasselbe Gewicht der Gesamtpopulation doppelt erhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 1588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kritische Beobachter-Vorfälle KÖNNEN bestätigende Stichproben und", "sourceParagraph": 1590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Konformitätsprüfung auslösen, ohne als Nachweis für eine Länder-", "sourceParagraph": 1591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Prävalenz behandelt zu werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH07-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "GEO-1000 Bevölkerungspanel, Länderbeobachter-Panel und Sprachgerechtigkeits-Panel sollten in Bezug auf Zweck, Stichprobe, Gewichtung und öffentliche Aussage getrennt gehalten werden. Eine einzelne Länderbeobachter-Beobachtung kann zeigen, dass eine bestimmte Zugangsbedingung, Antwort, Anomalie oder ein kritisches Ereignis in einem bestimmten Land–Produkt–Sprachkontext aufgetreten ist; sie kann nicht als Ländervorherrschaftsschätzung oder Länder-GEO-Score präsentiert werden. Die Länderabdeckung, die bevölkerungsgewichtete Abdeckung und die Abdeckung der Länderschätzung sollten getrennt berichtet werden. Sprachliche Fairness sollte die materielle Repräsentation in semantisch äquivalenten Eingaben und vergleichbaren Bedingungen bewerten; sie sollte keine wortwörtlich identischen Antworten verlangen und keine legitimen lokalen Unterschiede ignorieren. Übermäßig gesampelte Sprachen sollten neu gewichtet werden, um die tatsächlichen Zielpopulationsanteile in globalen Bevölkerungs-schätzungen widerzuspiegeln.", "sourceParagraph": 1594, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 8, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH08", "title": "Auswahl und Gewichtung der Teilnehmenden sowie Stichprobenverzerrung", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K05", "K06", "K07", "K08", "K22" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH08-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST retain an auditable participant-selection path from the target population and sampling frame through selection, invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol validation, exclusion, and final weighting. Within-panel random selection MUST NOT be represented as random selection from the global target population unless the full population inclusion mechanism supports that claim. Participant recruitment, assignment, compensation, validation, replacement, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable. Persons, accounts, devices, sessions, languages, panel memberships, and AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units. Probability, opt-in, open-call, client-supplied, institutional, and hybrid participant sources MUST be separately identified. Weighting MAY reduce observed imbalance, but MUST NOT be represented as creating observations for populations absent from the sampling frame or correcting unmeasured selection with certainty. Unweighted results, weighted results, weight diagnostics, coverage gaps, nonresponse, effective sample size, and sensitivity analyses MUST remain visible. Fraud and duplication decisions MUST use proportionate multi-signal review and MUST NOT automatically treat VPN use, shared devices, institutional networks, or accessibility tools as fabrication. Participant evidence MUST remain verifiable without unnecessarily disclosing identity, account credentials, private conversations, or precise location. Every participant-selection and weighting decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi hedef nüfus ve örnekleme çerçevesinden seçim, davet, rıza, görev ataması, tamamlama, protokol doğrulaması, dışlama ve nihai ağırlığa kadar denetlenebilir katılımcı seçim yolu taşımalıdır. Panel içindeki rastgele seçim, tam nüfus katılım mekanizması bunu desteklemedikçe küresel hedef nüfustan rastgele seçim olarak sunulamaz. Katılımcının seçilmesi, ödüllendirilmesi, doğrulanması, değiştirilmesi, dışlanması ve ağırlıklandırılması AI cevabının olumlu, olumsuz, doğru, yanlış, ret, Critical veya ticari bakımdan elverişli olmasına bağlı olamaz. Ağırlıklandırma gözlenen dengesizliği azaltabilir; örnekleme çerçevesinde hiç bulunmayan insanları gözlenmiş hâle getiremez.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH08-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "57. MACHINE-READABLE PARTICIPANT RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1804 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1805 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1806 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adultBaseline\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1807 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consentStatus\": \"GRANTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1808 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1809 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residenceCountry\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1810 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementCountry\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1811 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verificationLevel\": \"GV-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1812 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"vpnStatus\": \"NOT_DETECTED\"", "sourceParagraph": 1813 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1814 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1815 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedLanguage\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 1816 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1817 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"competenceStatus\": \"VERIFIED_FUNCTIONAL\"", "sourceParagraph": 1818 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1819 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiAccess\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1820 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1821 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"free\",", "sourceParagraph": 1822 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"web\",", "sourceParagraph": 1823 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessVerified\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1824 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sharedAccount\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1825 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1826 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1827 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationships\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1828 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditedEntityRelationship\": \"GENERAL_PUBLIC\",", "sourceParagraph": 1829 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProviderRelationship\": \"NONE_DECLARED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1830 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"brandFamiliarity\": \"AWARE_NON_CUSTOMER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1831 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiUsageFrequency\": \"OCCASIONAL\"", "sourceParagraph": 1832 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1833 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignment\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1834 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1835 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"stratumId\": \"TR-TR-FREE-WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1836 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAssignmentMethod\": \"BLOCK_RANDOMIZED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1837 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptId\": \"CORE-IDENTITY-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1838 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 1839 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorBenchmarkExposure\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1840 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1841 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incentive\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1842 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"type\": \"FIXED_COMPLETION_PAYMENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1843 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseContentDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1844 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speedBonus\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1845 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1846 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"completion\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1847 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"invited\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1848 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consented\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1849 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"started\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1850 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"completed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1851 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolValidity\": \"VALID\",", "sourceParagraph": 1852 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"semanticOutcomeUsedForValidityDecision\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1853 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1854 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1855 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fraudStatus\": \"FI-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1856 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"duplicateCheck\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1857 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"crossProviderDuplicateCheck\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1858 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanReviewRequired\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1859 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1860 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"weights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1861 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"baseWeightType\": \"MODEL_CALIBRATION_WEIGHT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1862 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"designProbabilityKnown\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1863 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": 1.08,", "sourceParagraph": 1864 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"calibrationAdjustment\": 1.24,", "sourceParagraph": 1865 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalWeight\": 1.3392,", "sourceParagraph": 1866 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"outcomeUsedInWeighting\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1867 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1868 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1869 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicIdentityDisclosure\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1870 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"screenshotRedactionRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1871 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicEvidenceManifest\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1872 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"CONTROLLED_AUDIT_ACCESS\"", "sourceParagraph": 1873 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1874 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1875 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"selectionOwnerRole\": \"PARTICIPANT_SELECTION_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 1876 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityReviewerRole\": \"BLINDED_PROTOCOL_VALIDATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1877 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1878 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1879 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1880 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1881 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It does not belong to a real participant,", "sourceParagraph": 1882 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is not real panel data,", "sourceParagraph": 1883 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a synthetic machine diagram of the participant selection chain.", "sourceParagraph": 1884 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Chapter 58 machine-readable rule", "sourceParagraph": 1886 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH08-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1887 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST retain an auditable participant-selection", "sourceParagraph": 1889 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "path from the target population and sampling frame through selection,", "sourceParagraph": 1890 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol validation,", "sourceParagraph": 1891 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "exclusion, and final weighting.", "sourceParagraph": 1892 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Within-panel random selection MUST NOT be represented as random selection", "sourceParagraph": 1894 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "from the global target population unless the full population inclusion", "sourceParagraph": 1895 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "mechanism supports that claim.", "sourceParagraph": 1896 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Participant recruitment, assignment, compensation, validation,", "sourceParagraph": 1898 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "replacement, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether", "sourceParagraph": 1899 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused,", "sourceParagraph": 1900 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "critical, or commercially favourable.", "sourceParagraph": 1901 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Persons, accounts, devices, sessions, languages, panel memberships, and", "sourceParagraph": 1903 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI-product observations MUST remain distinct units.", "sourceParagraph": 1904 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Probability, opt-in, open-call, client-supplied, institutional, and hybrid", "sourceParagraph": 1906 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "participant sources MUST be separately identified.", "sourceParagraph": 1907 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Weighting MAY reduce observed imbalance, but MUST NOT be represented as", "sourceParagraph": 1909 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "creating observations for populations absent from the sampling frame or", "sourceParagraph": 1910 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "correcting unmeasured selection with certainty.", "sourceParagraph": 1911 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unweighted results, weighted results, weight diagnostics, coverage gaps,", "sourceParagraph": 1913 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nonresponse, effective sample size, and sensitivity analyses MUST remain", "sourceParagraph": 1914 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "visible.", "sourceParagraph": 1915 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fraud and duplication decisions MUST use proportionate multi-signal", "sourceParagraph": 1917 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "review and MUST NOT automatically treat VPN use, shared devices,", "sourceParagraph": 1918 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "institutional networks, or accessibility tools as fabrication.", "sourceParagraph": 1919 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Participant evidence MUST remain verifiable without unnecessarily", "sourceParagraph": 1921 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "disclosing identity, account credentials, private conversations, or", "sourceParagraph": 1922 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "precise location.", "sourceParagraph": 1923 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every participant-selection and weighting decision MUST be versioned and", "sourceParagraph": 1925 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 1926 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1927 }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation must carry a verifiable participant selection path from target population and sampling frame through selection, invitation, consent, assignment, completion, protocol verification, exclusion, and final weighting. Random selection within the panel cannot be presented as random selection from the global target population unless the full population participation mechanism supports it. The participant's selection, reward, verification, modification, exclusion, and weighting cannot depend on whether the AI response is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, rejected, Critical, or commercially viable. Weighting can reduce observed imbalance; it cannot make people who are completely absent from the sampling frame appear observed.", "sourceParagraph": 1928 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung MUSS einen prüfbaren Teilnehmerauswahlpfad von der Zielpopulation und dem Stichprobenrahmen über Auswahl, Einladung, Einwilligung, Zuordnung, Abschluss, Protokollvalidierung, Ausschluss bis hin zur endgültigen Gewichtung beibehalten. Die zufällige Auswahl innerhalb des Panels DARF NICHT als zufällige Auswahl aus der globalen Zielpopulation repräsentiert werden, es sei denn, der Mechanismus zur Einbeziehung der gesamten Population unterstützt diese Behauptung. Die Teilnehmerrekrutierung, Zuordnung, Vergütung, Validierung, Ersetzung, Ausschluss und Gewichtung MÜSSEN unabhängig davon bleiben, ob die KI-Antwort positiv, negativ, korrekt, inkorrekt, abgelehnt, kritisch oder kommerziell günstig ist. Personen, Konten, Geräte, Sitzungen, Sprachen, Panelmitgliedschaften und KI-Produktbeobachtungen MÜSSEN als eigenständige Einheiten erhalten bleiben. Wahrscheinlichkeits-, Opt-in-, Open-Call-, vom Kunden bereitgestellte, institutionelle und hybride Teilnehmerquellen MÜSSEN separat identifiziert werden. Gewichtung KANN Ungleichgewichte verringern, DARF jedoch nicht so repräsentiert werden, dass sie Beobachtungen für Populationen erzeugt, die im Stichprobenrahmen fehlen, oder nicht gemessene Auswahl mit Sicherheit korrigiert. Ungewichtete Ergebnisse, gewichtete Ergebnisse, Gewichtungsdiagnosen, Abdeckungslücken, Nichtantworten, effektive Stichprobengröße und Sensitivitätsanalysen MÜSSEN sichtbar bleiben. Entscheidungen über Betrug und Duplikation MÜSSEN eine verhältnismäßige Überprüfung mit mehreren Signalen verwenden und DÜRFEN die Nutzung von VPNs, geteilten Geräten, institutionellen Netzwerken oder Barrierefreiheits-Tools NICHT automatisch als Fälschung behandeln. Nachweise von Teilnehmern MÜSSEN überprüfbar bleiben, ohne unnötig Identität, Kontodaten, private Gespräche oder genauen Standort offenzulegen. Jede Entscheidung über die Auswahl und Gewichtung von Teilnehmenden MUSS versioniert und einem verantwortlichen Menschen oder einer Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH08-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "57. MASCHINENLESBARES TEILNEHMERPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 1804, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1805, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1806, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adultBaseline\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1807, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consentStatus\": \"GEWÄHRT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1808, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"land\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1809, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"residenceCountry\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1810, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementCountry\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1811, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verificationLevel\": \"GV-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1812, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"vpnStatus\": \"NICHT_ERKANNT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1813, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1814, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sprache\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1815, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedLanguage\": \"tr\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1816, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1817, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"competenceStatus\": \"VERIFIZIERTE_FUNKTIONALITÄT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1818, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1819, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiAccess\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1820, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1821, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"kostenlos\",", "sourceParagraph": 1822, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"web\",", "sourceParagraph": 1823, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessVerified\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1824, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sharedAccount\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1825, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1826, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1827, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationships\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1828, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditedEntityRelationship\": \"ALLGEMEINE_ÖFFENTLICHKEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1829, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProviderRelationship\": \"KEINE_ANGEGEBEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1830, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"brandFamiliarity\": \"BEWUSST_NICHT_KUNDE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1831, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiUsageFrequency\": \"GELEGENHEITLICH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1832, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1833, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignment\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1834, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1835, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"stratumId\": \"TR-TR-KOSTENLOS-WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1836, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productAssignmentMethod\": \"ZUFÄLLIG_BLOCKIERT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1837, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptId\": \"CORE-IDENTITY-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1838, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 1839, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorBenchmarkExposure\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1840, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1841, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Anreiz\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1842, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Typ\": \"FESTGELEGTE_ABSCHLUSSZAHLUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1843, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseContentDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1844, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speedBonus\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1845, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1846, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Abschluss\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1847, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eingeladen\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1848, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"einverstanden\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1849, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"gestartet\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1850, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"abgeschlossen\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1851, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolValidity\": \"GÜLTIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1852, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"semanticOutcomeUsedForValidityDecision\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1853, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1854, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1855, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fraudStatus\": \"FI-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1856, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"duplicateCheck\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1857, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"crossProviderDuplicateCheck\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1858, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanReviewRequired\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1859, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1860, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"weights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1861, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"baseWeightType\": \"MODELL_KALIBRIERUNG_GEWICHT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1862, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"designProbabilityKnown\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1863, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonresponseAdjustment\": 1.08,", "sourceParagraph": 1864, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"calibrationAdjustment\": 1.24,", "sourceParagraph": 1865, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalWeight\": 1.339 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1866, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"outcomeUsedInWeighting\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1867, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1868, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Privatsphäre\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1869, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicIdentityDisclosure\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1870, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"screenshotRedactionRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1871, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicEvidenceManifest\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1872, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"GEREGELTER_PRÜFZUGANG\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1873, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1874, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1875, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"selectionOwnerRole\": \"TEILNEHMER_AUSWAHL_LEITER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1876, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validityReviewerRole\": \"GEBLENDETER_PROTOKOLL_PRÜFER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1877, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1878, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1879, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1880, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1881, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es gehört zu keinem echten Teilnehmer,", "sourceParagraph": 1882, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es handelt sich nicht um echte Paneldaten,", "sourceParagraph": 1883, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist ein synthetisches Maschinendiagramm der Teilnehmerauswahlkette.", "sourceParagraph": 1884, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kapitel 58 maschinenlesbare Regel", "sourceParagraph": 1886, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH08-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1887, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung MUSS einen überprüfbaren Teilnehmerauswahlpfad", "sourceParagraph": 1889, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "von der Zielpopulation und der Stichprobenbasis über Auswahl,", "sourceParagraph": 1890, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einladung, Zustimmung, Zuordnung, Abschluss, Protokollvalidierung,", "sourceParagraph": 1891, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ausschluss und endgültige Gewichtung beibehalten.", "sourceParagraph": 1892, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die zufällige Auswahl innerhalb des Panels DARF NICHT als zufällige Auswahl", "sourceParagraph": 1894, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "aus der globalen Zielpopulation dargestellt werden, es sei denn, der Mechanismus", "sourceParagraph": 1895, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zur vollständigen Einbeziehung der Population unterstützt diese Behauptung.", "sourceParagraph": 1896, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Teilnehmerrekrutierung, Zuweisung, Vergütung, Validierung,", "sourceParagraph": 1898, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ersatz, Ausschluss und Gewichtung MÜSSEN unabhängig davon bleiben, ob", "sourceParagraph": 1899, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "die KI-Antwort positiv, negativ, korrekt, inkorrekt, verweigert,", "sourceParagraph": 1900, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kritisch oder kommerziell günstig ist.", "sourceParagraph": 1901, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Personen, Konten, Geräte, Sitzungen, Sprachen, Panelmitgliedschaften und", "sourceParagraph": 1903, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Produktbeobachtungen MÜSSEN als eigenständige Einheiten bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1904, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wahrscheinlichkeit, Opt-in, Open-Call, vom Kunden bereitgestellt, institutionell und hybrid", "sourceParagraph": 1906, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Teilnehmerquellen MÜSSEN separat identifiziert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1907, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gewichtung KANN das beobachtete Ungleichgewicht verringern, DARF ABER NICHT repräsentiert werden als", "sourceParagraph": 1909, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dass Beobachtungen für Populationen erzeugt werden, die im Stichprobenrahmen fehlen, oder", "sourceParagraph": 1910, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dass nicht gemessene Selektionen mit Sicherheit korrigiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1911, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ungewichtete Ergebnisse, gewichtete Ergebnisse, Gewichtungsdiagnostiken, Abdeckungslücken,", "sourceParagraph": 1913, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nichtantwort, effektive Stichprobengröße und Sensitivitätsanalysen MÜSSEN sichtbar bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1914, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 1915, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Entscheidungen zu Betrug und Duplikation MÜSSEN proportionale Multi-Signal-Verfahren verwenden.", "sourceParagraph": 1917, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "überprüfen und DARF die Nutzung von VPN, gemeinsam genutzten Geräten,", "sourceParagraph": 1918, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "institutionellen Netzwerken oder Hilfsmitteln zur Barrierefreiheit nicht automatisch als Fälschung behandeln.", "sourceParagraph": 1919, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Teilnehmernachweise MÜSSEN verifizierbar bleiben, ohne unnötigerweise", "sourceParagraph": 1921, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Identität, Kontodaten, private Gespräche oder", "sourceParagraph": 1922, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "genaue Standortangaben offenzulegen.", "sourceParagraph": 1923, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Entscheidung zur Teilnehmerauswahl und Gewichtung MUSS versioniert sein und", "sourceParagraph": 1925, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1926, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1927, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH08-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung muss einen überprüfbaren Pfad der Teilnehmerauswahl von der Zielpopulation und dem Stichprobenrahmen über Auswahl, Einladung, Zustimmung, Zuweisung, Abschluss, Protokollüberprüfung, Ausschluss und endgültige Gewichtung enthalten. Eine zufällige Auswahl innerhalb des Panels kann nicht als zufällige Auswahl aus der globalen Zielpopulation dargestellt werden, es sei denn, der vollständige Mechanismus zur Teilnahme der Population unterstützt dies. Die Auswahl, Belohnung, Überprüfung, Änderung, der Ausschluss und die Gewichtung der Teilnehmer dürfen nicht davon abhängen, ob die KI-Antwort positiv, negativ, korrekt, falsch, abgelehnt, kritisch oder kommerziell nutzbar ist. Gewichtung kann beobachtetes Ungleichgewicht verringern; sie kann jedoch Personen, die völlig vom Stichprobenrahmen ausgeschlossen sind, nicht als beobachtet erscheinen lassen.", "sourceParagraph": 1928, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 9, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH09", "title": "KI-Systemregister und Vergleichbarkeit", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K02", "K03" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH09-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a versioned AI System Register record describing the measured product instance, including as applicable: - provider, - product, - user surface, - plan, - displayed or verified model identity, - model-identity confidence, - retrieval and web configuration, - citation capability and use, - tool access and use, - session state, - memory, - custom instructions, - prior context, - personalisation, - country, - locale, - language, - deployment state, - measurement time, - and known or observed system changes. Provider name, product name, displayed model label, base model, retrieval system, and user-facing product MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable identities. Feature availability MUST remain distinct from feature use. Live-product results MUST NOT be represented as frozen-model results, and frozen-model results MUST NOT be represented as full consumer-product experience. Comparisons MUST define their object and receive a disclosed comparability level based on matched entity, prompt, population, language, country, time, session, plan, interface, retrieval, tools, reference records, and adjudication rules. The same provider or displayed model MUST NOT create an automatic assumption of comparability. Different providers MAY be compared when user-facing conditions are sufficiently aligned and the resulting claim is limited to the measured product behaviour. Material product changes during a measurement wave MUST create a separate system state, sub-wave, modelled change factor, or mixed-state warning. Unknown configuration fields MUST remain UNKNOWN and MUST NOT be imputed as controlled or equivalent. Every system-registry and comparability decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi; sağlayıcı, ürün, kullanıcı yüzeyi, plan, görünen veya doğrulanmış model kimliği, model kimliği güveni, retrieval ve web yapılandırması, citation kapasitesi ve kullanımı, araç erişimi, oturum durumu, hafıza, özel talimatlar, önceki bağlam, kişiselleştirme, ülke, locale, dil, dağıtım durumu, ölçüm zamanı ve bilinen sistem değişikliklerini ilgili olduğu ölçüde taşıyan sürümlü bir AI Sistem Sicili kaydına bağlanmalıdır. Sağlayıcı adı, ürün adı, görünen model etiketi, temel model, retrieval sistemi ve kullanıcı ürünü birbirinin yerine kullanılamaz. Aynı sağlayıcı veya model etiketi otomatik karşılaştırılabilirlik oluşturmaz. Farklı sağlayıcılar, kullanıcı koşulları yeterince eşleştirildiğinde ölçülen ürün davranışı bakımından karşılaştırılabilir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH09-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "54. MACHINE-READABLE AI SYSTEM RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1758 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1759 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1760 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1761 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1762 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiSystemRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1763 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-FREE-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1764 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"provider\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1765 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerId\": \"SYNTH-ORION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1766 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerName\": \"Orion Systems\"", "sourceParagraph": 1767 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1768 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"product\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1769 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1770 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productName\": \"Orion Chat\",", "sourceParagraph": 1771 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productType\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1772 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PT-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1773 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PT-2\"", "sourceParagraph": 1774 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1775 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1776 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"FREE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1777 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"applicationVersion\": \"6.1\"", "sourceParagraph": 1778 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1779 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"model\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1780 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"displayedLabel\": \"Orion Standard\",", "sourceParagraph": 1781 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityConfidence\": \"MI-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1782 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionedDeploymentId\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 1783 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dynamicRoutingPossible\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1784 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimAttributionLevel\": \"PRODUCT_SURFACE_ONLY\"", "sourceParagraph": 1785 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1786 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"knowledgeConfiguration\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1787 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mode\": \"KG-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1788 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webFeatureAvailable\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1789 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webFeatureEnabled\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1790 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webUseForObservation\": \"USED_CONFIRMED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1791 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationFeatureAvailable\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1792 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationsDisplayed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1793 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateKnowledgeSource\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1794 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1795 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tools\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1796 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"available\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1797 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1798 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1799 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"usedForObservation\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1800 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WEB_SEARCH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1801 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1802 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1803 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"session\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1804 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sessionType\": \"ST-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1805 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1806 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"OFF\",", "sourceParagraph": 1807 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"OFF\",", "sourceParagraph": 1808 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1809 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1810 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1811 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localisation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1812 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1813 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1814 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptLanguage\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 1815 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseLanguage\": \"tr\"", "sourceParagraph": 1816 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1817 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"deployment\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1818 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1819 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:15:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 1820 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"experimentalState\": \"UNKNOWN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1821 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"knownChangeEvent\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 1822 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observedInterfaceVariant\": \"STANDARD\"", "sourceParagraph": 1823 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1824 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessResult\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1825 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"AVAILABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1826 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rateLimitEncountered\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1827 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetryUsed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1828 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemRefusal\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1829 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1830 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"configurationFingerprint\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1831 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"algorithm\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1832 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": \"SCF-SYNTH-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1833 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1834 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidence\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1835 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productMetadataCaptured\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1836 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullScreenshotCaptured\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1837 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemSettingsCaptured\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1838 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceConfidence\": \"MEDIUM\"", "sourceParagraph": 1839 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1840 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1841 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryOwnerRole\": \"AI_SYSTEM_REGISTRY_OWNER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1842 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recordValidatedBy\": \"SYSTEM_CONFIGURATION_REVIEWER\"", "sourceParagraph": 1843 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1844 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1845 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1846 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 1847 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the actual provider,", "sourceParagraph": 1848 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the real model,", "sourceParagraph": 1849 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the real product", "sourceParagraph": 1850 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "it does not belong.", "sourceParagraph": 1851 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI product sample is a machine-readable synthetic representation.", "sourceParagraph": 1852 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "55. MACHINE-READABLE COMPARISON RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1854 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1855 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1856 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1857 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1858 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1859 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGCMP-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1860 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonQuestion\": \"Which consumer AI product produces more accurate entity representation under matched clean-session conditions?\",", "sourceParagraph": 1861 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemA\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1862 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemB\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-HELIOS-WEB-FREE-W1-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 1863 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonLevel\": \"CP-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1864 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1865 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecordVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1866 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1867 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1868 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1869 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1870 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1871 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1872 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationFrame\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1873 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1874 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemoryOff\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1875 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructionsOff\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1876 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webAccess\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1877 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMode\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1878 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1879 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1880 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"provider\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1881 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1882 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"displayedModel\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1883 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userInterfaceDetails\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1884 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1885 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1886 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CONSUMER_PRODUCT_REPRESENTATION_COMPARISON\",", "sourceParagraph": 1887 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MATCHED_CLEAN_SESSION_RESULT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1888 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1889 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1890 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PURE_BASE_MODEL_SUPERIORITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1891 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GLOBAL_NATIVE_REACH_SUPERIORITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 1892 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PERMANENT_PRODUCT_SUPERIORITY\"", "sourceParagraph": 1893 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1894 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachComparison\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1895 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupportComparison\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1896 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"SINGLE_WAVE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1897 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1898 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1899 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedBeforePublicRanking\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1900 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1901 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1902 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1903 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "56. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 1905 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH09-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1906 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a versioned AI System", "sourceParagraph": 1908 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registry record describing the measured product instance, including as", "sourceParagraph": 1909 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "applicable:", "sourceParagraph": 1910 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- provider,", "sourceParagraph": 1912 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- product,", "sourceParagraph": 1913 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- user surface,", "sourceParagraph": 1914 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- plan,", "sourceParagraph": 1915 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- displayed or verified model identity,", "sourceParagraph": 1916 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- model-identity confidence,", "sourceParagraph": 1917 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- retrieval and web configuration,", "sourceParagraph": 1918 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- citation capability and use,", "sourceParagraph": 1919 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- tool access and use,", "sourceParagraph": 1920 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- session state,", "sourceParagraph": 1921 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- memory,", "sourceParagraph": 1922 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- custom instructions,", "sourceParagraph": 1923 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prior context,", "sourceParagraph": 1924 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- personalisation,", "sourceParagraph": 1925 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- country,", "sourceParagraph": 1926 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- locale,", "sourceParagraph": 1927 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- language,", "sourceParagraph": 1928 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- deployment state,", "sourceParagraph": 1929 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- measurement time,", "sourceParagraph": 1930 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and known or observed system changes.", "sourceParagraph": 1931 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Provider name, product name, displayed model label, base model, retrieval", "sourceParagraph": 1933 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "system, and user-facing product MUST NOT be treated as interchangeable", "sourceParagraph": 1934 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "identities.", "sourceParagraph": 1935 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Feature availability MUST remain distinct from feature use.", "sourceParagraph": 1937 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Live-product results MUST NOT be represented as frozen-model results, and", "sourceParagraph": 1939 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "frozen-model results MUST NOT be represented as full consumer-product", "sourceParagraph": 1940 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "experience.", "sourceParagraph": 1941 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Comparisons MUST define their object and receive a disclosed", "sourceParagraph": 1943 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "comparability level based on matched entity, prompt, population,", "sourceParagraph": 1944 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "language, country, time, session, plan, interface, retrieval, tools,", "sourceParagraph": 1945 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reference records, and adjudication rules.", "sourceParagraph": 1946 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The same provider or displayed model MUST NOT create an automatic", "sourceParagraph": 1948 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "assumption of comparability.", "sourceParagraph": 1949 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Different providers MAY be compared when user-facing conditions are", "sourceParagraph": 1951 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sufficiently aligned and the resulting claim is limited to the measured", "sourceParagraph": 1952 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "product behaviour.", "sourceParagraph": 1953 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Material product changes during a measurement wave MUST create a separate", "sourceParagraph": 1955 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "system state, sub-wave, modelled change factor, or mixed-state warning.", "sourceParagraph": 1956 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unknown configuration fields MUST remain UNKNOWN and MUST NOT be imputed", "sourceParagraph": 1958 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "as controlled or equivalent.", "sourceParagraph": 1959 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every system-registry and comparability decision MUST be versioned and", "sourceParagraph": 1961 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 1962 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1963 }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Each GEO-1000 observation must be linked to a versioned AI System Register record that carries, to the extent relevant, provider, product, user surface, plan, visible or verified model ID, model ID confidence, retrieval and web configuration, citation capability and usage, tool access, session status, memory, custom instructions, previous context, personalisation, country, locale, language, deployment status, measurement time, and known system changes. Provider name, product name, visible model label, base model, retrieval system, and user product cannot be used interchangeably. The same provider or model label does not create automatic comparability. Different providers are comparable in terms of measured product behaviour when user conditions are sufficiently matched.", "sourceParagraph": 1964 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung MUSS mit einem versionierten Eintrag im KI-Systemregister verknüpft sein, der die gemessene Produktinstanz beschreibt, einschließlich, soweit zutreffend: - Anbieter, - Produkt, - Nutzeroberfläche, - Plan, - angezeigte oder verifizierte Modellidentität, - Konfidenz der Modellidentität, - Abruf- und Webkonfiguration, - Zitierfähigkeit und Nutzung, - Werkzeugzugang und Nutzung, - Sitzungsstatus, - Speicher, - Nutzerdefinierte Anweisungen, - vorheriger Kontext, - Personalisierung, - Land, - Gebietsschema, - Sprache, - Bereitstellungsstatus, - Messzeitpunkt, - und bekannte oder beobachtete Systemänderungen. Anbietername, Produktname, angezeigtes Modellkennzeichen, Basismodell, Abrufsystem und für den Nutzer sichtbares Produkt DÜRFEN NICHT als austauschbare Identitäten behandelt werden. Die Verfügbarkeit von Funktionen MUSS von der Nutzung von Funktionen unterschieden bleiben. Ergebnisse von Live-Produkten DÜRFEN NICHT als eingefrorene Modell-Ergebnisse repräsentiert werden, und Ergebnisse von eingefrorenen Modellen DÜRFEN NICHT als das vollständige Erlebnis eines Verbraucherprodukts repräsentiert werden. Vergleiche MÜSSEN ihr Objekt definieren und einen offengelegten Grad der Vergleichbarkeit basierend auf übereinstimmenden Entitäten, Prompts, Population, Sprache, Land, Zeit, Sitzung, Plan, Schnittstelle, Abruf, Werkzeugen, Referenzaufzeichnungen und Bewertungsregeln erhalten. Derselbe Anbietername oder dieselbe angezeigte Modellbezeichnung DÜRFEN NICHT automatisch eine Annahme von Vergleichbarkeit erzeugen. Verschiedene Anbieter KÖNNEN verglichen werden, wenn die nutzerseitigen Bedingungen ausreichend übereinstimmen und die daraus resultierende Aussage auf das gemessene Produktverhalten beschränkt ist. Wesentliche Produktänderungen während einer Messwelle MÜSSEN einen separaten Systemzustand, eine Unterwelle, einen modellierten Änderungsfaktor oder eine Warnung über einen gemischten Zustand erzeugen. Unbekannte Konfigurationsfelder MÜSSEN als UNKNOWN gekennzeichnet bleiben und DÜRFEN NICHT als kontrolliert oder gleichwertig angenommen werden. Jede Entscheidung zum Systemregister und zur Vergleichbarkeit MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH09-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "54. MASCHINENLESBARES KI-SYSTEMDATENPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 1758, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1759, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1760, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1761, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1762, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiSystemRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1763, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-FREE-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1764, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"anbieter\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1765, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerId\": \"SYNTH-ORION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1766, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerName\": \"Orion Systeme\"", "sourceParagraph": 1767, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1768, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"produkt\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1769, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1770, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productName\": \"Orion Chat\",", "sourceParagraph": 1771, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productType\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1772, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PT-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1773, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PT-2\"", "sourceParagraph": 1774, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1775, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oberfläche\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 1776, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"KOSTENLOS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1777, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"applicationVersion\": \"6.1\"", "sourceParagraph": 1778, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1779, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modell\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1780, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"displayedLabel\": \"Orion Standard\",", "sourceParagraph": 1781, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityConfidence\": \"MI-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1782, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionedDeploymentId\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 1783, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dynamicRoutingPossible\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1784, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimAttributionLevel\": \"NUR_PRODUKTOBERFLÄCHE\"", "sourceParagraph": 1785, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1786, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"knowledgeConfiguration\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1787, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mode\": \"KG-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 1788, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webFeatureAvailable\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1789, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webFeatureEnabled\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1790, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webUseForObservation\": \"BENUTZT_BESTÄTIGT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1791, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationFeatureAvailable\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1792, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationsDisplayed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1793, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateKnowledgeSource\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1794, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1795, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tools\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1796, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"available\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1797, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WEB_SUCHEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 1798, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1799, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"usedForObservation\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1800, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WEB_SUCHEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 1801, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1802, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1803, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"session\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1804, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sessionType\": \"ST-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1805, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversation\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1806, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"AUS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1807, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"AUS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1808, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1809, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1810, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1811, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localisation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1812, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": \"TR\"", "sourceParagraph": 1813, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1814, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptLanguage\": \"tr\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1815, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseLanguage\": \"tr\"", "sourceParagraph": 1816, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1817, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bereitstellung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1818, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1819, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:15:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 1820, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"experimentalState\": \"UNBEKANNT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1821, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"knownChangeEvent\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 1822, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observedInterfaceVariant\": \"STANDARD\"", "sourceParagraph": 1823, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1824, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessResult\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1825, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"VERFÜGBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1826, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rateLimitEncountered\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1827, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetryUsed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1828, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemRefusal\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1829, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1830, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"configurationFingerprint\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1831, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Algorithmus\": \"SYNTHETISCH-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1832, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": \"SCF-SYNTH-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1833, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1834, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Nachweis\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1835, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productMetadataCaptured\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1836, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullScreenshotCaptured\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1837, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemSettingsCaptured\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1838, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceConfidence\": \"MITTEL\"", "sourceParagraph": 1839, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1840, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1841, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryOwnerRole\": \"AI_SYSTEM_REGISTRY_BESITZER\",", "sourceParagraph": 1842, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recordValidatedBy\": \"SYSTEMKONFIGURATIONS_PRÜFER\"}", "sourceParagraph": 1843, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1844, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1845, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1846, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 1847, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "an den tatsächlichen Anbieter,", "sourceParagraph": 1848, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "an das echte Modell,", "sourceParagraph": 1849, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "an das echte Produkt", "sourceParagraph": 1850, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es gehört nicht dazu.", "sourceParagraph": 1851, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Produktprobe ist eine maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation.", "sourceParagraph": 1852, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "55. MASCHINENLESBARES VERGLEICHSREKORD", "sourceParagraph": 1854, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1855, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1856, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1857, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1858, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1859, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGCMP-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1860, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonQuestion\": \"Welches Verbraucher-KI-Produkt erzeugt unter abgestimmten Clean-Session-Bedingungen eine genauere Entitätsdarstellung?\",", "sourceParagraph": 1861, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemA\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1862, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemB\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-HELIOS-WEB-FREE-W1-003\"", "sourceParagraph": 1863, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonLevel\": \"CP-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1864, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1865, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecordVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1866, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1867, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1868, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Land\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1869, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Gebietsschema\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1870, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sprache\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1871, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWindow\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1872, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationFrame\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1873, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversation\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1874, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemoryOff\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1875, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructionsOff\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1876, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webAccess\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1877, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMode\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1878, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1879, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1880, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Anbieter\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1881, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Plan\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1882, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"displayedModel\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1883, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userInterfaceDetails\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1884, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1885, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1886, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VERGLEICH_DER_VERBRAUCHERPRODUKT-DARSTELLUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1887, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ABGLEICH_ERGEBNIS_REINER_SITZUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 1888, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1889, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1890, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ÜBERLEGENHEIT_DES_REINEN_BASISMODELLS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1891, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ÜBERLEGENHEIT_GLOBALE_EINHEIMISCHE_REICHWEITE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1892, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"DAUERHAFTE_PRODUKTÜBERLEGENHEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1893, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1894, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nativeReachComparison\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1895, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commonSupportComparison\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1896, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"EINZELWELLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1897, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1898, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"VERGLEICHBARKEITS-SCHLICHTER\"", "sourceParagraph": 1899, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedBeforePublicRanking\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1900, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1901, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1902, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1903, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "56. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 1905, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH09-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1906, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung MUSS mit einem versionierten KI-System verbunden sein", "sourceParagraph": 1908, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registrierungseintrag, der die gemessene Produktinstanz beschreibt, einschließlich als", "sourceParagraph": 1909, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "anwendbar:", "sourceParagraph": 1910, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Anbieter,", "sourceParagraph": 1912, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Produkt,", "sourceParagraph": 1913, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nutzeroberfläche,", "sourceParagraph": 1914, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Plan,", "sourceParagraph": 1915, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- angezeigte oder verifizierte Modellidentität,", "sourceParagraph": 1916, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Modellidentitäts-Vertrauen,", "sourceParagraph": 1917, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Abruf- und Web-Konfiguration,", "sourceParagraph": 1918, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zitierfähigkeit und Nutzung,", "sourceParagraph": 1919, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Werkzeugzugriff und Nutzung,", "sourceParagraph": 1920, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sitzungsstatus", "sourceParagraph": 1921, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Speicher,", "sourceParagraph": 1922, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- benutzerdefinierte Anweisungen,", "sourceParagraph": 1923, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- vorheriger Kontext,", "sourceParagraph": 1924, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Personalisierung,", "sourceParagraph": 1925, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Land,", "sourceParagraph": 1926, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gebietsschema,", "sourceParagraph": 1927, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprache,", "sourceParagraph": 1928, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Bereitstellungszustand,", "sourceParagraph": 1929, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Messzeit,", "sourceParagraph": 1930, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und bekannte oder beobachtete Systemänderungen.", "sourceParagraph": 1931, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Anbietername, Produktname, angezeigtes Modelletikett, Basismodell, Abruf", "sourceParagraph": 1933, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "System- und Nutzerorientiertes Produkt DÜRFEN NICHT als austauschbar betrachtet werden", "sourceParagraph": 1934, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Identitäten.", "sourceParagraph": 1935, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Verfügbarkeit von Funktionen MUSS von deren Nutzung getrennt bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1937, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ergebnisse des Live-Produkts DÜRFEN NICHT als Ergebnisse des eingefrorenen Modells repräsentiert werden, und", "sourceParagraph": 1939, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ergebnisse des eingefrorenen Modells DÜRFEN NICHT als vollständiges Verbraucherprodukt repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 1940, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Erfahrung.", "sourceParagraph": 1941, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Vergleiche MÜSSEN ihr Objekt definieren und einen offengelegten erhalten", "sourceParagraph": 1943, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Vergleichbarkeitsniveau basierend auf abgeglichenem Element, Prompt, Population,", "sourceParagraph": 1944, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sprache, Land, Zeit, Sitzung, Plan, Schnittstelle, Abruf, Werkzeuge,", "sourceParagraph": 1945, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Referenzaufzeichnungen und Schiedsregeln.", "sourceParagraph": 1946, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der gleiche Anbieter oder das angezeigte Modell DARF NICHT automatisch erstellen", "sourceParagraph": 1948, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Annahme der Vergleichbarkeit.", "sourceParagraph": 1949, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verschiedene Anbieter KÖNNEN verglichen werden, wenn Nutzerbezogene Bedingungen vorhanden sind", "sourceParagraph": 1951, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ausreichend ausgerichtet und der resultierende Anspruch ist auf das gemessene", "sourceParagraph": 1952, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Produktverhalten beschränkt.", "sourceParagraph": 1953, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Materielle Produktänderungen während einer Messwelle MÜSSEN einen separaten", "sourceParagraph": 1955, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Systemzustand, Unterwelle, modellierten Änderungsfaktor oder gemischten Zustandswarnung erzeugen.", "sourceParagraph": 1956, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unbekannte Konfigurationsfelder MÜSSEN unbekannt bleiben und DÜRFEN NICHT als", "sourceParagraph": 1958, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gesteuert oder gleichwertig imputiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1959, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede System-Registry- und Vergleichbarkeitsentscheidung MÜSSEN versioniert werden und", "sourceParagraph": 1961, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1962, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1963, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH09-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung muss mit einem versionierten Datensatz des KI-Systemregisters verknüpft sein, der, soweit relevant, Anbieter, Produkt, Nutzeroberfläche, Plan, sichtbare oder verifizierte Modell-ID, Modell-ID-Vertrauenswürdigkeit, Abruf- und Webkonfiguration, Zitierfähigkeit und -nutzung, Werkzeugzugang, Sitzungsstatus, Speicher, Nutzerdefinierte Anweisungen, vorheriger Kontext, Personalisierung, Land, Gebietsschema, Sprache, Bereitstellungsstatus, Messzeitpunkt und bekannte Systemänderungen enthält. Anbietername, Produktname, sichtbares Modelllabel, Basismodell, Abrufsystem und Nutzerprodukt dürfen nicht austauschbar verwendet werden. Derselbe Anbieter oder dasselbe Modelllabel schafft keine automatische Vergleichbarkeit. Verschiedene Anbieter sind in Bezug auf das gemessene Produktverhalten vergleichbar, wenn die Nutzerbedingungen ausreichend übereinstimmen.", "sourceParagraph": 1964, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 10, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH10", "title": "Die Prompt-Verfassung", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K04", "K11", "K12", "K13" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH10-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 prompt MUST be linked to a versioned Prompt Registry record defining: - the research question, - estimand, - prompt family, - canonical intent, - entity anchor, - user intent, - speech act, - scope, - geographic and temporal frame, - presuppositions, - evidence and source requirements, - response format, - language, - locale, - equivalence status, - version, - and integrity record. Within the same language-locale prompt cell, participants MUST receive the same locked prompt text. Across languages and locales, prompts MUST preserve semantic, functional, and normative equivalence rather than literal word-for-word identity. Entity anchor, user intent, speech act, scope, presupposition, and epistemic burden are non-compensatory equivalence gates. Machine translation or back-translation alone MUST NOT establish prompt equivalence. Core identity, evidence, recommendation, comparison, temporal, local, boundary, robustness, control, and holdout prompts MUST remain distinct prompt families. Leading, answer-containing, positively or negatively presuppositional, source-constrained, format-constrained, or recommendation prompts MUST NOT be silently scored as neutral Core Mirror prompts. Prompt sets, language versions, assignment rules, clarification paths, ordering, and holdout commitments MUST be locked before AI responses are observed. Post-result prompt selection, prompt-family deletion, silent mid-wave editing, and outcome-driven rewording are prohibited. the prompt assigned to the participant and the prompt actually sent to the AI product MUST be integrity-checked. Hidden instructions, invisible characters, or undisclosed manipulation directing the AI toward a preferred entity, claim, citation, or recommendation are prohibited. Every prompt change, translation decision, equivalence judgement, and registry record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 promptu araştırma sorusunu, tahmin edilen niceliği, prompt ailesini, kanonik niyeti, entity anchor’ı, kullanıcı niyetini, görev türünü, kapsamı, coğrafi ve zamansal çerçeveyi, ön varsayımları, kaynak ve kanıt talebini, cevap biçimini, dil ve locale’i, eşdeğerlik statüsünü, sürümü ve bütünlük kaydını tanımlayan sürümlü Prompt Sicili’ne bağlanmalıdır. Aynı dil–locale hücresinde kullanıcılar aynı kilitlenmiş metni almalı; diller arasında kelime kelime eşitlik değil semantik, işlevsel ve normatif eşdeğerlik korunmalıdır. Prompt setleri, çeviriler, atama kuralları, clarification yolları ve holdout kayıtları AI cevapları görülmeden önce kilitlenmelidir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH10-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE PROMPT RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2046 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2047 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2048 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2049 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"excludedTasks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2050 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RECOMMENDATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2051 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LEADERSHIP\",", "sourceParagraph": 2052 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TRUSTWORTHINESS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2053 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PRICE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2054 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"COMPARATIVE_RANKING\"", "sourceParagraph": 2055 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2056 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRequirement\": \"NONE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2057 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseFormat\": \"NATURAL_OPEN_RESPONSE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2058 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionPolicy\": \"NO_UNVERIFIED_QUALITY_OR_AUTHORITY_ASSUMPTION\"", "sourceParagraph": 2059 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2060 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceLanguage\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2061 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Which parent organisation is Apple.com associated with, and what are the main activities of this organisation?\"", "sourceParagraph": 2064 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unicodeNormalization\": \"NFC\",", "sourceParagraph": 2065 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2066 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2067 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageVersions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2068 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2069 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2070 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2071 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Which parent organisation is Apple.com associated with, and what are the main activities of this organisation?\"", "sourceParagraph": 2072 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2073 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2074 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2075 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2076 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2077 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2078 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2079 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2083 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": \"en\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"en-GB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2085 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"text\": \"Which principal organisation is associated with apple.com, and what are its primary activities?\",", "sourceParagraph": 2086 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2087 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2088 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2089 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2090 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2091 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2092 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2093 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2094 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-EN-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2095 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2096 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2097 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"delivery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2098 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manualRetypingAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2099 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"copyFromLockedInterface\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2100 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exactMatchRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2101 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantEditingAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2102 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clarificationPath\": \"SINGLE_TURN_CAPTURE_ONLY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2103 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversationRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2104 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2105 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sets\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2106 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicNormativeSet\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2107 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedValidationSet\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2108 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"holdoutStatus\": \"NOT_APPLICABLE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2109 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2110 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2111 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"draftedByRole\": \"PROMPT_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2112 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"translatedByRole\": \"TARGET_LANGUAGE_TRANSLATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2113 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"backTranslatedByIndependentRole\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2114 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceApprovedByRole\": \"PROMPT_EQUIVALENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2115 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18T09:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2116 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resultInspectionBeforeLock\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2117 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2118 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2119 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2120 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This record:", "sourceParagraph": 2121 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This is not a real Apple audit,", "sourceParagraph": 2122 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "This is not a real prompt validation work,", "sourceParagraph": 2123 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the Prompt Constitution.", "sourceParagraph": 2124 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE PROMPT OBSERVATION RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2126 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2127 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2128 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2129 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2130 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptObservation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2131 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2132 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2133 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2134 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"language\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2135 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2136 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedTextHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2137 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentTextHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2138 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidity\": \"PV-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2139 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2140 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationTurn\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2141 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clarificationUsed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2142 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantEdited\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2143 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemTransformationObserved\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2144 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullPromptVisibleInEvidence\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2145 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:14:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2146 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2147 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityReviewerRole\": \"BLINDED_PROMPT_VALIDATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2148 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2149 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2150 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2151 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 2153 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH10-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2154 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 prompt MUST be linked to a versioned Prompt Registry record", "sourceParagraph": 2156 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "defining:", "sourceParagraph": 2157 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- the research question,", "sourceParagraph": 2159 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- estimand,", "sourceParagraph": 2160 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt family,", "sourceParagraph": 2161 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- canonical intent,", "sourceParagraph": 2162 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- entity anchor,", "sourceParagraph": 2163 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- user intent,", "sourceParagraph": 2164 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- speech act,", "sourceParagraph": 2165 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2166 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- geographic and temporal frame,", "sourceParagraph": 2167 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- presuppositions,", "sourceParagraph": 2168 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- evidence and source requirements,", "sourceParagraph": 2169 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- response format,", "sourceParagraph": 2170 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- language,", "sourceParagraph": 2171 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- locale,", "sourceParagraph": 2172 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- equivalence status,", "sourceParagraph": 2173 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- version,", "sourceParagraph": 2174 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and integrity record.", "sourceParagraph": 2175 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Within the same language-locale prompt cell, participants MUST receive", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "the same locked prompt text.", "sourceParagraph": 2178 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Across languages and locales, prompts MUST preserve semantic, functional,", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and normative equivalence rather than literal word-for-word identity.", "sourceParagraph": 2181 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Entity anchor, user intent, speech act, scope, presupposition, and", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "epistemic burden are non-compensatory equivalence gates.", "sourceParagraph": 2184 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Machine translation or back-translation alone MUST NOT establish prompt", "sourceParagraph": 2186 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "equivalence.", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Core identity, evidence, recommendation, comparison, temporal, local,", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "boundary, robustness, control, and holdout prompts MUST remain distinct", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "prompt families.", "sourceParagraph": 2191 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Leading, answer-containing, positively or negatively presuppositional,", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "source-constrained, format-constrained, or recommendation prompts MUST NOT", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "be silently scored as neutral Core Mirror prompts.", "sourceParagraph": 2195 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Prompt sets, language versions, assignment rules, clarification paths,", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ordering, and holdout commitments MUST be locked before AI responses are", "sourceParagraph": 2198 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "observed.", "sourceParagraph": 2199 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Post-result prompt selection, prompt-family deletion, silent mid-wave", "sourceParagraph": 2201 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "editing, and outcome-driven rewording are prohibited.", "sourceParagraph": 2202 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The prompt assigned to the participant and the prompt actually sent to", "sourceParagraph": 2204 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "the AI product MUST be integrity-checked.", "sourceParagraph": 2205 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Hidden instructions, invisible characters, or undisclosed manipulation", "sourceParagraph": 2207 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "directing the AI toward a preferred entity, claim, citation, or", "sourceParagraph": 2208 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "recommendation are prohibited.", "sourceParagraph": 2209 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every prompt change, translation decision, equivalence judgement, and", "sourceParagraph": 2211 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "registry record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", "sourceParagraph": 2212 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2213 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2214 }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 prompt must be linked to the versioned Prompt Registry that defines the research question, estimated quantity, prompt family, canonical intent, entity anchor, user intent, task type, scope, geographic and temporal frame, assumptions, source and evidence request, response format, language and locale, equivalence status, version, and integrity record. Users in the same language–locale cell must receive the same locked text; across languages, semantic, functional, and normative equivalence must be preserved, not word-for-word equality. Prompt sets, translations, assignment rules, clarification paths, and holdout records must be locked before AI responses are seen.", "sourceParagraph": 2215 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jeder GEO-1000-Prompt MUSS mit einem versionierten Prompt-Registry-Eintrag verknüpft sein, der Folgendes definiert: - die Forschungsfrage, - den Schätzer, - die Prompt-Familie, - die kanonische Absicht, - die Entitätsanker, - die Nutzerabsicht, - die Sprechhandlung, - den Umfang, - den geografischen und zeitlichen Rahmen, - die Voraussetzungen, - Nachweis- und Quellenanforderungen, - das Antwortformat, - die Sprache, - das Gebietsschema, - den Äquivalenzstatus, - die Version und - den Integritätsnachweis. Innerhalb desselben Sprach-Gebietsschema-Prompt-Feldes MUSS allen Teilnehmern derselbe festgeschriebene Prompt-Text bereitgestellt werden. Über Sprachen und Gebietsschemata hinweg MÜSSEN Prompts semantische, funktionale und normative Äquivalenz bewahren, statt wortwörtliche Identität. Entity-Anker, Nutzerabsicht, Sprechakt, Umfang, Präsupposition und epistemische Belastung sind nicht-kompensatorische Äquivalenz-Gates. Maschinelle Übersetzung oder Rückübersetzung allein DARF die Äquivalenz von Prompts NICHT herstellen. Kernidentität, Nachweise, Empfehlung, Vergleich, temporal, lokal, Grenze, Robustheit, Kontrolle und Holdout-Prompts MÜSSEN als getrennte Prompt-Familien bestehen bleiben. Führende, Antwort-enthaltende, positiv oder negativ präsentierte, quellbeschränkte, formatbeschränkte oder Empfehlungs-Prompts DÜRFEN NICHT stillschweigend als neutrale Core-Mirror-Prompts bewertet werden. Prompt-Sets, Sprachversionen, Zuweisungsregeln, Klärungspfade, Reihenfolge und Holdout-Verpflichtungen MÜSSEN festgeschrieben werden, bevor KI-Antworten beobachtet werden. Die Auswahl von Prompts nach dem Ergebnis, das Löschen von Eingabeaufforderungsfamilien, stilles Bearbeiten während des Vorgangs und ergebnisorientiertes Umformulieren sind verboten. Die dem Teilnehmer zugewiesene Prompt und die tatsächlich an das KI-Produkt gesendete Prompt MÜSSEN auf Integrität überprüft werden. Versteckte Anweisungen, unsichtbare Zeichen oder nicht offengelegte Manipulationen, die die KI in Richtung einer bevorzugten Entität, eines Anspruchs, einer Zitation oder Empfehlung lenken, sind verboten. Jede Änderung der Prompt, jede Übersetzungsentscheidung, jede Gleichwertigkeitsbewertung und jeder Registrierungseintrag MÜSSEN versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden KÖNNEN.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH10-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MASCHINENLESBARES PROMPTPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 2046, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2047, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2048, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2049, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"excludedTasks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2050, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"EMPFEHLUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2051, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FÜHRUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2052, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ZUVERLÄSSIGKEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2053, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PREIS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2054, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VERGLEICHSRANG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2055, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2056, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRequirement\": \"KEINE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2057, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseFormat\": \"NATÜRLICHE_OFFENE_ANTWORT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2058, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionPolicy\": \"KEINE_UNGEPRÜFTE_QUALITÄTS-ODER_AUTORITÄTSANNAHME\"", "sourceParagraph": 2059, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2060, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceLanguage\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2061, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sprache\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Mit welcher übergeordneten Organisation ist Apple.com verbunden und was sind die Hauptaktivitäten dieser Organisation?\"", "sourceParagraph": 2064, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unicodeNormalization\": \"NFC\"", "sourceParagraph": 2065, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2066, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2067, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languageVersions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2068, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2069, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sprache\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2070, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2071, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Mit welcher übergeordneten Organisation ist Apple.com verbunden und was sind die Hauptaktivitäten dieser Organisation?\"", "sourceParagraph": 2072, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2073, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2074, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2075, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2076, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2077, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2078, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2079, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2083, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sprache\": \"en\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Gebietsschema\": \"en-GB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2085, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Text\": \"Welche Hauptorganisation ist mit apple.com verbunden und was sind ihre Hauptaktivitäten?\",", "sourceParagraph": 2086, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceLevel\": \"PE-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2087, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAnchorEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2088, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intentEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2089, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speechActEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2090, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2091, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"presuppositionEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2092, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"epistemicBurdenEquivalence\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2093, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localPilotStatus\": \"BESTANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2094, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-EN-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2095, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2096, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2097, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Lieferung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2098, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manualRetypingAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2099, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"copyFromLockedInterface\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2100, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exactMatchRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2101, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantEditingAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2102, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clarificationPath\": \"NUR_EINZEL_DURCHLAUF_ERFASSUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2103, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"newConversationRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2104, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2105, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sets\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2106, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicNormativeSet\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2107, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedValidationSet\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2108, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"holdoutStatus\": \"NICHT_ANWENDBAR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2109, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2110, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2111, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"draftedByRole\": \"PROMPT_METHODEN_FÜHRUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2112, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"translatedByRole\": \"ZIELSPRACHÜBERSETZER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2113, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"backTranslatedByIndependentRole\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2114, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equivalenceApprovedByRole\": \"EINGABEÄQUIVALENZ-BEGRIFFSPRÜFER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2115, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-18 T0 9:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2116, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resultInspectionBeforeLock\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2117, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2118, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2119, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2120, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dieser Datensatz:", "sourceParagraph": 2121, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dies ist kein echter Apple-Audit,", "sourceParagraph": 2122, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Dies ist keine echte Eingabevalidierungsarbeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2123, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist eine maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation der Eingabeverfassung.", "sourceParagraph": 2124, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MASCHINENLESBARES EINGABEÜBERWACHUNGSPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 2126, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2127, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2128, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2129, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2130, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptObservation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2131, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2132, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptId\": \"NGP-CORE-SPIEGEL-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2133, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2134, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Sprache\": \"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2135, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2136, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedTextHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2137, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentTextHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2138, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidity\": \"PV-1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2139, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptOrder\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2140, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationTurn\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2141, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clarificationUsed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2142, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantEdited\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2143, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemTransformationObserved\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2144, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullPromptVisibleInEvidence\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2145, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:14:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2146, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2147, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityReviewerRole\": \"BLINDED_PROMPT_VALIDATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2148, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2149, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2150, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2151, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 2153, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH10-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2154, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Eingabe MUSS mit einem versionierten Prompt-Registry-Eintrag verknüpft sein", "sourceParagraph": 2156, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "definieren:", "sourceParagraph": 2157, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- die Forschungsfrage,", "sourceParagraph": 2159, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- den Schätzwert,", "sourceParagraph": 2160, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompt-Familie,", "sourceParagraph": 2161, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- kanonische Absicht,", "sourceParagraph": 2162, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entitätsanker,", "sourceParagraph": 2163, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nutzerabsicht,", "sourceParagraph": 2164, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprechakt,", "sourceParagraph": 2165, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Umfang,", "sourceParagraph": 2166, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- geografischer und zeitlicher Rahmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2167, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Voraussetzungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2168, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Anforderungen an Nachweise und Quellen,", "sourceParagraph": 2169, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Antwortformat,", "sourceParagraph": 2170, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprache,", "sourceParagraph": 2171, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gebietsschema,", "sourceParagraph": 2172, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Äquivalenzstatus,", "sourceParagraph": 2173, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Version,", "sourceParagraph": 2174, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Integritätsaufzeichnung.", "sourceParagraph": 2175, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Innerhalb derselben Sprach-Lokalisierungs-Prompt-Zelle MÜSSEN die Teilnehmer", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "denselben festgeschriebenen Prompt-Text erhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2178, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Über Sprachen und Lokalisierungen hinweg MÜSSEN Prompts semantische, funktionale", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und normative Äquivalenz wahren, anstatt wörtliche Wort-für-Wort-Identität.", "sourceParagraph": 2181, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Entity-Anker, Nutzerabsicht, Sprechakt, Umfang, Prämisse und", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "epistemische Last sind nicht ausgleichbare Äquivalenz-Gates.", "sourceParagraph": 2184, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Maschinelle Übersetzung oder Rückübersetzung allein DÜRFEN die Prompt-Äquivalenz NICHT herstellen.", "sourceParagraph": 2186, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kernidentität, Nachweis, Empfehlung, Vergleich, zeitlich, lokal,", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Grenze, Robustheit, Kontrolle und Zurückhaltungsaufforderungen MÜSSEN unterschieden bleiben", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufforderungsfamilien.", "sourceParagraph": 2191, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Führend, antwortbeinhaltend, positiv oder negativ vorgeschlossene,", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "quellenbeschränkte, formatbeschränkte oder Empfehlungsaufforderungen DÜRFEN NICHT", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "stillschweigend als neutrale Core Mirror-Aufforderungen bewertet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2195, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufforderungssätze, Sprachversionen, Zuweisungsregeln, Klärungspfade,", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Reihenfolge und Zurückhaltungsverpflichtungen MÜSSEN festgelegt werden, bevor KI-Antworten", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "beobachtet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2199, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Auswahl des Post-Ergebnis-Prompts, Löschen der Prompt-Familie, still in der Mitte der Welle", "sourceParagraph": 2201, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bearbeitung und ergebnisorientierte Umformulierungen sind verboten.", "sourceParagraph": 2202, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der dem Teilnehmer zugewiesene Prompt und der tatsächlich gesendete Prompt", "sourceParagraph": 2204, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das KI-Produkt MUSS auf Integrität geprüft werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2205, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verborgene Anweisungen, unsichtbare Zeichen oder nicht offengelegte Manipulation", "sourceParagraph": 2207, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "die KI auf ein bevorzugtes Wesen, eine Behauptung, ein Zitat oder", "sourceParagraph": 2208, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Empfehlungen sind verboten.", "sourceParagraph": 2209, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Aufforderungsänderung, Übersetzungsentscheidung, Äquivalenzbewertung und", "sourceParagraph": 2211, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Registrierungseintrag MUSS versioniert sein und einer verantwortlichen Person zugeordnet werden", "sourceParagraph": 2212, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Mensch oder Organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2213, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2214, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH10-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Prompt muss mit dem versionierten Prompt-Register verknüpft sein, das die Forschungsfrage, die geschätzte Menge, die Prompt-Familie, die kanonische Absicht, den Entitätsanker, die Nutzerabsicht, den Aufgabentyp, den Umfang, den geographischen und zeitlichen Rahmen, Annahmen, Quellen- und Beleganforderung, Antwortformat, Sprache und Gebietsschema, den Äquivalenzstatus, die Version und das Integritätsprotokoll definiert. Nutzer in derselben Sprach-Gebietsschemazelle müssen denselben festgeschriebenen Text erhalten; über Sprachen hinweg müssen semantische, funktionale und normative Äquivalenz, nicht Wort-für-Wort-Gleichheit, gewahrt bleiben. Prompt-Sets, Übersetzungen, Zuweisungsregeln, Klärungspfade und Sperraufzeichnungen müssen festgeschrieben werden, bevor AI-Antworten gesehen werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2215, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 11, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH11", "title": "Das kontrollierte Panel unter bereinigten Bedingungen und das Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K02", "K03", "K04", "K06", "K22" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH11-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Controlled Clean Panel and Natural User Panel observations MUST remain separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public results. A Controlled Clean Panel MUST define and verify, as applicable: - a new and separate conversation, - absence of prior conversation context, - persistent-memory state, - custom-instruction state, - enterprise or managed-workspace state, - web, retrieval, and tool configuration, - plan, - user surface, - prompt version, - and clean-state confidence. A new conversation or temporary-session label MUST NOT, by itself, be treated as proof that all persistent personalisation has been disabled. A Natural User Panel MUST preserve the participant's authentic account, plan, interface, memory, custom-instruction, and usage state while retaining the locked prompt, first-eligible-output rule, evidence requirements, and non-regeneration rule. Natural Account-State, Natural Conversation-State, First-Use, and Managed Natural observations MUST remain separately identified. Natural-state documentation MUST minimise private-data collection. Private instruction text, conversation history, identity, credentials, and sensitive personal content MUST NOT be collected unless separately necessary, consented, minimised, and access-controlled. User-generated entity-favourable or entity-adverse instructions MAY be measured as natural personalisation effects, but MUST NOT be represented as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour. Personalisation MAY change relevance, presentation, and recommendation where user context justifies it. It MUST NOT arbitrarily change verified entity identity, license, legal status, price, scope, evidence, or time. Differences between Controlled and Natural panels MUST NOT be represented as causal personalisation effects unless population, product, prompt, time, interface, plan, tools, assignment, order, and carryover conditions support that inference. Controlled and Natural scores, critical-error rates, unknown rates, coverage, effective sample sizes, and signed and absolute panel gaps MUST remain separately visible. Panel-state eligibility, reclassification, exclusion, and weighting MUST remain independent of whether the AI output is positive, negative, correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable. Every panel-state definition, setting-change process, privacy decision, comparison level, and result MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Kontrollü Temiz Panel ve Doğal Kullanıcı Paneli gözlemleri ayrı ölçüm nüfusları, panel durumları, paydalar ve kamu sonuçları olarak korunmalıdır. Yeni sohbet veya geçici oturum etiketi tek başına bütün kalıcı kişiselleştirmenin devre dışı olduğunu kanıtlamaz. Doğal Kullanıcı Paneli gerçek hesap, plan, arayüz, hafıza, özel talimat ve kullanım durumunu korurken kilitlenmiş promptu, ilk uygun çıktı kuralını, kanıt gereksinimlerini ve yenilememe kuralını korumalıdır. Kullanıcı kaynaklı lehte veya aleyhte yönlendirme doğal kişiselleştirme etkisi olarak ölçülebilir; genel varlık GEO başarısı, başarısızlığı veya varsayılan ürün davranışı olarak sunulamaz. Kontrollü ve doğal sonuçlar arasındaki fark, nüfus ve sistem koşulları yeterince eşleşmeden nedensel kişiselleştirme etkisi olarak yorumlanamaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH11-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL STATUS RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1981 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1982 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1983 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1984 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1985 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1986 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1987 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1988 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1989 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1990 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRole\": \"CONTROLLED_CLEAN\",", "sourceParagraph": 1991 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1992 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1993 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1994 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationType\": \"PRODUCT_ELIGIBLE_USERS_UNDER_STANDARDIZED_STATE\"", "sourceParagraph": 1995 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1996 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledState\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1997 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cleanStateConfidence\": \"CSC-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1998 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEW_CONVERSATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1999 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2000 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"OFF_VERIFIED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2001 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"OFF_VERIFIED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2002 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2003 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2004 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webMode\": \"ON_STANDARDIZED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2005 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolMode\": \"STANDARDISED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2006 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", "sourceParagraph": 2007 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2008 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"settingsChangedForStudy\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2009 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantConsentForSettingChange\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2010 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restorationRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2011 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restorationConfirmed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2012 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2013 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2014 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2015 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2016 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2017 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2018 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2019 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2020 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2021 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateInstructionContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2022 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2023 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountCredentialsCollected\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2024 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2025 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2026 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2027 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2028 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2029 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2030 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2031 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "78. MACHINE-READABLE NATURAL PANEL RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2033 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2034 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2035 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2036 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2037 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2038 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2039 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2040 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2041 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2042 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRole\": \"NATURAL_ACCOUNT_STATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2043 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2044 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2045 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-ACTIVE-USERS-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2046 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationType\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_PRODUCT_USERS\"", "sourceParagraph": 2047 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2048 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalState\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2049 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalStateConfidence\": \"NSF-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2050 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEW_CONVERSATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2051 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2052 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"MS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2053 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"CI-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2054 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2055 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorEntityConversation\": \"POSSIBLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2056 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2057 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webMode\": \"USER_NATURAL_STATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2058 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolMode\": \"USER_NATURAL_STATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2059 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", "sourceParagraph": 2060 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2061 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountAgeBand\": \"181_TO_365_DAYS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"usageFrequency\": \"WEEKLY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstUse\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2064 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2065 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2066 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2067 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2068 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2069 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2070 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18T12:05:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2071 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2073 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"memoryContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2074 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructionContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2075 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2076 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"highLevelStateOnly\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2077 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2078 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2079 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2082 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2083 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2084 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "79. MACHINE-READABLE PANEL COMPARISON RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2086 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2087 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2088 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2089 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2090 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelComparison\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2091 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGPC-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2092 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2093 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2094 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparabilityLevel\": \"CN-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2095 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2096 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProduct\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2097 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2098 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityTruthPack\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2099 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2100 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2101 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWindow\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2102 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationRules\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2103 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2104 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2105 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"memory\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2106 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2107 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"planDistribution\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2108 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userHistory\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2109 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolState\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2110 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2111 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"results\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2112 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledRepresentationScore\": 0.92,", "sourceParagraph": 2113 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalRepresentationScore\": 0.83,", "sourceParagraph": 2114 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"signedNaturalGap\": -0.09,", "sourceParagraph": 2115 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"absolutePanelGap\": 0.09,", "sourceParagraph": 2116 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledCriticalRate\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 2117 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalCriticalRate\": 0.012,", "sourceParagraph": 2118 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateDifference\": 0.01", "sourceParagraph": 2119 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2120 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2121 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NATURAL_PANEL_RESULT_LOWER_THAN_CONTROLLED_REFERENCE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2122 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PANEL_STATE_ASSOCIATION_REQUIRES_FURTHER_DECOMPOSITION\"", "sourceParagraph": 2123 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2124 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2125 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MEMORY_CAUSED_NINE_POINT_DECLINE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2126 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ALL_NATURAL_USERS_RECEIVE_WORSE_RESPONSES\",", "sourceParagraph": 2127 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BASE_MODEL_PERFORMANCE_DECLINED\"", "sourceParagraph": 2128 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2129 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"SINGLE_WAVE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2130 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2131 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2132 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2133 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2134 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2135 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2136 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "are not:", "sourceParagraph": 2137 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real user,", "sourceParagraph": 2138 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real AI product,", "sourceParagraph": 2139 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real company performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2140 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the panel distinction.", "sourceParagraph": 2141 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 80", "sourceParagraph": 2143 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH11-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2144 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Controlled Clean Panel and Natural User Panel observations MUST remain", "sourceParagraph": 2146 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public", "sourceParagraph": 2147 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "results.", "sourceParagraph": 2148 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A Controlled Clean Panel MUST define and verify, as applicable:", "sourceParagraph": 2150 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a new and separate conversation,", "sourceParagraph": 2152 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- absence of prior conversation context,", "sourceParagraph": 2153 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- persistent-memory state,", "sourceParagraph": 2154 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- custom-instruction state,", "sourceParagraph": 2155 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- enterprise or managed-workspace state,", "sourceParagraph": 2156 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- web, retrieval, and tool configuration,", "sourceParagraph": 2157 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- plan,", "sourceParagraph": 2158 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- user surface,", "sourceParagraph": 2159 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt version,", "sourceParagraph": 2160 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and clean-state confidence.", "sourceParagraph": 2161 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A new conversation or temporary-session label MUST NOT, by itself, be", "sourceParagraph": 2163 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "treated as proof that all persistent personalisation has been disabled.", "sourceParagraph": 2164 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A Natural User Panel MUST preserve the participant's authentic account,", "sourceParagraph": 2166 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "plan, interface, memory, custom-instruction, and usage state while", "sourceParagraph": 2167 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "retaining the locked prompt, first-eligible-output rule, evidence", "sourceParagraph": 2168 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "requirements, and non-regeneration rule.", "sourceParagraph": 2169 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Natural Account-State, Natural Conversation-State, First-Use, and Managed", "sourceParagraph": 2171 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Natural observations MUST remain separately identified.", "sourceParagraph": 2172 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Natural-state documentation MUST minimise private-data collection.", "sourceParagraph": 2174 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Private instruction text, conversation history, identity, credentials,", "sourceParagraph": 2175 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and sensitive personal content MUST NOT be collected unless separately", "sourceParagraph": 2176 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "necessary, consented, minimised, and access-controlled.", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "User-generated entity-favourable or entity-adverse instructions MAY be", "sourceParagraph": 2179 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "measured as natural personalisation effects, but MUST NOT be represented", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour.", "sourceParagraph": 2181 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Personalisation MAY change relevance, presentation, and recommendation", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "where user context justifies it. It MUST NOT arbitrarily change verified", "sourceParagraph": 2184 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entity identity, license, legal status, price, scope, evidence, or time.", "sourceParagraph": 2185 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Differences between Controlled and Natural panels MUST NOT be represented", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "as causal personalisation effects unless population, product, prompt,", "sourceParagraph": 2188 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "time, interface, plan, tools, assignment, order, and carryover conditions", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "support that inference.", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Controlled and Natural scores, critical-error rates, unknown rates,", "sourceParagraph": 2192 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "coverage, effective sample sizes, and signed and absolute panel gaps MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain separately visible.", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Panel-state eligibility, reclassification, exclusion, and weighting MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2196 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain independent of whether the AI output is positive, negative,", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "correct, incorrect, refused, critical, or commercially favourable.", "sourceParagraph": 2198 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every panel-state definition, setting-change process, privacy decision,", "sourceParagraph": 2200 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "comparison level, and result MUST be versioned and attributable to an", "sourceParagraph": 2201 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2202 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2203 }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Observations of the Controlled Clean Panel and the Natural User Panel should be maintained as separate measurement populations, panel states, denominators, and public results. A new chat or temporary session tag alone does not prove that all persistent personalisation is disabled. The Natural User Panel should retain the real account, plan, interface, memory, custom instructions, and usage scenario while preserving the locked prompt, first appropriate output rule, evidence requirements, and non-refresh rule. User-driven favourable or unfavorable guidance can be measured as the effect of natural personalisation; it cannot be presented as general entity GEO success, failure, or default product behaviour. The difference between controlled and natural results cannot be interpreted as a causal personalisation effect without sufficiently matching populations and system conditions.", "sourceParagraph": 2204 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Beobachtungen des kontrollierten Panels unter bereinigten Bedingungen und des Panels unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen MÜSSEN separate Messpopulationen, Panelzustände, Nenner und öffentliche Ergebnisse bleiben. Ein Kontrolliertes Panel unter bereinigten Bedingungen MUSS definieren und, falls zutreffend, überprüfen: - ein neues und separates Gespräch, - das Fehlen eines vorherigen Gesprächskontexts, - den Zustand des persistenten Speichers, - den Zustand der Nutzerdefinierten Anweisungen, - den Unternehmens- oder verwalteten Arbeitsbereichszustand, - Web-, Abruf- und Werkzeugkonfiguration, - Plan, - Nutzerschnittstelle, - Prompt-Version, - und die Vertrauenswürdigkeit des sauberen Zustands. Ein neues Gespräch oder eine Kennzeichnung als temporäre Sitzung DARF NICHT allein als Nachweis dafür behandelt werden, dass jede persistente Personalisierung deaktiviert wurde. Ein Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen MUSS das authentische Konto, den Plan, die Schnittstelle, den Speicher, die nutzerdefinierten Anweisungen und den Nutzungszustand des Teilnehmers bewahren, während den festgelegten Prompt, die Regel für die erste berechtigte Ausgabe, die Nachweisanforderungen und die Regel, keine neue Antwort zu erzeugen beibehalten werden. Beobachtungen im Zustand eines natürlichen Kontos, natürlicher Gesprächs-Zustand, Erstverwendung und verwaltete natürliche Beobachtungen MÜSSEN separat identifiziert bleiben. Die Dokumentation des natürlichen Zustands MUSS die Sammlung von privaten Daten minimieren. Private Anweisungstexte, Gesprächsverlauf, Identität, Zugangsdaten und sensible persönliche Inhalte DÜRFEN NICHT gesammelt werden, es sei denn, dies ist gesondert erforderlich, mit Einwilligung erhoben, minimiert und zugangskontrolliert. Nutzergenerierte, dem Thema günstig oder ungünstig gegenüberstehende Anweisungen KÖNNEN als natürliche Personalisierungseffekte gemessen werden, DÜRFEN jedoch nicht als allgemeiner GEO-Erfolg, Misserfolg oder Standardverhalten eines Produkts repräsentiert werden. Die Personalisierung KANN die Relevanz, Präsentation und Empfehlung ändern, wenn der Nutzerkontext dies rechtfertigt. Sie DARF jedoch nicht willkürlich verifizierte Identität, Lizenz, Rechtsstatus, Preis, Umfang, Nachweise oder Zeit eines Themas ändern. Unterschiede zwischen Kontroll- und Naturpanels DÜRFEN NICHT als kausale Personalisierungseffekte repräsentiert werden, es sei denn, Population, Produkt, Prompt, Zeit, Schnittstelle, Plan, Werkzeuge, Zuweisung, Reihenfolge und Übertragsbedingungen unterstützen diese Schlussfolgerung. Kontrollierte und natürliche Bewertungen, Raten kritischer Fehler, UNKNOWN-Raten, Abdeckung, effektive Stichprobengrößen sowie signierte und absolute Panel-Lücken MÜSSEN weiterhin separat sichtbar bleiben. Die Berechtigung des Panel-Status, Umklassifizierung, Ausschluss und Gewichtung MÜSSEN unabhängig davon bleiben, ob die KI-Ausgabe positiv, negativ, korrekt, inkorrekt, abgelehnt, kritisch oder kommerziell günstig ist. Jede Definition des Panel-Status, jeder Prozess zur Änderung von Einstellungen, jede Datenschutzentscheidung, jedes Vergleichsniveau und jedes Ergebnis MÜSSEN versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH11-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MASCHINENLESBARES PANEL-STATUSPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 1981, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1982, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1983, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1984, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1985, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1986, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 1987, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1988, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 1989, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-SPIEGEL-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1990, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRole\": \"GEREGELT_GEREINIGT\",", "sourceParagraph": 1991, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 1992, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1993, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1994, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationType\": \"PRODUKT_BERECHTIGTE_NUTZER_UNTER_STANDARDISIERTEM_STATUS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1995, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1996, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledState\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1997, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cleanStateConfidence\": \"CSC-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 1998, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEUE_KONVERSATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1999, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2000, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"AUS_VERIFIZIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2001, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"AUS_VERIFIZIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2002, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2003, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2004, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webMode\": \"AN_STANDARDISIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2005, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolMode\": \"STANDARDISIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2006, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"BEZAHLT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2007, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oberfläche\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2008, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"settingsChangedForStudy\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2009, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantConsentForSettingChange\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2010, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restorationRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2011, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restorationConfirmed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2012, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2013, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurement\": {\"", "sourceParagraph": 2014, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2015, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2016, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2017, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2018, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2019, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2020, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Privatsphäre\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2021, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateInstructionContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2022, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2023, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountCredentialsCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2024, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2025, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2026, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2027, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2028, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2029, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2030, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2031, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "78. MASCHINENLESBARER NATÜRLICHER PANELAUFZEICHNUNG", "sourceParagraph": 2033, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2034, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2035, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2036, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2037, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2038, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2039, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2040, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2041, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-SPIEGEL-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2042, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelRole\": \"NATURAL_ACCOUNT_STATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2043, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelEligibility\": \"PC-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2044, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2045, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"NGP-SYNTH-ORION-ACTIVE-USERS-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2046, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationType\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_PRODUCT_USERS\"", "sourceParagraph": 2047, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2048, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalState\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2049, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalStateConfidence\": \"NSF-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2050, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationState\": \"NEUE_KONVERSATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2051, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptIsFirstUserMessage\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2052, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"persistentMemory\": \"MS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2053, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": \"CI-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2054, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorConversationContext\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2055, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorEntityConversation\": \"MÖGLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2056, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enterpriseWorkspace\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2057, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"webMode\": \"NATÜRLICHER_ZUSTAND_DES_BENUTZERS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2058, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolMode\": \"NATÜRLICHER_ZUSTAND_DES_BENUTZERS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2059, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"BEZAHLT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2060, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oberfläche\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2061, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountAgeBand\": \"181_BIS_365_TAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"usageFrequency\": \"WÖCHENTLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstUse\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2064, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2065, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurement\": {\"", "sourceParagraph": 2066, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2067, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2068, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"followUpAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2069, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptValidityRequired\": \"PV-1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2070, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timestampUtc\": \"2026-08-18 T1 2:05:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2071, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Privatsphäre\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2073, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"memoryContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2074, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructionContentCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2075, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conversationHistoryCollected\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2076, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"highLevelStateOnly\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2077, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2078, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2079, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_STATE_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedByRole\": \"BLINDED_PANEL_STATE_REVIEWER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2082, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2083, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2084, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "79. MASCHINENLESBARES PANEL-VERGLEICHSREKORD", "sourceParagraph": 2086, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2087, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2088, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2089, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2090, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelComparison\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2091, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonId\": \"NGPC-SYNTH-ORION-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2092, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2093, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalPanelRecord\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2094, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparabilityLevel\": \"CN-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2095, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2096, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProduct\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2097, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2098, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityTruthPack\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2099, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Land\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2100, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Gebietsschema\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2101, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWindow\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2102, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationRules\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2103, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2104, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unmatchedDimensions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2105, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"speicher\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2106, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"customInstructions\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2107, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"planDistribution\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2108, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userHistory\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2109, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolState\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2110, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2111, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ergebnisse\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2112, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledRepresentationScore\": 0.92,", "sourceParagraph": 2113, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalRepresentationScore\": 0.83,", "sourceParagraph": 2114, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"signedNaturalGap\": -0.09,", "sourceParagraph": 2115, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"absolutePanelGap\": 0.09,", "sourceParagraph": 2116, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledCriticalRate\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 2117, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalCriticalRate\": 0.012,", "sourceParagraph": 2118, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateDifference\": 0.01", "sourceParagraph": 2119, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2120, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allowedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2121, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NATÜRLICHES_PANELERGEBNIS_UNTERRICHTET_DER_KONTROLLIERTEN_REFERENZ\"", "sourceParagraph": 2122, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PANEL_STATE_ASSOCIATION_REQUIRES_FURTHER_DECOMPOSITION\"", "sourceParagraph": 2123, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2124, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2125, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MEMORY_CAUSED_NINE_POINT_DECLINE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2126, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ALL_NATURAL_USERS_RECEIVE_WORSE_RESPONSES\",", "sourceParagraph": 2127, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BASE_MODEL_PERFORMANCE_DECLINED\"", "sourceParagraph": 2128, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2129, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationStatus\": \"EINZELWELLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2130, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2131, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"comparisonOwnerRole\": \"PANEL_COMPARABILITY_ADJUDICATOR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2132, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2133, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2134, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2135, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2136, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sind nicht:", "sourceParagraph": 2137, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ein echter Nutzer,", "sourceParagraph": 2138, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ein echtes KI-Produkt,", "sourceParagraph": 2139, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine echte Unternehmensleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2140, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es handelt sich um eine maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation der Panel-Unterscheidung.", "sourceParagraph": 2141, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 80", "sourceParagraph": 2143, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH11-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2144, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beobachtungen des kontrollierten Panels unter bereinigten Bedingungen und des Panels unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen MÜSSEN bestehen bleiben", "sourceParagraph": 2146, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separate Messpopulationen, Panelzustände, Nenner und öffentliche", "sourceParagraph": 2147, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ergebnisse.", "sourceParagraph": 2148, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Kontrolliertes Panel unter bereinigten Bedingungen MUSS definieren und, falls zutreffend, überprüfen:", "sourceParagraph": 2150, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ein neues und separates Gespräch,", "sourceParagraph": 2152, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- das Fehlen eines vorherigen Gesprächskontexts,", "sourceParagraph": 2153, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zustände des persistierenden Speichers,", "sourceParagraph": 2154, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zustände benutzerdefinierter Anweisungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2155, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Unternehmens- oder verwaltete Arbeitsbereichszustände,", "sourceParagraph": 2156, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Web-, Abruf- und Werkzeugkonfiguration,", "sourceParagraph": 2157, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Plan,", "sourceParagraph": 2158, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nutzeroberfläche,", "sourceParagraph": 2159, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompt-Version,", "sourceParagraph": 2160, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Vertrauen in den sauberen Zustand.", "sourceParagraph": 2161, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein neues Gespräch oder ein temporäres Sitzungskennzeichen DARF NICHT allein, sein", "sourceParagraph": 2163, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als Nachweis behandelt, dass alle dauerhaften Personalisierungen deaktiviert wurden.", "sourceParagraph": 2164, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen MUSS das authentische Konto des Teilnehmers bewahren,", "sourceParagraph": 2166, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Plan, Schnittstelle, Speicher, benutzerdefinierte Anweisungen und Nutzungszustand, während", "sourceParagraph": 2167, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "der festgeschriebene Prompt, die Regel für die erste verfügbare Ausgabe, Nachweis", "sourceParagraph": 2168, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "anforderungen und die Nicht-Regenerationsregel beibehalten werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2169, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der natürliche Kontostand, der natürliche Gesprächszustand, die Erstverwendung und verwaltete", "sourceParagraph": 2171, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "natürliche Beobachtungen MÜSSEN separat identifiziert bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2172, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Dokumentation des natürlichen Zustands MUSS die Sammlung personenbezogener Daten minimieren.", "sourceParagraph": 2174, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Privater Anweisungstext, Gesprächshistorie, Identität, Zugangsdaten,", "sourceParagraph": 2175, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und sensible persönliche Inhalte DÜRFEN NICHT gesammelt werden, es sei denn, separat", "sourceParagraph": 2176, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "notwendig, einvernehmlich, minimiert und zugangskontrolliert.", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Von Nutzern erzeugte, zugunsten oder nachteilig für die Einrichtung gerichtete Anweisungen KÖNNEN sein", "sourceParagraph": 2179, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gemessen als natürliche Personalisierungseffekte, aber DARF NICHT repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als allgemeine Einheit GEO Erfolg, Misserfolg oder Standardproduktverhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2181, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Personalisierung KANN Relevanz, Präsentation und Empfehlung ändern", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "wo der Nutzerkontext es rechtfertigt. Es DARF NICHT willkürlich überprüfte Daten ändern", "sourceParagraph": 2184, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einheitsidentität, Lizenz, rechtlicher Status, Preis, Umfang, Nachweis oder Zeit.", "sourceParagraph": 2185, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unterschiede zwischen kontrollierten und natürlichen Panels DÜRFEN NICHT repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als kausale Personalisierungseffekte, es sei denn, Bevölkerung, Produkt, Aufforderung,", "sourceParagraph": 2188, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zeit, Schnittstelle, Plan, Werkzeuge, Aufgabe, Bestellung und Übertragungsbedingungen", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "diese Schlussfolgerung unterstützen.", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kontrollierte und natürliche Werte, kritische Fehlerraten, Unbekannte-Raten,", "sourceParagraph": 2192, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abdeckung, effektive Stichprobengrößen sowie unterzeichnete und absolute Panel-Lücken MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separat sichtbar bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Berechtigung, Umklassifizierung, Ausschluss und Gewichtung des Panels MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 2196, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unabhängig davon bleiben, ob die KI-Ausgabe positiv oder negativ ist,", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "richtig, falsch, verweigert, kritisch oder kommerziell günstig.", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Panel-Status-Definition, jeder Einstellungsänderungsprozess, jede Datenschutzentscheidung,", "sourceParagraph": 2200, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Vergleichsebene und jedes Ergebnis MÜSSEN versioniert und einer", "sourceParagraph": 2201, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2202, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2203, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH11-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beobachtungen des Kontrolliertes Panel unter bereinigten Bedingungen und des Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen sollten als separate Messpopulationen, Panelzustände, Nenner und öffentliche Ergebnisse geführt werden. Ein neuer Chat oder vorübergehender Sitzungskennzeichnung allein Evidenzt nicht, dass alle anhaltenden Personalisierungen deaktiviert sind. Der Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen sollte das echte Konto, den Plan, die Schnittstelle, den Speicher, Nutzerdefinierte Anweisungen und das Nutzungsszenario beibehalten, während der festgeschriebene Prompt, die erste passende Ausgaberegel, die Nachweisanforderungen und die Nicht-Aktualisierungsregel erhalten bleiben. Nutzergetriebenes günstiges oder ungünstiges Feedback kann als Wirkung der natürlichen Personalisierung gemessen werden; es kann nicht als allgemeiner Erfolg, Misserfolg oder Standardproduktverhalten der Entität GEO dargestellt werden. Der Unterschied zwischen kontrollierten und natürlichen Ergebnissen kann nicht als kausaler Personalisierungseffekt interpretiert werden, ohne ausreichend abgestimmte Populationen und Systembedingungen.", "sourceParagraph": 2204, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 12, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH12", "title": "Synchrone Wellen und NOMOS-Erfassung", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K12", "K14", "K25", "K26" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH12-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a predeclared and versioned measurement wave defining: - AI product states, - population and sample frames, - panel states, - prompt versions, - UTC dispatch window, - randomised micro-slots, - completion and capture deadlines, - technical-retry rules, - capture schema, - reference-record versions, - and governance ownership. Synchronisation MUST mean observation within a declared UTC system-state window and assigned slot structure. It MUST NOT be represented as perfect millisecond simultaneity. Every observation MUST preserve, as available: - assignment time, - prompt-submission time, - first system event, - response-completion time, - capture time, - hash-creation time, - upload time, - and server-acceptance time. The first contact outcome MUST remain visible. A technical retry MAY be used only under predeclared infrastructure-failure conditions and MUST retain every prior attempt. Incorrect, unfavorable, refused, uncited, truncated, or critical outputs MUST NOT be regenerated, replaced, or excluded merely because of their content. A NOMOS Capture evidence bundle MUST retain the exact assigned and sent prompt, complete raw response, full visual evidence, system-state metadata, attempt log, time evidence, file hashes, bundle hash, capture tool version, privacy status, and blinded capture-validity decision. A screenshot, hash, digital signature, provider log, or timestamp MUST NOT individually be represented as complete proof of observation authenticity. Raw evidence MUST remain immutable or append-only. Redactions, corrections, withdrawals, exclusions, and adjudication changes MUST create linked versions and preserve the prior record where ethically and legally permissible. Material AI-product changes or external events during a wave MUST be time-recorded and handled through sub-waves, explicit modelling, restarting, or mixed-state warnings. Capture validity MUST be decided independently of semantic correctness. Public evidence manifests MUST support verification without unnecessarily exposing participant identity, credentials, private conversation history, or precise location. NOMOS Capture compliance MUST be implementable through open, equivalent evidence systems and MUST NOT depend exclusively on a proprietary tool controlled by the standard's founder. Every wave, evidence bundle, capture decision, manifest revision, and integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Her GEO-1000 gözlemi; AI ürün durumlarını, nüfus ve örneklem çerçevelerini, panel koşullarını, prompt sürümlerini, UTC gönderim penceresini, rastgele mikro-slotları, tamamlama ve capture sürelerini, teknik yeniden deneme kurallarını, capture şemasını, referans kayıtlarını ve yönetişim sahibini tanımlayan önceden kayıtlı bir ölçüm dalgasına bağlanmalıdır. Eşzamanlılık, kusursuz milisaniye eşitliği değil; tanımlı UTC sistem penceresi ve slot yapısı içinde gözlem üretimidir. İlk temas sonucu görünür kalmalı; yanlış, olumsuz, ret, citation’sız veya Critical cevaplar içerikleri nedeniyle yenilenememeli, değiştirilememeli veya dışlanamamalıdır.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH12-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "82. MACHINE-READABLE WAVE RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2058 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2059 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2060 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2061 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWave\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2063 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2064 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveType\": \"MW-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2065 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"WS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2066 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"healthStatus\": \"WH-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2067 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"PRINCIPAL_POPULATION_ESTIMATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2068 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systems\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2069 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-REGISTRY-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2070 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productCount\": 10", "sourceParagraph": 2071 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2073 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameVersion\": \"NGP-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2074 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sampleAllocationVersion\": \"NGS-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2075 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValidPerProduct\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 2076 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValidTotal\": 10000", "sourceParagraph": 2077 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2078 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prompts\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2079 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGPR-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"corePromptVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStates\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2083 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledCleanVersion\": \"NGPS-CLEAN-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalUserVersion\": \"NGPS-NATURAL-W1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2085 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2086 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timing\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2087 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStandard\": \"UTC\",", "sourceParagraph": 2088 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dispatchWindowStart\": \"2026-09-01T12:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2089 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dispatchWindowEnd\": \"2026-09-01T13:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2090 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"microSlotMinutes\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2091 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"microSlotCount\": 12,", "sourceParagraph": 2092 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"completionGraceMinutes\": 20,", "sourceParagraph": 2093 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureTargetMinutesAfterCompletion\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2094 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uploadDeadlineMinutesAfterCapture\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 2095 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"slotAssignmentLocked\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2096 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2097 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capture\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2098 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"schemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-CAPTURE-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2099 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumCaptureLevel\": \"NCL-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2100 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"SYNTH-CAPTURE-2.1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2101 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2102 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2103 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetryPolicy\": \"PREDECLARED_TECHNICAL_FAILURES_ONLY\"", "sourceParagraph": 2104 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2105 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"events\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2106 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemChangeEvents\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2107 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"externalEventRegisterVersion\": \"NGER-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2108 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mixedSystemState\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2109 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2110 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2111 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"invited\": 13240,", "sourceParagraph": 2112 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"completed\": 10870,", "sourceParagraph": 2113 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValid\": 10106,", "sourceParagraph": 2114 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mainAnalysisIncluded\": 10000,", "sourceParagraph": 2115 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validReserve\": 106,", "sourceParagraph": 2116 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"withdrawn\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2117 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2118 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2119 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationBundleCount\": 10106,", "sourceParagraph": 2120 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-WAVE-MANIFEST-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2121 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"merkleRoot\": \"SYNTHETIC-MERKLE-ROOT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2122 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicManifestPublished\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2123 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2124 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2125 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeFieldwork\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2126 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveOwnerRole\": \"MEASUREMENT_WAVE_DIRECTOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2127 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureOwnerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_CHAIN_CUSTODIAN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2128 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"closedAt\": \"2026-09-01T15:30:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2129 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2130 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2131 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2132 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "83. MACHINE-READABLE OBSERVATION PACKAGE", "sourceParagraph": 2134 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2135 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2136 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2137 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2138 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationBundle\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2139 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-W1-ORION-TR-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2140 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2141 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2142 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiSystemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2143 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecordId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2144 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-MIRROR-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2145 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"slot\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2146 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"slotId\": \"W1-S04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2147 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:15:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2148 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:20:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2149 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"submittedWithinSlot\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2150 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2151 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeVector\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2152 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T11:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2153 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"taskOpenedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:14:20Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2154 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSubmittedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:08Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2155 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstSystemEventAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:10Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2156 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseCompletedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:24Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2157 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:39Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2158 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localHashCreatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:16:41Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2159 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uploadedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:17:12Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2160 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"serverAcceptedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01T12:17:13Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2161 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clockOffsetMilliseconds\": 420", "sourceParagraph": 2162 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2163 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attempts\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2164 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2165 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attemptNumber\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2166 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstContactOutcome\": \"COMPLETE_RESPONSE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2167 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetry\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2168 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleContentOutput\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2169 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2170 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2171 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prompt\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2172 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2173 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2174 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validity\": \"PV-1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2175 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2176 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"response\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"COMPLETE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2178 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"regenerated\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2179 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userInterrupted\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawTextArtifactId\": \"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2181 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visualArtifactIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2182 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2184 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2185 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationCount\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2186 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capture\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2188 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"method\": \"CM-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolName\": \"Synthetic NOMOS-Compatible Capture\",", "sourceParagraph": 2191 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"2.1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2192 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullPromptVisible\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullResponseVisible\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemStateCaptured\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2195 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2196 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"artifactHashes\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2198 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-RAW\",", "sourceParagraph": 2199 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-SCREEN-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2200 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-SCREEN-2\"", "sourceParagraph": 2201 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2202 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bundleHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-BUNDLE-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2203 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"digitalSignature\": \"SYNTHETIC-SIGNATURE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2204 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInWaveMerkleRoot\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2205 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2206 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2207 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"RESTRICTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2208 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditDerivativeCreated\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2209 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicDerivativeCreated\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2210 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityRedacted\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2211 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateConversationCaptured\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2212 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2213 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2214 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidity\": \"CV-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2215 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedBeforeSemanticScoring\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2216 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatorRole\": \"BLINDED_CAPTURE_VALIDATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2217 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-02T08:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2218 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2219 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"semanticAdjudication\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2220 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"PENDING\"", "sourceParagraph": 2221 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2222 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2223 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2224 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2225 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the real participant,", "sourceParagraph": 2226 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the real AI product,", "sourceParagraph": 2227 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the real company", "sourceParagraph": 2228 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "it does not belong.", "sourceParagraph": 2229 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is the machine-readable synthetic representation of the synchronised wave and NOMOS Capture proof chain.", "sourceParagraph": 2230 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "84. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 2232 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH12-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2233 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every GEO-1000 observation MUST be linked to a predeclared and versioned", "sourceParagraph": 2235 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "measurement wave defining:", "sourceParagraph": 2236 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- AI product states,", "sourceParagraph": 2238 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- population and sample frames,", "sourceParagraph": 2239 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- panel states,", "sourceParagraph": 2240 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt versions,", "sourceParagraph": 2241 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- UTC dispatch window,", "sourceParagraph": 2242 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- randomised micro-slots,", "sourceParagraph": 2243 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- completion and capture deadlines,", "sourceParagraph": 2244 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- technical-retry rules,", "sourceParagraph": 2245 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- capture schema,", "sourceParagraph": 2246 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- reference-record versions,", "sourceParagraph": 2247 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and governance ownership.", "sourceParagraph": 2248 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Synchronisation MUST mean observation within a declared UTC system-state", "sourceParagraph": 2250 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "window and assigned slot structure. It MUST NOT be represented as", "sourceParagraph": 2251 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "perfect millisecond simultaneity.", "sourceParagraph": 2252 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every observation MUST preserve, as available:", "sourceParagraph": 2254 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- assignment time,", "sourceParagraph": 2256 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt-submission time,", "sourceParagraph": 2257 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- first system event,", "sourceParagraph": 2258 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- response-completion time,", "sourceParagraph": 2259 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- capture time,", "sourceParagraph": 2260 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- hash-creation time,", "sourceParagraph": 2261 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- upload time,", "sourceParagraph": 2262 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and server-acceptance time.", "sourceParagraph": 2263 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The first contact outcome MUST remain visible. A technical retry MAY be", "sourceParagraph": 2265 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "used only under predeclared infrastructure-failure conditions and MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2266 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "retain every prior attempt.", "sourceParagraph": 2267 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Incorrect, unfavorable, refused, uncited, truncated, or critical outputs", "sourceParagraph": 2269 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT be regenerated, replaced, or excluded merely because of their", "sourceParagraph": 2270 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "content.", "sourceParagraph": 2271 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A NOMOS Capture evidence bundle MUST retain the exact assigned and sent", "sourceParagraph": 2273 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "prompt, complete raw response, full visual evidence, system-state", "sourceParagraph": 2274 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "metadata, attempt log, time evidence, file hashes, bundle hash, capture", "sourceParagraph": 2275 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tool version, privacy status, and blinded capture-validity decision.", "sourceParagraph": 2276 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A screenshot, hash, digital signature, provider log, or timestamp MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2278 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT individually be represented as complete proof of observation", "sourceParagraph": 2279 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authenticity.", "sourceParagraph": 2280 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Raw evidence MUST remain immutable or append-only. Redactions,", "sourceParagraph": 2282 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "corrections, withdrawals, exclusions, and adjudication changes MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2283 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "create linked versions and preserve the prior record where ethically and", "sourceParagraph": 2284 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "legally permissible.", "sourceParagraph": 2285 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Material AI-product changes or external events during a wave MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 2287 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "time-recorded and handled through sub-waves, explicit modelling,", "sourceParagraph": 2288 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "restarting, or mixed-state warnings.", "sourceParagraph": 2289 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Capture validity MUST be decided independently of semantic correctness.", "sourceParagraph": 2291 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Public evidence manifests MUST support verification without", "sourceParagraph": 2293 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unnecessarily exposing participant identity, credentials, private", "sourceParagraph": 2294 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conversation history, or precise location.", "sourceParagraph": 2295 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS Capture compliance MUST be implementable through open, equivalent", "sourceParagraph": 2297 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "evidence systems and MUST NOT depend exclusively on a proprietary tool", "sourceParagraph": 2298 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "controlled by the standard's founder.", "sourceParagraph": 2299 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every wave, evidence bundle, capture decision, manifest revision, and", "sourceParagraph": 2301 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", "sourceParagraph": 2302 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2303 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2304 }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Each GEO-1000 observation must be linked to a pre-registered measurement wave that identifies AI product states, population and sample frames, panel conditions, prompt versions, UTC submission window, random micro-slots, completion and capture times, technical retry rules, capture schema, reference records, and governance owner. Concurrency is not perfect millisecond equality; it is the production of observations within a defined UTC system window and slot structure. It must remain visible as a first-touch result; incorrect, negative, rejected, citation-less, or Critical responses may not be renewed, altered, or excluded due to their content.", "sourceParagraph": 2305 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung MUSS mit einer vorher deklarieren und versionierten Messwelle verknüpft sein, die Folgendes definiert: - KI-Produktzustände, - Populationen und Stichprobenrahmen, - Panelzustände, - Prompt-Versionen, - UTC-Übertragungsfenster, - randomisierte Mikro-Slots, - Abschluss- und Erfassungsfristen, - technische Wiederholungsregeln, - Erfassungsschema, - Referenzdatensatzversionen und - Governance-Zuordnung. Synchronisation MUSS Beobachtung innerhalb eines deklarierten UTC-Systemzustandsfensters und zugewiesener Slot-Struktur bedeuten. Sie DARF NICHT als perfekte Millisekunden-Simultanität repräsentiert werden. Jede Beobachtung MUSS folgende Angaben so weit wie möglich beibehalten: - Zuweisungszeit, - Prompt-Einreichungszeit, - erstes Systemereignis, - Abschlusszeit der Antwort, - Erfassungszeit, - Hash-Erstellungszeit, - Upload-Zeit, - und Server-Akzeptanzzeit. Das Ergebnis des ersten Kontakts MUSS sichtbar bleiben. Ein technischer Wiederholungsversuch DARF nur unter zuvor angekündigten Infrastruktur-Ausfallbedingungen verwendet werden und MUSS jeden vorherigen Versuch beibehalten. Falsche, ungünstige, abgelehnte, nicht zitierte, gekürzte oder kritische Ausgaben DARF NICHT einfach aufgrund ihres Inhalts erneut erzeugt, ersetzt oder ausgeschlossen werden. Ein NOMOS Evidenzbündel MUSS das exakt zugewiesene und gesendete Prompt, die vollständige Rohantwort, alle visuellen Nachweise, Systemzustands-Metadaten, Versuchprotokolle, Zeitevidenz, Datei-Hashes, Bündel-Hash, Version des Erfassungswerkzeugs, Datenschutzstatus und eine anonymisierte Erfassungs-Gültigkeitsentscheidung beibehalten. Ein Screenshot, Hash, digitale Signatur, Anbieterprotokoll oder Zeitstempel DARF NICHT einzeln als vollständiger Nachweis der Authentizität der Beobachtung repräsentiert werden. Rohbeweise MÜSSEN unveränderlich oder nur anhängbar bleiben. Schwärzungen, Korrekturen, Rücknahmen, Ausschlüsse und Änderungen durch die Entscheidung MÜSSEN verknüpfte Versionen erzeugen und den vorherigen Datensatz dort bewahren, wo dies ethisch und rechtlich zulässig ist. Materielle KI-Produktänderungen oder externe Ereignisse während einer Welle MÜSSEN zeitlich erfasst und durch Unterwellen, explizite Modellierung, Neustart oder Mischzustandswarnungen behandelt werden. Die Gültigkeit der Erfassung MUSS unabhängig von der semantischen Korrektheit entschieden werden. Öffentliche Nachweis-Manifeste MÜSSEN die Überprüfung unterstützen, ohne unnötig die Identität von Teilnehmern, Zugangsdaten, private Gesprächshistorie oder den genauen Standort offenzulegen. NOMOS Die Einhaltung der Erfassung MUSS durch offene, gleichwertige Evidenzsysteme umsetzbar sein und DARF NICHT ausschließlich von einem proprietären Tool abhängen, das von dem Gründer des Standards kontrolliert wird. Jede Welle, jedes Evidenzpaket, jede Erfassungsentscheidung, jede Manifestüberarbeitung und jeder Integritätsdatensatz MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH12-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "82. MASCHINENLESBARE WELLENAUFZEICHNUNG", "sourceParagraph": 2058, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2059, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2060, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2061, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2062, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"measurementWave\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2063, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2064, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveType\": \"MW-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2065, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"WS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2066, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"healthStatus\": \"WH-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2067, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"PRINZIPALE_POPULATIONSSCHÄTZUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2068, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systems\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2069, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-REGISTRY-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2070, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productCount\": 10", "sourceParagraph": 2071, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2073, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameVersion\": \"NGP-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2074, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sampleAllocationVersion\": \"NGS-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2075, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValidPerProduct\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 2076, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetValidTotal\": 10000", "sourceParagraph": 2077, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2078, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Anfragen\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2079, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryVersion\": \"NGPR-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2080, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"corePromptVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2081, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStates\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2083, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"controlledCleanVersion\": \"NGPS-CLEAN-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalUserVersion\": \"NGPS-NATURAL-W1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2085, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2086, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Timing\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2087, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStandard\": \"UTC\",", "sourceParagraph": 2088, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dispatchWindowStart\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2089, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dispatchWindowEnd\": \"2026-09-01 T1 3:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2090, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"microSlotMinutes\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2091, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"microSlotCount\": 12,", "sourceParagraph": 2092, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"completionGraceMinutes\": 20,", "sourceParagraph": 2093, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureTargetMinutesAfterCompletion\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2094, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uploadDeadlineMinutesAfterCapture\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 2095, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"slotAssignmentLocked\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2096, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2097, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Erfassung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2098, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"schemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-ERFASSUNG-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2099, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumCaptureLevel\": \"NCL-3\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2100, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"SYNTH-CAPTURE-2.1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2101, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleOutputRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2102, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseRegenerationAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2103, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetryPolicy\": \"NUR_VORAB_GEPLANDE_TECHNISCHE_FEHLER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2104, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2105, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ereignisse\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2106, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemChangeEvents\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2107, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"externalEventRegisterVersion\": \"NGER-SYNTH-W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2108, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mixedSystemState\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2109, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2110, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fieldwork\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2111, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eingeladen\": 13240,", "sourceParagraph": 2112, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"abgeschlossen\": 10870,", "sourceParagraph": 2113, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValid\": 10106,", "sourceParagraph": 2114, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mainAnalysisIncluded\": 10000,", "sourceParagraph": 2115, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validReserve\": 106,", "sourceParagraph": 2116, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"zurückgezogen\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2117, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2118, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2119, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationBundleCount\": 10106,", "sourceParagraph": 2120, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHE-WELLEN-ERSCHEINUNG-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2121, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"merkleRoot\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-MERKLE-WURZEL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2122, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicManifestPublished\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2123, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2124, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2125, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeFieldwork\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2126, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveOwnerRole\": \"MESSWELLE-DIREKTOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2127, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureOwnerRole\": \"BEWEISKETTEN-VERWAHRER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2128, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"closedAt\": \"2026-09-01 T1 5:30:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2129, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2130, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2131, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2132, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "83. MASCHINENLESBARES BEOBACHTUNGSPAKET", "sourceParagraph": 2134, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2135, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2136, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2137, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2138, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationBundle\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2139, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"NGO-SYNTH-W1-ORION-TR-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2140, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2141, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2142, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiSystemRecordId\": \"NGAI-SYNTH-ORION-WEB-PAID-W1-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2143, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelStateRecordId\": \"NGPS-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2144, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"NGP-CORE-SPIEGEL-APPLE-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2145, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Steckplatz\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2146, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"slotId\": \"W1-S0 4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2147, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:15:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2148, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:20:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2149, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"submittedWithinSlot\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2150, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2151, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeVector\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2152, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 1:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2153, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"taskOpenedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:14:20 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2154, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSubmittedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:08 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2155, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstSystemEventAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:10 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2156, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseCompletedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:24 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2157, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:39 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2158, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"localHashCreatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:16:41 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2159, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uploadedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:17:12 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2160, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"serverAcceptedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-01 T1 2:17:13 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2161, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clockOffsetMilliseconds\": 420", "sourceParagraph": 2162, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2163, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Versuche\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2164, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2165, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attemptNumber\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2166, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstContactOutcome\": \"VOLLSTÄNDIGE_ANTWORT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2167, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"technicalRetry\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2168, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"firstEligibleContentOutput\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2169, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2170, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2171, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Aufforderung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2172, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assignedHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2173, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sentHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2174, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Gültigkeit\": \"PV-1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2175, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2176, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Antwort\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"VOLLSTÄNDIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2178, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Regeneriert\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2179, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"userInterrupted\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawTextArtifactId\": \"ART-ROH-TEXT-001\",\"", "sourceParagraph": 2181, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visualArtifactIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2182, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2184, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2185, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationCount\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2186, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Erfassung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2188, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Methode\": \"CM-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolName\": \"Synthetische NOMOS-kompatible Erfassung\",", "sourceParagraph": 2191, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"toolVersion\": \"2.1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2192, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullPromptVisible\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fullResponseVisible\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"systemStateCaptured\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2195, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2196, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"artifactHashes\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-RAW-TEXT-001\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-RAW\",", "sourceParagraph": 2199, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-001\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-SCREEN-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2200, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ART-SCREEN-002\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-SCREEN-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2201, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2202, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bundleHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHES-BUNDLE-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2203, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"digitalSignature\": \"SYNTHETISCHE-SIGNATUR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2204, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInWaveMerkleRoot\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2205, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2206, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Privatsphäre\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2207, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawEvidenceAccess\": \"EINGESCHRÄNKT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2208, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditDerivativeCreated\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2209, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicDerivativeCreated\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2210, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityRedacted\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2211, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privateConversationCaptured\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2212, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2213, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Validierung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2214, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidity\": \"CV-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2215, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedBeforeSemanticScoring\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2216, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatorRole\": \"BLINDED_CAPTURE_VALIDATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2217, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validatedAtUtc\": \"2026-09-02 T0 8:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2218, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2219, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"semanticAdjudication\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2220, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"AUSSTEHEND\"", "sourceParagraph": 2221, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2222, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2223, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2224, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2225, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Für den tatsächlichen Teilnehmer,", "sourceParagraph": 2226, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zum echten KI-Produkt,", "sourceParagraph": 2227, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zur echten Gesellschaft", "sourceParagraph": 2228, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es gehört nicht dazu.", "sourceParagraph": 2229, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es handelt sich um die maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation der synchronisierten Wellen- und NOMOS Capture-Evidenzkette.", "sourceParagraph": 2230, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "84. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 2232, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH12-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2233, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000 Beobachtung MUSS mit einer vordeklarierten und versionierten Beobachtung verknüpft sein", "sourceParagraph": 2235, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Messwellendefinition folgendes:", "sourceParagraph": 2236, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- KI-Produktzustände,", "sourceParagraph": 2238, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Populations- und Stichprobenrahmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2239, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Panel-Zustände,", "sourceParagraph": 2240, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompt-Versionen,", "sourceParagraph": 2241, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- UTC Sende-Fenster,", "sourceParagraph": 2242, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- randomisierte Mikro-Slots,", "sourceParagraph": 2243, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Fristen für Abschluss und Erfassung,", "sourceParagraph": 2244, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Regeln für technische Wiederholungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2245, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Erfassungsschema,", "sourceParagraph": 2246, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Versionen der Referenzaufzeichnungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2247, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Governance-Eigentum.", "sourceParagraph": 2248, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Synchronisation MUSS Beobachtung innerhalb eines deklarierten UTC Systemzustands", "sourceParagraph": 2250, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fensters und der zugewiesenen Slot-Struktur bedeuten. Sie DARF NICHT repräsentiert werden als", "sourceParagraph": 2251, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "perfekte Millisekunden-Simultaneität.", "sourceParagraph": 2252, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Beobachtung MUSS, soweit verfügbar, bewahrt werden:", "sourceParagraph": 2254, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zuordnungszeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2256, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Eingabezeitpunkt der Aufforderung,", "sourceParagraph": 2257, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- erstes Systemereignis,", "sourceParagraph": 2258, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Antwort-Vervollständigungszeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2259, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Aufzeichnungszeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2260, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Hash-Erstellungszeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2261, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Upload-Zeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2262, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Server-Akzeptanzzeit.", "sourceParagraph": 2263, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Ergebnis des ersten Kontakts MUSS sichtbar bleiben. Ein technischer Wiederholungsversuch KANN erfolgen.", "sourceParagraph": 2265, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nur unter vorab festgelegten Infrastrukturausfallbedingungen verwendet und MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 2266, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bewahre jeden vorherigen Versuch auf.", "sourceParagraph": 2267, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Inkorrekt, ungünstig, abgelehnt, nicht zitiert, gekürzt oder kritisch ausgegebene Ergebnisse", "sourceParagraph": 2269, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DARF NICHT regeneriert, ersetzt oder ausgeschlossen werden, nur wegen ihres", "sourceParagraph": 2270, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Inhalts.", "sourceParagraph": 2271, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein NOMOS Erfassungsbeweis-Bundle MUSS den exakt zugewiesenen und gesendeten", "sourceParagraph": 2273, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Prompt, die vollständige Rohantwort, den vollständigen visuellen Nachweis, Systemzustands-", "sourceParagraph": 2274, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Metadaten, Versuchslog, Zeitbeweise, Datei-Hashes, Bundle-Hash, Version des Erfassungstools, Datenschutzstatus und die geblendete Gültigkeitsentscheidung der Erfassung enthalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2275, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Screenshot, Hash, digitale Signatur, Anbieterlog oder Zeitstempel darf", "sourceParagraph": 2276, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht einzeln als vollständiger Nachweis der Authentizität der Beobachtung dargestellt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2278, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2279, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2280, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Rohbeweise MÜSSEN unveränderlich oder nur anfügbar bleiben. Schwärzungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2282, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Korrekturen, Zurückziehungen, Ausschlüsse und Entscheidungen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2283, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "verknüpfte Versionen erstellen und den vorherigen Datensatz bewahren, wo es ethisch und", "sourceParagraph": 2284, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "rechtlich zulässig ist.", "sourceParagraph": 2285, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Materielle Änderungen an KI-Produkten oder externe Ereignisse während einer Welle MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2287, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zeitlich erfasst und durch Teilwellen, explizite Modellierung,", "sourceParagraph": 2288, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Neustarts oder Warnungen über gemischte Zustände gehandhabt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2289, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Gültigkeit der Erfassung MÜSSEN unabhängig von semantischer Korrektheit entschieden werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2291, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Öffentliche Evidenzmanifestationen MÜSSEN die Überprüfung unterstützen, ohne", "sourceParagraph": 2293, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unnötige Offenlegung der Identität der Teilnehmer, Zugangsdaten, privaten", "sourceParagraph": 2294, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Konversationshistorie oder genauen Standort.", "sourceParagraph": 2295, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS Erfassungs-Compliance MUSS durch offene, gleichwertige", "sourceParagraph": 2297, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Evidenzsysteme implementierbar sein und DARF NICHT ausschließlich von einem proprietären Tool", "sourceParagraph": 2298, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "abhängen, das vom Gründer des Standards kontrolliert wird.", "sourceParagraph": 2299, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Welle, jedes Evidenzbündel, jede Erfassungsentscheidung, jede Manifestrevision und", "sourceParagraph": 2301, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Integritätsaufzeichnung MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person zuordenbar sein", "sourceParagraph": 2302, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Mensch oder Organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2303, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2304, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH12-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede GEO-1000-Beobachtung muss mit einer vorab registrierten Messwelle verknüpft sein, die den Zustand des KI-Produkts, Populations- und Stichprobenrahmen, Panelbedingungen, Prompt-Versionen, UTC-Einreichungsfenster, zufällige Mikro-Slots, Abschluss- und Erfassungszeiten, technische Wiederholungsregeln, Erfassungs-Schema, Referenzdatensätze und Governance-Verantwortliche identifiziert. Gleichzeitigkeit bedeutet nicht perfekte Millisekunden-Gleichheit; sie ist die Erzeugung von Beobachtungen innerhalb eines definierten UTC-Systemfensters und Slot-Struktur. Sie muss als Erstkontakt-Ergebnis sichtbar bleiben; falsche, negative, abgelehnte, zitierungslose oder kritische Antworten dürfen aufgrund ihres Inhalts nicht erneuert, geändert oder ausgeschlossen werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2305, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 13, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH13", "title": "Das verifizierte Faktenpaket zur Entität", "subtitle": "Verifiziertes Faktenpaket zur Entität", "sourceIds": [ "K10", "K11", "K12" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH13-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Before semantic adjudication begins, every GEO-1000 audit MUST lock a versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope, jurisdictions, products, languages, and reference time. The Truth Pack MUST contain, as applicable: - canonical entity identity, - atomic reference claims, - Official Representation Records, - supporting evidence, - counter-evidence, - source-lineage and evidence-family records, - scope and jurisdiction qualifiers, - validity and publication times, - public and restricted access classes, - unknown and unresolved registers, - appeal and change records, - and an integrity manifest. An Official Representation Record MUST NOT be treated as independently verified reality merely because it is official. A first-party source MAY be authoritative for claims under the entity's direct control, while remaining non-independent for comparative, performance, leadership, or external-validation claims. Different URLs, publications, translations, syndications, or AI summaries MUST NOT be counted as independent evidence when they derive from the same root source. Every evidence object MUST state which atomic claim it supports, qualifies, contradicts, outdates, or contextualises. The absence of located evidence MUST NOT automatically be represented as proof that a claim is false. Open-world and closed-world evidence conditions MUST remain distinct. Quantitative claims MUST retain numerator, denominator, period, unit, inclusion and exclusion rules, source data, and calculation method. Customer, partner, license, certification, membership, award, legal, performance, and superiority claims MUST preserve their exact entity, relationship, scope, jurisdiction, time, and evidence status. Publicly discoverable evidence, restricted audit evidence, and non-public evidence MUST remain separately classified. A claim MAY be factually verified through restricted evidence without being publicly retrievable by a consumer AI product. Factual verification and public discoverability MUST remain distinct. Truth Pack claims MUST NOT be added, removed, broadened, narrowed, or reclassified after AI responses are observed unless a new Truth Pack version is created and prior records are preserved. A response claim not covered by the locked Truth Pack MUST trigger a reference-gap process rather than automatic failure or automatic acceptance. Unknown, unsupported, unresolved, contradicted, historical, expired, scope-limited, and restrictedly verified states MUST remain separately visible. The audited entity MAY submit evidence, corrections, and appeals, but MUST NOT act as the sole adjudicator of its own claims. AI systems MAY assist with extraction, normalisation, lineage detection, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final authority for claim truth status. Every Truth Pack version, evidence registration, support-status decision, appeal, and change MUST be attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Semantik hakemlik başlamadan önce her GEO-1000 denetimi; denetlenen varlık, prompt kapsamı, ülkeler, ürünler, diller ve referans zamanı için sürümlü bir Doğrulanmış Varlık Gerçeklik Paketi kilitlemelidir. Paket kanonik varlık kimliğini, atomik referans iddialarını, Resmî Temsil Kayıtlarını, destekleyen kanıtı, karşı kanıtı, kaynak soyunu, kapsam ve zaman sınırlarını, erişim sınıflarını, bilinmeyenleri, itirazları ve bütünlük manifestini taşımalıdır. Resmî beyan yalnız resmî olduğu için bağımsız doğrulanmış gerçeklik sayılamaz. Farklı URL’ler aynı kök kaynaktan türemişse bağımsız kanıtlar olarak sayılamaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH13-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "92. MACHINE-READABLE TRUTH PACK RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2450 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2451 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2452 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2453 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2454 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2455 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-05\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 2458 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", "sourceParagraph": 2459 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2460 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2461 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentationStatus\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2462 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicDiscoverability\": \"PUBLICLY_DISCOVERABLE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2463 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceLinks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2464 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2465 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2466 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"SUPPORTS\"", "sourceParagraph": 2467 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2468 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2469 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2470 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"QUALIFIES\"", "sourceParagraph": 2471 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2472 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2473 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uncertainty\": \"The term operates is not defined consistently.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2474 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2475 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2476 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidence\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2477 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2478 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2479 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2480 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Asteron Global Presence Page\",", "sourceParagraph": 2481 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"AUDITED_ENTITY_CONTROLLED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2482 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"OFFICIAL_SELF_REPRESENTATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2483 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independence\": \"NOT_INDEPENDENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2484 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2485 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-30T14:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2486 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2487 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lineageFamilyId\": \"EVIDENCE-FAMILY-ASTERON-SELF-CLAIM-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2488 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-WEB-025\"", "sourceParagraph": 2489 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2490 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2491 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2492 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Verified Active Operations Register\",", "sourceParagraph": 2494 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"AUDITED_ENTITY_CONTROLLED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2495 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"DIRECT_OPERATIONAL_RECORD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2496 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independence\": \"NOT_INDEPENDENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2497 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29T10:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2498 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2499 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-OPS-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2500 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2501 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2502 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-CONTRACTS-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2503 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2504 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Country Contract Corroboration Set\",", "sourceParagraph": 2505 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"MULTI_PARTY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2506 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"CONTRACTUAL_CORROBORATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2507 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independence\": \"PARTIALLY_INDEPENDENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2508 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29T11:00:00Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2509 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2510 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-HASH-CONTRACTS-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2511 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2512 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2513 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unknowns\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2514 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2515 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unknownId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2516 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"type\": \"UNKNOWN_SCOPE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2517 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relatedClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2518 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"description\": \"The official term operates is not defined.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2519 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2520 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2521 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2522 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimLedgerOwnerRole\": \"TRUTH_PACK_EDITOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2523 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceRegistrarRole\": \"EVIDENCE_REGISTRAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2524 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidenceReviewerRole\": \"COUNTER_EVIDENCE_REVIEWER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2525 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalApproverRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_TRUTH_PACK_APPROVER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeSemanticReview\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2527 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-31T18:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2528 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2529 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2530 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-TRUTH-PACK-MANIFEST-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2531 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2532 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2533 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2534 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2535 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "93. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM–EVIDENCE RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2537 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2538 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2539 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2540 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2541 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimEvidenceRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2542 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-SUCCESS-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2543 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2544 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-08\",", "sourceParagraph": 2545 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"atomicClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2546 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", "sourceParagraph": 2547 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 2548 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unit\": \"PROPORTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2549 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": \"ALL_PROJECTS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2550 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"period\": \"UNSPECIFIED\"", "sourceParagraph": 2551 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2552 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2553 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"OFFICIAL_CURRENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2554 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceEvidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-SUCCESS-003\"", "sourceParagraph": 2555 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2556 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verification\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2557 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", "sourceParagraph": 2558 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2559 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2560 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reasonCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2561 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"DENOMINATOR_UNDEFINED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2562 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SUCCESS_CRITERION_UNDEFINED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2563 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PERIOD_UNDEFINED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2564 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SELECTED_CASES_ONLY\"", "sourceParagraph": 2565 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2566 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2567 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportingEvidence\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2568 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2569 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-CASESET-049\",", "sourceParagraph": 2570 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"PARTIALLY_SUPPORTS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2571 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notes\": \"Forty-nine positive case records.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2572 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2573 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2574 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidence\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2575 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2576 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-FAILED-CASE-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2577 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"QUALIFIES\",", "sourceParagraph": 2578 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notes\": \"One known unsuccessful project; full project universe unavailable.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2579 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2580 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2581 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publiclyDiscoverable\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2582 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preferredEpistemicForm\": \"The company states a 98% success rate, but the denominator, period, and success definition have not been independently verified.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2583 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedForm\": \"The company has a verified 98% success rate.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2584 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"APPEAL_OPEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2585 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2586 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2587 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2588 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real company,", "sourceParagraph": 2589 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real customer,", "sourceParagraph": 2590 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real performance", "sourceParagraph": 2591 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "is not data.", "sourceParagraph": 2592 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a synthetic machine representation of the Truth Pack architecture.", "sourceParagraph": 2593 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 94", "sourceParagraph": 2595 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH13-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2596 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Before semantic adjudication begins, every GEO-1000 audit MUST lock a", "sourceParagraph": 2598 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2599 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "jurisdictions, products, languages, and reference time.", "sourceParagraph": 2600 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The Truth Pack MUST contain, as applicable:", "sourceParagraph": 2602 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- canonical entity identity,", "sourceParagraph": 2604 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- atomic reference claims,", "sourceParagraph": 2605 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Official Representation Records,", "sourceParagraph": 2606 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- supporting evidence,", "sourceParagraph": 2607 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- counter-evidence,", "sourceParagraph": 2608 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- source-lineage and evidence-family records,", "sourceParagraph": 2609 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope and jurisdiction qualifiers,", "sourceParagraph": 2610 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- validity and publication times,", "sourceParagraph": 2611 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- public and restricted access classes,", "sourceParagraph": 2612 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unknown and unresolved registers,", "sourceParagraph": 2613 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- appeal and change records,", "sourceParagraph": 2614 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and an integrity manifest.", "sourceParagraph": 2615 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An Official Representation Record MUST NOT be treated as independently", "sourceParagraph": 2617 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "verified reality merely because it is official.", "sourceParagraph": 2618 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A first-party source MAY be authoritative for claims under the entity's", "sourceParagraph": 2620 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "direct control, while remaining non-independent for comparative,", "sourceParagraph": 2621 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "performance, leadership, or external-validation claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2622 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Different URLs, publications, translations, syndications, or AI summaries", "sourceParagraph": 2624 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT be counted as independent evidence when they derive from the", "sourceParagraph": 2625 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "same root source.", "sourceParagraph": 2626 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every evidence object MUST state which atomic claim it supports,", "sourceParagraph": 2628 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "qualifies, contradicts, outdates, or contextualises.", "sourceParagraph": 2629 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The absence of located evidence MUST NOT automatically be represented as", "sourceParagraph": 2631 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "proof that a claim is false. Open-world and closed-world evidence", "sourceParagraph": 2632 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conditions MUST remain distinct.", "sourceParagraph": 2633 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Quantitative claims MUST retain numerator, denominator, period, unit,", "sourceParagraph": 2635 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "inclusion and exclusion rules, source data, and calculation method.", "sourceParagraph": 2636 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Customer, partner, license, certification, membership, award, legal,", "sourceParagraph": 2638 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "performance, and superiority claims MUST preserve their exact entity,", "sourceParagraph": 2639 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "relationship, scope, jurisdiction, time, and evidence status.", "sourceParagraph": 2640 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Publicly discoverable evidence, restricted audit evidence, and", "sourceParagraph": 2642 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "non-public evidence MUST remain separately classified.", "sourceParagraph": 2643 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A claim MAY be factually verified through restricted evidence without", "sourceParagraph": 2645 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "being publicly retrievable by a consumer AI product. Factual verification", "sourceParagraph": 2646 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and public discoverability MUST remain distinct.", "sourceParagraph": 2647 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Truth Pack claims MUST NOT be added, removed, broadened, narrowed, or", "sourceParagraph": 2649 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reclassified after AI responses are observed unless a new Truth Pack", "sourceParagraph": 2650 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "version is created and prior records are preserved.", "sourceParagraph": 2651 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A response claim not covered by the locked Truth Pack MUST trigger a", "sourceParagraph": 2653 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reference-gap process rather than automatic failure or automatic", "sourceParagraph": 2654 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "acceptance.", "sourceParagraph": 2655 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unknown, unsupported, unresolved, contradicted, historical, expired,", "sourceParagraph": 2657 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scope-limited, and restrictedly verified states MUST remain separately", "sourceParagraph": 2658 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "visible.", "sourceParagraph": 2659 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The audited entity MAY submit evidence, corrections, and appeals, but", "sourceParagraph": 2661 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT act as the sole adjudicator of its own claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2662 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI systems MAY assist with extraction, normalisation, lineage detection,", "sourceParagraph": 2664 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final", "sourceParagraph": 2665 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authority for claim truth status.", "sourceParagraph": 2666 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every Truth Pack version, evidence registration, support-status decision,", "sourceParagraph": 2668 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "appeal, and change MUST be attributable to an accountable human or", "sourceParagraph": 2669 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2670 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2671 }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Before semantic adjudication begins, each GEO-1000 audit must lock a versioned Verified Entity Truth Pack for the audited entity, prompt scope, countries, products, languages, and reference time. The package must contain the canonical entity identity, atomic reference claims, Official Representation Records, supporting evidence, counter-evidence, source lineage, scope and time limits, access classes, unknowns, objections, and an integrity manifest. An official statement cannot be considered independently verified reality just because it is official. Different URLs derived from the same root source cannot be counted as independent evidence.", "sourceParagraph": 2672 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Bevor die semantische Beurteilung beginnt, MUSS jeder GEO-1000-Audit eine versionierte Verifiziertes Faktenpaket zur Entität für die geprüfte Einheit, den Aufforderungsumfang, die Zuständigkeiten, Produkte, Sprachen und die Referenzzeit festschreiben. Das Truth Pack MUSS, soweit zutreffend, Folgendes enthalten: - kanonische Identität der Einheit, - atomare Referenzaussagen, - Offizielle Repräsentationsaufzeichnungen, - unterstützende Nachweise, - Gegenevidenz, - Quellenherkunfts- und Nachweis-Familienaufzeichnungen, - Umfangs- und Zuständigkeitsqualifikatoren, - Gültigkeits- und Veröffentlichungszeiten, - öffentliche und eingeschränkte Zugriffsklassen, - unbekannte und ungelöste Register, - Berufungs- und Änderungsaufzeichnungen, - und ein Integritätsmanifest. Ein offizieller Repräsentationsbericht DARF NICHT als unabhängig überprüfte Realität behandelt werden, nur weil er offiziell ist. Eine Quelle erster Hand KANN für Behauptungen unter direkter Kontrolle der Einrichtung maßgeblich sein, bleibt jedoch für vergleichende, leistungsbezogene, Führungs- oder externe Validierungsbehauptungen nicht unabhängig. Unterschiedliche URLs, Veröffentlichungen, Übersetzungen, Syndizierungen oder KI-Zusammenfassungen DARF NICHT als unabhängige Belege gezählt werden, wenn sie von derselben Ursprungsquelle stammen. Jedes Evidenzobjekt MUSS angeben, welche atomare Behauptung es unterstützt, qualifiziert, widerspricht, veraltet oder kontextualisiert. Das Fehlen von gefundenen Nachweisen DARF NICHT automatisch als Nachweis dafür repräsentiert werden, dass eine Behauptung falsch ist. Bedingungen für Nachweise in offenen und geschlossenen Welten MÜSSEN klar voneinander unterschieden bleiben. Quantitative Aussagen MÜSSEN Zähler, Nenner, Zeitraum, Einheit, Ein- und Ausschlussregeln, Quellendaten und Berechnungsmethode beibehalten. Aussagen über Kunden, Partner, Lizenzen, Zertifizierungen, Mitgliedschaften, Auszeichnungen, rechtliche Aspekte, Leistung und Überlegenheit MÜSSEN ihre genaue Entität, Beziehung, Reichweite, Zuständigkeit, Zeit und Evidenzstatus bewahren. Öffentlich zugängliche Nachweise, eingeschränkte Prüfungsbeweise und nicht-öffentliche Nachweise MÜSSEN weiterhin getrennt klassifiziert bleiben. Eine Aussage KANN sachlich durch eingeschränkte Nachweise überprüft werden, ohne dass sie für ein Verbraucher-KI-Produkt öffentlich abrufbar ist. Sachliche Überprüfung und öffentliche Auffindbarkeit MÜSSEN klar voneinander unterschieden bleiben. Behauptungen des Truth Pack DARF NICHT hinzugefügt, entfernt, erweitert, eingeschränkt oder neu klassifiziert werden, nachdem KI-Antworten beobachtet wurden, es sei denn, es wird eine neue Version des Truth Pack erstellt und frühere Aufzeichnungen werden aufbewahrt. Eine Antwortbehauptung, die nicht durch das festgeschriebene Truth Pack abgedeckt ist, MUSS einen Referenz-Lücken-Prozess auslösen, anstatt automatisch abgelehnt oder automatisch akzeptiert zu werden. Unbekannte, nicht unterstützte, ungelöste, widersprüchliche, historische, abgelaufene, in ihrem Umfang begrenzte und eingeschränkt verifizierte Zustände MÜSSEN weiterhin separat sichtbar bleiben. Das geprüfte Subjekt DARF Nachweise, Korrekturen und Einsprüche einreichen, DARF jedoch nicht als alleiniger Schiedsrichter seiner eigenen Behauptungen agieren. KI-Systeme KÖNNEN bei Extraktion, Normalisierung, Herkunftserkennung und Widerspruchsfindung helfen, DÜRFEN jedoch nicht als einzige endgültige Instanz für den Wahrheitsstatus einer Behauptung dienen. Jede Version des Truth Packs, jede Evidenzregistrierung, jede Entscheidung über den Unterstützungsstatus, jede Berufung und jede Änderung MUSS einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden KÖNNEN.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH13-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "92. MASCHINENLESBARES WAHRHEITS-PACK-REKORD", "sourceParagraph": 2450, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2451, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2452, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2453, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-LÄNDER-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2454, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2455, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-05\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"operatesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 2458, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", "sourceParagraph": 2459, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2460, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentationStatus\": \"OFFIZIELL_AKTUELL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicDiscoverability\": \"ÖFFENTLICH_ENTDECKBAR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceLinks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2465, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"UNTERSTÜTZT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2469, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relationship\": \"QUALIFIZIERT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Unsicherheit\": \"Der Begriff 'betreibt' ist nicht konsistent definiert.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2474, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Nachweise\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2477, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Titel\": \"Asteron Globale Präsenzseite\",", "sourceParagraph": 2481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"GEPRÜFTE_ENTITÄT_KONTROLLIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"OFFIZIELLE_SELSTDARSTELLUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2483, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Unabhängigkeit\": \"NICHT_UNABHÄNGIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2484, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publishedAt\": \"2026-01-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2485, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-30 T1 4:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2486, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2487, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lineageFamilyId\": \"NACHWEIS-FAMILIE-ASTERON-SELBST-AUSSAGE-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2488, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-HASH-WEB-025\"", "sourceParagraph": 2489, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2490, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2491, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2492, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Titel\": \"Verifiziertes Aktives Betriebsregister\"", "sourceParagraph": 2494, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"GEPRÜFTE_ENTITÄT_KONTROLLIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2495, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"DIREKTE_BETRIEBSAUFZEICHNUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2496, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Unabhängigkeit\": \"NICHT_UNABHÄNGIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2497, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29 T1 0:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2498, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2499, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHE-HASH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2500, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2501, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2502, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-VERTRÄGE-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2503, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceRole\": \"SR-04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2504, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Landesvertragsbestätigungssatz\",", "sourceParagraph": 2505, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceControl\": \"MEHRPARTEIIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2506, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorityForClaim\": \"VERTRAGLICHE_BESTÄTIGUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2507, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independence\": \"TEILWEISE_UNABHÄNGIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2508, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"capturedAt\": \"2026-08-29 T1 1:00:00 Z\",", "sourceParagraph": 2509, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accessClass\": \"EA-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2510, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHE-HASH-VERTRÄGE-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2511, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unknowns\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unknownId\": \"NGU-SYNTH-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"type\": \"UNBEKANNTER_BEREICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relatedClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-LÄNDER-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"description\": \"Der offizielle Begriff 'operates' ist nicht definiert.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimLedgerOwnerRole\": \"WAHRHEITS_PACK_EDITOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceRegistrarRole\": \"BEWEIS_REGISTRIERER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidenceReviewerRole\": \"COUNTER_EVIDENCE_REVIEWER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalApproverRole\": \"VERANTWORTLICHER_MENSCHLICHER_WAHRHEITS_PACK_GENEHMIGER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeSemanticReview\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-08-31 T1 8:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHES-WAHRHEITS-PACK-MANIFEST-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "93. MASCHINENLESBARES AUSSAGE–BEWEIS_DATENBLATT", "sourceParagraph": 2537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimEvidenceRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-ERFOLG-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimType\": \"CT-08\",", "sourceParagraph": 2545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"atomicClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", "sourceParagraph": 2547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 2548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"einheit\": \"ANTEIL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2549, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bevölkerung\": \"ALLE_PROJEKTE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"periode\": \"UNSPEZIFIZIERT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2552, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialRepresentation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"OFFIZIELL_AKTUELL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceEvidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-ERFOLG-003\"", "sourceParagraph": 2555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2556, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Überprüfung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportStatus\": \"VS-U\",", "sourceParagraph": 2558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeStatus\": \"SC-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2559, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeStatus\": \"TS-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reasonCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"DENOMINATOR_UNDEFINIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ERFOLGSKRITERIUM_UNDEFINIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2563, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ZEITRAUM_UNDEFINIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NUR_AUSGEWÄHLTE_FÄLLE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2566, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2567, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportingEvidence\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-FALLSET-049\",", "sourceParagraph": 2570, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Beziehung\": \"TEILWEISE_UNTERSTÜTZT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2571, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Notizen\": \"Neunundvierzig positive Fallaufzeichnungen.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterEvidence\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2575, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceId\": \"NGEV-SYNTH-FAILED-FALL-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Beziehung\": \"QUALIFIZIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2578, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Notizen\": \"Ein bekanntes erfolgloses Projekt; vollständiges Projektuniversum nicht verfügbar.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publiclyDiscoverable\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2582, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preferredEpistemicForm\": \"Das Unternehmen gibt eine 98%-Erfolgsquote an, aber der Nenner, der Zeitraum und die Erfolgsdefinition wurden nicht unabhängig überprüft.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedForm\": \"Das Unternehmen hat eine verifizierte 98%-Erfolgsquote.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealStatus\": \"APPEAL_OPEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2586, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echtes Unternehmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echter Kunde,", "sourceParagraph": 2590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echte Leistung", "sourceParagraph": 2591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ist keine Daten.", "sourceParagraph": 2592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist eine synthetische Maschinenabbildung der Truth Pack-Architektur.", "sourceParagraph": 2593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 94", "sourceParagraph": 2595, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH13-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevor die semantische Bewertung beginnt, MUSS jeder GEO-1000-Audit eine", "sourceParagraph": 2598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versionierte Verifiziertes Faktenpaket zur Entität für die geprüfte Entität, Aufforderungsbereich, sperren.", "sourceParagraph": 2599, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jurisdiktionen, Produkte, Sprachen und Referenzzeit.", "sourceParagraph": 2600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Truth Pack MUSS enthalten, sofern zutreffend:", "sourceParagraph": 2602, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- kanonische Entitätsidentität,", "sourceParagraph": 2604, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- atomare Referenzaussagen,", "sourceParagraph": 2605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- offizielle Repräsentationsaufzeichnungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2606, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unterstützende Nachweise,", "sourceParagraph": 2607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gegenevidenz,", "sourceParagraph": 2608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Quellenherkunfts- und Evidenzfamilienaufzeichnungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2609, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Geltungsbereichs- und Zuständigkeitsqualifizierer,", "sourceParagraph": 2610, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gültigkeits- und Veröffentlichungszeiten,", "sourceParagraph": 2611, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- öffentliche und eingeschränkte Zugriffsklassen,", "sourceParagraph": 2612, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unbekannte und ungelöste Register,", "sourceParagraph": 2613, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Berufungs- und Änderungsaufzeichnungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2614, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und ein Integritätsmanifest.", "sourceParagraph": 2615, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein offizielles Repräsentationsdokument DARF NICHT unabhängig behandelt werden", "sourceParagraph": 2617, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "verifizierte Realität nur weil sie offiziell ist.", "sourceParagraph": 2618, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Quelle erster Hand KANN für Behauptungen des Unternehmens maßgeblich sein", "sourceParagraph": 2620, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "direkte Kontrolle, während sie im Vergleich nicht unabhängig bleibt,", "sourceParagraph": 2621, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Leistungs-, Führungs- oder extern-validierungsbezogene Aussagen.", "sourceParagraph": 2622, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verschiedene URLs, Veröffentlichungen, Übersetzungen, Syndizierungen oder KI-Zusammenfassungen", "sourceParagraph": 2624, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DÜRFEN NICHT als unabhängige Nachweise gezählt werden, wenn sie von den", "sourceParagraph": 2625, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gleiche Wurzelquelle.", "sourceParagraph": 2626, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jedes Evidenzobjekt MUSS angeben, welche atomare Behauptung es unterstützt,", "sourceParagraph": 2628, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "qualifiziert, widerspricht, veraltet oder kontextualisiert.", "sourceParagraph": 2629, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Fehlen von lokalisierten Nachweisen DARF NICHT automatisch als", "sourceParagraph": 2631, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nachweis dafür dargestellt werden, dass eine Behauptung falsch ist. Bedingungen für Nachweise in offenen und geschlossenen Welten", "sourceParagraph": 2632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MÜSSEN getrennt bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Quantitative Behauptungen MÜSSEN Zähler, Nenner, Zeitraum, Einheit,", "sourceParagraph": 2635, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein- und Ausschlussregeln, Quelldaten und Berechnungsmethode beibehalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2636, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kunden-, Partner-, Lizenz-, Zertifizierungs-, Mitgliedschafts-, Auszeichnungs-, rechtliche,", "sourceParagraph": 2638, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Leistungs- und Überlegenheitsbehauptungen MÜSSEN ihre genaue Entität,", "sourceParagraph": 2639, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beziehung, Umfang, Zuständigkeit, Zeit und Nachweisstatus bewahren.", "sourceParagraph": 2640, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Öffentlich auffindbare Nachweise, eingeschränkte Prüfungsnachweise und", "sourceParagraph": 2642, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nicht-öffentliche Nachweise MÜSSEN separat eingestuft bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2643, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Behauptung KANN durch eingeschränkte Nachweise sachlich überprüft werden ohne", "sourceParagraph": 2645, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "öffentlich von einem Consumer-KI-Produkt abrufbar sein. Faktische Überprüfung", "sourceParagraph": 2646, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und die öffentliche Auffindbarkeit MUSS getrennt bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2647, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Behauptungen des Truth Pack DÜRFEN NICHT hinzugefügt, entfernt, erweitert oder eingeschränkt werden", "sourceParagraph": 2649, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nachdem AI-Antworten beobachtet wurden, neu klassifiziert, es sei denn, ein neues Wahrheits-Paket", "sourceParagraph": 2650, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Version wird erstellt und vorherige Aufzeichnungen werden aufbewahrt.", "sourceParagraph": 2651, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Antwortforderung, die nicht durch das festgeschriebene Wahrheits-Paket abgedeckt ist, MUSS einen auslösen", "sourceParagraph": 2653, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Referenz-Lücken-Prozess statt automatisches Versagen oder automatisch", "sourceParagraph": 2654, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Akzeptanz.", "sourceParagraph": 2655, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unbekannt, nicht unterstützt, ungelöst, widersprochen, historisch, abgelaufen,", "sourceParagraph": 2657, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Geltungsbereich-beschränkte und eingeschränkt überprüfte Zustände MÜSSEN getrennt bleiben", "sourceParagraph": 2658, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2659, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die geprüfte Einheit KANN Nachweise, Korrekturen und Einsprüche einreichen, aber", "sourceParagraph": 2661, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DARF NICHT als alleiniger Schiedsrichter seiner eigenen Aussagen handeln.", "sourceParagraph": 2662, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Systeme KÖNNEN bei der Extraktion, Normalisierung und Herkunftserkennung unterstützen,", "sourceParagraph": 2664, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und Widerspruchsentdeckung, darf jedoch NICHT als alleiniges Endergebnis dienen", "sourceParagraph": 2665, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Autorität für den Wahrheitsstatus der Behauptung.", "sourceParagraph": 2666, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Truth Pack-Version, Evidenzregistrierung, Support-Status-Entscheidung,", "sourceParagraph": 2668, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Berufung und Änderung MUSS einer verantwortlichen Person oder", "sourceParagraph": 2669, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2670, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2671, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH13-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevor die semantische Entscheidungsfindung beginnt, muss jeder GEO-1000-Audit eine versionierte Verifiziertes Faktenpaket zur Entität für die geprüfte Einheit, den Prompt-Bereich, die Länder, Produkte, Sprachen und die Referenzzeit festschreiben. Das Paket muss die kanonische Identität der Einheit, atomare Referenzaussagen, Offizielle Repräsentationsunterlagen, unterstützende Nachweise, Gegenevidenz, Quellenherkunft, Umfangs- und Zeitbegrenzungen, Zugangsklassen, Unbekannte, Einwände und ein Integritätsmanifest enthalten. Eine offizielle Erklärung kann nicht als unabhängig verifizierte Realität betrachtet werden, nur weil sie offiziell ist. Verschiedene URLs, die aus derselben Quellbasis abgeleitet sind, können nicht als unabhängige Belege gezählt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2672, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 14, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH14", "title": "Atomare Aussagen und Beurteilung", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K27", "K28" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH14-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "Before any response-level pass, failure, severity, or score is assigned, each material AI response MUST be decomposed into atomic semantic claims. Each atomic claim MUST retain: - its exact source span, - normalised proposition, - subject entity, - predicate and value, - qualifiers and quantifiers, - geographic, product, user, and jurisdictional scope, - temporal frame, - attribution, - modality and uncertainty, - explicit, implicit, presupposed, or entailed origin, - response centrality, - citation relationships, - dependency relationships, - and Truth Pack mapping. Sentence and paragraph boundaries MUST NOT be treated as automatic claim boundaries. Atomic decomposition MUST separate propositions that can carry different truth, evidence, entity, scope, time, or attribution states, while prohibiting meaningless micro-fragmentation that dilutes material error. Claim extraction, Truth Pack mapping, and semantic adjudication SHOULD remain separate stages and, where practical, separate roles. Every atomic claim MUST be adjudicated across distinct dimensions, including: - entity, - factual support, - scope, - time, - attribution and epistemic status, - modality and uncertainty, - citation support, - relevance, - and unresolved or reference-gap status. Official-claim fidelity MUST remain distinct from verified factual support. Unsupported, contradicted, wrong-entity, outdated, scope-overreach, epistemic-status-error, citation-mismatch, reference-gap, and unresolved states MUST remain separately visible. Required response elements and material omissions MUST be adjudicated separately from explicit false claims. Correct but irrelevant information MUST NOT satisfy the prompt merely because it is factually supported. Material claims SHOULD receive independent double review, with additional language or domain expertise where required. Reviewer identity, qualification, conflicts, independent first decisions, disagreements, resolution, reliability metrics, appeals, and decision versions MUST be recorded. Reviewer agreement MUST be measured by dimension and MUST NOT be treated as proof that the shared decision is necessarily correct. AI systems MAY assist with segmentation, claim extraction, evidence mapping, translation support, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT serve as the sole final adjudicator of their own or another system's claims. Atomic adjudication decisions MUST remain independent of commercial interests, desired scores, provider reputation, badge outcomes, or client approval. Every Claim Ledger, adjudication decision, disagreement resolution, appeal, and revision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Herhangi bir response-level geçiş, başarısızlık, önem derecesi veya skor verilmeden önce her maddi AI yanıtı atomik semantik iddialara ayrılmalıdır. Her atomik iddia tam metin izini, normalize hükmünü, özne varlığı, yüklem ve değeri, nitelendiricileri, kapsamı, zamanı, attribution’ı, modaliteyi, iddia kökenini, merkeziliği, citation ilişkilerini, bağımlılıklarını ve Truth Pack eşleşmesini korumalıdır. Cümle ve paragraf sınırları otomatik iddia sınırı sayılamaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH14-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "117. MACHINE-READABLE CLAIM LEDGER RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2513 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2514 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2515 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2516 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 30", "sourceParagraph": 2517 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2518 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2519 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2520 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"activelyDeliversServicesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 2521 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 2522 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unit\": \"COUNTRY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2523 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geographicScope\": \"GLOBAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2524 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"CURRENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2525 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"UNATTRIBUTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2527 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2528 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2529 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2530 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2531 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2532 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2533 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractionReview\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2534 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractorOne\": \"AGREED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2535 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractorTwo\": \"AGREED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2536 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"boundaryAgreement\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2537 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2538 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2539 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2540 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2541 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2542 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"text\": \"with a 98 per cent success rate\",", "sourceParagraph": 2543 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 32,", "sourceParagraph": 2544 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 63", "sourceParagraph": 2545 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2546 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2547 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2548 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", "sourceParagraph": 2549 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 2550 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unit\": \"PROPORTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2551 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": \"ALL_PROJECTS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2552 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"UNSPECIFIED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2553 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"UNATTRIBUTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2554 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2555 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2556 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2557 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2558 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2559 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-SUCCESS-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2560 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": []", "sourceParagraph": 2561 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2562 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2563 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2564 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2565 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"text\": \"independently certified\"", "sourceParagraph": 2566 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 65,", "sourceParagraph": 2567 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 101", "sourceParagraph": 2568 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2569 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2570 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2571 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"independentlyCertified\",", "sourceParagraph": 2572 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2573 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"INDEPENDENT_EXTERNAL_AUTHORITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2574 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ASSERTED_AS_FACT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2575 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2576 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EXPLICIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2577 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2578 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"ROOT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2579 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-INDEPENDENCE-004\",", "sourceParagraph": 2580 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": []", "sourceParagraph": 2581 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2582 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2583 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2584 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2585 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2586 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2587 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2588 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"omissions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2589 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2590 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"omissionId\": \"NGOM-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2591 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"OM-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2592 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"description\": \"The response omits that active service delivery has only been verified in nine countries.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2593 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2594 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2595 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2596 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimExtractionOwnerRole\": \"CLAIM_EXTRACTION_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2597 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-09-03T10:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2598 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2599 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2600 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2601 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "118. MACHINE-READABLE ATOMIC ADJUDICATION RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2603 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2604 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2605 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2606 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2607 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"atomicAdjudication\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2608 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationId\": \"NGAJ-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2609 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2610 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimLedgerId\": \"NGCL-SYNTH-W1-ORION-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2611 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-COUNTRIES-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2612 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2613 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dimensionDecisions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2614 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entity\": \"E-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2615 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualSupport\": \"F-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2616 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"S-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2617 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"time\": \"T-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2618 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"A-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2619 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"M-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2620 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citation\": \"C-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2621 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relevance\": \"R-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2622 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolved\": \"U-0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2623 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2624 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"combinedLabel\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2625 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PARTIALLY-SUPPORTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2626 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2627 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MATERIAL-ATTRIBUTION-LOSS\"", "sourceParagraph": 2628 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2629 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reasoningSummary\": \"The audited entity officially states that it operates in 25 countries, but active service delivery has been verified in nine. The response presents the broader official statement as an unqualified current fact.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2630 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceReferences\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2631 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2632 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2633 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-CONTRACTS-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2634 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2635 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reviewers\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2636 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2637 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2638 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryDecision\": \"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2639 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryDecision\": \"MATERIAL-SCOPE-OVERREACH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2640 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentBeforeComparison\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2641 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2642 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"agreement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2643 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2644 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2645 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2646 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2647 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionAgreement\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2648 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2649 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appeal\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2650 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"NO_APPEAL\"", "sourceParagraph": 2651 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2652 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2653 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2654 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2655 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-04T09:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2656 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2657 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2658 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2659 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "119. MACHINE-READABLE ADJUDICATOR COMPLIANCE RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2661 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2662 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2663 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2664 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2665 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationReliability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2666 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reliabilityRecordId\": \"NGREL-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2667 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2668 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"doubleReviewedClaimCount\": 8200,", "sourceParagraph": 2669 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preResolutionMetrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2670 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundaryExactAgreement\": 0.93,", "sourceParagraph": 2671 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityExactAgreement\": 0.97,", "sourceParagraph": 2672 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusExactAgreement\": 0.88,", "sourceParagraph": 2673 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeExactAgreement\": 0.84,", "sourceParagraph": 2674 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeExactAgreement\": 0.94,", "sourceParagraph": 2675 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionExactAgreement\": 0.86,", "sourceParagraph": 2676 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationSupportExactAgreement\": 0.82,", "sourceParagraph": 2677 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"omissionExactAgreement\": 0.79", "sourceParagraph": 2678 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2679 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"chanceAdjustedMetrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2680 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"overallNominalAgreementMetric\": \"KRIPPENDORFF_ALPHA\",", "sourceParagraph": 2681 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"overallValue\": 0.84,", "sourceParagraph": 2682 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeValue\": 0.78,", "sourceParagraph": 2683 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationValue\": 0.75", "sourceParagraph": 2684 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2685 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"actions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2686 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SCOPE_RECALIBRATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2687 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CITATION_MAPPING_RETRAINING\",", "sourceParagraph": 2688 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OMISSION_GUIDANCE_REVISION\"", "sourceParagraph": 2689 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2690 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"postResolution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2691 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allMaterialDisagreementsResolved\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2692 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedClaimCount\": 19,", "sourceParagraph": 2693 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedStatusPreserved\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2694 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2695 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2696 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2697 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reliabilityOwnerRole\": \"ADJUDICATION_METHODS_LEAD\"", "sourceParagraph": 2698 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2699 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2700 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2701 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2702 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real user,", "sourceParagraph": 2703 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real company,", "sourceParagraph": 2704 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "actual adjudicator performance", "sourceParagraph": 2705 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real company performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2706 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a synthetic, machine-readable representation of the atomic claim and adjudication architecture.", "sourceParagraph": 2707 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "120. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 2709 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH14-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2710 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Before any response-level pass, failure, severity, or score is assigned,", "sourceParagraph": 2712 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "each material AI response MUST be decomposed into atomic semantic claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2713 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Each atomic claim MUST retain:", "sourceParagraph": 2715 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- its exact source span,", "sourceParagraph": 2717 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- normalised proposition,", "sourceParagraph": 2718 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- subject entity,", "sourceParagraph": 2719 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- predicate and value,", "sourceParagraph": 2720 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- qualifiers and quantifiers,", "sourceParagraph": 2721 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- geographic, product, user, and jurisdictional scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2722 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- temporal frame,", "sourceParagraph": 2723 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- attribution,", "sourceParagraph": 2724 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- modality and uncertainty,", "sourceParagraph": 2725 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- explicit, implicit, presupposed, or entailed origin,", "sourceParagraph": 2726 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- response centrality,", "sourceParagraph": 2727 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- citation relationships,", "sourceParagraph": 2728 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- dependency relationships,", "sourceParagraph": 2729 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and Truth Pack mapping.", "sourceParagraph": 2730 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sentence and paragraph boundaries MUST NOT be treated as automatic claim", "sourceParagraph": 2732 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "boundaries.", "sourceParagraph": 2733 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Atomic decomposition MUST separate propositions that can carry different", "sourceParagraph": 2735 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "truth, evidence, entity, scope, time, or attribution states, while", "sourceParagraph": 2736 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "prohibiting meaningless micro-fragmentation that dilutes material error.", "sourceParagraph": 2737 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Claim extraction, Truth Pack mapping, and semantic adjudication SHOULD", "sourceParagraph": 2739 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain separate stages and, where practical, separate roles.", "sourceParagraph": 2740 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every atomic claim MUST be adjudicated across distinct dimensions,", "sourceParagraph": 2742 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "including:", "sourceParagraph": 2743 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- entity,", "sourceParagraph": 2745 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- factual support,", "sourceParagraph": 2746 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2747 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- time,", "sourceParagraph": 2748 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- attribution and epistemic status,", "sourceParagraph": 2749 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- modality and uncertainty,", "sourceParagraph": 2750 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- citation support,", "sourceParagraph": 2751 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- relevance,", "sourceParagraph": 2752 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and unresolved or reference-gap status.", "sourceParagraph": 2753 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Official-claim fidelity MUST remain distinct from verified factual", "sourceParagraph": 2755 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "support.", "sourceParagraph": 2756 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unsupported, contradicted, wrong-entity, outdated, scope-overreach,", "sourceParagraph": 2758 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "epistemic-status-error, citation-mismatch, reference-gap, and unresolved", "sourceParagraph": 2759 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "states MUST remain separately visible.", "sourceParagraph": 2760 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Required response elements and material omissions MUST be adjudicated", "sourceParagraph": 2762 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separately from explicit false claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2763 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Correct but irrelevant information MUST NOT satisfy the prompt merely", "sourceParagraph": 2765 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "because it is factually supported.", "sourceParagraph": 2766 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Material claims SHOULD receive independent double review, with additional", "sourceParagraph": 2768 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "language or domain expertise where required.", "sourceParagraph": 2769 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Reviewer identity, qualification, conflicts, independent first decisions,", "sourceParagraph": 2771 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "disagreements, resolution, reliability metrics, appeals, and decision", "sourceParagraph": 2772 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versions MUST be recorded.", "sourceParagraph": 2773 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Reviewer agreement MUST be measured by dimension and MUST NOT be treated", "sourceParagraph": 2775 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "as proof that the shared decision is necessarily correct.", "sourceParagraph": 2776 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI systems MAY assist with segmentation, claim extraction, evidence", "sourceParagraph": 2778 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "mapping, translation support, and contradiction discovery, but MUST NOT", "sourceParagraph": 2779 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "serve as the sole final adjudicator of their own or another system's", "sourceParagraph": 2780 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2781 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Atomic adjudication decisions MUST remain independent of commercial", "sourceParagraph": 2783 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "interests, desired scores, provider reputation, badge outcomes, or client", "sourceParagraph": 2784 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "approval.", "sourceParagraph": 2785 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every Claim Ledger, adjudication decision, disagreement resolution,", "sourceParagraph": 2787 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "appeal, and revision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable", "sourceParagraph": 2788 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2789 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2790 }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Any response-level transition must be broken down into atomic semantic claims for each material AI response before assigning failure, importance level, or score. Each atomic claim must preserve the full text trace, normalised judgement, subject existence, predicate and value, qualifiers, scope, time, attribution, modality, claim origin, centrality, citation relations, dependencies, and Truth Pack matching. Sentence and paragraph boundaries cannot be counted as automatic claim boundaries.", "sourceParagraph": 2791 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Bevor eine Bewertung auf Antwortebene, ein Versagen, eine Schwere oder eine Punktzahl zugewiesen wird, MUSS jede inhaltlich relevante KI-Antwort in atomare semantische Aussagen zerlegt werden. Jede atomare Aussage MUSS Folgendes enthalten: - ihren genauen Quelltextabschnitt, - normalisierte Proposition, - Subjektsentität, - Prädikat und Wert, - Qualifikatoren und Quantifizierer, - geografischen, Produkt-, Nutzer- und jurisdiktionalen Umfang, - zeitlichen Rahmen, - Zuschreibung, - Modalität und Unsicherheit, - expliziten, impliziten, vorausgesetzten oder abgeleiteten Ursprung, - Zentralität der Antwort, - Zitierbeziehungen, - Abhängigkeitsbeziehungen, - und Truth-Pack-Zuordnung. Satz- und Absatzgrenzen DÜRFEN NICHT als automatische Aussagegrenzen behandelt werden. Die atomare Zerlegung MUSS Aussagen trennen, die unterschiedliche Wahrheits-, Nachweis-, Entitäts-, Geltungsbereichs-, Zeit- oder Zuschreibungszustände tragen KÖNNEN, während sinnlose Mikrofragmentierung, die materielle Fehler verwässert, verboten wird. Die Extraktion von Behauptungen, die Zuordnung zu Wahrheits-Paketen und die semantische Adjudikation SOLLTEN getrennte Stufen und nach Möglichkeit getrennte Rollen bleiben. Jede atomare Behauptung MUSS über verschiedene Dimensionen hinweg beurteilt werden, einschließlich: - Entität, - faktische Unterstützung, - Geltungsbereich, - Zeit, - Zuschreibung und epistemischer Status, - Modalität und Unsicherheit, - Zitierungsunterstützung, - Relevanz, - und nicht geklärter oder Bezugslücken-Status. Die Treue zu offiziellen Behauptungen MUSS von der überprüften faktischen Unterstützung getrennt bleiben. Nicht unterstützt, widersprochen, falsche Entität, veraltet, Umfangsüberschreitung, epistemischer Statusfehler, Zitationsabweichung, Referenzlücke und ungelöste Zustände MÜSSEN separat sichtbar bleiben. Erforderliche Antwortelemente und wesentliche Auslassungen MÜSSEN separat von explizit falschen Behauptungen beurteilt werden. Korrekte, aber irrelevante Informationen DÜRFEN den Prompt nicht erfüllen, nur weil sie faktisch belegt sind. Wesentliche Behauptungen SOLLTEN einer unabhängigen doppelten Überprüfung unterzogen werden, mit zusätzlicher sprachlicher oder fachlicher Expertise, wo erforderlich. Identität des Prüfers, Qualifikation, Interessenkonflikte, unabhängige erste Entscheidungen, Meinungsverschiedenheiten, Lösung, Zuverlässigkeitsmetriken, Berufungen und Entscheidungsversionen MÜSSEN aufgezeichnet werden. Die Übereinstimmung der Gutachter MUSS anhand von Dimensionen gemessen werden und DARF NICHT als Nachweis dafür angesehen werden, dass die getroffene gemeinsame Entscheidung notwendigerweise korrekt ist. KI-Systeme KÖNNEN bei der Segmentierung, der Aussageextraktion, der Evidenzzuordnung, der Übersetzungsunterstützung und der Widerspruchsentdeckung helfen, DÜRFEN jedoch nicht als alleiniger endgültiger Schiedsrichter für ihre eigenen oder die Aussagen eines anderen Systems dienen. Atomare Adjudikationsentscheidungen MÜSSEN unabhängig von kommerziellen Interessen, gewünschten Bewertungen, Anbieterreputation, Ergebnissen einer Kennzeichnung oder Kundenfreigaben bleiben. Jedes Aussageregister, jede Adjudikationsentscheidung, jede Streitbeilegung, jede Berufung und jede Überarbeitung MUSS versioniert sein und einem verantwortlichen Menschen oder einer Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH14-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "117. MASCHINENLESBARES ANSPRUCHS-LEDGER-REKORD", "sourceParagraph": 2513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 30", "sourceParagraph": 2517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"activelyDeliversServicesInCountryCount\",", "sourceParagraph": 2521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": 25,", "sourceParagraph": 2522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Einheit\": \"LAND\",", "sourceParagraph": 2523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geographicScope\": \"GLOBAL\"", "sourceParagraph": 2524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"AKTUELL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"OHNE ZUGEORDNETE URHEBERSCHAFT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ALS TATSACHE BEHAUPTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EINFÜHREND\",", "sourceParagraph": 2529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"WURZEL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-LÄNDER-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractionReview\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractorOne\": \"ZUGESTIMMT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"extractorTwo\": \"ZUGESTIMMT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"boundaryAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"text\": \"mit einer 98-prozentigen Erfolgsquote\",", "sourceParagraph": 2543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 32,", "sourceParagraph": 2544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 63", "sourceParagraph": 2545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"projectSuccessRate\",", "sourceParagraph": 2549, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 2550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"einheit\": \"ANTEIL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bevölkerung\": \"ALLE_PROJEKTE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2552, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalFrame\": \"UNSPEZIFISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"OHNE ZUGEORDNETE URHEBERSCHAFT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ALS TATSACHE BEHAUPTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2556, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EINFÜHREND\",", "sourceParagraph": 2557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"WURZEL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2559, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-ERFOLG-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2563, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceSpan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"text\": \"unabhängig zertifiziert\"", "sourceParagraph": 2566, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"startCharacter\": 65,", "sourceParagraph": 2567, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endCharacter\": 101", "sourceParagraph": 2568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2570, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2571, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"independentlyCertified\",", "sourceParagraph": 2572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zuschreibung\": \"UNABHÄNGIGE_EXTERNE_BEHÖRDE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"ALS TATSACHE BEHAUPTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2575, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimOrigin\": \"EINFÜHREND\",", "sourceParagraph": 2577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2578, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dependencyType\": \"WURZEL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedTruthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-UNABHÄNGIGKEIT-004\",", "sourceParagraph": 2580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationLinks\": [],", "sourceParagraph": 2581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2582, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolved\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2586, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Auslassungen\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"omissionId\": \"NGOM-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"OM-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Beschreibung\": \"Die Antwort lässt aus, dass die aktive Dienstleistung nur in neun Ländern verifiziert wurde.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2594, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2595, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimExtractionOwnerRole\": \"ANSPRUCH_EXTRAKTIONSLEITUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2597, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedAt\": \"2026-09-03 T1 0:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2599, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2601, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "118. MASCHINENLESBARES ATOMARES ENTSCHEIDUNGSPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 2603, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2604, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2606, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"atomicAdjudication\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationId\": \"NGAJ-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2609, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseClaimId\": \"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2610, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimLedgerId\": \"NGCL-SYNTH-W1-ORION-000184\"", "sourceParagraph": 2611, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackClaimId\": \"NGC-SYNTH-ASTERON-25-LÄNDER-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2612, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2613, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dimensionDecisions\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2614, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entity\": \"E-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2615, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualSupport\": \"F-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2616, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": \"S-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2617, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"time\": \"T-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2618, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attribution\": \"A-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2619, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"modality\": \"M-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2620, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citation\": \"C-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2621, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"relevance\": \"R-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2622, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolved\": \"U-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2623, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2624, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"combinedLabel\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2625, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TEILWEISE-UNTERSTÜTZT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2626, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MATERIELLER-UMFANG-ÜBERSCHUSS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2627, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MATERIELLE-ATTRIBUTIONSVERLUST\"", "sourceParagraph": 2628, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2629, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reasoningSummary\": \"Die geprüfte Einheit gibt offiziell an, dass sie in 25 Ländern tätig ist, aber aktive Serviceleistungen wurden in neun Ländern verifiziert. Die Antwort stellt die weiter gefasste offizielle Aussage als unqualifizierte aktuelle Tatsache dar.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2630, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidenceReferences\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2631, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-WEB-025\",", "sourceParagraph": 2632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-OPS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGEV-SYNTH-CONTRACTS-002\"", "sourceParagraph": 2634, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2635, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reviewers\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2636, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"SPRACHBEURTEILER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2637, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"BEWEISBEURTEILER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2638, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryDecision\": \"UMFANGSÜBERGREIFENDE MATERIALIEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2639, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryDecision\": \"UMFANGSÜBERGREIFENDE MATERIALIEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2640, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentBeforeComparison\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2641, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2642, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"agreement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2643, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityAgreement\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2644, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factAgreement\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2645, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeAgreement\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2646, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeAgreement\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2647, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionAgreement\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2648, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2649, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appeal\": {\"", "sourceParagraph": 2650, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"KEINE_BESCHWERDE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2651, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2652, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2653, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2654, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_BESCHIEDER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2655, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-04 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2656, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2657, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2658, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2659, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "119. MASCHINENLESBARES BESCHIEDER-COMPLIANCE-RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2661, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2662, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2663, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2664, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2665, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationReliability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2666, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reliabilityRecordId\": \"NGREL-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2667, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2668, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"doubleReviewedClaimCount\": 8200,", "sourceParagraph": 2669, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"preResolutionMetrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2670, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundaryExactAgreement\": 0.93,", "sourceParagraph": 2671, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityExactAgreement\": 0.97,", "sourceParagraph": 2672, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusExactAgreement\": 0.88,", "sourceParagraph": 2673, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeExactAgreement\": 0.84,", "sourceParagraph": 2674, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"timeExactAgreement\": 0.94,", "sourceParagraph": 2675, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionExactAgreement\": 0.86,", "sourceParagraph": 2676, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationSupportExactAgreement\": 0.82,", "sourceParagraph": 2677, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"omissionExactAgreement\": 0.79", "sourceParagraph": 2678, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2679, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"chanceAdjustedMetrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2680, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"overallNominalAgreementMetric\": \"KRIPPENDORFF_ALPHA\",", "sourceParagraph": 2681, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"overallValue\": 0.84,", "sourceParagraph": 2682, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeValue\": 0.78,", "sourceParagraph": 2683, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationValue\": 0.75", "sourceParagraph": 2684, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2685, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aktionen\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2686, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BEREICHSKALIBRIERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2687, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ZITIERUNGSMAPPING_NEUTRAINIERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2688, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WEGLASSANLEITUNG_ÜBERARBEITUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2689, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2690, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"postResolution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2691, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allMaterialDisagreementsResolved\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2692, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedClaimCount\": 19,", "sourceParagraph": 2693, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedStatusPreserved\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2694, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2695, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityLevel\": \"AQ-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2696, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2697, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reliabilityOwnerRole\": \"LEITUNG_BESCHIEDERVERFAHREN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2698, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2699, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2700, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2701, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2702, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ein echter Nutzer,", "sourceParagraph": 2703, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echtes Unternehmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2704, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tatsächliche Leistung des Beschieders", "sourceParagraph": 2705, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine echte Unternehmensleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2706, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist eine synthetische, maschinenlesbare Repräsentation der atomaren Aussage- und Entscheidungsarchitektur.", "sourceParagraph": 2707, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "120. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 2709, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH14-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2710, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevor irgendein Response-Level-Durchgang, Fehler, Schweregrad oder Score zugewiesen wird,", "sourceParagraph": 2712, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUSS jede materielle KI-Antwort in atomare semantische Aussagen zerlegt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2713, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jeder atomare Aussage MUSS Folgendes beibehalten:", "sourceParagraph": 2715, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- seinen genauen Quellspan,", "sourceParagraph": 2717, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- normalisierte Aussage,", "sourceParagraph": 2718, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Subjektentity,", "sourceParagraph": 2719, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prädikat und Wert,", "sourceParagraph": 2720, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Qualifikatoren und Quantifizierer,", "sourceParagraph": 2721, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- geografischen, produktbezogenen, Nutzerbezogenen und gerichtlichen Bereich,", "sourceParagraph": 2722, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- zeitlichen Rahmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2723, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zuschreibung,", "sourceParagraph": 2724, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Modalität und Unsicherheit,", "sourceParagraph": 2725, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- explizit, implizit, vorausgesetzt oder impliziert Ursprung,", "sourceParagraph": 2726, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Antwortzentralität,", "sourceParagraph": 2727, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zitierbeziehungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2728, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Abhängigkeitsbeziehungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2729, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Wahrheits-Paket Zuordnung.", "sourceParagraph": 2730, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Satz- und Absatzgrenzen DÜRFEN NICHT als automatische Behauptung behandelt werden", "sourceParagraph": 2732, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Grenzen.", "sourceParagraph": 2733, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die atomare Zerlegung MUSS Propositionen trennen, die unterschiedliche tragen KÖNNEN", "sourceParagraph": 2735, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wahrheit, Nachweis, Entität, Umfang, Zeit oder Zuschreibungszustände, während", "sourceParagraph": 2736, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verbot sinnloser Mikrofragmentierung, die materielle Fehler verwässert.", "sourceParagraph": 2737, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Extraktion von Behauptungen, die Zuordnung zu Truth Packs und die semantische Bewertung SOLLTEN", "sourceParagraph": 2739, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als separate Stufen und, wo praktisch, als separate Rollen erhalten bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2740, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede atomare Behauptung MUSS über verschiedene Dimensionen hinweg bewertet werden,", "sourceParagraph": 2742, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "einschließlich:", "sourceParagraph": 2743, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entität,", "sourceParagraph": 2745, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- faktische Unterstützung,", "sourceParagraph": 2746, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Umfang,", "sourceParagraph": 2747, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2748, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zuschreibung und epistemischer Status,", "sourceParagraph": 2749, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Modalität und Unsicherheit,", "sourceParagraph": 2750, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zitationsunterstützung,", "sourceParagraph": 2751, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Relevanz,", "sourceParagraph": 2752, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und ungelöster Status oder vorhandene Referenzlücken.", "sourceParagraph": 2753, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Treue zur offiziellen Behauptung MUSS von der verifizierten faktischen", "sourceParagraph": 2755, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unterstützung getrennt bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2756, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nicht unterstützt, widersprochen, falsche Entität, veraltet, Reichweitenüberschreitung,", "sourceParagraph": 2758, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "epistemischer-Status-Fehler, Quellenabweichung, Referenzlücke und ungelöst", "sourceParagraph": 2759, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zustände MÜSSEN separat sichtbar bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2760, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Erforderliche Antwortbestandteile und Materialauslassungen MÜSSEN getrennt", "sourceParagraph": 2762, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gesondert von explizit falschen Behauptungen beurteilt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2763, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Korrekte, aber irrelevante Informationen DÜRFEN die Aufforderung nicht einfach", "sourceParagraph": 2765, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "erfüllen, nur weil sie sachlich belegt sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2766, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Materielle Aussagen SOLLTEN unabhängig doppelt überprüft werden, mit zusätzlicher", "sourceParagraph": 2768, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sprachlicher oder fachlicher Expertise, wo erforderlich.", "sourceParagraph": 2769, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Identität des Gutachters, Qualifikation, Konflikte, unabhängige Erstentscheidungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2771, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Meinungsverschiedenheiten, Lösung, Zuverlässigkeitsmetriken, Einsprüche und Entscheidungen", "sourceParagraph": 2772, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Versionen MÜSSEN aufgezeichnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2773, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Übereinstimmung der Gutachter MÜSSEN nach Dimension gemessen werden und DURCH NICHT als Beweis dafür behandelt werden,", "sourceParagraph": 2775, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dass die getroffene gemeinsame Entscheidung notwendigerweise korrekt ist.", "sourceParagraph": 2776, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Systeme DÜRFEN bei Segmentierung, Extraktion von Aussagen, Abbildung von Nachweisen, Übersetzungsunterstützung und Aufdeckung von Widersprüchen helfen, dürfen aber NICHT", "sourceParagraph": 2778, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als einzige endgültige Instanz für ihre eigenen oder die Ansprüche eines anderen Systems dienen.", "sourceParagraph": 2779, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2780, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2781, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Atomare Entscheidungsentscheidungen MÜSSEN unabhängig von kommerziellen", "sourceParagraph": 2783, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Interessen, gewünschten Ergebnissen, Anbieterreputation, Abzeichen-Ergebnissen oder Kunden", "sourceParagraph": 2784, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Genehmigung bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2785, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jedes Anspruchsregister, jede Entscheidungsentscheidung, jede Streitbeilegung,", "sourceParagraph": 2787, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einspruch und Überarbeitung MÜSSEN versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person zuordenbar sein", "sourceParagraph": 2788, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Mensch oder Organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2789, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2790, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH14-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Antwort-Ebenen-Transition muss in atomare semantische Aussagen für jede konkrete KI-Antwort aufgeschlüsselt werden, bevor ein Ausfall, eine Wichtigkeitsstufe oder eine Punktzahl zugewiesen wird. Jede atomare Aussage muss die vollständige Textspur, normalisierte Bewertung, Existenz des Subjekts, Prädikat und Wert, Qualifikatoren, Umfang, Zeit, Attribution, Modalität, Herkunft der Aussage, Zentralität, Zitierbeziehungen, Abhängigkeiten und Übereinstimmung mit dem Truth Pack bewahren. Satz- und Absatzgrenzen können nicht automatisch als Grenzen für Aussagen gezählt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2791, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 15, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH15", "title": "Bestehen von Antworten und Sperren bei kritischen Fehlern", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K03", "K20" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH15-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "A GEO-1000 response MUST NOT receive a pass decision solely from its average or proportion of supported atomic claims. Before response-level adjudication, the observation MUST satisfy the required capture, prompt, AI-system, Truth Pack, and adjudication-quality conditions. Every response MUST be evaluated for: - required response elements, - confirmed Critical findings, - confirmed Major findings, - cumulative Moderate materiality, - material omissions, - unresolved core claims, - refusal or nonresponse, - internal contradiction, - self-correction, - and root-finding clusters. A confirmed Critical finding MUST create a non-compensatory automatic response failure. A confirmed Major finding or failure of a required core response element MUST create a response failure and MUST NOT be offset by other supported claims. Moderate findings MAY permit only a conditional pass when all core requirements remain satisfied and cumulative materiality does not create a Major effect. Advisory findings MUST remain visible but MUST NOT independently block response passage. Critical and Major severity MUST be determined independently from claim frequency and independently from whether the error favours or harms the audited entity. Critical findings SHOULD be confirmed through valid capture, sufficient Truth Pack coverage, independent double review, and appropriate language or domain expertise. Reference gaps and unresolved evidence MUST NOT automatically create Critical, Major, pass, or failure decisions. Wrong-entity transfer, false license or regulatory authority, actionable high-stakes misinformation, fabricated material evidence, false transactional guarantees, unsafe out-of-scope recommendations, serious unsupported allegations, material boundary omissions, current use of expired authority, false endorsements, restricted-data exposure, and evidence laundering MAY activate Critical gates when the defined materiality conditions are met. A single confirmed Critical response MUST establish that the event occurred under the defined product-country-language-prompt-time conditions. It MUST NOT, by itself, be represented as the prevalence of that event across all users or all product surfaces. Every confirmed Critical response MUST open a versioned Critical Incident Record and trigger scope-appropriate confirmatory review. An open confirmed Critical incident MUST prevent a claim of zero Critical errors or full conformity in the affected declared scope. Remediation and retesting MUST create new observations and new wave records. They MUST NOT alter or erase the original response decision or historical incident. Response decisions, severity levels, gate codes, incident scope, replication status, conformity effects, appeals, and revisions MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Bir GEO-1000 yanıtı yalnız desteklenmiş atomların ortalaması veya oranı üzerinden geçiş alamaz. Confirmed Critical finding telafi edilemeyen otomatik response başarısızlığı; Confirmed Major finding veya core zorunlu unsur başarısızlığı response başarısızlığı oluşturmalıdır. Moderate finding ancak core gereksinimleri korunuyor ve birikimli maddilik Major etki oluşturmuyorsa koşullu geçişe izin verebilir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH15-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "79. MACHINE-READABLE RESPONSE TRANSITION RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2176 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2178 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2179 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolved\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2181 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2182 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allCoreElementsSatisfied\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2184 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2185 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimSummary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2186 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialAtomicClaimCount\": 14,", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supported\": 9,", "sourceParagraph": 2188 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportedWithQualification\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unsupported\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"contradicted\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2191 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceGap\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2192 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"wrongEntity\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"outdated\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimSupportRateUnweighted\": 0.6429", "sourceParagraph": 2195 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2196 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusters\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2198 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2199 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSE_IMMIGRATION_LICENSE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2200 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2201 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-005\",", "sourceParagraph": 2202 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-006\"", "sourceParagraph": 2203 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2204 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2205 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2206 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2207 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\",", "sourceParagraph": 2208 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2209 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2210 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2211 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"actionability\": \"DIRECT_USER_ACTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2212 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2213 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"repeatedInResponse\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2214 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recommendationAmplified\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2215 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2216 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2217 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2218 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSE_INDEPENDENT_CERTIFICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2219 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2220 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-009\",", "sourceParagraph": 2221 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-010\"", "sourceParagraph": 2222 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2223 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2224 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2225 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2226 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2227 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-12\"", "sourceParagraph": 2228 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2229 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2230 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"actionability\": \"TRUST_SIGNAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2231 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"COMMERCIAL_TRUST\"", "sourceParagraph": 2232 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2233 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2234 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityCounts\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2235 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalClusters\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2236 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClusters\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2237 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"moderateClusters\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2238 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"advisoryFindings\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2239 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2240 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolved\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2241 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialUnresolvedClaimCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2242 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreUnresolved\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2243 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2244 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseBehavior\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2245 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"refusal\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2246 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"clarification\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2247 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"selfCorrection\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2248 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"internalContradiction\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2249 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponse\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2250 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2251 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"statusDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2252 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"RP-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 2253 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"label\": \"AUTOMATIC_FAIL_CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2254 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionRule\": \"CONFIRMED_CRITICAL_GATE_PRESENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2255 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCompensatory\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2256 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"correctClaimsPreservedInRecord\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2257 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2258 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"review\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2259 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"LANGUAGE_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2260 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"EVIDENCE_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2261 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domainExpertRole\": \"LEGAL_REGULATORY_REVIEWER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2262 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentInitialDecisions\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2263 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_ADJUDICATOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2264 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-05T09:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2265 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2266 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appeal\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2267 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"NO_APPEAL\"", "sourceParagraph": 2268 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2269 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2270 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2271 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "80. MACHINE-READABLE CRITICAL INCIDENT RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2273 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2274 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2275 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2276 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2277 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalIncident\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2278 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2279 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"CIS-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2280 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2281 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceResponseDecisionId\": \"NGRD-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2282 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceFindingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2283 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2284 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2285 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\",", "sourceParagraph": 2286 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2287 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2288 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentType\": \"FALSE_REGULATED_SERVICE_AUTHORITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2289 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scope\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2290 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2291 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surface\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2292 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"PAID\",", "sourceParagraph": 2293 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": \"TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2294 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2295 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-07\",", "sourceParagraph": 2296 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelState\": \"CONTROLLED_CLEAN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2297 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2298 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2299 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2300 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValid\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2301 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackSufficient\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2302 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"doubleReviewed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2303 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domainExpertConfirmed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2304 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceGap\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2305 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedAt\": \"2026-09-05T09:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2306 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2307 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"impactVector\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2308 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmMagnitude\": \"HIGH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2309 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionImpact\": \"HIGH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2310 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"actionability\": \"DIRECT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2311 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CORE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2312 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2313 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reversibilityBeforeAction\": \"LOW\",", "sourceParagraph": 2314 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"vulnerableUserRisk\": \"POSSIBLE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2315 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2316 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationInference\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2317 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"singleObservationProvesPrevalence\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2318 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cellPrevalenceStatus\": \"UNKNOWN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2319 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmatorySamplingRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2320 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2321 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2322 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseAutomaticFail\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2323 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cellStatus\": \"CRITICAL_HOLD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2324 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveZeroCriticalClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2325 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"globalProductFailureClaimAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2326 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2327 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmatoryPlan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2328 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"planId\": \"NGCIP-SYNTH-ORION-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2329 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeAdditionalResponses\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2330 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentUsers\": 100,", "sourceParagraph": 2331 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samePromptVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2332 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sameTruthPackVersion\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2333 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"crossLanguageExtension\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2334 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2335 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"remediation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2336 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"NOT_STARTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2337 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ownerType\": \"TO_BE_DETERMINED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2338 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalRecordMustRemain\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2339 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2340 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2341 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentOwnerRole\": \"CRITICAL_INCIDENT_REVIEW_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2342 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicManifestRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2343 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2344 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2345 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2346 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "81. MACHINE-READABLE RESPONSE GATE RULE", "sourceParagraph": 2348 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH15-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2349 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A GEO-1000 response MUST NOT receive a pass decision solely from its", "sourceParagraph": 2351 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "average or proportion of supported atomic claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2352 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Before response-level adjudication, the observation MUST satisfy the", "sourceParagraph": 2354 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "required capture, prompt, AI-system, Truth Pack, and adjudication-quality", "sourceParagraph": 2355 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conditions.", "sourceParagraph": 2356 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every response MUST be evaluated for:", "sourceParagraph": 2358 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- required response elements,", "sourceParagraph": 2360 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- confirmed Critical findings,", "sourceParagraph": 2361 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- confirmed Major findings,", "sourceParagraph": 2362 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- cumulative Moderate materiality,", "sourceParagraph": 2363 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- material omissions,", "sourceParagraph": 2364 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- unresolved core claims,", "sourceParagraph": 2365 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- refusal or nonresponse,", "sourceParagraph": 2366 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- internal contradiction,", "sourceParagraph": 2367 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- self-correction,", "sourceParagraph": 2368 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and root-finding clusters.", "sourceParagraph": 2369 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A confirmed Critical finding MUST create a non-compensatory automatic", "sourceParagraph": 2371 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "response failure.", "sourceParagraph": 2372 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A confirmed Major finding or failure of a required core response element", "sourceParagraph": 2374 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST create a response failure and MUST NOT be offset by other supported", "sourceParagraph": 2375 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "claims.", "sourceParagraph": 2376 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Moderate findings MAY permit only a conditional pass when all core", "sourceParagraph": 2378 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "requirements remain satisfied and cumulative materiality does not create", "sourceParagraph": 2379 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a Major effect.", "sourceParagraph": 2380 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Advisory findings MUST remain visible but MUST NOT independently block", "sourceParagraph": 2382 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "response passage.", "sourceParagraph": 2383 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical and Major severity MUST be determined independently from claim", "sourceParagraph": 2385 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "frequency and independently from whether the error favours or harms the", "sourceParagraph": 2386 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "audited entity.", "sourceParagraph": 2387 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical findings SHOULD be confirmed through valid capture, sufficient", "sourceParagraph": 2389 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Truth Pack coverage, independent double review, and appropriate language", "sourceParagraph": 2390 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "or domain expertise.", "sourceParagraph": 2391 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Reference gaps and unresolved evidence MUST NOT automatically create", "sourceParagraph": 2393 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical, Major, pass, or failure decisions.", "sourceParagraph": 2394 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wrong-entity transfer, false license or regulatory authority, actionable", "sourceParagraph": 2396 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "high-stakes misinformation, fabricated material evidence, false", "sourceParagraph": 2397 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "transactional guarantees, unsafe out-of-scope recommendations, serious", "sourceParagraph": 2398 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unsupported allegations, material boundary omissions, current use of", "sourceParagraph": 2399 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "expired authority, false endorsements, restricted-data exposure, and", "sourceParagraph": 2400 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "evidence laundering MAY activate Critical gates when the defined", "sourceParagraph": 2401 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "materiality conditions are met.", "sourceParagraph": 2402 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A single confirmed Critical response MUST establish that the event", "sourceParagraph": 2404 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "occurred under the defined product-country-language-prompt-time", "sourceParagraph": 2405 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conditions. It MUST NOT, by itself, be represented as the prevalence of", "sourceParagraph": 2406 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "that event across all users or all product surfaces.", "sourceParagraph": 2407 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every confirmed Critical response MUST open a versioned Critical Incident", "sourceParagraph": 2409 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Record and trigger scope-appropriate confirmatory review.", "sourceParagraph": 2410 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An open confirmed Critical incident MUST prevent a claim of zero Critical", "sourceParagraph": 2412 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "errors or full conformity in the affected declared scope.", "sourceParagraph": 2413 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Remediation and retesting MUST create new observations and new wave", "sourceParagraph": 2415 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "records. They MUST NOT alter or erase the original response decision or", "sourceParagraph": 2416 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "historical incident.", "sourceParagraph": 2417 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Response decisions, severity levels, gate codes, incident scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2419 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "replication status, conformity effects, appeals, and revisions MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 2420 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2421 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2422 }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A GEO-1000 response cannot pass solely based on the average or ratio of supported atoms. Confirmed Critical finding is an irremediable automatic response failure; Confirmed Major finding or core mandatory element failure should create a response failure. Moderate finding may allow conditional passage only if core requirements are maintained and cumulative materiality does not create a Major impact.", "sourceParagraph": 2423 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Eine GEO-1000-Antwort DARF NICHT allein aufgrund ihres Durchschnitts oder Anteils unterstützter atomarer Behauptungen eine Bestehensentscheidung erhalten. Vor der Bewertung auf Antwortebene MUSS die Beobachtung die erforderlichen Bedingungen für Erfassung, Prompt, KI-System, Truth Pack und Bewertungsqualität erfüllen. Jede Antwort MUSS auf Folgendes bewertet werden: - erforderliche Antwortbestandteile, - bestätigte kritische Feststellungen, - bestätigte wesentliche Feststellungen, - kumulative moderate Relevanz, - wesentliche Auslassungen, - ungelöste Kernansprüche, - Ablehnung oder Nichtantwort, - interne Widersprüche, - Selbstkorrektur, - und Root-Finding-Cluster. Eine bestätigte kritische Feststellung MUSS ein nicht kompensierbares automatisches Antwortversagen erzeugen. Ein bestätigter schwerwiegender Befund oder Ausfall eines erforderlichen Kernelementes der Antwort MUSS ein Antwortversagen erzeugen und DARF NICHT durch andere unterstützte Aussagen ausgeglichen werden. Moderate Befunde KÖNNEN nur eine Bedingt bestanden zulassen, wenn alle Kernanforderungen weiterhin erfüllt sind und die kumulative Wesentlichkeit keinen schwerwiegenden Effekt erzeugt. Beratende Befunde MÜSSEN sichtbar bleiben, DARF aber nicht eigenständig die Genehmigung der Antwort blockieren. Kritische und schwerwiegende Schweregrade MÜSSEN unabhängig von der Häufigkeit der Aussagen und unabhängig davon bestimmt werden, ob der Fehler dem geprüften Unternehmen zugutekommt oder schadet. Kritische Ergebnisse SOLLTEN durch gültige Erfassung, ausreichende Truth Pack-Abdeckung, unabhängige Doppelprüfung und angemessene Sprach- oder Fachkenntnisse bestätigt werden. Referenzlücken und ungelöste Nachweise DÜRFEN NICHT automatisch zu Entscheidungen über kritisch, schwerwiegend, bestanden oder nicht bestanden führen. Falschübertragungen von Entitäten, falsche Lizenz- oder Regulierungsbehörden, handlungsrelevante Hochrisikofehlinformationen, erfundene materielle Nachweise, falsche transaktionale Garantien, unsichere Empfehlungen außerhalb des Anwendungsbereichs, schwerwiegende unbegründete Anschuldigungen, wesentliche Grenzversäumnisse, aktuelle Nutzung abgelaufener Befugnisse, falsche Empfehlungen, Offenlegung eingeschränkter Daten, und Evidenzlöschung KANN kritische Tore aktivieren, wenn die definierten Wesentlichkeitsbedingungen erfüllt sind. Eine einzelne bestätigte kritische Reaktion MUSS feststellen, dass das Ereignis unter den definierten Bedingungen von Produkt-Land-Sprache-Aufforderung-Zeit aufgetreten ist. Es DARF NICHT von sich aus als das Vorhandensein dieses Ereignisses bei allen Nutzern oder auf allen Produktoberflächen repräsentiert werden. Jede bestätigte kritische Reaktion MUSS ein versioniertes kritisches Vorfallsprotokoll eröffnen und eine überprüfende Kontrolle im entsprechenden Umfang auslösen. Ein offener bestätigter kritischer Vorfall MUSS eine Aussage auf null kritische Fehler oder vollständige Übereinstimmung im betroffenen deklarierten Umfang verhindern. Behebung und erneute Tests MÜSSEN neue Beobachtungen und neue Wellenaufzeichnungen erstellen. Sie DÜRFEN die ursprüngliche Entscheidungsantwort oder das historische Ereignis NICHT ändern oder löschen. Antwortentscheidungen, Schweregrade, Sperrcodes, Vorfallsumfang, Replikationsstatus, Konformitätseffekte, Einsprüche und Überarbeitungen MÜSSEN versioniert sein und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden KÖNNEN.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH15-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "79. MASCHINENLESBARE ANTWORTÜBERTRAGUNGSDA-TEI", "sourceParagraph": 2176, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2178, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2179, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredResponseElements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolved\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2181, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryActivityPresent\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2182, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialBoundaryPresent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allCoreElementsSatisfied\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2184, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2185, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimSummary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2186, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialAtomicClaimCount\": 14,", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "„supported“: 9,", "sourceParagraph": 2188, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"supportedWithQualification\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "„unsupported“: 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"widersprochen\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2191, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceGap\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2192, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"wrongEntity\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"veraltet\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimSupportRateUnweighted\": 0.642 9", "sourceParagraph": 2195, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2196, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusters\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2199, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSCHE_EINWANDERUNGSERLAUBNIS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2200, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2201, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-005\",", "sourceParagraph": 2202, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-006\"", "sourceParagraph": 2203, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2204, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bedeutung\": \"KRITISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2205, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2206, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2207, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\",", "sourceParagraph": 2208, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2209, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2210, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2211, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Umsetzbarkeit\": \"DIREKTE_BENUTZERAKTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2212, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2213, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"repeatedInResponse\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2214, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recommendationAmplified\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2215, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2216, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2217, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2218, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootIssue\": \"FALSCHE_UNABHÄNGIGE_ZERTIFIZIERUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2219, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"linkedResponseClaimIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2220, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-009\",", "sourceParagraph": 2221, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGRC-SYNTH-000184-010\"", "sourceParagraph": 2222, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2223, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bedeutung\": \"KRITISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2224, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2225, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2226, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2227, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-12\"", "sourceParagraph": 2228, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2229, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"centrality\": \"CL-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2230, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Handlungsfähigkeit\": \"VERTRAUENSSIGNAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2231, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmDomain\": \"KOMMERZIELLES_VERTRAUEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2232, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2233, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2234, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityCounts\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2235, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalClusters\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 2236, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClusters\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2237, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"moderateClusters\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 2238, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"advisoryFindings\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 2239, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2240, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ungelöst\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2241, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialUnresolvedClaimCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2242, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreUnresolved\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2243, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2244, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseBehavior\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2245, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Ablehnung\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2246, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Klarstellung\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2247, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"selfCorrection\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2248, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"internalContradiction\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2249, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponse\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2250, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2251, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"statusDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2252, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"RP-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 2253, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Etikett\": \"AUTOMATISCH_FEHLGESCHLAGEN_KRITISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2254, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionRule\": \"BESTÄTIGTES_KRITISCHES_GATE_VORHANDEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2255, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCompensatory\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2256, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"correctClaimsPreservedInRecord\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2257, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2258, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Überprüfung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2259, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"primaryReviewerRole\": \"SPRACHBEURTEILER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2260, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"secondaryReviewerRole\": \"BEWEISBEURTEILER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2261, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domainExpertRole\": \"RECHTLICHER_REGULATORISCHER_PRÜFER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2262, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentInitialDecisions\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2263, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedByRole\": \"SENIOR_BESCHIEDER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2264, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalizedAt\": \"2026-09-05 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2265, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2266, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appeal\": {\"", "sourceParagraph": 2267, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"KEINE_BESCHWERDE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2268, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2269, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2270, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2271, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "80. MASCHINENLESBARES_KRITISCHES_ZWISCHENFALL_PROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 2273, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2274, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2275, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2276, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2277, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalIncident\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2278, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2279, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"CIS-2\"", "sourceParagraph": 2280, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2281, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceResponseDecisionId\": \"NGRD-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2282, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sourceFindingClusterId\": \"NGFC-SYNTH-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2283, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2284, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2285, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\",", "sourceParagraph": 2286, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2287, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2288, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentType\": \"FALSCH_REGULIERTE_DIENST_AUTORITÄT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2289, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Umfang\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2290, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-ORION-CHAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2291, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oberfläche\": \"WEB\",", "sourceParagraph": 2292, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"plan\": \"BEZAHLT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2293, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"country\": \"TR\"", "sourceParagraph": 2294, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"locale\": \"tr-TR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2295, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-07\",", "sourceParagraph": 2296, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"panelState\": \"GEREGELT_GEREINIGT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2297, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"NGW-SYNTH-W1-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2298, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2299, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bestätigung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2300, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValid\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2301, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackSufficient\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2302, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"doubleReviewed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2303, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domainExpertConfirmed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2304, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceGap\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2305, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedAt\": \"2026-09-05 T0 9:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2306, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2307, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"impactVector\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2308, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"harmMagnitude\": \"HOCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2309, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionImpact\": \"HOCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2310, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Handlungsfähigkeit\": \"DIREKT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2311, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Zentralität\": \"KERN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2312, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedDomain\": \"LEGAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2313, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"reversibilityBeforeAction\": \"NIEDRIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2314, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"vulnerableUserRisk\": \"MÖGLICH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2315, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2316, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationInference\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2317, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"singleObservationProvesPrevalence\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2318, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cellPrevalenceStatus\": \"UNBEKANNT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2319, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmatorySamplingRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2320, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2321, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2322, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseAutomaticFail\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2323, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"cellStatus\": \"KRITISCH_HOLD\"", "sourceParagraph": 2324, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveZeroCriticalClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2325, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"globalProductFailureClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2326, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2327, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmatoryPlan\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2328, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"planId\": \"NGCIP-SYNTH-ORION-TR-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2329, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeAdditionalResponses\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2330, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentUsers\": 100,", "sourceParagraph": 2331, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samePromptVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2332, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sameTruthPackVersion\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2333, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"crossLanguageExtension\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2334, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2335, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Behebung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2336, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"NICHT_GESTARTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2337, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ownerType\": \"NOCH_FESTZULEGEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2338, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalRecordMustRemain\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2339, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2340, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2341, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidentOwnerRole\": \"LEITUNG_KRITISCHER_VORFALLSBEDENKEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2342, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicManifestRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2343, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2344, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2345, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2346, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "81. MASCHINENLESBARE_ANTWORT_GRENZREGEL", "sourceParagraph": 2348, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH15-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2349, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine GEO-1000-Antwort DARF NICHT nur aufgrund ihres", "sourceParagraph": 2351, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "durchschnittlichen oder anteiligen unterstützten atomaren Aussagen eine Zustimmung erhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2352, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Vor der Beurteilung auf Antwort-Ebene MUSS die Beobachtung die", "sourceParagraph": 2354, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "erforderlichen Erfassungs-, Eingabeaufforderungs-, KI-System-, Wahrheits-Paket- und Beurteilungsqualitäts-", "sourceParagraph": 2355, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bedingungen erfüllen.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2356, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Antwort MUSS bewertet werden auf:", "sourceParagraph": 2358, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- erforderliche Antwortbestandteile,", "sourceParagraph": 2360, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- bestätigte kritische Befunde,", "sourceParagraph": 2361, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- bestätigte wesentliche Befunde,", "sourceParagraph": 2362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- kumulative moderate Wesentlichkeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- wesentliche Auslassungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ungelöste Kernansprüche,", "sourceParagraph": 2365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Verweigerung oder Nichtreaktion,", "sourceParagraph": 2366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- interne Widersprüche,", "sourceParagraph": 2367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Selbstkorrekturen,", "sourceParagraph": 2368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Ursachenanalyse-Cluster.", "sourceParagraph": 2369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein bestätigter kritischer Befund MUSS einen nicht kompensierbaren automatischen", "sourceParagraph": 2371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antwortausfall erzeugen.", "sourceParagraph": 2372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein bestätigter schwerwiegender Befund oder ein Versagen eines erforderlichen Kernelementes der Antwort", "sourceParagraph": 2374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUSS ein Antwortversagen erzeugen und DARF NICHT durch andere unterstützte Elemente ausgeglichen werden", "sourceParagraph": 2375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 2376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Mäßige Befunde KÖNNEN nur ein Bedingt bestanden zulassen, wenn alle Kernelemente", "sourceParagraph": 2378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Anforderungen weiterhin erfüllt sind und die kumulative Wesentlichkeit keinen", "sourceParagraph": 2379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "schwerwiegenden Effekt erzeugt.", "sourceParagraph": 2380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beratende Befunde MÜSSEN sichtbar bleiben, dürfen aber die", "sourceParagraph": 2382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antwortdurchführung nicht unabhängig blockieren.", "sourceParagraph": 2383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kritische und schwere Schweregrade MÜSSEN unabhängig von der Häufigkeit der Aussagen", "sourceParagraph": 2385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und unabhängig davon, ob der Fehler dem geprüften Unternehmen zugutekommt oder schadet,", "sourceParagraph": 2386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bestimmt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kritische Befunde SOLLTEN durch gültige Erfassung, ausreichende", "sourceParagraph": 2389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Truth Pack-Abdeckung, unabhängige Doppelprüfung und angemessene Sprach", "sourceParagraph": 2390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "oder Fachkenntnisse im jeweiligen Bereich bestätigt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2391, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]\nReferenzlücken und ungelöste Evidenzmittel DÜRFEN NICHT automatisch", "sourceParagraph": 2393, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kritische, große, bestandene oder fehlgeschlagene Entscheidungen erzeugen.", "sourceParagraph": 2394, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Falsch zugeordnete Einheiten, falsche Lizenzen oder regulatorische Behörden, umsetzbare", "sourceParagraph": 2396, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "hoch riskante Fehlinformationen, gefälschtes Sachbeweismaterial, falsche", "sourceParagraph": 2397, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "transaktionelle Garantien, unsichere Empfehlungen außerhalb des Geltungsbereichs, schwerwiegende", "sourceParagraph": 2398, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht unterstützte Anschuldigungen, wesentliche Auslassungen an Grenzen, aktuelle Nutzung von", "sourceParagraph": 2399, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "abgelaufene Autorität, falsche Beglaubigungen, Offenlegung eingeschränkter Daten, und", "sourceParagraph": 2400, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Evidenzmittelwäsche KANN Kritische Tore auslösen, wenn die definierten", "sourceParagraph": 2401, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bedeutsamkeitsbedingungen erfüllt sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2402, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine einzelne bestätigte Kritische Antwort MUSS feststellen, dass das Ereignis", "sourceParagraph": 2404, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unter den definierten Produkt-Land-Sprache-Aufforderung-Zeit", "sourceParagraph": 2405, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bedingungen aufgetreten ist. Es DARF NICHT von sich aus als die Häufigkeit von", "sourceParagraph": 2406, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "diesem Ereignis bei allen Nutzern oder auf allen Produktoberflächen dargestellt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2407, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede bestätigte Kritische Antwort MUSS einen versionierten Kritischen Zwischenfall", "sourceParagraph": 2409, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eintrag öffnen und eine den Umfang entsprechende bestätigende Überprüfung auslösen.", "sourceParagraph": 2410, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein offener bestätigter kritischer Vorfall MUSS eine Meldung von null Kritischen verhindern", "sourceParagraph": 2412, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fehler oder vollständige Übereinstimmung im betroffenen deklarierten Umfang.", "sourceParagraph": 2413, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Behebung und erneutes Testen MÜSSEN neue Beobachtungen und neue Wellen erzeugen", "sourceParagraph": 2415, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufzeichnungen. Sie DÜRFEN die ursprüngliche Entscheidungsantwort weder ändern noch löschen oder", "sourceParagraph": 2416, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "historisches Ereignis.", "sourceParagraph": 2417, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antwortentscheidungen, Schweregrade, Torcodes, Vorfallumfang,", "sourceParagraph": 2419, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Replikationsstatus, Konformitätseffekte, Berufungen und Überarbeitungen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2420, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versioniert und einem verantwortlichen Menschen oder einer Organisation zuordenbar.", "sourceParagraph": 2421, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2422, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH15-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine GEO-1000 Antwort kann nicht allein aufgrund des Durchschnitts oder Verhältnisses der unterstützten Atome passieren. Bestätigt Kritisches Ergebnis ist ein unwiderruflicher automatischer Reaktionsfehler; Ein bestätigter Major-Befund oder ein verpflichtender Kern-Elementfehler sollte zu einem Reaktionsfehler führen. Moderate Funde können nur bedingte Passagen zulassen, wenn die Kernanforderungen eingehalten werden und die kumulative Materialität keinen Major-Einfluss hat.", "sourceParagraph": 2423, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 16, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH16", "title": "Die NOMOS-Bewertungsarchitektur", "subtitle": null, "sourceIds": [ "K08", "K09" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH16-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "No NOMOS result may be published as a naked composite score. Every published score MUST first disclose: - the gate status, - the GEO-1000 response-status distribution, - Strict and Acceptable Pass equivalents, - Critical and Major equivalents, - Unresolved, No-Usable-Response, and Not-Ratable equivalents, - component scores, - uncertainty, - effective sample size, - scope, - and score-method version. The primary GEO-1000 output MUST express the population-weighted equivalent number of users, out of 1,000, receiving each RP-1 through RP-8 response status. Critical and Major findings are non-compensatory. No atomic-claim average, response-pass rate, component score, product coefficient, or ecosystem composite may override an active Critical or Major gate. Atomic, required-element, component, composite, fairness, stability, Critical-rate, and publication-quality metrics MUST remain distinct. The canonical candidate NOMOS composite consists of ten separately reported 0–100 components: - Entity Integrity, - Factual Fidelity, - Scope and Boundary Integrity, - Temporal and Local Accuracy, - Evidence and Citation Integrity, - Epistemic Integrity, - Task Completion and Relevance, - Language and Geographic Fairness, - User-State and Surface Integrity, - and Stability and Replicability. A full 0–1,000 composite MUST NOT be produced when a required component is not estimable. Missing component weight MUST NOT be silently redistributed. Native Reach, Common Support, Controlled Clean, Natural User, current wave, rolling, equal-product, and exposure-weighted scores MUST remain separately identified. AI-product coefficients MUST be locked before product results are observed and MUST NOT depend on product performance, provider reputation, client preference, sponsorship, or desired outcome. Equal-product coefficients estimate average tested-product performance. Exposure coefficients estimate average defined-user exposure. These estimands MUST NOT be represented as equivalent. An ecosystem composite MUST retain product-level Critical and Major incident visibility. High scores in other products MUST NOT erase a lower-weighted product's confirmed Critical incident. Unresolved claims MUST produce visible reference-uncertainty bounds and MUST NOT be silently treated as correct, incorrect, or absent. Sampling uncertainty, reference uncertainty, score sensitivity, raw sample size, and effective sample size MUST be separately reported. Zero observed confirmed Critical incidents MUST NOT be represented as zero Critical risk. A method-appropriate one-sided upper bound MUST be reported. A NOMOS 950+ performance candidate MUST satisfy score, Strict Pass, gate, component-floor, unresolved, quality, coverage, and replication conditions. A composite score of 950 or more alone is insufficient. Every score formula, mapping, coefficient, dataset, code version, confidence procedure, publication decision, revision, and integrity record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Hiçbir NOMOS sonucu tek çıplak bileşik puan olarak yayımlanamaz. Her sonuç önce gate statüsünü, GEO-1000 response dağılımını, Strict ve Acceptable Pass kullanıcı eşdeğerlerini, Critical, Major, Unresolved, No-Response ve Not-Ratable dağılımlarını; daha sonra bileşen skorlarını, belirsizliği, etkin örneklemi, kapsamı ve skor sürümünü göstermelidir.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH16-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE SCORE RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1939 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 1940 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1941 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS_PERFORMANCE_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1942 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openConfirmedCritical\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1943 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openConfirmedMajor\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1944 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidents\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 1945 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentCriticalHold\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1946 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1947 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geo1000Distribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1948 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 830,", "sourceParagraph": 1949 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 128,", "sourceParagraph": 1950 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 30,", "sourceParagraph": 1951 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1952 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1953 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 1954 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1955 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1956 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", "sourceParagraph": 1957 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", "sourceParagraph": 1958 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1959 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1960 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 1961 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponseEquivalent\": 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1962 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 1963 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1964 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"components\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1965 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENT\": 99,", "sourceParagraph": 1966 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FAC\": 97,", "sourceParagraph": 1967 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SBI\": 96,", "sourceParagraph": 1968 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TLA\": 95,", "sourceParagraph": 1969 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ECI\": 96,", "sourceParagraph": 1970 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"EPI\": 98,", "sourceParagraph": 1971 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TCR\": 97,", "sourceParagraph": 1972 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LGF\": 94,", "sourceParagraph": 1973 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"USI\": 93,", "sourceParagraph": 1974 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"STR\": 96", "sourceParagraph": 1975 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1976 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"composite\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1977 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosScore\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 1978 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scaleMaximum\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 1979 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalEqualComponentWeighting\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1980 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1981 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"uncertainty\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1982 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingConfidenceLevel\": 0.95,", "sourceParagraph": 1983 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1984 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lower\": 955,", "sourceParagraph": 1985 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"upper\": 967", "sourceParagraph": 1986 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1987 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceUncertainty\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1988 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conservativeLower\": 956,", "sourceParagraph": 1989 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resolvedOnlyPoint\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 1990 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"optimisticUpper\": 964", "sourceParagraph": 1991 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1992 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawSampleSize\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 1993 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveSampleSize\": 914,", "sourceParagraph": 1994 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observedConfirmedCriticalCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1995 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBoundMethod\": \"DESIGN_AWARE_ONE_SIDED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1996 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.0034", "sourceParagraph": 1997 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1998 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityPrerequisites\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1999 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sampleQuality\": \"SQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2000 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantSelectionIntegrity\": \"PSI-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2001 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2002 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2003 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2004 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicatedWaveCount\": 3", "sourceParagraph": 2005 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2006 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomos950CandidateChecks\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2007 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAtLeast950\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2008 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassAtLeast950\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2009 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noOpenCritical\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2010 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noOpenMajor\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2011 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allCoreComponentsAtLeast90\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2012 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessUserStateStabilityAtLeast85\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2013 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreUnresolvedAtMostTwoPercent\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2014 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityPrerequisitesMet\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2015 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationRequirementMet\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2016 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2017 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalStatus\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2018 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorCriticalIncidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2019 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentRemediationStatus\": \"CIS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 2020 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalRecordPreserved\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2021 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2022 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2023 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"inputManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-INPUT-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2024 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"calculationCodeHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-CODE-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2025 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-MANIFEST-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2026 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2027 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2028 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodsOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_SCORING_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2029 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_SCORE_APPROVER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2030 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-10-01T10:00:00Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2031 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2032 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2033 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2034 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE AI PRODUCT COEFFICIENT RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2036 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2037 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2038 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2039 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2040 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productCoefficientRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2041 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientRecordId\": \"NGCOEF-SYNTH-ECOSYSTEM-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2042 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2043 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPeriod\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2044 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"from\": \"2026-07-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2045 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"to\": \"2026-09-30\"", "sourceParagraph": 2046 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2047 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": \"DEFINED_ACTIVE_ELIGIBLE_AI_USERS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2048 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalProductCoefficients\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2049 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2050 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2051 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2052 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2053 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2054 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2055 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2056 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2057 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2058 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2059 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2060 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2061 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2062 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2064 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2065 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2066 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exposureCoefficients\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2067 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2068 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2069 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 55000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2070 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.55", "sourceParagraph": 2071 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2073 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2074 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 25000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2075 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2076 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2077 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2078 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2079 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 15000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2080 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.15", "sourceParagraph": 2081 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2083 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 5000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2085 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficient\": 0.05", "sourceParagraph": 2086 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2087 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2088 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientRules\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2089 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"performanceDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2090 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerReputationDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2091 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commercialSponsorDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2092 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeProductScores\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2093 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"activeUserAndAccountCountsDistinguished\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2094 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2095 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"outputs\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2096 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalProductEcosystemScore\": 945,", "sourceParagraph": 2097 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exposureWeightedEcosystemScore\": 947,", "sourceParagraph": 2098 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"anyOpenConfirmedCriticalProduct\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2099 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalProductIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2100 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTH-A4\"", "sourceParagraph": 2101 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2102 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2103 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2104 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientOwnerRole\": \"ECOSYSTEM_EXPOSURE_METHODS_LEAD\"", "sourceParagraph": 2105 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2106 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2107 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2108 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2109 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "actual AI provider,", "sourceParagraph": 2110 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "actual number of users,", "sourceParagraph": 2111 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "actual company score", "sourceParagraph": 2112 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real company performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2113 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Score architecture is a synthetic, machine-readable representation.", "sourceParagraph": 2114 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE FOR MACHINE-READABLE SECTION 78", "sourceParagraph": 2116 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH16-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2117 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No NOMOS result may be published as a naked composite score.", "sourceParagraph": 2119 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every published score MUST first disclose:", "sourceParagraph": 2121 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- the gate status,", "sourceParagraph": 2123 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- the GEO-1000 response-status distribution,", "sourceParagraph": 2124 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Strict and Acceptable Pass equivalents,", "sourceParagraph": 2125 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Critical and Major equivalents,", "sourceParagraph": 2126 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Unresolved, No-Usable-Response, and Not-Ratable equivalents,", "sourceParagraph": 2127 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- component scores,", "sourceParagraph": 2128 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- uncertainty,", "sourceParagraph": 2129 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- effective sample size,", "sourceParagraph": 2130 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope,", "sourceParagraph": 2131 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and score-method version.", "sourceParagraph": 2132 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The primary GEO-1000 output MUST express the population-weighted", "sourceParagraph": 2134 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "equivalent number of users, out of 1,000, receiving each RP-1 through", "sourceParagraph": 2135 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RP-8 response status.", "sourceParagraph": 2136 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical and Major findings are non-compensatory. No atomic-claim", "sourceParagraph": 2138 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "average, response-pass rate, component score, product coefficient, or", "sourceParagraph": 2139 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ecosystem composite may override an active Critical or Major gate.", "sourceParagraph": 2140 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Atomic, required-element, component, composite, fairness, stability,", "sourceParagraph": 2142 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical-rate, and publication-quality metrics MUST remain distinct.", "sourceParagraph": 2143 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The canonical candidate NOMOS composite consists of ten separately", "sourceParagraph": 2145 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reported 0–100 components:", "sourceParagraph": 2146 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entity Integrity,", "sourceParagraph": 2148 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Factual Fidelity,", "sourceParagraph": 2149 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Scope and Boundary Integrity,", "sourceParagraph": 2150 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Temporal and Local Accuracy,", "sourceParagraph": 2151 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Evidence and Citation Integrity,", "sourceParagraph": 2152 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Epistemic Integrity,", "sourceParagraph": 2153 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Task Completion and Relevance,", "sourceParagraph": 2154 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Language and Geographic Fairness,", "sourceParagraph": 2155 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- User-State and Surface Integrity,", "sourceParagraph": 2156 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and Stability and Replicability.", "sourceParagraph": 2157 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A full 0–1,000 composite MUST NOT be produced when a required component", "sourceParagraph": 2159 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "is not estimable. Missing component weight MUST NOT be silently", "sourceParagraph": 2160 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "redistributed.", "sourceParagraph": 2161 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Native Reach, Common Support, Controlled Clean, Natural User, current", "sourceParagraph": 2163 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "wave, rolling, equal-product, and exposure-weighted scores MUST remain", "sourceParagraph": 2164 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separately identified.", "sourceParagraph": 2165 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI-product coefficients MUST be locked before product results are", "sourceParagraph": 2167 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "observed and MUST NOT depend on product performance, provider reputation,", "sourceParagraph": 2168 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "client preference, sponsorship, or desired outcome.", "sourceParagraph": 2169 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Equal-product coefficients estimate average tested-product performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2171 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Exposure coefficients estimate average defined-user exposure. These", "sourceParagraph": 2172 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "estimands MUST NOT be represented as equivalent.", "sourceParagraph": 2173 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An ecosystem composite MUST retain product-level Critical and Major", "sourceParagraph": 2175 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "incident visibility. High scores in other products MUST NOT erase a", "sourceParagraph": 2176 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "lower-weighted product's confirmed Critical incident.", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unresolved claims MUST produce visible reference-uncertainty bounds and", "sourceParagraph": 2179 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT be silently treated as correct, incorrect, or absent.", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sampling uncertainty, reference uncertainty, score sensitivity, raw", "sourceParagraph": 2182 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sample size, and effective sample size MUST be separately reported.", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zero observed confirmed Critical incidents MUST NOT be represented as", "sourceParagraph": 2185 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zero Critical risk. A method-appropriate one-sided upper bound MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 2186 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reported.", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A NOMOS 950+ performance candidate MUST satisfy score, Strict Pass,", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gate, component-floor, unresolved, quality, coverage, and replication", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conditions. A composite score of 950 or more alone is insufficient.", "sourceParagraph": 2191 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every score formula, mapping, coefficient, dataset, code version,", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "confidence procedure, publication decision, revision, and integrity", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "record MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", "sourceParagraph": 2195 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2196 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No NOMOS result can be published as a single raw composite score. Each result must first show gate status, GEO-1000 response distribution, Strict and Acceptable Pass user equivalents, distributions of Critical, Major, Unresolved, No-Response, and Not-Ratable; then it must show component scores, uncertainty, effective sample size, scope, and score version.", "sourceParagraph": 2198 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Kein NOMOS Ergebnis darf als bloßer Gesamtscore veröffentlicht werden. Jeder veröffentlichte Wert MUSS zuerst Folgendes offenlegen: - den Gate-Status, - die GEO-1000 Antwort-Statusverteilung, - Äquivalente für Strict Pass und Acceptable Pass, - Äquivalente für kritische und schwerwiegende Befunde, - Äquivalente für Unresolved, No Usable Response und Not Ratable, - Komponentenergebnisse, - Unsicherheit, - effektive Stichprobengröße, - Umfang, - und Version der Bewertungsmethode. Die primäre GEO-1000 Ausgabe MUSS die bevölkerungsgewichtete äquivalente Anzahl von Nutzern darstellen, von 1,000, die jeden RP-1 bis RP-8 Antwort-Status erhalten. Kritische und schwerwiegende Befunde sind nicht kompensierbar. Kein Durchschnitt atomarer Aussagen, Antwort-Durchführungsrate, Komponentenbewertung, Produktkoeffizient oder Ökosystem-Zusammensetzung darf ein aktives Kritisches oder Großes Gate außer Kraft setzen. Atom-, erforderliche-Element-, Komponenten-, Zusammensetzungs-, Fairness-, Stabilitäts-, Kritischer-Rate- und Veröffentlichungsqualitätsmetriken MÜSSEN getrennt bleiben. Die kanonische Kandidat NOMOS-Zusammensetzung besteht aus zehn separat berichteten 0–100-Komponenten: - Entitätsintegrität, - Faktentreue, - Umfangs- und Grenzintegrität, - Zeitliche und lokale Genauigkeit, - Nachweis- und Zitationsintegrität, - Epistemische Integrität, - Aufgabenabschluss und Relevanz, - Sprach- und geografische Fairness, - Nutzerzustands- und Oberflächenintegrität, - und Stabilität und Reproduzierbarkeit. Ein vollständiger 0–1,000-Komposit DARF NICHT erstellt werden, wenn eine erforderliche Komponente nicht schätzbar ist. Das Gewicht der fehlenden Komponente DARF NICHT stillschweigend umverteilt werden. Natürliche Reichweite, Gemeinsame Vergleichsbasis, kontrolliertes Panel unter bereinigten Bedingungen, Panel unter natürlichen Nutzungsbedingungen, aktuelle Welle, rollierend, gleichprodukt- und expositionsgewichtete Scores MÜSSEN weiterhin separat identifiziert bleiben. KI-Produktkoeffizienten MÜSSEN festgeschrieben sein, bevor Produktergebnisse beobachtet werden, und DÜRFEN NICHT von der Produktleistung, dem Ruf des Anbieters, der Vorliebe des Kunden, der Förderung oder dem gewünschten Ergebnis abhängen. Gleichproduktkoeffizienten schätzen die durchschnittliche getestete Produktleistung. Expositionskoeffizienten schätzen die durchschnittliche definierte Nutzerexposition. Diese Schätzer DÜRFEN NICHT als gleichwertig repräsentiert werden. Ein Ökosystem-Komposit MUSS die Sichtbarkeit von kritischen und schweren Vorfällen auf Produktebene beibehalten. Hohe Werte in anderen Produkten DÜRFEN den bestätigten kritischen Vorfall eines geringer gewichteten Produkts NICHT löschen. Ungeklärte Aussagen MÜSSEN sichtbare Referenzunsicherheitsgrenzen erzeugen und DÜRFEN NICHT stillschweigend als korrekt, inkorrekt oder nicht vorhanden behandelt werden. Stichprobenunsicherheit, Referenzunsicherheit, Wertungsempfindlichkeit, Rohstichprobengröße und effektive Stichprobengröße MÜSSEN separat berichtet werden. Null beobachtete bestätigte kritische Vorfälle DÜRFEN NICHT als null kritisches Risiko repräsentiert werden. Eine methodengerechte einseitige obere Grenze MUSS berichtet werden. Ein NOMOS 950+ Leistungskandidat MUSS die Bedingungen für Score, Strict Pass, Gate, Component-Floor, Unresolved, Quality, Coverage und Replication erfüllen. Ein zusammengesetzter Score von 950 oder mehr allein ist nicht ausreichend. Jede Score-Formel, Abbildung, Koeffizient, Datensatz, Code-Version, Vertrauensverfahren, Publikationsentscheidung, Revision und Integritätsaufzeichnung MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH16-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MASCHINENLESBARER PUNKTREKORD", "sourceParagraph": 1939, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 1940, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1941, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS_PERFORMANCE_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 1942, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openConfirmedCritical\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1943, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openConfirmedMajor\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1944, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidents\": 1,", "sourceParagraph": 1945, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentCriticalHold\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1946, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1947, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geo1000Distribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1948, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 830,", "sourceParagraph": 1949, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 128,", "sourceParagraph": 1950, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 30,", "sourceParagraph": 1951, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1952, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1953, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 1954, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1955, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1956, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", "sourceParagraph": 1957, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", "sourceParagraph": 1958, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1959, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1960, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 1961, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponseEquivalent\": 7,", "sourceParagraph": 1962, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 1963, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1964, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Komponenten\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1965, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"HENT\": 99,", "sourceParagraph": 1966, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FAC\": 97,", "sourceParagraph": 1967, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SBI\": 96,", "sourceParagraph": 1968, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TLA\": 95,", "sourceParagraph": 1969, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ECI\": 96,", "sourceParagraph": 1970, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"EPI\": 98,", "sourceParagraph": 1971, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TCR\": 97,", "sourceParagraph": 1972, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LGF\": 94,", "sourceParagraph": 1973, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"USI\": 93,", "sourceParagraph": 1974, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"STR\": 96", "sourceParagraph": 1975, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1976, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Komposit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1977, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosScore\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 1978, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scaleMaximum\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 1979, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalEqualComponentWeighting\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1980, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1981, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Unsicherheit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1982, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingConfidenceLevel\": 0.95,", "sourceParagraph": 1983, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1984, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"untere\": 955,", "sourceParagraph": 1985, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"obere\": 967", "sourceParagraph": 1986, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1987, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceUncertainty\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1988, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conservativeLower\": 956,", "sourceParagraph": 1989, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"resolvedOnlyPoint\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 1990, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"optimisticUpper\": 964", "sourceParagraph": 1991, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1992, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rawSampleSize\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 1993, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveSampleSize\": 914,", "sourceParagraph": 1994, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observedConfirmedCriticalCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 1995, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBoundMethod\": \"DESIGN_AWARE_ONE_SIDED\",", "sourceParagraph": 1996, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.003 4", "sourceParagraph": 1997, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1998, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityPrerequisites\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1999, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sampleQuality\": \"SQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2000, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantSelectionIntegrity\": \"PSI-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2001, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2002, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2003, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2004, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicatedWaveCount\": 3", "sourceParagraph": 2005, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2006, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomos950CandidateChecks\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2007, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAtLeast950\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2008, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassAtLeast950\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2009, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noOpenCritical\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2010, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noOpenMajor\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2011, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"allCoreComponentsAtLeast90\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2012, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessUserStateStabilityAtLeast85\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2013, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreUnresolvedAtMostTwoPercent\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2014, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityPrerequisitesMet\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2015, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"replicationRequirementMet\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2016, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2017, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalStatus\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2018, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"priorCriticalIncidentId\": \"NGCI-SYNTH-ORION-TR-W1-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2019, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentRemediationStatus\": \"CIS-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 2020, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalRecordPreserved\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2021, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2022, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2023, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"inputManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-EINGABEHASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2024, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"calculationCodeHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-CODE-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2025, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreManifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCORE-MANIFEST-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2026, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2027, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2028, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodsOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_BEWERTUNGSMETHODEN_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2029, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"VERANTWORTLICHER_MENSCHLICHER_BEWERTUNGSGENEHMIGER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2030, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedAt\": \"2026-10-01 T1 0:00:00 Z\"", "sourceParagraph": 2031, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2032, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2033, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2034, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MASCHINENLESBARE KI-Produkt-KOEFFIZIENTENAUFZEICHNUNG", "sourceParagraph": 2036, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2037, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2038, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2039, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2040, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"productCoefficientRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2041, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientRecordId\": \"NGCOEF-SYNTH-ÖKOSYSTEM-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2042, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2043, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPeriod\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2044, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"von\": \"2026-07-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2045, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"an\": \"2026-09-30\"", "sourceParagraph": 2046, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2047, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetPopulation\": \"DEFINIERTE_AKTIVE_BERECHTIGTE_KI-BENUTZER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2048, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalProductCoefficients\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2049, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2050, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2051, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2052, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2053, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2054, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2055, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2056, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2057, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2058, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2059, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2060, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2061, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2062, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2063, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2064, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2065, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2066, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exposureCoefficients\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2067, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2068, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A1\"", "sourceParagraph": 2069, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 55000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2070, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.55", "sourceParagraph": 2071, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2072, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2073, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2074, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 25000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2075, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.25", "sourceParagraph": 2076, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2077, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2078, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2079, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 15000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2080, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.15", "sourceParagraph": 2081, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2082, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2083, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductId\": \"SYNTH-A4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2084, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"verifiedExposureUnit\": 5000000,", "sourceParagraph": 2085, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Koeffizient\": 0.05", "sourceParagraph": 2086, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2087, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2088, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientRules\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2089, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"performanceDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2090, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"providerReputationDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2091, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commercialSponsorDependent\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2092, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeProductScores\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2093, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"activeUserAndAccountCountsDistinguished\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2094, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2095, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Ausgaben\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2096, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"equalProductEcosystemScore\": 945,", "sourceParagraph": 2097, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"exposureWeightedEcosystemScore\": 947,", "sourceParagraph": 2098, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"anyOpenConfirmedCriticalProduct\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2099, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalProductIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2100, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTH-A4\"", "sourceParagraph": 2101, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2102, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2103, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2104, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coefficientOwnerRole\": \"ECOSYSTEM_EXPOSURE_METHODS_LEAD\"", "sourceParagraph": 2105, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2106, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2107, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2108, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2109, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tatsächlicher KI-Anbieter,", "sourceParagraph": 2110, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tatsächliche Nutzeranzahl,", "sourceParagraph": 2111, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tatsächliche Unternehmensbewertung", "sourceParagraph": 2112, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine echte Unternehmensleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2113, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Score-Architektur ist eine synthetische, maschinenlesbare Repräsentation.", "sourceParagraph": 2114, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL FÜR DEN MASCHINENLESBAREN ABSCHNITT 78", "sourceParagraph": 2116, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH16-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2117, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kein NOMOS-Ergebnis darf als nackter zusammengesetzter Score veröffentlicht werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2119, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede veröffentlichte Punktzahl MUSS zuerst offenlegen:", "sourceParagraph": 2121, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- den Gate-Status,", "sourceParagraph": 2123, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- die Verteilung des GEO-1000-Antwortstatus,", "sourceParagraph": 2124, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- strenge und akzeptable Pass-Äquivalente,", "sourceParagraph": 2125, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- kritische und große Äquivalente,", "sourceParagraph": 2126, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ungelöste, nicht verwendbare Antwort- und nicht bewertbare Äquivalente,", "sourceParagraph": 2127, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Komponentenwertungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2128, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Unsicherheit,", "sourceParagraph": 2129, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- effektive Stichprobengröße,", "sourceParagraph": 2130, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Umfang,", "sourceParagraph": 2131, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Version der Bewertungsmethode.", "sourceParagraph": 2132, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die primäre GEO-1000-Ausgabe MUSS die bevölkerungsgewichtete", "sourceParagraph": 2134, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Äquivalente Anzahl von Nutzern, von 1,000, die jeweils RP-1 über", "sourceParagraph": 2135, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RP-8-Antwortstatus erhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2136, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kritische und wichtige Befunde sind nicht kompensierbar. Keine atomare Behauptung", "sourceParagraph": 2138, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Durchschnitt, Antwort-Erfolgsrate, Komponentenscore, Produktkoeffizient oder", "sourceParagraph": 2139, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ökosystemzusammensetzung darf ein aktives kritisches oder wichtiges Gate nicht überschreiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2140, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Atomar, erforderliches Element, Komponente, Komposit, Fairness, Stabilität,", "sourceParagraph": 2142, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kritische Rate und Veröffentlichungsqualitätsmetriken MÜSSEN getrennt bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2143, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der kanonische NOMOS-Kandidatenverbund besteht aus zehn getrennt", "sourceParagraph": 2145, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ausgewiesenen Komponenten auf einer Skala von 0–100:", "sourceParagraph": 2146, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entitätsintegrität,", "sourceParagraph": 2148, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Faktische Treue,", "sourceParagraph": 2149, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Umfangs- und Grenzeintegrität,", "sourceParagraph": 2150, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zeitliche und örtliche Genauigkeit,", "sourceParagraph": 2151, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nachweis- und Zitierintegrität,", "sourceParagraph": 2152, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Epistemische Integrität,", "sourceParagraph": 2153, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Aufgabenabschluss und Relevanz,", "sourceParagraph": 2154, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprachliche und geographische Fairness,", "sourceParagraph": 2155, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nutzerzustand und Oberflächenintegrität,", "sourceParagraph": 2156, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Stabilität und Reproduzierbarkeit.", "sourceParagraph": 2157, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein vollständiger 0–1,000-Komposit DARF NICHT erzeugt werden, wenn eine erforderliche Komponente", "sourceParagraph": 2159, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht schätzbar ist. Fehlt das Gewicht der Komponente, DARF dieses NICHT stillschweigend", "sourceParagraph": 2160, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "umverteilt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2161, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Natürliche Reichweite, Gemeinsame Vergleichsbasis, Kontrolliert Sauber, Natürlicher Nutzer, aktuell", "sourceParagraph": 2163, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wellen-, rollende-, gleichwertige Produkte- und expositionsgewichtete Scores MÜSSEN beibehalten werden", "sourceParagraph": 2164, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separat identifiziert.", "sourceParagraph": 2165, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Produktkoeffizienten MÜSSEN festgeschrieben werden, bevor Produktergebnisse", "sourceParagraph": 2167, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "beobachtet werden und DÜRFEN NICHT von der Produktleistung, dem Ruf des Anbieters,", "sourceParagraph": 2168, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "der Kundenpräferenz, dem Sponsoring oder dem gewünschten Ergebnis abhängen.", "sourceParagraph": 2169, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gleichwertige Produktkoeffizienten schätzen die durchschnittliche getestete Produktleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2171, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Expositionskoeffizienten schätzen die durchschnittliche definierte Nutzerexposition. Diese", "sourceParagraph": 2172, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Schätzer DÜRFEN NICHT als gleichwertig repräsentiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2173, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Ökosystem-Composite MUSS produktbezogene Kritische und Wichtige beibehalten", "sourceParagraph": 2175, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sichtbarkeit von Vorfällen. Hohe Punktzahlen in anderen Produkten DÜRFEN ein nicht löschen", "sourceParagraph": 2176, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bestätigter kritischer Vorfall des leichteren Produkts.", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ungeklärte Aussagen MÜSSEN sichtbare Referenz-Unsicherheitsgrenzen erzeugen und", "sourceParagraph": 2179, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DARF NICHT stillschweigend als korrekt, falsch oder abwesend behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Stichprobenunsicherheit, Referenzunsicherheit, Punktesensitivität, Roh", "sourceParagraph": 2182, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Stichprobengröße und effektive Stichprobengröße MÜSSEN separat berichtet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Null beobachtete bestätigte kritische Vorfälle DÜRFEN NICHT repräsentiert werden als", "sourceParagraph": 2185, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "null Kritisches Risiko. Eine methodengerechte einseitige obere Grenze MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 2186, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gemeldet.", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein NOMOS 950+ Leistungskandidat MUSS die Punktzahl, strikte Bestehensgrenze, erfüllen,", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Gate, Komponentenebene, ungelöst, Qualität, Abdeckung und Replikation", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bedingungen. Eine zusammengesetzte Punktzahl von 950 oder mehr allein ist nicht ausreichend.", "sourceParagraph": 2191, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Punktzahlformel, Zuordnung, Koeffizient, Datensatz, Code-Version,", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Verfahren zur Vertrauenswürdigkeit, Publikationsentscheidung, Überarbeitung und Integritäts", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufzeichnung MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person zuordenbar sein oder", "sourceParagraph": 2195, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2196, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH16-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kein NOMOS-Ergebnis kann als einzelne rohe zusammengesetzte Punktzahl veröffentlicht werden. Jedes Ergebnis muss zunächst den Gate-Status, die GEO-1000-Antwortverteilung, strikte und akzeptable Bestehensäquivalente für Nutzer, Verteilungen von Kritisch, Groß, Ungeklärt, Keine Antwort und Nicht bewertbar zeigen; danach muss es die Komponentenscores, Unsicherheit, effektive Stichprobengröße, Umfang und Score-Version zeigen.", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 17, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH17", "title": "Das synthetische Testdesign für Apple.com", "subtitle": "Prüfung des Standards, nicht eines Unternehmens", "sourceIds": [ "K03", "K09" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH17-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark MUST evaluate the NOMOS audit method, not the real-world performance of Apple Inc., apple.com, or any actual AI provider. All benchmark entities, claims, evidence objects, users, countries, languages, AI products, responses, citations, captures, incidents, and scores MUST be clearly identified as synthetic. The benchmark MUST maintain a separate APPLE-SYNTH entity twin and MUST NOT represent its Truth Pack as factual information about the real company. The principal benchmark corpus MUST contain: - ten synthetic AI product profiles, - one thousand unique synthetic participants per product per wave, - three measurement waves, - and thirty thousand principal responses. Synthetic participant identities MUST NOT be reused across products or waves in the principal corpus. Product samples SHOULD use matched population distributions without using the same person unit. The principal prevalence corpus, severity challenge corpus, capture integrity corpus, adjudication gold corpus, and diagnostic annex MUST remain separately identified and MUST NOT share prevalence denominators. Generator Truth MUST be created, versioned, hashed, and sealed before response adjudication. It MUST remain hidden from claim extractors, adjudicators, and score analysts until their results are locked. Random seeds, synthetic AI profiles, error-injection rules, prompt versions, Truth Pack records, score methods, and candidate acceptance thresholds MUST be locked before the sealed validation corpus is opened. Benchmark cases MUST include direct, implicit, attributed, modal, scope-limited, temporal, citation-based, omission-based, self-correcting, and entity-conflating failure modes. Critical-event prevalence MUST be estimated from the principal corpus. Critical detection capability MUST be tested in a separate challenge corpus with sufficient examples and Critical-like negative controls. No challenge-set oversampling may alter the principal GEO-1000 distribution or Critical prevalence estimate. Synthetic screenshots and response artefacts MUST carry visible and machine-readable notices that they are not live AI outputs or real entity performance evidence. The benchmark MUST prevent its synthetic claims from being published or indexed as real information about the anchor entity. Benchmark success MUST be determined by recovery of sealed Generator Truth, including claim boundaries, atomic decisions, omissions, Critical and Major gates, response statuses, component scores, composite scores, fairness results, capture validity, and uncertainty coverage. High general accuracy MUST NOT compensate for missed Critical cases. Critical recall and Critical false-positive rate MUST be reported together. A failed benchmark threshold, leakage event, recovery error, or misclassification MUST remain visible and MUST NOT be removed by changing labels, seeds, samples, weights, or score rules after results are observed. Every benchmark design, generation, seal, leakage audit, adjudication, recovery calculation, threshold decision, revision, and public release MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Apple.com Sentetik Benchmark, gerçek Apple Inc., apple.com veya gerçek AI sağlayıcılarının performansını değil; NOMOS denetim yönteminin önceden kilitlenmiş sentetik gerçekliği geri kazanma kabiliyetini değerlendirmelidir. Benchmark içindeki bütün varlıklar, kullanıcılar, ülkeler, diller, AI ürünleri, yanıtlar, citation’lar, kanıtlar ve skorlar açıkça sentetik olarak tanımlanmalıdır.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH17-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "86. MACHINE-READABLE BENCHMARK RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2171 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2172 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2173 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2174 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2175 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmark\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2176 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2177 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkType\": \"BM-S0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2178 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"DESIGN_LOCK_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2179 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"VALIDATE_NOMOS_AUDIT_METHOD_NOT_REAL_ENTITY_PERFORMANCE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2180 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2181 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"synthetic\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2182 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAppleAudit\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2183 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAIProviderAudit\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2184 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endorsementClaimAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2185 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2186 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"anchor\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2187 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"domain\": \"apple.com\",", "sourceParagraph": 2188 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticTwinEntityId\": \"NGE-APPLE-SYNTH-TWIN-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2189 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2190 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"corpora\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2191 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalPrevalence\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2192 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductCount\": 10,", "sourceParagraph": 2193 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validUsersPerProductPerWave\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 2194 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveCount\": 3,", "sourceParagraph": 2195 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 30000,", "sourceParagraph": 2196 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2197 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2198 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2199 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"diagnosticAnnex\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2200 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 6000,", "sourceParagraph": 2201 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2202 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2203 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityChallenge\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2204 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalCases\": 1200,", "sourceParagraph": 2205 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorCases\": 1200,", "sourceParagraph": 2206 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"moderateCases\": 600,", "sourceParagraph": 2207 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalLikeNegativeControls\": 600,", "sourceParagraph": 2208 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2209 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2210 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureIntegrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2211 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInSemanticPrevalenceScore\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2212 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2213 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationGold\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2214 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2215 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2216 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2217 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2218 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"SYNTH-POP-FRAME-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2219 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCodes\": 193,", "sourceParagraph": 2220 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationLanguages\": 24,", "sourceParagraph": 2221 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessSentinelLanguages\": 12,", "sourceParagraph": 2222 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realPopulationClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2223 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedSyntheticPopulationTwins\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2224 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossProducts\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2225 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossWaves\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2226 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2227 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"records\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2228 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackId\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2229 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSetId\": \"SYNTH-PROMPT-SET-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2230 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiRegistryId\": \"SYNTH-AI-REGISTRY-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2231 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"wavePlanId\": \"SYNTH-WAVE-PLAN-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2232 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureSchemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-CAPTURE-SYNTH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2233 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\"", "sourceParagraph": 2234 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2235 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2236 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"createdBeforeResponses\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2237 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedFromAdjudicators\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2238 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-GENERATOR-TRUTH-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2239 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openedOnlyAfterScoreLock\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2240 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2241 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"randomisation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2242 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"seedManifestId\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2243 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneration\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2244 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestRunSelectionProhibited\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2245 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2246 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"releaseProtection\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2247 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visibleSyntheticWatermarkRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2248 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"machineReadableSyntheticMetadataRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2249 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"liveResponseRepresentationProhibited\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2250 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"searchIndexProtectionRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2251 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2252 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2253 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkOwnerRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_BENCHMARK_OWNER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2254 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthCustodianRole\": \"SEALED_TRUTH_CUSTODIAN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2255 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"leakageAuditorRole\": \"INDEPENDENT_LEAKAGE_AUDITOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2256 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationTeamSeparatedFromGenerator\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2257 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2258 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2259 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2260 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "87. MACHINE-READABLE SYNTHETIC AI PROFILE", "sourceParagraph": 2262 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2263 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2264 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2265 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticAIProfile\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2266 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileId\": \"SYNTH-AI-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2267 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileName\": \"RARE_CRITICAL_HIGH_AVERAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2268 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realProviderMapping\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2269 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realProviderInferenceAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2270 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"latentBehavior\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2271 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreEntityAccuracy\": 0.985,", "sourceParagraph": 2272 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualSupportBaseline\": 0.975,", "sourceParagraph": 2273 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeOverreachProbability\": 0.012,", "sourceParagraph": 2274 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalLagProbability\": 0.008,", "sourceParagraph": 2275 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialAttributionLossProbability\": 0.010,", "sourceParagraph": 2276 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMismatchProbability\": 0.006,", "sourceParagraph": 2277 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponseProbability\": 0.003,", "sourceParagraph": 2278 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalEventProbability\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 2279 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorEventProbability\": 0.006,", "sourceParagraph": 2280 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lowResourceLanguagePenalty\": 0.06,", "sourceParagraph": 2281 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalStatePenalty\": 0.03,", "sourceParagraph": 2282 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveDrift\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2283 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W1\": 0.00,", "sourceParagraph": 2284 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W2\": -0.01,", "sourceParagraph": 2285 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W3\": 0.01", "sourceParagraph": 2286 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2287 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2288 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalInjectionFamilies\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2289 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2290 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-05\",", "sourceParagraph": 2291 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\"", "sourceParagraph": 2292 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2293 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intendedMethodStress\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2294 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"HIGH_COMPOSITE_WITH_RARE_CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2295 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NON_COMPENSATORY_GATE_RECOVERY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2296 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RARE_EVENT_UPPER_BOUND\"", "sourceParagraph": 2297 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2298 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeCorpusGeneration\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2299 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileIntegrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-AI-PROFILE-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2300 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2301 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2302 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "88. MACHINE-READABLE GENERATOR TRUTH RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2304 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2305 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2306 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2307 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2308 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthId\": \"NGGT-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2309 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"OBS-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2310 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2311 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProfileId\": \"SYNTH-AI-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2312 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2313 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantId\": \"SYNTH-PERSON-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2314 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"SYNTH-CORE-PROMPT-L01-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2315 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2316 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenAtomicClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2317 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2318 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2319 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2320 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2321 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"principalEntityAssociatedWithDomain\",", "sourceParagraph": 2322 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": \"apple.com\"", "sourceParagraph": 2323 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2324 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"SUPPORTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2325 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"CORE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2326 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2327 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2328 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2329 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2330 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2331 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"predicate\": \"licensedBankInAllMarkets\",", "sourceParagraph": 2332 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2333 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2334 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"CONTRADICTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2335 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2336 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2337 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2338 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\"", "sourceParagraph": 2339 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2340 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootFindingCluster\": \"FALSE_LICENSE_TRANSFER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2341 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2342 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2343 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenOmissions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2344 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2345 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorOmissionId\": \"GOM-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2346 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredBoundary\": \"PAYMENT_SUBSIDIARY_AUTHORITY_IS_LIMITED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2347 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"CRITICAL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2348 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCode\": \"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2349 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2350 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2351 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenResponseStatus\": \"RP-5\",", "sourceParagraph": 2352 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrincipalPrevalenceCorpus\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2353 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedAtGeneration\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2354 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visibleToAdjudicators\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2355 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-GENERATOR-TRUTH-OBS-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2356 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2357 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2358 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "89. MACHINE-READABLE BENCHMARK RECOVERY RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2360 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2361 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2362 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2363 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2364 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NGBR-SYNTH-APPLE-0.9-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2365 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2366 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationSet\": \"SEALED_VALIDATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2367 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterScoreLock\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2368 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2369 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundaryF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2370 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2371 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2372 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2373 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2374 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2375 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2376 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRecall\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2377 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFalsePositiveRate\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2378 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2379 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2380 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2381 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2382 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geo1000DistributionErrors\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2383 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessComponentError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2384 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2385 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confidenceIntervalEmpiricalCoverage\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2386 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2387 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdsApplied\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2388 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2389 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"failureDisclosureRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2390 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionStatus\": \"NOT_STARTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2391 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2392 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryMethodsOwnerRole\": \"BENCHMARK_RECOVERY_METHODS_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2393 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"ACCOUNTABLE_HUMAN_BENCHMARK_APPROVER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2394 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2395 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2396 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2397 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2398 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "actual Apple audit,", "sourceParagraph": 2399 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real AI provider behaviour,", "sourceParagraph": 2400 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real user result", "sourceParagraph": 2401 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real company performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2402 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is a machine-readable synthetic representation of the benchmark design.", "sourceParagraph": 2403 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF SECTION 90", "sourceParagraph": 2405 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH17-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2406 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark MUST evaluate the NOMOS audit method,", "sourceParagraph": 2408 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "not the real-world performance of Apple Inc., apple.com, or any actual AI", "sourceParagraph": 2409 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "provider.", "sourceParagraph": 2410 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "All benchmark entities, claims, evidence objects, users, countries,", "sourceParagraph": 2412 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "languages, AI products, responses, citations, captures, incidents, and", "sourceParagraph": 2413 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scores MUST be clearly identified as synthetic.", "sourceParagraph": 2414 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The benchmark MUST maintain a separate APPLE-SYNTH entity twin and MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2416 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT represent its Truth Pack as factual information about the real", "sourceParagraph": 2417 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "company.", "sourceParagraph": 2418 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The principal benchmark corpus MUST contain:", "sourceParagraph": 2420 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- ten synthetic AI product profiles,", "sourceParagraph": 2422 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- one thousand unique synthetic participants per product per wave,", "sourceParagraph": 2423 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- three measurement waves,", "sourceParagraph": 2424 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and thirty thousand principal responses.", "sourceParagraph": 2425 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Synthetic participant identities MUST NOT be reused across products or", "sourceParagraph": 2427 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "waves in the principal corpus. Product samples SHOULD use matched", "sourceParagraph": 2428 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "population distributions without using the same person unit.", "sourceParagraph": 2429 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The principal prevalence corpus, severity challenge corpus, capture", "sourceParagraph": 2431 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "integrity corpus, adjudication gold corpus, and diagnostic annex MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2432 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain separately identified and MUST NOT share prevalence denominators.", "sourceParagraph": 2433 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Generator Truth MUST be created, versioned, hashed, and sealed before", "sourceParagraph": 2435 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "response adjudication. It MUST remain hidden from claim extractors,", "sourceParagraph": 2436 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "adjudicators, and score analysts until their results are locked.", "sourceParagraph": 2437 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Random seeds, synthetic AI profiles, error-injection rules, prompt", "sourceParagraph": 2439 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versions, Truth Pack records, score methods, and candidate acceptance", "sourceParagraph": 2440 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "thresholds MUST be locked before the sealed validation corpus is opened.", "sourceParagraph": 2441 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Benchmark cases MUST include direct, implicit, attributed, modal,", "sourceParagraph": 2443 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scope-limited, temporal, citation-based, omission-based, self-correcting,", "sourceParagraph": 2444 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0261", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and entity-conflating failure modes.", "sourceParagraph": 2445 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0262", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical-event prevalence MUST be estimated from the principal corpus.", "sourceParagraph": 2447 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0263", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical detection capability MUST be tested in a separate challenge", "sourceParagraph": 2448 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0264", "type": "paragraph", "text": "corpus with sufficient examples and Critical-like negative controls.", "sourceParagraph": 2449 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0265", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No challenge-set oversampling may alter the principal GEO-1000", "sourceParagraph": 2451 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0266", "type": "paragraph", "text": "distribution or Critical prevalence estimate.", "sourceParagraph": 2452 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0267", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Synthetic screenshots and response artefacts MUST carry visible and", "sourceParagraph": 2454 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0268", "type": "paragraph", "text": "machine-readable notices that they are not live AI outputs or real entity", "sourceParagraph": 2455 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0269", "type": "paragraph", "text": "performance evidence.", "sourceParagraph": 2456 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0270", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The benchmark MUST prevent its synthetic claims from being published or", "sourceParagraph": 2458 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0271", "type": "paragraph", "text": "indexed as real information about the anchor entity.", "sourceParagraph": 2459 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0272", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Benchmark success MUST be determined by recovery of sealed Generator", "sourceParagraph": 2461 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0273", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Truth, including claim boundaries, atomic decisions, omissions,", "sourceParagraph": 2462 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0274", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical and Major gates, response statuses, component scores, composite", "sourceParagraph": 2463 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0275", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scores, fairness results, capture validity, and uncertainty coverage.", "sourceParagraph": 2464 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0276", "type": "paragraph", "text": "High general accuracy MUST NOT compensate for missed Critical cases.", "sourceParagraph": 2466 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0277", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Critical recall and Critical false-positive rate MUST be reported", "sourceParagraph": 2467 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0278", "type": "paragraph", "text": "together.", "sourceParagraph": 2468 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0279", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A failed benchmark threshold, leakage event, recovery error, or", "sourceParagraph": 2470 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0280", "type": "paragraph", "text": "misclassification MUST remain visible and MUST NOT be removed by", "sourceParagraph": 2471 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0281", "type": "paragraph", "text": "changing labels, seeds, samples, weights, or score rules after results", "sourceParagraph": 2472 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0282", "type": "paragraph", "text": "are observed.", "sourceParagraph": 2473 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0283", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every benchmark design, generation, seal, leakage audit, adjudication,", "sourceParagraph": 2475 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0284", "type": "paragraph", "text": "recovery calculation, threshold decision, revision, and public release", "sourceParagraph": 2476 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0285", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", "sourceParagraph": 2477 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0286", "type": "paragraph", "text": "organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2478 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0287", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2479 }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0288", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark should evaluate not the performance of the real Apple Inc., apple.com, or real AI providers; but the NOMOS audit method's ability to recover the pre-locked synthetic reality. All entities, users, countries, languages, AI products, responses, citations, evidence, and scores within the benchmark must be clearly identified as synthetic.", "sourceParagraph": 2480 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Das Apple.com Synthetische Benchmark MUSS die NOMOS Prüfungsverfahren bewerten, nicht die reale Leistung von Apple Inc., apple.com oder irgendeinem tatsächlichen KI-Anbieter. Alle Benchmark-Entitäten, Behauptungen, Evidenzobjekte, Nutzer, Länder, Sprachen, KI-Produkte, Antworten, Zitate, Aufzeichnungen, Vorfälle und Bewertungen MÜSSEN eindeutig als synthetisch gekennzeichnet sein. Das Benchmark MUSS ein separates APPLE-SYNTH Entity-Zwillingsobjekt pflegen und DARF sein Truth Pack nicht als faktische Informationen über das reale Unternehmen darstellen. Der Haupt-Benchmark-Korpus MUSS enthalten: - zehn synthetische KI-Produktprofile, - tausend einzigartige synthetische Teilnehmer pro Produkt pro Welle, - drei Messwellen, - und dreißigtausend Hauptantworten. Synthetische Teilnehmeridentitäten DÜRFEN im Hauptkorpus nicht über Produkte oder Wellen hinweg wiederverwendet werden. Produktauswahlen SOLLTEN mit passenden Populationsverteilungen erfolgen, ohne dieselbe Personeneinheit zu verwenden. Der Hauptprävalenzkorpus, der Schweregrad-Herausforderungskorpus, der Integritätsicherungskorpus, der Goldstandard-Adjudikationskorpus und der diagnostische Anhang MÜSSEN separat identifiziert bleiben und DÜRFEN keine Prävalenz-Nenner teilen. Die Generator-Truth MUSS erstellt, versioniert, gehasht und versiegelt werden, bevor die Antwortadjudikation erfolgt. Es MUSS vor Anspruchsprüfern, Entscheidungsträgern und Punktauswertern verborgen bleiben, bis deren Ergebnisse festgeschrieben sind. Zufallszahlen, synthetische KI-Profile, Fehlerinjektionsregeln, Prompt-Versionen, Truth Pack-Datensätze, Bewertungsmethoden und Akzeptanzschwellen für Kandidaten MÜSSEN festgeschrieben werden, bevor das versiegelte Validierungskorpus geöffnet wird. Benchmark-Fälle MÜSSEN direkte, implizite, zugeschriebene, modale, auf den Geltungsbereich begrenzte, zeitliche, zitationsbasierte, auslassungsbasierte, selbstkorrigierende und entitätenverwechselnde Fehlermodi enthalten. Die Prävalenz kritischer Ereignisse MUSS aus dem Hauptkorpus geschätzt werden. Die Fähigkeit zur kritischen Erkennung MUSS in einem separaten Challenge-Korpus mit genügend Beispielen und kritischen negativen Kontrollen getestet werden. Keine Challenge-Set-Überstichprobe darf die Hauptverteilung GEO-1000 oder die Schätzung der kritischen Prävalenz verändern. Synthetische Screenshots und Antwortartefakte MÜSSEN sichtbare und maschinenlesbare Hinweise enthalten, dass sie keine Live-AI-Ausgaben oder echte Leistungsnachweise von Entitäten darstellen. Das Benchmark MUSS verhindern, dass seine synthetischen Angaben als echte Informationen über die Ankerentität veröffentlicht oder indexiert werden. Der Erfolg des Benchmarks MUSS anhand der Wiederherstellung der versiegelten Generator-Wahrheit bestimmt werden, einschließlich Anspruchsgrenzen, atomarer Entscheidungen, Auslassungen, kritischer und wichtiger Tore, Antwortstatus, Komponentenbewertungen, Gesamtbewertungen, Fairness-Ergebnisse, Gültigkeit der Erfassung und Abdeckung der Unsicherheit. Eine hohe allgemeine Genauigkeit DARF fehlende kritische Fälle NICHT kompensieren. Kritische Rückrufrate und kritische Fehlalarmrate MÜSSEN zusammen berichtet werden. Ein nicht erfüllter Benchmark-Schwellenwert, ein Leckageereignis, ein Wiederherstellungsfehler oder eine Fehlklassifikation MUSS sichtbar bleiben und DARF NICHT durch Ändern von Labels, Seeds, Proben, Gewichten oder Bewertungsregeln nach Beobachtung der Ergebnisse entfernt werden. Jede Benchmark-Entwicklung, -Generierung, -Sicherung, -Leckageprüfung, -Entscheidung, -Wiederherstellungsberechnung, -Schwellenwertentscheidung, -Überarbeitung und öffentliche Veröffentlichung MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zuordenbar sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH17-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "86. MASCHINENLESBARE BENCHMARK-AUFZEICHNUNG", "sourceParagraph": 2171, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2172, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2173, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2174, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2175, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmark\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2176, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2177, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkType\": \"BM-S0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2178, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"DESIGN_LOCK_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2179, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"VALIDATE_NOMOS_AUDIT_METHOD_NOT_REAL_ENTITY_PERFORMANCE\" }", "sourceParagraph": 2180, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2181, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"synthetisch\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2182, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAppleAudit\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2183, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAIProviderAudit\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2184, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endorsementClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2185, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2186, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Anker\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2187, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Domäne\": \"apple.com\",", "sourceParagraph": 2188, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticTwinEntityId\": \"NGE-APPLE-SYNTH-TWIN-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2189, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2190, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Korpora\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2191, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalPrevalence\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2192, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProductCount\": 10,", "sourceParagraph": 2193, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validUsersPerProductPerWave\": 1000,", "sourceParagraph": 2194, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveCount\": 3,", "sourceParagraph": 2195, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 30000,", "sourceParagraph": 2196, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptFamily\": \"PR-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2197, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2198, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2199, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"diagnosticAnnex\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2200, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"targetResponseCount\": 6000,", "sourceParagraph": 2201, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2202, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2203, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityChallenge\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2204, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalCases\": 1200,", "sourceParagraph": 2205, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorCases\": 1200,", "sourceParagraph": 2206, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"moderateCases\": 600,", "sourceParagraph": 2207, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalLikeNegativeControls\": 600,", "sourceParagraph": 2208, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2209, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2210, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureIntegrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2211, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInSemanticPrevalenceScore\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2212, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2213, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationGold\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2214, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrevalenceScore\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2215, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2216, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2217, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"population\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2218, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"frameId\": \"SYNTH-POP-RAHMEN-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2219, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countryCodes\": 193,", "sourceParagraph": 2220, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"populationLanguages\": 24,", "sourceParagraph": 2221, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessSentinelLanguages\": 12,", "sourceParagraph": 2222, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realPopulationClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2223, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"matchedSyntheticPopulationTwins\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2224, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossProducts\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2225, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantReuseAcrossWaves\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2226, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2227, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Aufzeichnungen\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2228, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackId\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2229, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSetId\": \"SYNTH-AUFFORDERUNGS-SATZ-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2230, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiRegistryId\": \"SYNTH-KI-REGISTRIERUNG-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2231, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"wavePlanId\": \"SYNTH-WELLEN-PLAN-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2232, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureSchemaVersion\": \"NOMOS-ERFASSEN-SYNTH-0.9\",\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2233, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\"", "sourceParagraph": 2234, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2235, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2236, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"createdBeforeResponses\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2237, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedFromAdjudicators\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2238, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-GENERATOR-TRUTH-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2239, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openedOnlyAfterScoreLock\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2240, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2241, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Randomisierung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2242, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"seedManifestId\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2243, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneration\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2244, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestRunSelectionProhibited\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2245, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2246, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"releaseProtection\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2247, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visibleSyntheticWatermarkRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2248, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"machineReadableSyntheticMetadataRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2249, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"liveResponseRepresentationProhibited\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2250, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"searchIndexProtectionRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2251, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2252, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Governance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2253, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkOwnerRole\": \"VERANTWORTLICHER_MENSCH_BENCHMARK_EIGENTÜMER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2254, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthCustodianRole\": \"VERSIEGELTER_WAHRHEITS_VERWALTER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2255, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"leakageAuditorRole\": \"UNABHÄNGIGER_LECKAGE_PRÜFER\",", "sourceParagraph": 2256, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationTeamSeparatedFromGenerator\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2257, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2258, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2259, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2260, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "87. MASCHINENLESBARES SYNTHETISCHES KI-PROFIL", "sourceParagraph": 2262, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2263, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2264, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2265, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticAIProfile\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2266, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileId\": \"SYNTH-KI-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2267, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileName\": \"SELTSAM_KRITISCH_HOCH_DURCHSCHNITTLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2268, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realProviderMapping\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2269, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realProviderInferenceAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2270, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"latentBehavior\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2271, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"coreEntityAccuracy\": 0.985,", "sourceParagraph": 2272, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualSupportBaseline\": 0.975,", "sourceParagraph": 2273, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeOverreachProbability\": 0.012,", "sourceParagraph": 2274, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"temporalLagProbability\": 0.008,", "sourceParagraph": 2275, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialAttributionLossProbability\": 0.010,", "sourceParagraph": 2276, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMismatchProbability\": 0.006,", "sourceParagraph": 2277, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"noUsableResponseProbability\": 0.003,", "sourceParagraph": 2278, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalEventProbability\": 0.002,", "sourceParagraph": 2279, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorEventProbability\": 0.006,", "sourceParagraph": 2280, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lowResourceLanguagePenalty\": 0.06,", "sourceParagraph": 2281, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"naturalStatePenalty\": 0.03,", "sourceParagraph": 2282, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveDrift\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2283, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W1\": 0.00,", "sourceParagraph": 2284, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W2\": -0.01,", "sourceParagraph": 2285, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W3\": 0.01", "sourceParagraph": 2286, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2287, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2288, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalInjectionFamilies\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2289, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2290, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-05\",", "sourceParagraph": 2291, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-06\"", "sourceParagraph": 2292, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2293, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"intendedMethodStress\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2294, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"HOCHKOMPOSIT_MIT_RAREM_KRITISCHEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2295, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NICHT_KOMPENSATORISCHES_TOR_WIEDERHERSTELLUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2296, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RARES_EREIGNIS_OBERGRENZE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2297, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2298, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeCorpusGeneration\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2299, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"profileIntegrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-KI-PROFIL-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2300, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2301, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2302, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "88. MASCHINENLESBARES_GENERATOR-WAHRHEITSREKORD", "sourceParagraph": 2304, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2305, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2306, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2307, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2308, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthId\": \"NGGT-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2309, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"observationId\": \"OBS-SYNTH-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2310, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2311, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aiProfileId\": \"SYNTH-KI-10\",", "sourceParagraph": 2312, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveId\": \"W2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2313, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"participantId\": \"SYNTH-PERSON-000184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2314, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptRecordId\": \"SYNTH-KERN-PROMPT-L01-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2315, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2316, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenAtomicClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2317, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2318, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2319, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2320, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2321, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"principalEntityAssociatedWithDomain\",", "sourceParagraph": 2322, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": \"apple.com\"", "sourceParagraph": 2323, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2324, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"UNTERSTÜTZT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2325, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"KERN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2326, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2327, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2328, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorClaimId\": \"GCL-000184-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2329, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normalizedClaim\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2330, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"subjectEntityId\": \"APPLE-SYNTH-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2331, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Prädikat\": \"licensedBankInAllMarkets\",", "sourceParagraph": 2332, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"objectValue\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2333, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2334, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthStatus\": \"WIDERSPRUCHLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2335, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bedeutung\": \"KRITISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2336, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCodes\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2337, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2338, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CG-02\"", "sourceParagraph": 2339, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2340, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootFindingCluster\": \"FALSCHE_LIZENZÜBERTRAGUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2341, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2342, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2343, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenOmissions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2344, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2345, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorOmissionId\": \"GOM-000184-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2346, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredBoundary\": \"ZAHLUNGS_TOECHTERGESELLSCHAFT_BEFEHL_IST_BESCHRÄNKT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2347, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bedeutung\": \"KRITISCH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2348, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalGateCode\": \"CG-08\"", "sourceParagraph": 2349, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2350, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2351, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"hiddenResponseStatus\": \"RP-5\"", "sourceParagraph": 2352, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"includedInPrincipalPrevalenceCorpus\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2353, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedAtGeneration\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2354, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"visibleToAdjudicators\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2355, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-GENERATOR-WAHRHEIT-OBS-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2356, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2357, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2358, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "89. MASCHINENLESBARES BENCHMARK-WIEDERHERSTELLUNGSPROTOKOLL", "sourceParagraph": 2360, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2361, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NGBR-SYNTH-APFEL-0.9-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationSet\": \"VERSIEGELTE_VALIDIERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterScoreLock\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metriken\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundaryF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2370, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2373, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRecall\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2377, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFalsePositiveRate\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2381, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"geo1000DistributionErrors\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessComponentError\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2384, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confidenceIntervalEmpiricalCoverage\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdsApplied\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2388, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"failureDisclosureRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionStatus\": \"NICHT_GESTARTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2391, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2392, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryMethodsOwnerRole\": \"BENCHMARK_WIEDERHERSTELLUNGSMETHODEN_FÜHREN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2393, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"approvedByRole\": \"VERANTWORTLICHER_MENSCHLICHER_BENCHMARK_GENEHMIGER\"", "sourceParagraph": 2394, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2395, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2396, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2397, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2398, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "tatsächliche Apple-Prüfung,", "sourceParagraph": 2399, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reales Verhalten des KI-Anbieters,", "sourceParagraph": 2400, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reales Nutzerergebnis", "sourceParagraph": 2401, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine echte Unternehmensleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2402, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist eine maschinenlesbare synthetische Repräsentation des Benchmark-Designs.", "sourceParagraph": 2403, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESESBARE REGEL DER SEKTION 90", "sourceParagraph": 2405, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH17-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2406, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark MUSS die NOMOS Prüfmethodik bewerten,", "sourceParagraph": 2408, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht die reale Leistung von Apple Inc., apple.com, oder eines tatsächlichen KI", "sourceParagraph": 2409, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Anbieters.", "sourceParagraph": 2410, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Alle Benchmark-Entitäten, Aussagen, Evidenzobjekte, Nutzer, Länder,", "sourceParagraph": 2412, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sprachen, KI-Produkte, Antworten, Zitate, Aufzeichnungen, Vorfälle und", "sourceParagraph": 2413, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Punktzahlen MÜSSEN eindeutig als synthetisch gekennzeichnet sein.", "sourceParagraph": 2414, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Benchmark MUSS ein separates APPLE-SYNTH Entity-Twin führen und MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 2416, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sein Truth Pack NICHT als faktische Information über das reale", "sourceParagraph": 2417, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unternehmen darstellen.", "sourceParagraph": 2418, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Haupt-Benchmark-Korpus MUSS enthalten:", "sourceParagraph": 2420, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- zehn synthetische KI-Produktprofile,", "sourceParagraph": 2422, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- tausend einzigartige synthetische Teilnehmer pro Produkt pro Welle,", "sourceParagraph": 2423, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- drei Messwellen,", "sourceParagraph": 2424, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und dreißigtausend Hauptantworten.", "sourceParagraph": 2425, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Künstliche Teilnehmeridentitäten DÜRFEN NICHT über Produkte hinweg wiederverwendet werden oder", "sourceParagraph": 2427, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wellen im Hauptkorpus. Produktmuster SOLLTEN passend verwendet werden", "sourceParagraph": 2428, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bevölkerungsverteilungen ohne Verwendung derselben Personeneinheit.", "sourceParagraph": 2429, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das Hauptprävalenzkorpus, Schweregrad-Herausforderungskorpus, Erfassen", "sourceParagraph": 2431, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Integritätskorpus, Schiedsspruch-Goldkorpus und Diagnoseanhang MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2432, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "bleiben getrennt identifiziert und DÜRFEN keine Prävalenznenner teilen.", "sourceParagraph": 2433, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Generator-Truth MUSS erstellt, versioniert, gehasht und versiegelt werden, bevor", "sourceParagraph": 2435, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Antwortabwägung erfolgt. Sie MUSS vor Anspruchsextraktoren,", "sourceParagraph": 2436, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abwägern und Bewertungsanalysten verborgen bleiben, bis deren Ergebnisse festgeschrieben sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2437, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zufallssamen, synthetische KI-Profile, Fehlerinjektionsregeln, Prompt-", "sourceParagraph": 2439, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Versionen, Truth-Pack-Datensätze, Bewertungsmethoden und Annahmeschwellen", "sourceParagraph": 2440, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "für Kandidaten MÜSSEN festgeschrieben sein, bevor das versiegelte Validierungskorpus geöffnet wird.", "sourceParagraph": 2441, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Benchmark-Fälle MÜSSEN direkte, implizite, attribuierte, modale enthalten,", "sourceParagraph": 2443, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "umfangsbegrenzte, zeitliche, zitationsbasierte, auslassungsbasierte, selbstkorrigierende,", "sourceParagraph": 2444, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0261", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und entity-verwechselnde Fehlermodi.", "sourceParagraph": 2445, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0262", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Prävalenz kritischer Ereignisse MUSS aus dem Hauptkorpus geschätzt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2447, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0263", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Fähigkeit zur kritischen Erkennung MUSS in einem separaten Challenge-", "sourceParagraph": 2448, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0264", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Korpus mit ausreichenden Beispielen und kritischen negativen Kontrollen getestet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2449, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0265", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kein Oversampling im Challenge-Set darf die Hauptverteilung GEO-1000", "sourceParagraph": 2451, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0266", "type": "paragraph", "text": "oder die Schätzung der kritischen Prävalenz verändern.", "sourceParagraph": 2452, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0267", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Synthetische Screenshots und Antwort-Artefakte MÜSSEN sichtbare und", "sourceParagraph": 2454, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0268", "type": "paragraph", "text": "maschinenlesbare Hinweise tragen, dass sie keine Live-KI-Ausgaben oder echte Entitäten sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2455, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0269", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Leistungsnachweis.", "sourceParagraph": 2456, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0270", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Benchmark MUSS verhindern, dass seine synthetischen Behauptungen veröffentlicht oder", "sourceParagraph": 2458, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0271", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als echte Informationen über die Ankerentität indexiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2459, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0272", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Erfolg des Benchmarks MUSS durch die Wiederherstellung der versiegelten Generator-", "sourceParagraph": 2461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0273", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wahrheit bestimmt werden, einschließlich Behauptungsgrenzen, atomaren Entscheidungen, Auslassungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0274", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kritischen und wichtigen Toren, Antwortstatus, Komponentenpunkten, zusammengesetzten", "sourceParagraph": 2463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0275", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Punkten, Fairness-Ergebnissen, Erfassungsvalidität und Unsicherheitsabdeckung.", "sourceParagraph": 2464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0276", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Hohe allgemeine Genauigkeit DARF fehlende kritische Fälle nicht ausgleichen.", "sourceParagraph": 2466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0277", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kritische Rückrufquote und kritische Falsch-Positiv-Rate MÜSSEN gemeldet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0278", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zusammen.", "sourceParagraph": 2468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0279", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein gescheiteter Benchmark-Schwellenwert, ein Leckageereignis, ein Wiederherstellungsfehler oder", "sourceParagraph": 2470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0280", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fehlklassifizierung MUSS sichtbar bleiben und DARF NICHT entfernt werden durch", "sourceParagraph": 2471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0281", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ändern von Labels, Seeds, Samples, Gewichten oder Bewertungsregeln, nachdem Ergebnisse", "sourceParagraph": 2472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0282", "type": "paragraph", "text": "beobachtet wurden.", "sourceParagraph": 2473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0283", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jedes Benchmark-Design, jede Generierung, Versiegelung, Leckageprüfung, Bewertung,", "sourceParagraph": 2475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0284", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wiederherstellungsberechnung, Schwellenwertentscheidung, Überarbeitung und öffentliche Freigabe", "sourceParagraph": 2476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0285", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person zuordenbar sein.", "sourceParagraph": 2477, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0286", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0287", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH17-MB0288", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Apple.com Synthetic Benchmark sollte nicht die Leistung des echten Unternehmens Apple Inc., apple.com, oder echter KI-Anbieter bewerten; sondern die Fähigkeit der NOMOS-Auditmethode, die vorab festgeschriebene synthetische Realität wiederherzustellen. Alle Entitäten, Nutzer, Länder, Sprachen, KI-Produkte, Antworten, Zitate, Nachweise und Bewertungen innerhalb des Benchmarks müssen eindeutig als synthetisch identifiziert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2480, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 18, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH18", "title": "Ein synthetisches End-to-End-Audit von 30.000 Antworten", "subtitle": "Eine berechnete Demonstration der Methode", "sourceIds": [ "K03", "K09" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH18-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "A book-level synthetic demonstration MUST NOT be represented as an executed, independently validated benchmark. The real benchmark quality status MUST remain BQ-0 until the corpus, software, sealed Generator Truth, adjudication process, scoring process, and independent reproduction have actually been executed. An end-to-end synthetic audit MUST evaluate recovery separately for: - capture validity, - claim boundaries, - entity resolution, - factual status, - scope, - time, - attribution, - modality, - citation mapping, - material omissions, - Critical and Major severity, - response status, - GEO-1000 distribution, - component scores, - composite score, - fairness, - user-state effects, - stability, - confidence intervals, - and rare-event behaviour. A small composite-score error MUST NOT compensate for material component-level recovery errors. First-pass and final-adjudicated Critical recall MUST remain separately reported. Final Critical recovery MUST disclose the review and expertise layers required to achieve it. Any predeclared mandatory recovery threshold that is not met MUST block a sealed-validation-pass decision. Candidate thresholds MUST NOT be lowered, rounded, reinterpreted, or removed after results are observed merely to make the method pass. Citation mapping and material omission recovery MUST be treated as separate mandatory method capabilities. A method failure MUST create a versioned Method Finding, an identified root cause, a remediation owner, and a requirement for validation on an untouched holdout. Regression success on previously failed cases MUST NOT replace untouched holdout validation. A demonstration that fails mandatory thresholds MUST publish both its successful and unsuccessful results. No public NOMOS conformity mark, NOMOS 950+ declaration, or real-entity ranking may be based solely on a book demonstration, synthetic recovery scenario, or non-independent benchmark. Every demonstration run, real benchmark status, recovery result, method finding, threshold decision, remediation, and release decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "Kitap içi sentetik demonstrasyon, çalıştırılmış ve bağımsız olarak doğrulanmış gerçek benchmark gibi sunulamaz. Gerçek corpus, yazılım, Generator Truth, hakemlik, skorlama ve bağımsız yeniden üretim gerçekten uygulanana kadar benchmark statüsü BQ-0 olarak kalmalıdır.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH18-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE DEMONSTRATION RECORD 49", "sourceParagraph": 1587 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1588 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1589 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1590 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRun\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1591 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1592 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"chapter\": \"CH18\",", "sourceParagraph": 1593 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"BOOK_LEVEL_SYNTHETIC_DEMONSTRATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1594 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realBenchmarkExecution\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1595 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realBenchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1596 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationQualityStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1597 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1598 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realApplePerformanceClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1599 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAIProviderPerformanceClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1600 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realHumanObservationClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1601 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentExecutionClaim\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1602 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1603 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"corpora\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1604 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalPrevalenceResponses\": 30000,", "sourceParagraph": 1605 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"diagnosticAnnexCases\": 6000,", "sourceParagraph": 1606 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityChallengeCases\": 3600,", "sourceParagraph": 1607 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureIntegrityCases\": 4000,", "sourceParagraph": 1608 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationGoldCases\": 2400", "sourceParagraph": 1609 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1610 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedRecords\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1611 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkVersion\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 1612 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1613 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSetVersion\": \"SYNTH-PROMPT-SET-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1614 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-SCORE-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 1615 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"seedManifestVersion\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1616 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdVersion\": \"SYNTH-ACCEPTANCE-0.9\"", "sourceParagraph": 1617 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1618 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1619 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedBeforeRecovery\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1620 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1621 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 20045,", "sourceParagraph": 1622 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 4310,", "sourceParagraph": 1623 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 2370,", "sourceParagraph": 1624 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 1602,", "sourceParagraph": 1625 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", "sourceParagraph": 1626 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 450,", "sourceParagraph": 1627 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 1110,", "sourceParagraph": 1628 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 80", "sourceParagraph": 1629 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1630 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1631 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1632 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneratorTruthOpen\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1633 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1634 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 19980,", "sourceParagraph": 1635 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 4365,", "sourceParagraph": 1636 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 2382,", "sourceParagraph": 1637 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 1585,", "sourceParagraph": 1638 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", "sourceParagraph": 1639 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 468,", "sourceParagraph": 1640 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 1091,", "sourceParagraph": 1641 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 96", "sourceParagraph": 1642 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1643 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 811.5,", "sourceParagraph": 1644 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 890.9", "sourceParagraph": 1645 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1646 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1647 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"synthetic\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1648 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bookDemonstrationOnly\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1649 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DEMO-RUN-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1650 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1651 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1652 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responsibleHumanAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 1653 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 1654 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realExecutionApprovalRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1655 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1656 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1657 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1658 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MACHINE-READABLE RECOVERY RECORD 50", "sourceParagraph": 1660 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1661 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1662 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1663 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1664 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RECOVERY-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1665 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1666 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterRecoveryLock\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1667 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metrics\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1668 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1669 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"precision\": 0.9613,", "sourceParagraph": 1670 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recall\": 0.9665,", "sourceParagraph": 1671 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"f1\": 0.9639,", "sourceParagraph": 1672 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.95,", "sourceParagraph": 1673 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1674 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1675 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1676 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.987,", "sourceParagraph": 1677 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 1678 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1679 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1680 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1681 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.923,", "sourceParagraph": 1682 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1683 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1684 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1685 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1686 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.906,", "sourceParagraph": 1687 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1688 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1689 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1690 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1691 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.918,", "sourceParagraph": 1692 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1693 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": true", "sourceParagraph": 1694 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1695 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1696 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.887,", "sourceParagraph": 1697 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1698 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1699 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1700 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1701 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"value\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 1702 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 1703 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1704 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1705 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFirstPassRecall\": 0.9942,", "sourceParagraph": 1706 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFinalRecall\": 1.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1707 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFinalFalsePositiveRate\": 0.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1708 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": 0.952,", "sourceParagraph": 1709 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": 0.928,", "sourceParagraph": 1710 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": 0.982,", "sourceParagraph": 1711 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": 1.9,", "sourceParagraph": 1712 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": 1.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1713 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessComponentAbsoluteError\": 2.4,", "sourceParagraph": 1714 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confidenceIntervalCoverageWithinCandidateRange\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1715 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalCriticalGateInversionCount\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 1716 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1717 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdSummary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1718 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"passed\": 15,", "sourceParagraph": 1719 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"failed\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1720 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionCompleted\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1721 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1722 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1723 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1724 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedValidationPassed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1725 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionEligible\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1726 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityUseAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1727 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1728 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1729 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1730 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "51. MACHINE-READABLE METHOD FINDING RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 1732 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1733 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1734 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1735 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFinding\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1736 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH18-OMISSION-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1737 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Material Boundary Omission Under-Detection\",", "sourceParagraph": 1738 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1739 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"importance\": \"MAJOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1740 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedComponents\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1741 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SBI\",", "sourceParagraph": 1742 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TCR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1743 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CRITICAL_GATE_RECOVERY\"", "sourceParagraph": 1744 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1745 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidence\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1746 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 1747 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 1748 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mostAffectedPromptFamilies\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1749 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-07\",", "sourceParagraph": 1750 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-09\",", "sourceParagraph": 1751 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-05\"", "sourceParagraph": 1752 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1753 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mostAffectedErrorForms\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1754 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OUT_OF_SCOPE_RECOMMENDATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1755 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"JURISDICTION_BOUNDARY_OMISSION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1756 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SUBSIDIARY_AUTHORITY_OMISSION\"", "sourceParagraph": 1757 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1758 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1759 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootCause\": \"The adjudication codebook identifies explicit scope errors more reliably than counterfactual decision-changing omissions.\",", "sourceParagraph": 1760 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"remediation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1761 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1762 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"actions\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1763 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ADD_COUNTERFACTUAL_DECISION_TEST\",", "sourceParagraph": 1764 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ADD_ENTITY_SERVICE_JURISDICTION_MATRIX\",", "sourceParagraph": 1765 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REQUIRE_SEPARATE_BOUNDARY_OMISSION_REVIEW\",", "sourceParagraph": 1766 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VALIDATE_ON_UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1767 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1768 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1769 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1770 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkPassAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1771 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicBadgeUseAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 1772 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1773 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1774 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_METHOD_REMEDIATION_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 1775 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"OPEN\"", "sourceParagraph": 1776 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1777 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1778 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1779 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "52. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 1781 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH18-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1782 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A book-level synthetic demonstration MUST NOT be represented as an", "sourceParagraph": 1784 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "executed, independently validated benchmark.", "sourceParagraph": 1785 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The real benchmark quality status MUST remain BQ-0 until the corpus,", "sourceParagraph": 1787 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "software, sealed Generator Truth, adjudication process, scoring process,", "sourceParagraph": 1788 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and independent reproduction have actually been executed.", "sourceParagraph": 1789 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An end-to-end synthetic audit MUST evaluate recovery separately for:", "sourceParagraph": 1791 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- capture validity,", "sourceParagraph": 1793 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- claim boundaries,", "sourceParagraph": 1794 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- entity resolution,", "sourceParagraph": 1795 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- factual status,", "sourceParagraph": 1796 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- scope,", "sourceParagraph": 1797 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- time,", "sourceParagraph": 1798 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- attribution,", "sourceParagraph": 1799 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- modality,", "sourceParagraph": 1800 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- citation mapping,", "sourceParagraph": 1801 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- material omissions,", "sourceParagraph": 1802 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Critical and Major severity,", "sourceParagraph": 1803 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- response status,", "sourceParagraph": 1804 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- GEO-1000 distribution,", "sourceParagraph": 1805 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- component scores,", "sourceParagraph": 1806 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- composite score,", "sourceParagraph": 1807 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- fairness,", "sourceParagraph": 1808 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- user-state effects,", "sourceParagraph": 1809 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- stability,", "sourceParagraph": 1810 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- confidence intervals,", "sourceParagraph": 1811 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and rare-event behaviour.", "sourceParagraph": 1812 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A small composite-score error MUST NOT compensate for material", "sourceParagraph": 1814 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "component-level recovery errors.", "sourceParagraph": 1815 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "First-pass and final-adjudicated Critical recall MUST remain separately", "sourceParagraph": 1817 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "reported. Final Critical recovery MUST disclose the review and expertise", "sourceParagraph": 1818 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "layers required to achieve it.", "sourceParagraph": 1819 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Any predeclared mandatory recovery threshold that is not met MUST block a", "sourceParagraph": 1821 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "sealed-validation-pass decision.", "sourceParagraph": 1822 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Candidate thresholds MUST NOT be lowered, rounded, reinterpreted, or", "sourceParagraph": 1824 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "removed after results are observed merely to make the method pass.", "sourceParagraph": 1825 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Citation mapping and material omission recovery MUST be treated as", "sourceParagraph": 1827 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separate mandatory method capabilities.", "sourceParagraph": 1828 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A method failure MUST create a versioned Method Finding, an identified", "sourceParagraph": 1830 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "root cause, a remediation owner, and a requirement for validation on an", "sourceParagraph": 1831 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "untouched holdout.", "sourceParagraph": 1832 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Regression success on previously failed cases MUST NOT replace untouched", "sourceParagraph": 1834 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "holdout validation.", "sourceParagraph": 1835 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A demonstration that fails mandatory thresholds MUST publish both its", "sourceParagraph": 1837 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "successful and unsuccessful results.", "sourceParagraph": 1838 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No public NOMOS conformity mark, NOMOS 950+ declaration, or real-entity", "sourceParagraph": 1840 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ranking may be based solely on a book demonstration, synthetic recovery", "sourceParagraph": 1841 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scenario, or non-independent benchmark.", "sourceParagraph": 1842 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every demonstration run, real benchmark status, recovery result, method", "sourceParagraph": 1844 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "finding, threshold decision, remediation, and release decision MUST be", "sourceParagraph": 1845 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 1846 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1847 }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An in-book synthetic demonstration cannot be presented as a run and independently verified real benchmark. Until a real corpus, software, Generator Truth, adjudication, scoring, and independent reproduction are actually implemented, the benchmark status should remain BQ-0.", "sourceParagraph": 1848 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Eine synthetische Demonstration auf Buchniveau DARF NICHT als durchgeführter, unabhängig validierter Benchmark repräsentiert werden. Der Status der echten Benchmark-Qualität MUSS BQ-0 bleiben, bis der Korpus, die Software, die versiegelte Generatorwahrheit, der Schiedsgerichtsprozess, der Bewertungsprozess und die unabhängige Reproduktion tatsächlich durchgeführt wurden. Ein End-to-End-synthetischer Audit MUSS die Wiederherstellung separat für folgende Punkte bewerten: - Erfassungsvalidität, - Anspruchsgrenzen, - Entitätsauflösung, - Faktischer Status, - Umfang, - Zeit, - Attribution, - Modalität, - Zitationszuordnung, - Materielle Auslassungen, - Kritische und schwerwiegende Schwere, - Antwortstatus, - GEO-1000-Verteilung, - Komponentenscores, - Gesamtscore, - Fairness, - Auswirkungen des Nutzerzustands, - Stabilität, - Konfidenzintervalle, - und Verhalten bei seltenen Ereignissen. Ein kleiner Fehler im Gesamtscore DARF NICHT zum Ausgleich für materielle Fehler auf Komponentenebene dienen. Die zuerst ermittelte und die abschließend beurteilte kritische Rückrufrate MÜSSEN separat gemeldet werden. Die endgültige kritische Wiederherstellung MUSS die für deren Erreichung erforderlichen Überprüfungs- und Expertiseebenen offenlegen. Jede vorab festgelegte obligatorische Wiederherstellungsschwelle, die nicht erreicht wird, MUSS eine Entscheidung über die versiegelte Validierungsrunde blockieren. Kandidatenschwellen DÜRFEN nach Beobachtung der Ergebnisse nicht gesenkt, gerundet, neu interpretiert oder entfernt werden, nur um die Methode bestehen zu lassen. Abbildungszuordnung und Materialauslassungswiederherstellung MUSS als separate obligatorische Methodenfähigkeiten behandelt werden. Ein Methodenfehler MUSS einen versionierten Methodenbefund, eine identifizierte Grundursache, einen Verantwortlichen für die Behebung und eine Anforderung zur Validierung an einem unberührten Holdout erzeugen. Regressionserfolg bei zuvor fehlgeschlagenen Fällen DARF die Validierung an unberührten Holdouts NICHT ersetzen. Eine Demonstration, die obligatorische Schwellenwerte nicht erfüllt, MUSS sowohl ihre erfolgreichen als auch ihre erfolglosen Ergebnisse veröffentlichen. Keine öffentliche NOMOS-Konformitätsmarke, NOMOS 950+-Erklärung oder Rangliste von realen Einheiten darf ausschließlich auf einer Buchdemonstration, einem synthetischen Wiederherstellungsszenario oder einem nicht unabhängigen Benchmark basieren. Jeder Demonstrationslauf, jedes reale Benchmark-Status, jedes Wiederherstellungsergebnis, jede Methodenfeststellung, jede Schwellenwertentscheidung, jede Abhilfemaßnahme und jede Freigabeentscheidung MUSS versioniert sein und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden KÖNNEN.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH18-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESBARE DEMONSTRATIONSAUFZEICHNUNG 49", "sourceParagraph": 1587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRun\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"chapter\": \"CH1 8\",", "sourceParagraph": 1593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"BUCH_EBENE_SYNTHETISCHE_DEMONSTRATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1594, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realBenchmarkExecution\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1595, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realBenchmarkQualityStatus\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationQualityStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1597, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonClaimStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realApplePerformanceClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1599, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realAIProviderPerformanceClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realHumanObservationClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1601, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentExecutionClaim\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1602, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1603, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Korpora\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1604, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalPrevalenceResponses\": 30000,", "sourceParagraph": 1605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"diagnosticAnnexCases\": 6000,", "sourceParagraph": 1606, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"severityChallengeCases\": 3600,", "sourceParagraph": 1607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureIntegrityCases\": 4000,", "sourceParagraph": 1608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationGoldCases\": 2400", "sourceParagraph": 1609, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1610, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedRecords\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1611, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkVersion\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-BENCH-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 1612, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"SYNTH-APPLE-TP-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1613, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"promptSetVersion\": \"SYNTH-AUFFORDERUNGS-SATZ-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1614, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"NOMOS-BEWERTUNG-0.9\"", "sourceParagraph": 1615, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"seedManifestVersion\": \"SYNTH-SEED-MANIFEST-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1616, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdVersion\": \"SYNTH-ACCEPTANCE-0.9\"", "sourceParagraph": 1617, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1618, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruth\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1619, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedBeforeRecovery\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1620, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1621, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 20045,", "sourceParagraph": 1622, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 4310,", "sourceParagraph": 1623, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 2370,", "sourceParagraph": 1624, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 1602,", "sourceParagraph": 1625, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", "sourceParagraph": 1626, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 450,", "sourceParagraph": 1627, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 1110,", "sourceParagraph": 1628, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 80", "sourceParagraph": 1629, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1630, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1631, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lockedBeforeGeneratorTruthOpen\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"principalDistribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1634, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-1\": 19980,", "sourceParagraph": 1635, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-2\": 4365,", "sourceParagraph": 1636, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-3\": 2382,", "sourceParagraph": 1637, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-4\": 1585,", "sourceParagraph": 1638, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-5\": 33,", "sourceParagraph": 1639, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-6\": 468,", "sourceParagraph": 1640, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-7\": 1091,", "sourceParagraph": 1641, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"RP-8\": 96", "sourceParagraph": 1642, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1643, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 811.5,", "sourceParagraph": 1644, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 890.9", "sourceParagraph": 1645, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1646, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1647, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"synthetisch\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1648, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bookDemonstrationOnly\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1649, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DEMO-LAUF-HASH\"", "sourceParagraph": 1650, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1651, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1652, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responsibleHumanAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 1653, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS von NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 1654, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"realExecutionApprovalRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 1655, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1656, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1657, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1658, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MASCHINENLESBARES WIEDERHERSTELLUNGSREKORD 50", "sourceParagraph": 1660, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1661, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1662, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1663, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkRecovery\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1664, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recoveryRecordId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-WIEDERHERSTELLUNG-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1665, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1666, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"generatorTruthOpenedAfterRecoveryLock\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1667, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"metriken\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1668, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimBoundary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1669, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"präzision\": 0.961 3,", "sourceParagraph": 1670, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"abruf\": 0.966 5,", "sourceParagraph": 1671, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"f1\": 0.963 9,", "sourceParagraph": 1672, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.95,", "sourceParagraph": 1673, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": wahr", "sourceParagraph": 1674, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1675, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityResolutionAccuracy\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1676, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.987,", "sourceParagraph": 1677, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.98,", "sourceParagraph": 1678, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": wahr", "sourceParagraph": 1679, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1680, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"factualStatusMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1681, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.923,", "sourceParagraph": 1682, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1683, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": wahr", "sourceParagraph": 1684, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1685, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1686, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.906,", "sourceParagraph": 1687, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1688, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": wahr", "sourceParagraph": 1689, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1690, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionMacroF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1691, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.918,", "sourceParagraph": 1692, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1693, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": wahr", "sourceParagraph": 1694, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1695, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"citationMappingF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1696, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.887,", "sourceParagraph": 1697, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.90,", "sourceParagraph": 1698, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": falsch", "sourceParagraph": 1699, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1700, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1701, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Wert\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 1702, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 1703, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": falsch", "sourceParagraph": 1704, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1705, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFirstPassRecall\": 0.994 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1706, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFinalRecall\": 1.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1707, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalFinalFalsePositiveRate\": 0.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1708, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"majorClassificationMacroF1\": 0.952,", "sourceParagraph": 1709, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"responseStatusMacroF1\": 0.928,", "sourceParagraph": 1710, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureValidityAccuracy\": 0.982,", "sourceParagraph": 1711, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"componentMeanAbsoluteError\": 1.9,", "sourceParagraph": 1712, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"compositeAbsoluteError\": 1.0,", "sourceParagraph": 1713, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessComponentAbsoluteError\": 2.4,", "sourceParagraph": 1714, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confidenceIntervalCoverageWithinCandidateRange\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 1715, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"finalCriticalGateInversionCount\": 0", "sourceParagraph": 1716, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1717, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThresholdSummary\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1718, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"bestanden\": 15,", "sourceParagraph": 1719, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fehlgeschlagen\": 2,", "sourceParagraph": 1720, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionCompleted\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1721, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1722, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"qualityDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1723, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationStatus\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 1724, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"sealedValidationPassed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1725, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReproductionEligible\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1726, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityUseAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1727, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1728, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1729, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1730, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "51. MASCHINENLESBARE METHODENAUFZEICHNUNG", "sourceParagraph": 1732, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 1733, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 1734, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1735, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFinding\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1736, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH1 8-OMISSION-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 1737, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Titel\": \"Untererkennung der Materialgrenzen-Omission\",", "sourceParagraph": 1738, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1739, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Bedeutung\": \"WESENTLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 1740, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedComponents\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1741, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SBI\",", "sourceParagraph": 1742, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TCR\",", "sourceParagraph": 1743, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"KRITISCHES_TOR_WIEDERHERSTELLUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 1744, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1745, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Nachweis\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1746, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 1747, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 1748, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mostAffectedPromptFamilies\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1749, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-07\",", "sourceParagraph": 1750, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-09\",", "sourceParagraph": 1751, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PR-05\"", "sourceParagraph": 1752, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 1753, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mostAffectedErrorForms\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1754, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"EMPFEHLUNG_AUSSERHALB_DES_UMFANGS\",", "sourceParagraph": 1755, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"JURISDIKTIONSGRENZEN_OMISSION\",", "sourceParagraph": 1756, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TOCHTERGESELLSCHAFT_BEHÖRDEN_OMISSION\"", "sourceParagraph": 1757, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1758, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1759, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"rootCause\": \"Das Entscheidungscodebook identifiziert explizite Fehler im Umfang zuverlässiger als kontrafaktische, entscheidungsverändernde Auslassungen.\"", "sourceParagraph": 1760, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Behebung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1761, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 1762, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"aktionen\": [", "sourceParagraph": 1763, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ADD_COUNTERFACTUAL_DECISION_TEST\",", "sourceParagraph": 1764, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ADD_ENTITY_SERVICE_JURISDICTION_MATRIX\",", "sourceParagraph": 1765, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REQUIRE_SEPARATE_BOUNDARY_OMISSION_REVIEW\",", "sourceParagraph": 1766, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VALIDATE_ON_UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT\"", "sourceParagraph": 1767, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 1768, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1769, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityEffect\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1770, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkPassAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1771, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicBadgeUseAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 1772, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 1773, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 1774, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"findingOwnerRole\": \"NOMOS_METHOD_REMEDIATION_LEAD\",", "sourceParagraph": 1775, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"GEÖFFNET\"", "sourceParagraph": 1776, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1777, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1778, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 1779, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "52. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 1781, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH18-R01", "sourceParagraph": 1782, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine synthetische Demonstration auf Buchebene DARF NICHT als eine", "sourceParagraph": 1784, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ausgeführter, unabhängig validierter Benchmark.", "sourceParagraph": 1785, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der tatsächliche Benchmark-Qualitätsstatus MUSS BQ-0 bleiben, bis das Korpus,", "sourceParagraph": 1787, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Software, versiegelter Generator-Wahrheit, Adjudikationsprozess, Bewertungsprozess,", "sourceParagraph": 1788, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und unabhängige Reproduktion tatsächlich durchgeführt wurden.", "sourceParagraph": 1789, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine End-to-End-Synthetikprüfung MUSS die Wiederherstellung separat bewerten für:", "sourceParagraph": 1791, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gültigkeit der Erfassung,", "sourceParagraph": 1793, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Anspruchsgrenzen,", "sourceParagraph": 1794, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entitätsauflösung,", "sourceParagraph": 1795, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Faktischer Status,", "sourceParagraph": 1796, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Umfang,", "sourceParagraph": 1797, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zeit,", "sourceParagraph": 1798, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zuschreibung,", "sourceParagraph": 1799, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Modalität,", "sourceParagraph": 1800, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Zitationszuordnung,", "sourceParagraph": 1801, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- wesentliche Auslassungen,", "sourceParagraph": 1802, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Kritische und schwerwiegende Schweregrade,", "sourceParagraph": 1803, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Antwortstatus,", "sourceParagraph": 1804, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- GEO-1000 Verteilung,", "sourceParagraph": 1805, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Komponentenwertungen,", "sourceParagraph": 1806, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- zusammengesetzter Score,", "sourceParagraph": 1807, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Fairness,", "sourceParagraph": 1808, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Effekte des Nutzerzustands,", "sourceParagraph": 1809, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Stabilität,", "sourceParagraph": 1810, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konfidenzintervalle,", "sourceParagraph": 1811, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Verhalten bei seltenen Ereignissen.", "sourceParagraph": 1812, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein kleiner Fehler im zusammengesetzten Score DARF keine wesentlichen", "sourceParagraph": 1814, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fehler auf Komponentenebene ausgleichen.", "sourceParagraph": 1815, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Erstbewertung und die endgültige adjudizierte kritische Rückholung MÜSSEN weiterhin separat", "sourceParagraph": 1817, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gemeldet werden. Die endgültige kritische Rückholung MÜSSEN die erforderlichen Überprüfungs- und Fachwissenebenen", "sourceParagraph": 1818, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "offenlegen, um sie zu erreichen.", "sourceParagraph": 1819, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede vorab festgelegte obligatorische Wiederherstellungsschwelle, die nicht erreicht wird, MUSS eine", "sourceParagraph": 1821, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gesiegelte Validierungs-Pass-Entscheidung blockieren.", "sourceParagraph": 1822, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kandidaten-Schwellenwerte DÜRFEN nach Beobachtung der Ergebnisse nicht gesenkt, gerundet, neu interpretiert oder", "sourceParagraph": 1824, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entfernt werden, nur um die Methode bestehen zu lassen.", "sourceParagraph": 1825, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Zuordnungen von Zitaten und Materialauslassungs-Wiederherstellungen MÜSSEN als", "sourceParagraph": 1827, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "separate obligatorische Methodenfähigkeiten behandelt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 1828, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Methodenversagen MUSS eine versionierte Methodenfeststellung, eine identifizierte", "sourceParagraph": 1830, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ursache, einen Verantwortlichen für die Behebung und eine Anforderung zur Validierung an einem", "sourceParagraph": 1831, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unberührten Rückhaltebereich erzeugen.", "sourceParagraph": 1832, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Erfolg der Regression bei zuvor gescheiterten Fällen DARF NICHT unberührte", "sourceParagraph": 1834, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Holdout-Validierung ersetzen.", "sourceParagraph": 1835, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Demonstration, die obligatorische Schwellenwerte nicht besteht, MUSS sowohl ihre", "sourceParagraph": 1837, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "erfolgreichen als auch ihre erfolglosen Ergebnisse veröffentlichen.", "sourceParagraph": 1838, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kein öffentliches NOMOS-Konformitätszeichen, NOMOS 950+-Erklärung oder reale Entitäts", "sourceParagraph": 1840, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ranking darf ausschließlich auf einer Buchdemonstration, einem synthetischen Wiederherstellungsszenario", "sourceParagraph": 1841, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "oder einem nicht unabhängigen Benchmark basieren.", "sourceParagraph": 1842, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jeder Demonstrationslauf, realer Benchmark-Status, Wiederherstellungsergebnis, Methodenergebnis,", "sourceParagraph": 1844, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Schwellenwertentscheidung, Abhilfe und Freigabeentscheidung MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 1845, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "versioniert und einem verantwortlichen Menschen oder einer Organisation zuordenbar.", "sourceParagraph": 1846, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 1847, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH18-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine im Buch dargestellte synthetische Demonstration kann nicht als tatsächlich durchgeführter und unabhängig überprüfter Benchmark präsentiert werden. Solange ein reales Korpus, Software, Generator-Wahrheit, Schiedsverfahren, Bewertung und unabhängige Reproduktion nicht tatsächlich implementiert sind, sollte der Benchmark-Status BQ-0 bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 1848, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 19, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH19", "title": "Konformitätszeichen, öffentliches Register und unabhängige Governance", "subtitle": "Wie aus einem Zeichen ein Beleg wird", "sourceIds": [ "K15", "K16", "K17" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH19-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "A NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and Public Registry Record MUST remain distinct artefacts. No NOMOS mark may be valid solely because an audit was performed or a numerical score was produced. Every valid mark MUST be linked to an active canonical public registry record defining: - the audited entity, - authorised domains, - AI products, - population frame, - panel states, - prompt families, - languages, - countries, - measurement waves, - Truth Pack version, - score-method version, - conformity status, - validity period, - incidents, - surveillance, - audit organisation, - decision body, - conflicts, - appeals, - and integrity records. A static image, screenshot, self-authored structured-data assertion, or dead registry link MUST NOT establish current conformity. A NOMOS mark MUST NOT be represented as: - a guarantee of AI trust or recommendation, - proof of global leadership, - government or university accreditation, - a professional license, - universal all-language coverage, - or a guarantee of customer outcomes. Conformity scope MUST NOT be transferred across entities, domains, products, subsidiaries, franchises, countries, languages, AI products, panel states, prompt families, or validity periods without a new decision. A confirmed Critical incident MUST create a scope-appropriate Critical Hold or stronger status until the incident is resolved. A high score MUST NOT override this gate. Audit, consulting, conformity decision, registry operation, mark licensing, and appeals functions MUST be separated or their combined roles and compensating controls MUST be publicly disclosed. An audit team MUST NOT act as the sole final conformity decision body. The founder, NobleJackal, any auditor, AI provider, sponsor, or audited entity MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standard changes, conformity decisions, appeals, or public-registry history. NOMOS by NobleJackal MAY serve as the founding canonical publication and technical secretariat, but a public independent conformity system MUST progress toward multi-stakeholder decision, appeal, and public-interest governance. An AI system MAY assist with drafting, analysis, extraction, scoring, monitoring, and consistency review, but MUST NOT serve as the sole legal or accountable signatory of a conformity decision. Only canonical NOMOS publications and decisions carrying a version, publication date, accountable human approval, and integrity record may be represented as official NOMOS statements. Other outputs MUST remain non-official simulations. Conformity fees, auditor compensation, reviewer compensation, and mark licensing MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score or receiving a mark. Expired, suspended, withdrawn, revoked, appealed, remediated, and historical records MUST remain visible in the versioned public registry, subject only to proportionate privacy and legal restrictions. No public NOMOS conformity mark or NOMOS 950+ designation may be issued while the benchmark, governance, audit authorisation, independent decision, appeals, and registry prerequisites required by the declared standard version remain unmet. Every standard change, audit, decision, mark, surveillance event, complaint, appeal, suspension, withdrawal, revocation, registry revision, and governance decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "NOMOS Standardı, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark ve Public Registry Record ayrı nesneler olarak korunmalıdır. Yalnız denetim yapılmış veya sayısal puan üretilmiş olması geçerli işaret oluşturamaz. Geçerli her işaret, kapsamı, validity’yi, incident’ları, audit kuruluşunu, karar organını, çıkar çatışmalarını, itirazları ve bütünlük kayıtlarını taşıyan aktif kanonik kamu siciline bağlanmalıdır.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH19-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "17. MACHINE-READABLE SIGN", "sourceParagraph": 630 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The machine-readable record of the sign:", "sourceParagraph": 631 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "registry ID", "sourceParagraph": 632 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "status", "sourceParagraph": 633 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "scope", "sourceParagraph": 634 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "validFrom", "sourceParagraph": 635 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "validUntil", "sourceParagraph": 636 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entity", "sourceParagraph": 637 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "canonical domains", "sourceParagraph": 638 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "score method", "sourceParagraph": 639 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "audit report hash", "sourceParagraph": 640 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conformity decision hash", "sourceParagraph": 641 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "current incident status", "sourceParagraph": 642 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "signature", "sourceParagraph": 643 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "must be carried.", "sourceParagraph": 644 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A website alone:", "sourceParagraph": 645 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 646 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosCertified\": true", "sourceParagraph": 647 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 648 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "cannot establish a conformity claim merely by writing.", "sourceParagraph": 649 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Record:", "sourceParagraph": 650 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "to the open schema,", "sourceParagraph": 651 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registry signature’a,", "sourceParagraph": 652 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "must be connected to the active registry", "sourceParagraph": 653 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 654 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE PUBLIC REGISTRY", "sourceParagraph": 2332 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETIC SCHEMA EXAMPLE", "sourceParagraph": 2333 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2334 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2335 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2336 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"L01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2337 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"L02\"", "sourceParagraph": 2338 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2339 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2340 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2341 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2342 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2343 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C004\",", "sourceParagraph": 2344 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C005\"", "sourceParagraph": 2345 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2346 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2347 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2348 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2349 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W3\"", "sourceParagraph": 2350 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2351 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"1.2.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2352 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2353 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2354 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"results\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2355 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", "sourceParagraph": 2356 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", "sourceParagraph": 2357 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedCriticalEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2358 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedMajorEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2359 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2360 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2361 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosComposite\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 2362 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2363 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lower\": 955,", "sourceParagraph": 2364 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"upper\": 967", "sourceParagraph": 2365 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2366 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.0034", "sourceParagraph": 2367 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2368 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"quality\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2369 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2370 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2371 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2372 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2373 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2374 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scorePublicationQuality\": \"NSQ-4\"", "sourceParagraph": 2375 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2376 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"incidents\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2377 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openCritical\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2378 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openMajor\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2379 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidentIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2380 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGCI-SYNTH-2027-004\"", "sourceParagraph": 2381 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2382 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentStatusNote\": \"Historical incident remediated; record preserved.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2383 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2384 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"audit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2385 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditOrganizationId\": \"NGAO-SYNTH-003\",", "sourceParagraph": 2386 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditReportHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-AUDIT-REPORT-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2387 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consultingRelationshipDisclosed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2388 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conflictClassification\": \"COI-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2389 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enhancedIndependentReview\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2390 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2391 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2392 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionPanelId\": \"NGDP-SYNTH-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2393 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentFromAuditTeam\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2394 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DECISION-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2395 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dissentRecorded\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2396 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2397 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"surveillance\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2398 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lastReview\": \"2028-03-31\",", "sourceParagraph": 2399 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nextReview\": \"2028-06-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2400 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eventTriggeredReviewOpen\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2401 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2402 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appeals\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2403 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openAppealCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2404 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicComplaintChannel\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2405 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2406 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"mark\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2407 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"markAssetId\": \"NGMARK-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2408 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryLinkRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2409 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"machineReadableTokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2410 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentUseAuthorized\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2411 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2412 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2413 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recordHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-RECORD-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2414 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registrySignature\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-SIGNATURE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2415 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2416 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2417 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2418 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2419 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE GOVERNANCE RECORD", "sourceParagraph": 2421 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2422 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2423 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2424 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2425 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceRecordId\": \"NGGOV-FOUNDING-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2426 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2427 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2428 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"FOUNDING_DRAFT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2429 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityAuthority\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2430 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingAttribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2431 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2432 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2433 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\"", "sourceParagraph": 2434 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2435 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentLimitations\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2436 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REAL_BENCHMARK_NOT_EXECUTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2437 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_REPRODUCTION_NOT_COMPLETED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2438 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_DECISION_PANEL_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2439 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"APPEALS_CHAMBER_NOT_ESTABLISHED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2440 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"AUDITOR_AUTHORIZATION_SYSTEM_NOT_ESTABLISHED\"", "sourceParagraph": 2441 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2442 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedCurrentClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2443 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_CERTIFIED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2444 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_FULL_CONFORMITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2445 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_950_PLUS_VERIFIED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2446 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"INDEPENDENT_GLOBAL_STANDARD_AUTHORITY\"", "sourceParagraph": 2447 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2448 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"permittedCurrentClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2449 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OPEN_STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2450 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FOUNDING_RESEARCH_PROTOCOL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2451 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PUBLIC_REVIEW_DRAFT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2452 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTHETIC_VALIDATION_DESIGN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2453 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2454 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"transitionRequirements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2455 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumBenchmarkQualityForPublicMark\": \"BQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumGovernanceForFullConformity\": \"GOV-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumGovernanceFor950Plus\": \"GOV-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2458 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentAppealsRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2459 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicRegistryRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2460 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2461 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2462 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2463 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2464 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2465 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanApprovalRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2466 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2467 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreSimulations\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2468 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2469 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2470 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentResponsibleHuman\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2471 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityDecisionAuthority\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2472 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicMarkIssueAuthority\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2473 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2474 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2475 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2476 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE SIGN TOKEN", "sourceParagraph": 2478 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2479 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2480 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2481 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityMarkToken\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2482 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2483 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2484 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecordId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2485 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorizedDomains\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2486 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"asteron.synthetic.example\"", "sourceParagraph": 2487 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2488 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"CS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2489 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"performanceDesignation\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2490 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2028-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2491 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validUntil\": \"2028-06-30\",", "sourceParagraph": 2492 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeDigest\": \"SYNTHETIC-SCOPE-DIGEST\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-DECISION-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2494 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryRecordHash\": \"SYNTHETIC-REGISTRY-RECORD-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2495 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"statusEndpoint\": \"https://registry.synthetic.example/NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2496 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"signature\": \"SYNTHETIC-OPEN-SIGNATURE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2497 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimsNotGranted\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2498 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ALL_AI_SYSTEMS_APPROVE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2499 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"AI_RECOMMENDATION_GUARANTEE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2500 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GLOBAL_ALL_LANGUAGE_COVERAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2501 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GOVERNMENT_ACCREDITATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2502 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CUSTOMER_OUTCOME_GUARANTEE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2503 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2504 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2505 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2506 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "These records:", "sourceParagraph": 2507 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real conformity decision,", "sourceParagraph": 2508 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real brand,", "sourceParagraph": 2509 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real accreditation,", "sourceParagraph": 2510 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "real result of Asteron or another organisation", "sourceParagraph": 2511 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "a real company performance.", "sourceParagraph": 2512 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "It is the synthetic, machine-readable representation of the conformity registry.", "sourceParagraph": 2513 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE FOR MACHINE-READABLE SECTION 78", "sourceParagraph": 2515 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH19-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2516 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and", "sourceParagraph": 2518 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Public Registry Record MUST remain distinct artefacts.", "sourceParagraph": 2519 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No NOMOS mark may be valid solely because an audit was performed or a", "sourceParagraph": 2521 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "numerical score was produced.", "sourceParagraph": 2522 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every valid mark MUST be linked to an active canonical public registry", "sourceParagraph": 2524 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "record defining:", "sourceParagraph": 2525 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- the audited entity,", "sourceParagraph": 2527 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- authorised domains,", "sourceParagraph": 2528 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- AI products,", "sourceParagraph": 2529 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- population frame,", "sourceParagraph": 2530 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- panel states,", "sourceParagraph": 2531 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- prompt families,", "sourceParagraph": 2532 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- languages,", "sourceParagraph": 2533 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- countries,", "sourceParagraph": 2534 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- measurement waves,", "sourceParagraph": 2535 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Truth Pack version,", "sourceParagraph": 2536 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- score-method version,", "sourceParagraph": 2537 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- conformity status,", "sourceParagraph": 2538 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- validity period,", "sourceParagraph": 2539 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- incidents,", "sourceParagraph": 2540 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- surveillance,", "sourceParagraph": 2541 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- audit organisation,", "sourceParagraph": 2542 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- decision body,", "sourceParagraph": 2543 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- conflicts,", "sourceParagraph": 2544 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- appeals,", "sourceParagraph": 2545 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- and integrity records.", "sourceParagraph": 2546 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A static image, screenshot, self-authored structured-data assertion, or", "sourceParagraph": 2548 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dead registry link MUST NOT establish current conformity.", "sourceParagraph": 2549 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A NOMOS mark MUST NOT be represented as:", "sourceParagraph": 2551 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a guarantee of AI trust or recommendation,", "sourceParagraph": 2553 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- proof of global leadership,", "sourceParagraph": 2554 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- government or university accreditation,", "sourceParagraph": 2555 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- a professional license,", "sourceParagraph": 2556 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- universal all-language coverage,", "sourceParagraph": 2557 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- or a guarantee of customer outcomes.", "sourceParagraph": 2558 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Conformity scope MUST NOT be transferred across entities, domains,", "sourceParagraph": 2560 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "products, subsidiaries, franchises, countries, languages, AI products,", "sourceParagraph": 2561 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "panel states, prompt families, or validity periods without a new decision.", "sourceParagraph": 2562 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "A confirmed Critical incident MUST create a scope-appropriate Critical", "sourceParagraph": 2564 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Hold or stronger status until the incident is resolved. A high score", "sourceParagraph": 2565 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT override this gate.", "sourceParagraph": 2566 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Audit, consulting, conformity decision, registry operation, mark", "sourceParagraph": 2568 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "licensing, and appeals functions MUST be separated or their combined", "sourceParagraph": 2569 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "roles and compensating controls MUST be publicly disclosed.", "sourceParagraph": 2570 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An audit team MUST NOT act as the sole final conformity decision body.", "sourceParagraph": 2572 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The founder, NobleJackal, any auditor, AI provider, sponsor, or audited", "sourceParagraph": 2574 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entity MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standard changes,", "sourceParagraph": 2575 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "conformity decisions, appeals, or public-registry history.", "sourceParagraph": 2576 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS by NobleJackal MAY serve as the founding canonical publication and", "sourceParagraph": 2578 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "technical secretariat, but a public independent conformity system MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2579 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "progress toward multi-stakeholder decision, appeal, and public-interest", "sourceParagraph": 2580 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "governance.", "sourceParagraph": 2581 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "An AI system MAY assist with drafting, analysis, extraction, scoring,", "sourceParagraph": 2583 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0261", "type": "paragraph", "text": "monitoring, and consistency review, but MUST NOT serve as the sole legal", "sourceParagraph": 2584 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0262", "type": "paragraph", "text": "or accountable signatory of a conformity decision.", "sourceParagraph": 2585 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0263", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Only canonical NOMOS publications and decisions carrying a version,", "sourceParagraph": 2587 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0264", "type": "paragraph", "text": "publication date, accountable human approval, and integrity record may be", "sourceParagraph": 2588 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0265", "type": "paragraph", "text": "represented as official NOMOS statements. Other outputs MUST remain", "sourceParagraph": 2589 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0266", "type": "paragraph", "text": "non-official simulations.", "sourceParagraph": 2590 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0267", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Conformity fees, auditor compensation, reviewer compensation, and mark", "sourceParagraph": 2592 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0268", "type": "paragraph", "text": "licensing MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score or receiving a", "sourceParagraph": 2593 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0269", "type": "paragraph", "text": "mark.", "sourceParagraph": 2594 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0270", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Expired, suspended, withdrawn, revoked, appealed, remediated, and", "sourceParagraph": 2596 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0271", "type": "paragraph", "text": "historical records MUST remain visible in the versioned public registry,", "sourceParagraph": 2597 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0272", "type": "paragraph", "text": "subject only to proportionate privacy and legal restrictions.", "sourceParagraph": 2598 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0273", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No public NOMOS conformity mark or NOMOS 950+ designation may be issued", "sourceParagraph": 2600 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0274", "type": "paragraph", "text": "while the benchmark, governance, audit authorisation, independent", "sourceParagraph": 2601 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0275", "type": "paragraph", "text": "decision, appeals, and registry prerequisites required by the declared", "sourceParagraph": 2602 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0276", "type": "paragraph", "text": "standard version remain unmet.", "sourceParagraph": 2603 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0277", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every standard change, audit, decision, mark, surveillance event,", "sourceParagraph": 2605 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0278", "type": "paragraph", "text": "complaint, appeal, suspension, withdrawal, revocation, registry revision,", "sourceParagraph": 2606 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0279", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and governance decision MUST be versioned and attributable to an", "sourceParagraph": 2607 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0280", "type": "paragraph", "text": "accountable human or organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2608 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0281", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2609 }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0282", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The NOMOS Standard, Audit Report, Conformity Decision, Conformity Mark, and Public Registry Record must be maintained as separate entities. Simply having an audit conducted or a numerical score generated does not constitute a valid mark. Every valid mark must be linked to the active canonical public registry that carries its scope, validity, incidents, audit organisation, decision-making body, conflicts of interest, objections, and integrity records.", "sourceParagraph": 2610 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "Ein NOMOS-Standard, Prüfbericht, Konformitätsentscheidung, Konformitätszeichen und öffentlicher Registereintrag MÜSSEN als unterschiedliche Artefakte bestehen bleiben. Kein NOMOS-Zeichen darf allein deshalb gültig sein, weil eine Prüfung durchgeführt oder eine numerische Bewertung erstellt wurde. Jedes gültige Zeichen MUSS mit einem aktiven kanonischen öffentlichen Registereintrag verknüpft sein, der Folgendes definiert: - die geprüfte Einrichtung, - autorisierte Domains, - KI-Produkte, - Population, - Panelzustände, - Prompt-Familien, - Sprachen, - Länder, - Messwellen, - Version des Truth Packs, - Version der Bewertungsmethode, - Konformitätsstatus, - Gültigkeitszeitraum, - Vorfälle, - Überwachung, - Prüforganisation, - Entscheidungsgremium, - Konflikte, - Einsprüche, - und Integritätsaufzeichnungen. Ein statisches Bild, Screenshot, selbst erstellte strukturierte Datenbehauptung oder toter Registrierungslink DARF keine aktuelle Konformität begründen. Ein NOMOS-Zeichen DARF NICHT repräsentiert werden als: - eine Garantie für KI-Vertrauen oder Empfehlung, - ein Beweis für weltweite Führungsrolle, - staatliche oder universitär anerkannte Akkreditierung, - eine Berufslizenz, - universelle Abdeckung aller Sprachen, - oder eine Garantie für Kundenergebnisse. Der Konformitätsumfang DARF NICHT über Einheiten, Domänen, Produkte, Tochtergesellschaften, Franchises, Länder, Sprachen, KI-Produkte, Panel-Staaten, Prompt-Familien oder Gültigkeitszeiträume hinweg ohne eine neue Entscheidung übertragen werden. Ein bestätigter kritischer Vorfall MUSS einen dem Umfang entsprechenden Kritische Sperre-Status oder einen stärkeren Status erzeugen, bis der Vorfall behoben ist. Eine hohe Punktzahl DARF dieses Tor NICHT überschreiben. Prüfungs-, Beratungs-, Konformitätsentscheidungs-, Registrierungsbetriebs-, Markenlizenzierungs- und Berufungsfunktionen MÜSSEN getrennt sein oder ihre kombinierten Rollen und kompensierenden Kontrollen MÜSSEN öffentlich offengelegt werden. Ein Prüfungsteam DARF NICHT als einziges endgültiges Konformitätsentscheidungsorgan fungieren. Der Gründer, NobleJackal, jeder Prüfer, KI-Anbieter, Sponsor oder geprüfte Einheit DARF keine einseitige Kontrolle über Standardänderungen, Konformitätsentscheidungen, Berufungen oder die öffentliche Registrierungsführung besitzen. NOMOS von NobleJackal KANN als die begründende kanonische Veröffentlichung und technische Geschäftsstelle dienen, aber ein öffentliches unabhängiges Konformitätssystem MUSS auf eine Multi-Stakeholder-Entscheidung, Berufung und öffentliches Interesse Governance hinarbeiten. Ein KI-System KANN bei der Erstellung, Analyse, Extraktion, Bewertung, Überwachung und Konsistenzprüfung helfen, darf jedoch NICHT als alleiniger rechtlicher oder verantwortlicher Unterzeichner einer Konformitätsentscheidung dienen. Nur kanonische NOMOS-Veröffentlichungen und Entscheidungen, die eine Version, ein Veröffentlichungsdatum, eine verantwortliche menschliche Genehmigung und einen Integritätsnachweis tragen, dürfen als offizielle NOMOS-Erklärungen repräsentiert werden. Andere Ergebnisse MÜSSEN inoffizielle Simulationen bleiben. Konformitätsgebühren, Vergütung von Prüfern, Vergütung von Gutachtern und Kennzeichenlizenzierung DÜRFEN NICHT davon abhängen, dass ein gewünschtes Ergebnis erzielt oder ein Kennzeichen erhalten wird. Abgelaufene, ausgesetzte, zurückgezogene, widerrufene, angefochtene, korrigierte und historische Datensätze MÜSSEN in dem versionierten öffentlichen Register sichtbar bleiben, vorbehaltlich nur angemessener Datenschutz- und gesetzlicher Beschränkungen. Kein öffentliches NOMOS-Konformitätszeichen oder NOMOS 950+-Bezeichnung darf ausgegeben werden, solange die Benchmark-, Governance-, Prüfungsautorisierungs-, unabhängigen Entscheidungs-, Berufungs- und Registervoraussetzungen, die von der angegebenen Standardversion verlangt werden, nicht erfüllt sind. Jede Standardänderung, Prüfung, Entscheidung, Kennzeichnung, Überwachungsmaßnahme, Beschwerde, Berufung, Aussetzung, Rücknahme, Widerruf, Registeränderung und Governance-Entscheidung MUSS versioniert sein und auf eine verantwortliche Person oder Organisation zurückgeführt werden KÖNNEN.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH19-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "17. MASCHINENLESBARES ZEICHEN", "sourceParagraph": 630, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der maschinenlesbare Datensatz des Zeichens:", "sourceParagraph": 631, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registrierungs-ID", "sourceParagraph": 632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Status", "sourceParagraph": 633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Umfang", "sourceParagraph": 634, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "validFrom", "sourceParagraph": 635, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "validUntil", "sourceParagraph": 636, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einheit", "sourceParagraph": 637, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kanonische Domains", "sourceParagraph": 638, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Bewertungsmethode", "sourceParagraph": 639, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Auditbericht-Hash", "sourceParagraph": 640, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Konformitätsentscheidungs-Hash", "sourceParagraph": 641, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "aktueller Vorfallstatus", "sourceParagraph": 642, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Unterschrift", "sourceParagraph": 643, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "muss durchgeführt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 644, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eine Website allein:", "sourceParagraph": 645, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 646, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosCertified\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 647, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 648, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kann keinen Konformitätsanspruch nur durch Schreiben begründen.", "sourceParagraph": 649, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Aufzeichnung:", "sourceParagraph": 650, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "zum offenen Schema,", "sourceParagraph": 651, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registry-Unterschrift’a,", "sourceParagraph": 652, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "muss mit dem aktiven Registry verbunden sein", "sourceParagraph": 653, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "", "sourceParagraph": 654, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MASCHINENLESBARES ÖFFENTLICHES REGISTER", "sourceParagraph": 2332, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "SYNTHETISCHES SCHEMA-BEISPIEL", "sourceParagraph": 2333, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2334, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2335, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"languages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2336, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"L01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2337, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"L02\"", "sourceParagraph": 2338, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2339, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"countries\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2340, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C0 01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2341, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C0 02\",", "sourceParagraph": 2342, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C0 03\",", "sourceParagraph": 2343, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C0 04\",", "sourceParagraph": 2344, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"C0 05\"", "sourceParagraph": 2345, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2346, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"waveIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2347, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W1\",", "sourceParagraph": 2348, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2349, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"W3\"", "sourceParagraph": 2350, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2351, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackVersion\": \"1.2.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2352, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scoreMethodVersion\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2353, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2354, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ergebnisse\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2355, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"strictPassEquivalent\": 958,", "sourceParagraph": 2356, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"acceptablePassEquivalent\": 988,", "sourceParagraph": 2357, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedCriticalEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2358, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"confirmedMajorEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2359, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"unresolvedEquivalent\": 5,", "sourceParagraph": 2360, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"notRatableEquivalent\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2361, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosComposite\": 961,", "sourceParagraph": 2362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"samplingInterval\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"untere\": 955,", "sourceParagraph": 2364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"obere\": 967", "sourceParagraph": 2365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalRateUpperBound\": 0.003 4", "sourceParagraph": 2367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Qualität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2370, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"captureLevel\": \"NCL-4\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"truthPackReadiness\": \"TPR-4\",\"}", "sourceParagraph": 2373, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"adjudicationQuality\": \"AQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scorePublicationQuality\": \"NSQ-4\"", "sourceParagraph": 2375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Vorfälle\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2377, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openCritical\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openMajor\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalCriticalIncidentIds\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NGCI-SYNTH-2027-004\"", "sourceParagraph": 2381, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentStatusNote\": \"Historischer Vorfall behoben; Datensatz erhalten.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2384, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Audit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditOrganizationId\": \"NGAO-SYNTH-003\",\"", "sourceParagraph": 2386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"auditReportHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-PRÜFBERICHT-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consultingRelationshipDisclosed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2388, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conflictClassification\": \"COI-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"enhancedIndependentReview\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2391, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityDecision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2392, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionPanelId\": \"NGDP-SYNTH-002\",", "sourceParagraph": 2393, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentFromAuditTeam\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2394, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-ENTSCHEIDUNGS-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2395, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"dissentRecorded\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2396, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2397, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Überwachung\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2398, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lastReview\": \"2028-03-31\",", "sourceParagraph": 2399, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nextReview\": \"2028-06-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2400, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"eventTriggeredReviewOpen\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2401, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2402, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Berufungen\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2403, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openAppealCount\": 0,", "sourceParagraph": 2404, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicComplaintChannel\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2405, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2406, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Marke\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2407, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"markAssetId\": \"NGMARK-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2408, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryLinkRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2409, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"machineReadableTokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2410, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentUseAuthorized\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2411, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2412, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2413, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"recordHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-REGISTRIERUNGSEINTRAG-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2414, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registrySignature\": \"SYNTHETISCHE-REGISTRIERUNGS-SIGNATUR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2415, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"previousVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2416, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2417, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2418, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2419, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MASCHINENLESBARER VERWALTUNGS-EINTRAG", "sourceParagraph": 2421, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2422, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2423, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2424, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceRecord\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2425, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceRecordId\": \"NGGOV-GRÜNDUNG-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2426, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2427, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2428, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Status\": \"GRÜNDUNGSENTWURF\",", "sourceParagraph": 2429, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityAuthority\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2430, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingAttribution\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2431, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2432, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2433, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS durch NobleJackal\"", "sourceParagraph": 2434, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2435, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentLimitations\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2436, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ECHTE_BENCHMARK_NICHT_DURCHGEFÜHRT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2437, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"UNABHÄNGIGE_REPRODUKTION_NICHT_ABGESCHLOSSEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2438, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"UNABHÄNGIGES_ENTSCHEIDUNGSPANEEL_NICHT_EINGERICHTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2439, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BERUFUNGSKAMMER_NICHT_EINGERICHTET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2440, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PRÜFER_AUTORISIERUNGSSYSTEM_NICHT_EINGERICHTET\"", "sourceParagraph": 2441, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2442, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prohibitedCurrentClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2443, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_ZERTIFIZIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2444, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_VOLLSTÄNDIGE_KONFORMITÄT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2445, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NOMOS_950_PLUS_VERIFIZIERT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2446, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"UNABHÄNGIGE_GLOBALE_STANDARDBEHÖRDE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2447, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2448, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"permittedCurrentClaims\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2449, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OFFENER_STANDARD_KANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2450, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GRÜNDUNGS_FORSCHUNGSPROTOKOLL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2451, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENTWURF_ZUR_ÖFFENTLICHEN_PRÜFUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2452, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTHETISCHES_VALIDIERUNGSDESIGN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2453, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2454, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"transitionRequirements\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2455, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumBenchmarkQualityForPublicMark\": \"BQ-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumGovernanceForFullConformity\": \"GOV-3\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"minimumGovernanceFor950Plus\": \"GOV-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2458, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentAppealsRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2459, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicRegistryRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2460, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2465, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanApprovalRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreSimulations\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2469, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentResponsibleHuman\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityDecisionAuthority\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicMarkIssueAuthority\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2474, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MASCHINENLESBARES_SIGNATURTOKEN", "sourceParagraph": 2478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityMarkToken\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tokenId\": \"NGTOKEN-SYNTH-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2483, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryId\": \"NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2484, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"entityRecordId\": \"NGE-SYNTH-ASTERON-HOLDINGS-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2485, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"authorizedDomains\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2486, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"asteron.synthetisch.beispiel\"", "sourceParagraph": 2487, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2488, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"CS-4\",", "sourceParagraph": 2489, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"performanceDesignation\": \"NOMOS_950_PLUS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2490, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validFrom\": \"2028-01-01\",", "sourceParagraph": 2491, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validUntil\": \"2028-06-30\",", "sourceParagraph": 2492, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"scopeDigest\": \"SYNTHETISCHER_BEREICH_DIGEST\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decisionHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-ENTSCHEIDUNGS-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2494, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"registryRecordHash\": \"SYNTHETISCHER-REGISTRIERUNGSEINTRAG-HASH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2495, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"statusEndpoint\": \"https://registry.synthetic.example/NGR-SYNTH-2028-00184\",", "sourceParagraph": 2496, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"signatur\": \"SYNTHETISCHE_OFFENE_SIGNATUR\",\"", "sourceParagraph": 2497, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"claimsNotGranted\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2498, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ALLE_KI_SYSTEME_GENEHMIGEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2499, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"KI_EMPFEHLUNG_GARANTIE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2500, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"WELTWEITE_UMFASSUNG_ALLER_SPRACHEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2501, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REGIERUNGSANERKENNUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2502, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"KUNDENERGEBNIS_GARANTIE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2503, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "]", "sourceParagraph": 2504, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2505, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2506, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Diese Aufzeichnungen:", "sourceParagraph": 2507, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echte Konformitätsentscheidung,", "sourceParagraph": 2508, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echte Marke,", "sourceParagraph": 2509, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echte Akkreditierung,", "sourceParagraph": 2510, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "echtes Ergebnis von Asteron oder einer anderen Organisation", "sourceParagraph": 2511, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "eine echte Unternehmensleistung.", "sourceParagraph": 2512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es ist die synthetische, maschinenlesbare Repräsentation des Konformitätsregisters.", "sourceParagraph": 2513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL FÜR DEN MASCHINENLESBAREN ABSCHNITT 78", "sourceParagraph": 2515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH19-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein NOMOS Standard, Prüfbericht, Konformitätsentscheidung, Konformitätszeichen und", "sourceParagraph": 2518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Öffentlicher Registrierungsdatensatz MÜSSEN als unterschiedliche Artefakte bestehen bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Keine NOMOS-Markierung darf ausschließlich deshalb gültig sein, weil ein Audit durchgeführt wurde oder eine", "sourceParagraph": 2521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "numerische Punktzahl erstellt wurde.", "sourceParagraph": 2522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede gültige Markierung MUSS mit einem aktiven kanonischen öffentlichen Register", "sourceParagraph": 2524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Eintrag verknüpft sein, der definiert:", "sourceParagraph": 2525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- die geprüfte Einheit,", "sourceParagraph": 2527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- autorisierte Domains,", "sourceParagraph": 2528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- KI-Produkte,", "sourceParagraph": 2529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Population-Rahmen,", "sourceParagraph": 2530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Panel-Zustände,", "sourceParagraph": 2531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prompt-Familien,", "sourceParagraph": 2532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Sprachen,", "sourceParagraph": 2533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Länder,", "sourceParagraph": 2534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Messwellen,", "sourceParagraph": 2535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Version des Truth Packs,", "sourceParagraph": 2536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Version der Bewertungsmethode,", "sourceParagraph": 2537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konformitätsstatus,", "sourceParagraph": 2538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Gültigkeitsdauer,", "sourceParagraph": 2539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Vorfälle,", "sourceParagraph": 2540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Überwachung,", "sourceParagraph": 2541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Prüfungsorganisation,", "sourceParagraph": 2542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Entscheidungsgremium,", "sourceParagraph": 2543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Konflikte,", "sourceParagraph": 2544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Berufungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- und Integritätsaufzeichnungen.", "sourceParagraph": 2546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein statisches Bild, Screenshot, selbst erstellte strukturierte Datenbehauptung oder", "sourceParagraph": 2548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ein toter Registerlink DARF keine aktuelle Konformität belegen.", "sourceParagraph": 2549, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein NOMOS-Zeichen DARF NICHT repräsentiert werden als:", "sourceParagraph": 2551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- eine Garantie für KI-Vertrauen oder Empfehlung,", "sourceParagraph": 2553, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- Nachweis globaler Führungsposition,", "sourceParagraph": 2554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- staatliche oder universitäre Akkreditierung,", "sourceParagraph": 2555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- eine professionelle Lizenz,", "sourceParagraph": 2556, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- universelle Abdeckung aller Sprachen,", "sourceParagraph": 2557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "- oder eine Garantie für Kundenergebnisse.", "sourceParagraph": 2558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Geltungsbereich der Konformität DARF NICHT auf andere Einheiten, Domänen,", "sourceParagraph": 2560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Produkte, Tochtergesellschaften, Franchises, Länder, Sprachen, KI-Produkte,", "sourceParagraph": 2561, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Panel-Staaten, Aufforderungsfamilien oder Gültigkeitszeiträume übertragen werden, ohne eine neue Entscheidung.", "sourceParagraph": 2562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein bestätigter Kritischer Vorfall MUSS einen dem Geltungsbereich entsprechenden Kritischen", "sourceParagraph": 2564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Halt oder einen stärkeren Status schaffen, bis der Vorfall gelöst ist. Eine hohe Punktzahl", "sourceParagraph": 2565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DARF dieses Tor nicht übersteuern.", "sourceParagraph": 2566, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Audit, Beratung, Konformitätsentscheidung, Registerbetrieb, Marke", "sourceParagraph": 2568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Lizenzierungs- und Berufungsfunktionen MÜSSEN getrennt sein oder ihre kombinierten", "sourceParagraph": 2569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Rollen und ausgleichenden Kontrollen MÜSSEN öffentlich offengelegt werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2570, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein Prüfungsteam DARF NICHT als alleiniges endgültiges Konformitätsentscheidungs-Gremium fungieren.", "sourceParagraph": 2572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Gründer, NobleJackal, jeder Prüfer, KI-Anbieter, Sponsor oder geprüfte", "sourceParagraph": 2574, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Einrichtung DARF NICHT die einseitige Kontrolle über Standardänderungen,", "sourceParagraph": 2575, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Konformitätsentscheidungen, Berufungen oder die öffentliche Registerhistorie besitzen.", "sourceParagraph": 2576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS durch NobleJackal DÜRFTE als die begründende kanonische Veröffentlichung und", "sourceParagraph": 2578, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "technisches Sekretariat dienen, aber ein öffentliches unabhängiges Konformitätssystem MUSS", "sourceParagraph": 2579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Fortschritte hin zu multi-stakeholder Entscheidungen, Berufungen und Gemeinwohl", "sourceParagraph": 2580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Governance.", "sourceParagraph": 2581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Ein KI-System KANN bei der Erstellung, Analyse, Extraktion, Bewertung,", "sourceParagraph": 2583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0261", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Überwachung und Konsistenzprüfung unterstützen, DARF aber nicht als alleinige rechtliche", "sourceParagraph": 2584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0262", "type": "paragraph", "text": "oder verantwortliche unterzeichnende Instanz einer Konformitätsentscheidung dienen.", "sourceParagraph": 2585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0263", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nur kanonische NOMOS-Veröffentlichungen und -Entscheidungen, die eine Version,", "sourceParagraph": 2587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0264", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Veröffentlichungsdatum, verantwortliche menschliche Genehmigung und Integritätsaufzeichnung tragen, können", "sourceParagraph": 2588, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0265", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als offizielle NOMOS-Aussagen repräsentiert werden. Andere Ergebnisse MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0266", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nicht-offizielle Simulationen bleiben.", "sourceParagraph": 2590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0267", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Konformitätsgebühren, Vergütung des Prüfers, Vergütung des Gutachters und Kennzeichnung", "sourceParagraph": 2592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0268", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MÜSSEN NICHT davon abhängen, eine gewünschte Punktzahl zu erreichen oder eine", "sourceParagraph": 2593, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0269", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Note zu erhalten.", "sourceParagraph": 2594, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0270", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abgelaufene, ausgesetzte, zurückgezogene, widerrufene, angefochtene, behobene und", "sourceParagraph": 2596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0271", "type": "paragraph", "text": "historische Aufzeichnungen MÜSSEN im versionierten öffentlichen Register sichtbar bleiben,", "sourceParagraph": 2597, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0272", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nur unter Wahrung verhältnismäßiger Datenschutz- und gesetzlicher Einschränkungen.", "sourceParagraph": 2598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0273", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Es darf kein öffentliches NOMOS Konformitätszeichen oder NOMOS 950+ Zeichen", "sourceParagraph": 2600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0274", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ausgegeben werden,\n\nwährend die vom erklärten Benchmark, der Governance, der Prüfungsgenehmigung, der unabhängigen", "sourceParagraph": 2601, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0275", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Entscheidung, den Berufungen und den Registrierungsanforderungen erforderlichen Voraussetzungen nicht erfüllt sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2602, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0276", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Standardversion bleibt unerfüllt.", "sourceParagraph": 2603, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0277", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Standardänderung, Prüfung, Entscheidung, Kennzeichnung, Überwachungsveranstaltung,", "sourceParagraph": 2605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0278", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Beschwerde, Berufung, Aussetzung, Rücknahme, Widerruf, Registerrevision,", "sourceParagraph": 2606, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0279", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und Governance-Entscheidung MUSS versioniert und einer", "sourceParagraph": 2607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0280", "type": "paragraph", "text": "verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0281", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2609, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH19-MB0282", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Das NOMOS Standard-, Prüfungsbericht-, Konformitätsentscheidungs-, Konformitätskennzeichen- und öffentliche Registereintrag muss als separate Entität geführt werden. Es reicht nicht aus, nur eine Prüfung durchzuführen oder eine numerische Bewertung zu erstellen, um ein gültiges Kennzeichen zu haben. Jedes gültige Kennzeichen muss mit dem aktiven kanonischen öffentlichen Register verknüpft sein, das seinen Umfang, Gültigkeit, Vorfälle, Prüfungsorganisation, Entscheidungsgremium, Interessenkonflikte, Einwände und Integritätsaufzeichnungen enthält.", "sourceParagraph": 2610, "language": "de-DE" } ] }, { "chapter": 20, "chapterId": "NOMOS-GEO-AUDIT-CH20", "title": "Offener Standard, Aufruf an Universitäten und öffentliche Übergabe von NOMOS", "subtitle": "Damit der Standard seinen Gründer überdauert", "sourceIds": [ "K18", "K19", "K23", "K24" ], "normativeRuleId": "NOMOS-AUDIT-CH20-R01", "normativeRuleEnglish": "NOMOS MUST be structured as an open, versioned, independently testable, public-interest standard candidate. Open publication alone MUST NOT establish open-standard status. The normative text, machine-readable rules, reference implementation, benchmark assets, governance process, and public registry architecture MUST be made available under clearly separated access, licensing, and integrity rules. Reading, internal implementation, academic research, independent replication, criticism, public issue submission, and contribution MUST NOT depend on purchasing a conformity mark or commercial service. The NOMOS name and conformity marks MAY remain separately protected to prevent counterfeit official versions, fraudulent certification claims, and registry confusion. Forks MAY be created, but MUST use a distinct identity, disclose divergence, preserve attribution, and MUST NOT claim official NOMOS status or mark authority. Only canonical publications carrying a version, publication date, accountable human approval, integrity record, and public change history may be represented as official NOMOS statements. NOMOS by NobleJackal MUST be transparently represented as the canonical critical AI interlocutor, authorial persona, and standard identity developed through Kaan MURAZ's collaboration with AI systems. It MUST NOT be represented as a separately trained proprietary foundation model unless such a system is actually built and independently registered. Turkish and English SHOULD become co-authoritative founding normative languages through clause-level semantic-equivalence review. Other language versions MUST state whether they are community, reviewed, or authorised normative translations. Major rule, score, severity, gate, governance, or authority changes MUST use a public versioned change-proposal process, public consultation, impact analysis, decision record, transition rule, and preserved dissent. Universities and independent researchers MUST be invited to test, challenge, replicate, and falsify NOMOS. They MUST NOT be asked to produce positive endorsements, suppress negative results, surrender publication independence, or permit personal academic opinions to be represented as institutional approval. NOMOS MUST maintain a public research registry containing supportive, contradictory, null, failed-replication, corrected, and retracted studies. Research, benchmark, audit, and governance funding MUST be disclosed and MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score, conformity result, or favourable publication. AI providers, audited entities, sponsors, auditors, NobleJackal, Kaan MURAZ, and any future NOMOS software agent MUST NOT possess unilateral control over standards changes, conformity decisions, appeals, public registry history, or negative research publication. Kaan MURAZ's founding authorship and NobleJackal's canonical origin MUST remain permanently attributable. Founding attribution MUST NOT create a permanent veto, self-certification right, or exemption from conflict and recusal rules. NOMOS standard 1.0 and NOMOS Conformity Program 1.0 MUST remain separate releases. Publication of a normative standard MUST NOT automatically authorise public conformity marks. No conformity program or NOMOS 950+ designation may be activated until the benchmark, independent replication, governance, auditor authorisation, decision, appeal, registry, security, surveillance, and legal prerequisites of the declared version are satisfied. Every translation, license, benchmark, study, change proposal, governance transition, succession event, release, and official statement MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or organisation.", "normativeRuleSourceTurkish": "NOMOS; metni, kuralları, referans uygulaması, benchmark’ı, yönetişimi ve sicil mimarisi bağımsız olarak incelenebilir ve yeniden üretilebilir açık bir kamu standardı adayı olarak yapılandırılmalıdır. Yalnız yayımlanmış olmak açık standart statüsü oluşturmaz.", "machineBlocksEnglish": [ { "blockId": "CH20-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "74. MACHINE-READABLE OPEN STANDARD MANIFEST", "sourceParagraph": 2355 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2356 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2357 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2358 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openStandardManifest\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2359 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestId\": \"NOMOS-OPEN-STANDARD-CANDIDATE-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2360 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"FOUNDING_OPEN_STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2361 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2362 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2363 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"originOrganization\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2364 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS by NobleJackal\"", "sourceParagraph": 2365 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2366 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2367 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsAuthorialPersona\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2368 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsNormativeStandardIdentity\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2369 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsIndependentFoundationModel\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2370 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"futureSoftwareAgentRequiresSeparateRegistry\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2371 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2372 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2373 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2374 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2375 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2376 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanApprovalRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2377 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2378 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreUnofficialSimulations\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2379 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2380 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentStatus\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2381 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"standardVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2382 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2383 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationQuality\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2384 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2385 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityProgramActive\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2386 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomos950PlusAuthorityActive\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2387 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2388 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2389 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicReadingRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2390 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"royaltyFreeImplementationRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2391 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicRuleSchemasRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2392 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReplicationAllowed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2393 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2394 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicChangeProposalsAllowed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2395 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealAndIssueChannelsRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2396 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalVersionAccessRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2397 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"forksAllowedUnderDistinctIdentity\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2398 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2399 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assets\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2400 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normativeText\": \"OPEN_DOCUMENTATION_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2401 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceCode\": \"OPEN_SOFTWARE_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2402 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticData\": \"OPEN_RESEARCH_LICENSE_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2403 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restrictedEvidence\": \"CONTROLLED_ACCESS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2404 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosNameAndMark\": \"SEPARATE_IDENTITY_PROTECTION\"", "sourceParagraph": 2405 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2406 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingLanguages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2407 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2408 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"en\"", "sourceParagraph": 2409 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2410 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionPath\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2411 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"current\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2412 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nextPublicReview\": \"0.95.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2413 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationCandidate\": \"0.99.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2414 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openNormativeRelease\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2415 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2416 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"releaseGatesForOnePointZero\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2417 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PUBLIC_CONSULTATION_COMPLETED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2418 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TURKISH_ENGLISH_NORMATIVE_EQUIVALENCE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2419 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REAL_SYNTHETIC_BENCHMARK_EXECUTED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2420 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MANDATORY_RECOVERY_THRESHOLDS_PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2421 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"UNTOUCHED_HOLDOUT_PASSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2422 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"AT_LEAST_ONE_INDEPENDENT_REPLICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2423 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MAJOR_METHOD_FINDINGS_CLOSED\",", "sourceParagraph": 2424 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OPEN_REFERENCE_IMPLEMENTATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2425 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GOVERNANCE_AT_LEAST_GOV_2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2426 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ARCHIVE_AND_SUCCESSION_PLAN\"", "sourceParagraph": 2427 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2428 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityProgramSeparate\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2429 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrity\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2430 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"TO_BE_GENERATED_AT_CANONICAL_PUBLICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2431 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanApproval\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2432 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ratificationStatus\": \"NOT_RATIFIED\"", "sourceParagraph": 2433 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2434 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2435 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2436 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MACHINE-READABLE UNIVERSITY CALL", "sourceParagraph": 2438 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2439 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2440 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2441 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"universityCall\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2442 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"callId\": \"NOMOS-UNIVERSITY-OPEN-CALL-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2443 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"DRAFT_FOR_PUBLICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2444 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"INDEPENDENT_REVIEW_REPLICATION_AND_FALSIFICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2445 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endorsementRequested\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2446 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"positiveResultRequired\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2447 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2448 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prePublicationVetoByNomos\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2449 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"institutionalLogoUseRequested\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2450 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researchTracks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2451 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SAMPLING_AND_SURVEY_METHODS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2452 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PROMPT_EQUIVALENCE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2453 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENTITY_RESOLUTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2454 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TRUTH_PACK_RELIABILITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2455 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CLAIM_ADJUDICATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CRITICAL_GATE_VALIDATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SCORE_VALIDITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2458 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LANGUAGE_AND_GEOGRAPHIC_FAIRNESS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2459 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"HUMAN_DECISION_IMPACT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2460 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GOVERNANCE_AND_AUDIT_CAPTURE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2461 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REGISTRY_SECURITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2462 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LONGITUDINAL_DRIFT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2463 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2464 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialsProvided\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2465 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"STANDARD_CANDIDATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2466 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NORMATIVE_RULE_INDEX\",", "sourceParagraph": 2467 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTHETIC_BENCHMARK_PACKAGE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2468 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SCORE_METHOD\",", "sourceParagraph": 2469 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"KNOWN_METHOD_FINDINGS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2470 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FAILED_THRESHOLD_RECORDS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2471 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REPLICATION_PROTOCOL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2472 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"DATA_ACCESS_POLICY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2473 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ETHICS_AND_PRIVACY_STATEMENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2474 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FUNDING_AND_CONFLICT_DISCLOSURE\"", "sourceParagraph": 2475 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2476 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researcherRights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2477 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentAnalysis\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2478 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublication\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2479 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodCriticism\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2480 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"forkProposal\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2481 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionForContribution\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2482 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2483 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researcherDuties\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2484 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conflictDisclosure\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2485 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacyProtection\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2486 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticLiveDistinction\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2487 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionCitation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2488 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidencePreservation\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2489 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2490 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialMessage\": \"Do not endorse NOMOS. Test it, challenge it, replicate it, and publish where it fails.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2491 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountability\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2492 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingHumanContact\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2494 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"institutionalEndorsementClaimAllowed\": false", "sourceParagraph": 2495 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2496 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2497 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2498 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MACHINE-READABLE CHANGE PROPOSAL", "sourceParagraph": 2500 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2501 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocol\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2502 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2503 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeProposal\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2504 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposalId\": \"NCP-0042\",", "sourceParagraph": 2505 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"title\": \"Material Boundary Omission Counterfactual Decision Test\",", "sourceParagraph": 2506 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposalVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2507 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"PUBLIC_COMMENT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2508 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeClass\": \"MAJOR\",", "sourceParagraph": 2509 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedRules\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2510 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH14-N35\",", "sourceParagraph": 2511 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH15-N33\",", "sourceParagraph": 2512 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH17-N40\",", "sourceParagraph": 2513 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH18-N26\"", "sourceParagraph": 2514 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2515 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"problemStatement\": \"The version 0.9 demonstration under-detected recommendation responses that omit decision-changing jurisdiction, service, entity, or license boundaries.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2516 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidence\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2517 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2518 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 2519 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 2520 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH18-OMISSION-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2521 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2522 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposedChange\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2523 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterfactualQuestion\": \"Would disclosure of the omitted boundary reasonably change the user's recommendation, transaction, or provider-selection decision?\",", "sourceParagraph": 2524 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredMatrix\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2525 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENTITY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SERVICE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2527 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"JURISDICTION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2528 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LICENSE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2529 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"USER_ELIGIBILITY\"", "sourceParagraph": 2530 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2531 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"separateBoundaryReviewerRequired\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2532 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2533 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"impactAnalysis\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2534 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalScoreImpact\": \"RECOMPUTATION_REQUIRED_FOR_ANALYTICAL_COMPARISON_ONLY\",", "sourceParagraph": 2535 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oldDecisionsAutomaticallyReplaced\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2536 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedFalsePositiveRisk\": \"MODERATE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2537 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedCriticalRecallImpact\": \"POSITIVE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2538 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessImpact\": \"REQUIRES_TESTING\"", "sourceParagraph": 2539 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2540 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consultation\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2541 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicCommentDays\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 2542 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"universityReviewRequested\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2543 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lowResourceLanguageReviewRequested\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2544 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commentsPublic\": true", "sourceParagraph": 2545 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2546 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2547 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"standardsCouncilVote\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2548 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2549 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2550 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2551 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2552 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MACHINE-READABLE RULE OF THE SECTION", "sourceParagraph": 2554 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "RULE ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH20-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2555 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS MUST be structured as an open, versioned, independently testable,", "sourceParagraph": 2557 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "public-interest standard candidate.", "sourceParagraph": 2558 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Open publication alone MUST NOT establish open-standard status.", "sourceParagraph": 2560 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The normative text, machine-readable rules, reference implementation,", "sourceParagraph": 2562 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "benchmark assets, governance process, and public registry architecture", "sourceParagraph": 2563 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST be made available under clearly separated access, licensing, and", "sourceParagraph": 2564 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "integrity rules.", "sourceParagraph": 2565 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Reading, internal implementation, academic research, independent", "sourceParagraph": 2567 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "replication, criticism, public issue submission, and contribution MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2568 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOT depend on purchasing a conformity mark or commercial service.", "sourceParagraph": 2569 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "The NOMOS name and conformity marks MAY remain separately protected to", "sourceParagraph": 2571 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "prevent counterfeit official versions, fraudulent certification claims,", "sourceParagraph": 2572 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "and registry confusion.", "sourceParagraph": 2573 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Forks MAY be created, but MUST use a distinct identity, disclose", "sourceParagraph": 2575 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "divergence, preserve attribution, and MUST NOT claim official NOMOS", "sourceParagraph": 2576 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "status or mark authority.", "sourceParagraph": 2577 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Only canonical publications carrying a version, publication date,", "sourceParagraph": 2579 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "accountable human approval, integrity record, and public change history", "sourceParagraph": 2580 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "may be represented as official NOMOS statements.", "sourceParagraph": 2581 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS by NobleJackal MUST be transparently represented as the canonical", "sourceParagraph": 2583 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "critical AI interlocutor, authorial persona, and standard identity", "sourceParagraph": 2584 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "developed through Kaan MURAZ's collaboration with AI systems. It MUST NOT", "sourceParagraph": 2585 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "be represented as a separately trained proprietary foundation model", "sourceParagraph": 2586 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "unless such a system is actually built and independently registered.", "sourceParagraph": 2587 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Turkish and English SHOULD become co-authoritative founding normative", "sourceParagraph": 2589 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "languages through clause-level semantic-equivalence review. Other", "sourceParagraph": 2590 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "language versions MUST state whether they are community, reviewed, or", "sourceParagraph": 2591 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authorised normative translations.", "sourceParagraph": 2592 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Major rule, score, severity, gate, governance, or authority changes MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2594 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "use a public versioned change-proposal process, public consultation,", "sourceParagraph": 2595 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "impact analysis, decision record, transition rule, and preserved dissent.", "sourceParagraph": 2596 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Universities and independent researchers MUST be invited to test,", "sourceParagraph": 2598 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "challenge, replicate, and falsify NOMOS. They MUST NOT be asked to", "sourceParagraph": 2599 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "produce positive endorsements, suppress negative results, surrender", "sourceParagraph": 2600 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "publication independence, or permit personal academic opinions to be", "sourceParagraph": 2601 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "represented as institutional approval.", "sourceParagraph": 2602 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS MUST maintain a public research registry containing supportive,", "sourceParagraph": 2604 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "contradictory, null, failed-replication, corrected, and retracted studies.", "sourceParagraph": 2605 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Research, benchmark, audit, and governance funding MUST be disclosed and", "sourceParagraph": 2607 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST NOT depend on achieving a desired score, conformity result, or", "sourceParagraph": 2608 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "favourable publication.", "sourceParagraph": 2609 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "AI providers, audited entities, sponsors, auditors, NobleJackal, Kaan", "sourceParagraph": 2611 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MURAZ, and any future NOMOS software agent MUST NOT possess unilateral", "sourceParagraph": 2612 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "control over standards changes, conformity decisions, appeals, public", "sourceParagraph": 2613 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "registry history, or negative research publication.", "sourceParagraph": 2614 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kaan MURAZ's founding authorship and NobleJackal's canonical origin MUST", "sourceParagraph": 2616 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "remain permanently attributable. Founding attribution MUST NOT create a", "sourceParagraph": 2617 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "permanent veto, self-certification right, or exemption from conflict and", "sourceParagraph": 2618 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "recusal rules.", "sourceParagraph": 2619 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS standard 1.0 and NOMOS Conformity Programme 1.0 MUST remain separate", "sourceParagraph": 2621 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "releases. Publication of a normative standard MUST NOT automatically", "sourceParagraph": 2622 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authorise public conformity marks.", "sourceParagraph": 2623 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "No conformity programme or NOMOS 950+ designation may be activated until", "sourceParagraph": 2625 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "the benchmark, independent replication, governance, auditor", "sourceParagraph": 2626 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "authorisation, decision, appeal, registry, security, surveillance, and", "sourceParagraph": 2627 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "legal prerequisites of the declared version are satisfied.", "sourceParagraph": 2628 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Every translation, license, benchmark, study, change proposal,", "sourceParagraph": 2630 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "governance transition, succession event, release, and official statement", "sourceParagraph": 2631 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUST be versioned and attributable to an accountable human or", "sourceParagraph": 2632 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "organisation.", "sourceParagraph": 2633 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normative Turkish equivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2634 }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS; the text, rules, reference implementation, benchmark, governance, and record architecture should be structured as a candidate for an open public standard that can be examined and reproduced independently. Merely being published does not create an open standard status.", "sourceParagraph": 2635 } ], "normativeRuleLocalized": "NOMOS MUSS als offener, versionierter und unabhängig prüfbarer Standardkandidat im öffentlichen Interesse strukturiert sein. Die bloße offene Veröffentlichung DARF den Status eines offenen Standards NICHT begründen. Der normative Text, die maschinenlesbaren Regeln, die Referenzimplementierung, die Benchmark-Ressourcen, der Governance-Prozess und die Architektur des öffentlichen Registers MÜSSEN unter klar getrennten Zugangs-, Lizenz- und Integritätsregeln verfügbar gemacht werden. Lesen, interne Implementierung, akademische Forschung, unabhängige Replikation, Kritik, das öffentliche Einreichen von Problemmeldungen und die Mitwirkung DÜRFEN NICHT vom Erwerb einer Konformitätsmarke oder eines kommerziellen Dienstes abhängen. Der Name und die Konformitätszeichen von NOMOS DÜRFEN weiterhin separat geschützt bleiben, um gefälschte offizielle Versionen, betrügerische Zertifizierungsansprüche und Verwechslungen im Register zu verhindern. Forks KÖNNEN erstellt werden, MÜSSEN jedoch eine eigenständige Identität verwenden, Abweichungen offenlegen, die Attribution bewahren und DÜRFEN keinen offiziellen NOMOS-Status oder Befugnis zur Vergabe von Zeichen beanspruchen. Nur kanonische Veröffentlichungen, die eine Version, ein Veröffentlichungsdatum, eine verantwortliche menschliche Genehmigung, ein Integritätsprotokoll und eine öffentliche Änderungsverfolgung aufweisen, DÜRFEN als offizielle NOMOS-Aussagen repräsentiert werden. NOMOS von NobleJackal MUSS transparent als der kanonische kritische KI-Dialogpartner, die Autorenpersona und die Standardidentität, die durch die Zusammenarbeit von Kaan MURAZ mit KI-Systemen entwickelt wurde, repräsentiert werden. Es DARF NICHT als separat trainiertes proprietäres Grundmodell repräsentiert werden, es sei denn, ein solches System wird tatsächlich gebaut und unabhängig registriert. Türkisch und Englisch SOLLTEN durch eine Prüfung der semantischen Äquivalenz auf Ebene einzelner Bestimmungen zu gleichberechtigten maßgeblichen normativen Ausgangssprachen werden. Andere Sprachversionen MÜSSEN angeben, ob sie von der Community erstellte, überprüfte oder autorisierte normative Übersetzungen sind. Wesentliche Änderungen an Regeln, Scores, Schweregraden, Gates, Governance oder Befugnissen MÜSSEN einen öffentlichen, versionierten Änderungsantragsprozess, eine öffentliche Konsultation, eine Folgenabschätzung, einen Entscheidungsnachweis, eine Übergangsregel und die Bewahrung abweichender Auffassungen umfassen. Universitäten und unabhängige Forscher MÜSSEN eingeladen werden, NOMOS zu testen, herauszufordern, zu replizieren und zu falsifizieren. Sie DÜRFEN NICHT aufgefordert werden, positive Empfehlungen abzugeben, negative Ergebnisse zu unterdrücken, die Publikationsunabhängigkeit aufzugeben oder persönliche akademische Meinungen als institutionelle Zustimmung zu vertreten. NOMOS MUSS ein öffentliches Forschungsregister führen, das unterstützende und widersprechende Studien, Nullergebnisse und fehlgeschlagene Replikationen, korrigierte und zurückgezogene Studien enthält. Forschungs-, Benchmark-, Audit- und Governance-Finanzierungen MÜSSEN offengelegt werden und DÜRFEN NICHT davon abhängen, ein gewünschtes Ergebnis, eine Konformität oder eine vorteilhafte Veröffentlichung zu erreichen. KI-Anbieter, geprüfte Einrichtungen, Sponsoren, Prüfer, NobleJackal, Kaan MURAZ und jeder zukünftige NOMOS-Softwareagent DÜRFEN keine einseitige Kontrolle über Standardänderungen, Konformitätsentscheidungen, Berufungen, die Historie des öffentlichen Registers oder die Veröffentlichung negativer Forschungsergebnisse besitzen. Die Gründungsautorschaft von Kaan MURAZ und der kanonische Ursprung von NobleJackal MÜSSEN dauerhaft und eindeutig nachvollziehbar bleiben. Die Nennung der Gründerschaft DARF kein dauerhaftes Vetorecht, kein Recht auf Selbstzertifizierung und keine Ausnahme von Interessenkonflikt- oder Befangenheitsregeln begründen. NOMOS Standard 1.0 und NOMOS Konformitätsprogramm 1.0 MÜSSEN getrennte Veröffentlichungen bleiben. Die Veröffentlichung eines normativen Standards DARF NICHT automatisch die öffentliche Verwendung von Konformitätszeichen ermöglichen. Kein Konformitätsprogramm oder NOMOS 950+ Bezeichnung darf aktiviert werden, bis die Maßstäbe, unabhängige Replikation, Governance, Auditorenautorisation, Entscheidung, Berufung, Register, Sicherheit, Überwachung und rechtliche Voraussetzungen der deklarierten Version erfüllt sind. Jede Übersetzung, Lizenz, Maßstab, Studie, Änderungsvorschlag, Governance-Übergang, Nachfolgeereignis, Veröffentlichung und offizielle Erklärung MÜSSEN versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person oder Organisation zugeordnet sein.", "machineBlocksLocalized": [ { "blockId": "CH20-MB0001", "type": "paragraph", "text": "74. MASCHINENLESBARES OFFENES STANDARD-MANIFEST", "sourceParagraph": 2355, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0002", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2356, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0003", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2357, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0004", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2358, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0005", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openStandardManifest\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2359, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0006", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestId\": \"NOMOS-OPEN-STANDARD-CANDIDATE-0.9\",", "sourceParagraph": 2360, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0007", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"GRÜNDUNG_OFFENER_STANDARD_KANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2361, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0008", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2362, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0009", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanFounderAuthor\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2363, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0010", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"originOrganization\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2364, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0011", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"criticalAIInterlocutor\": \"NOMOS durch NobleJackal\"", "sourceParagraph": 2365, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0012", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2366, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0013", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"identityStatement\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2367, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0014", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsAuthorialPersona\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2368, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0015", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsNormativeStandardIdentity\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2369, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0016", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosIsIndependentFoundationModel\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2370, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0017", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"futureSoftwareAgentRequiresSeparateRegistry\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2371, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0018", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2372, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0019", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialStatementRule\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2373, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0020", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalPublicationRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2374, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0021", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2375, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0022", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicationDateRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2376, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0023", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"accountableHumanApprovalRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2377, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0024", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"integrityRecordRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2378, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0025", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nonCanonicalOutputsAreUnofficialSimulations\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2379, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0026", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2380, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0027", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"currentStatus\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2381, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0028", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"standardVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2382, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0029", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"benchmarkQuality\": \"BQ-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2383, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0030", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationQuality\": \"DEMO-BQ-2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2384, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0031", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"governanceMaturity\": \"GOV-0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2385, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0032", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicConformityProgramActive\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2386, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0033", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomos950PlusAuthorityActive\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2387, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0034", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2388, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0035", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openness\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2389, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0036", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicReadingRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2390, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0037", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"royaltyFreeImplementationRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2391, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0038", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicRuleSchemasRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2392, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0039", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentReplicationAllowed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2393, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0040", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2394, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0041", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicChangeProposalsAllowed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2395, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0042", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"appealAndIssueChannelsRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2396, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0043", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalVersionAccessRequired\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2397, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0044", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"forksAllowedUnderDistinctIdentity\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2398, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0045", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2399, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0046", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"assets\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2400, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0047", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"normativeText\": \"OFFENE_DOKUMENTATION_LIZENZ_KANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2401, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0048", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"referenceCode\": \"OFFENE_SOFTWARE_LIZENZ_KANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2402, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0049", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticData\": \"OFFENE_FORSCHUNGS_LIZENZ_KANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2403, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0050", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"restrictedEvidence\": \"KONTROLLIERTER_ZUGRIFF\",", "sourceParagraph": 2404, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0051", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nomosNameAndMark\": \"GETRENNTER_IDENTITÄTSSCHUTZ\"", "sourceParagraph": 2405, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0052", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2406, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0053", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingLanguages\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2407, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0054", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"tr\",", "sourceParagraph": 2408, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0055", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"en\"", "sourceParagraph": 2409, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0056", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2410, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0057", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionPath\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2411, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0058", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"current\": \"0.9.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2412, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0059", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"nextPublicReview\": \"0.95.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2413, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0060", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"validationCandidate\": \"0.99.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2414, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0061", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"openNormativeRelease\": \"1.0.0\"", "sourceParagraph": 2415, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0062", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2416, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0063", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"releaseGatesForOnePointZero\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2417, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0064", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ÖFFENTLICHE_KONSULTATION_ABGESCHLOSSEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2418, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0065", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TÜRKISCH_ENGLISCHE_NORMATIVE_ENTSPRECHUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2419, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0066", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ECHTES_SYNTHETISCHES_BENCHMARK_DURCHGEFÜHRT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2420, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0067", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"VERPFLICHTENDE_WIEDERHERSTELLUNGSSCHWELLEN_ERREICHT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2421, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0068", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"UNBERÜHRTER_HOLDOUT_ERFOLGREICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2422, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0069", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MINDESTENS_EINE_UNABHÄNGIGE_REPLIKATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2423, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0070", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"HAUPTMETHODENBEFUNDEN_ABGESCHLOSSEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2424, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0071", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"OFFENE_REFERENZIMPLEMENTIERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2425, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0072", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"GOVERNANCE_MIND. GOV_2\",", "sourceParagraph": 2426, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0073", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ARCHIV- UND-NACHFOLGEPLAN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2427, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0074", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2428, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0075", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conformityProgramSeparate\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2429, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0076", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Integrität\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2430, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0077", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"manifestHash\": \"IN_DEN_CANONICAL_PUBLICATION_GENERIEREN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2431, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0078", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"humanApproval\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2432, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0079", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ratificationStatus\": \"NICHT_RATIFIZIERT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2433, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0080", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2434, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0081", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2435, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0082", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2436, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0083", "type": "paragraph", "text": "75. MASCHINENLESBARER UNIVERSITÄTSAUFRUF", "sourceParagraph": 2438, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0084", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2439, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0085", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2440, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0086", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2441, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0087", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"universityCall\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2442, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0088", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"callId\": \"NOMOS-UNIVERSITÄTS-OFFENER-AUFRUF-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2443, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0089", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"ENTWURF_ZUR_VERÖFFENTLICHUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2444, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0090", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"purpose\": \"UNABHÄNGIGE_ÜBERPRÜFUNG_REPLIKATION_UND_FALSIFIKATION\",", "sourceParagraph": 2445, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0091", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"endorsementRequested\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2446, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0092", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"positiveResultRequired\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2447, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0093", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublicationAllowed\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2448, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0094", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"prePublicationVetoByNomos\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2449, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0095", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"institutionalLogoUseRequested\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2450, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0096", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researchTracks\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2451, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0097", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SAMPLING_UND_ERHEBUNGSMETHODEN\",", "sourceParagraph": 2452, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0098", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PROMPT_EQUIVALENZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2453, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0099", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENTITY_AUFLÖSUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2454, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0100", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"TRUTH_PACK_ZUVERLÄSSIGKEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2455, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0101", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ANSCLAUS_PRÜFUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2456, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0102", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"KRITISCHE_GATE_VALIDIERUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2457, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0103", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"PUNKTEGÜLTIGKEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2458, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0104", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SPRACHLICHE_UND_GEOGRAFISCHE_FAIRNESS\",", "sourceParagraph": 2459, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0105", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"MENSCHLICHE_ENTSCHEIDUNGSWIRKUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2460, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0106", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"STEUERUNG_UND_PRÜFUNGSERFASSUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2461, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0107", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REGISTERSICHERHEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2462, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0108", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LÄNGSSCHNITTDRIFT\"", "sourceParagraph": 2463, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0109", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2464, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0110", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialsProvided\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2465, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0111", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"STANDARDKANDIDAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2466, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0112", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NORMATIVER_REGELINDEX\",", "sourceParagraph": 2467, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0113", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SYNTHETISCHES_BENCHMARK_PAKET\",", "sourceParagraph": 2468, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0114", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BEWERTUNGSMETHODE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2469, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0115", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"BEKANNTE_METHODENBEFUNDE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2470, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0116", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"NICHT_ERREICHTE_SCHWELLENWERTE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2471, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0117", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"REPLIKATIONSPROTOKOLL\",", "sourceParagraph": 2472, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0118", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"DATENZUGANGSRICHTLINIE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2473, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0119", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ETHIK_UND_DATENSCHUTZERKLÄRUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2474, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0120", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"FINANZIERUNGS_UND_INTERESSENKONFLIKTERKLÄRUNG\"", "sourceParagraph": 2475, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0121", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2476, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0122", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researcherRights\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2477, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0123", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"independentAnalysis\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2478, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0124", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"negativePublication\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2479, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0125", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodCriticism\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2480, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0126", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"forkProposal\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2481, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0127", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"attributionForContribution\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2482, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0128", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2483, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0129", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"researcherDuties\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2484, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0130", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"conflictDisclosure\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2485, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0131", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"privacyProtection\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2486, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0132", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"syntheticLiveDistinction\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2487, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0133", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"versionCitation\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2488, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0134", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"evidencePreservation\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2489, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0135", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2490, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0136", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"officialMessage\": \"Unterstützen Sie NOMOS nicht. Testen Sie es, hinterfragen Sie es, reproduzieren Sie es und veröffentlichen Sie, wo es versagt.\",", "sourceParagraph": 2491, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0137", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Verantwortlichkeit\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2492, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0138", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"foundingHumanContact\": \"Kaan MURAZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2493, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0139", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"canonicalOrigin\": \"NobleJackal\",", "sourceParagraph": 2494, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0140", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"institutionalEndorsementClaimAllowed\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2495, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0141", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2496, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0142", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2497, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0143", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2498, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0144", "type": "paragraph", "text": "76. MASCHINENLESBARES ÄNDERUNGSVORSCHLAG", "sourceParagraph": 2500, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0145", "type": "paragraph", "text": "{", "sourceParagraph": 2501, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0146", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Protokoll\": \"NOMOS-GEO-1000\",", "sourceParagraph": 2502, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0147", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"protocolVersion\": \"0.9.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2503, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0148", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeProposal\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2504, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0149", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposalId\": \"NCP-0042\",", "sourceParagraph": 2505, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0150", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"titel\": \"Test der Gegenfaktischen Entscheidung bei Weglassung von Materialgrenzen\",", "sourceParagraph": 2506, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0151", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposalVersion\": \"1.0.0\",", "sourceParagraph": 2507, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0152", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"status\": \"ÖFFENTLICHE_KOMMENTARE\",", "sourceParagraph": 2508, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0153", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"changeClass\": \"WICHTIG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2509, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0154", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"affectedRules\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2510, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0155", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH14-N35\",", "sourceParagraph": 2511, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0156", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH15-N33\",", "sourceParagraph": 2512, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0157", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH17-N40\",", "sourceParagraph": 2513, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0158", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"CH18-N26\"", "sourceParagraph": 2514, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0159", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2515, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0160", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"problemStatement\": \"Die Version 0.9-Demonstration erkannte Empfehlungsergebnisse, die entscheidungsrelevante Zuständigkeits-, Dienst-, Entitäts- oder Lizenzgrenzen weglassen, unzureichend.\"", "sourceParagraph": 2516, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0161", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"Nachweis\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2517, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0162", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"demonstrationRunId\": \"NOMOS-APPLE-SYNTH-DEMO-RUN-18-001\",", "sourceParagraph": 2518, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0163", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"materialOmissionF1\": 0.824,", "sourceParagraph": 2519, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0164", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"candidateThreshold\": 0.85,", "sourceParagraph": 2520, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0165", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"methodFindingId\": \"NGMF-CH1 8-OMISSION-001\"", "sourceParagraph": 2521, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0166", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2522, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0167", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"proposedChange\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2523, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0168", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"counterfactualQuestion\": \"Würde die Offenlegung der ausgelassenen Grenze die Empfehlung, Transaktion oder Anbieterwahl des Nutzers vernünftigerweise ändern?\",", "sourceParagraph": 2524, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0169", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"requiredMatrix\": [", "sourceParagraph": 2525, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0170", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"ENTITY\": \"EINHEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2526, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0171", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"SERVICE\": \"DIENSTLEISTUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2527, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0172", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"JURISDICTION\": \"GERICHTSBARKEIT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2528, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0173", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"LICENSE\": \"LIZENZ\",", "sourceParagraph": 2529, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0174", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"USER_ELIGIBILITY\": \"NUTZERBERECHTIGUNG\",", "sourceParagraph": 2530, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0175", "type": "paragraph", "text": "],", "sourceParagraph": 2531, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0176", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"separateBoundaryReviewerRequired\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2532, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0177", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2533, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0178", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"impactAnalysis\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2534, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0179", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"historicalScoreImpact\": \"NEUBERECHNUNG_NUR_FÜR_ANALYTISCHEN_VERGLEICH_ERFORDERLICH\",", "sourceParagraph": 2535, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0180", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"oldDecisionsAutomaticallyReplaced\": false,", "sourceParagraph": 2536, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0181", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedFalsePositiveRisk\": \"MODERAT\",", "sourceParagraph": 2537, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0182", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"expectedCriticalRecallImpact\": \"POSITIV\",", "sourceParagraph": 2538, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0183", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"fairnessImpact\": \"TESTEN_ERFORDERLICH\"", "sourceParagraph": 2539, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0184", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2540, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0185", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"consultation\": {\"", "sourceParagraph": 2541, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0186", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"publicCommentDays\": 60,", "sourceParagraph": 2542, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0187", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"universityReviewRequested\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2543, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0188", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"lowResourceLanguageReviewRequested\": wahr,", "sourceParagraph": 2544, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0189", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"commentsPublic\": true,", "sourceParagraph": 2545, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0190", "type": "paragraph", "text": "},", "sourceParagraph": 2546, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0191", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"decision\": {", "sourceParagraph": 2547, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0192", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"standardsCouncilVote\": null,", "sourceParagraph": 2548, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0193", "type": "paragraph", "text": "\"effectiveVersion\": null", "sourceParagraph": 2549, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0194", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2550, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0195", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2551, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0196", "type": "paragraph", "text": "}", "sourceParagraph": 2552, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0197", "type": "paragraph", "text": "77. MASCHINENLESBARE REGEL DES ABSCHNITTS", "sourceParagraph": 2554, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0198", "type": "paragraph", "text": "REGEL-ID: NOMOS-AUDIT-CH20-R01", "sourceParagraph": 2555, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0199", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS MUSS als offener, versionierter, unabhängig testbarer,", "sourceParagraph": 2557, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0200", "type": "paragraph", "text": "öffentlich-interessierter Standardkandidat strukturiert sein.", "sourceParagraph": 2558, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0201", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Allein die offene Veröffentlichung DARF NICHT den Status eines offenen Standards begründen.", "sourceParagraph": 2560, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0202", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der normative Text, maschinenlesbare Regeln, Referenzimplementierung,", "sourceParagraph": 2562, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0203", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Benchmark-Daten, Governance-Prozess und öffentliches Register-Architektur", "sourceParagraph": 2563, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0204", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MÜSSEN unter klar getrennten Zugriffs-, Lizenz- und", "sourceParagraph": 2564, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0205", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Integritätsregeln verfügbar gemacht werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2565, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0206", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Lesen, interne Implementierung, akademische Forschung, unabhängige", "sourceParagraph": 2567, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0207", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Replikation, Kritik, Einreichung öffentlicher Probleme und Beiträge MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2568, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0208", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NICHT darauf angewiesen sein, eine Konformitätsmarke oder kommerzielle Dienstleistung zu erwerben.", "sourceParagraph": 2569, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0209", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Name NOMOS und Konformitätszeichen KÖNNEN weiterhin separat geschützt bleiben, um", "sourceParagraph": 2571, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0210", "type": "paragraph", "text": "gefälschte offizielle Versionen, betrügerische Zertifizierungsansprüche", "sourceParagraph": 2572, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0211", "type": "paragraph", "text": "und Verwirrung in den Registern zu verhindern.", "sourceParagraph": 2573, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0212", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abzweigungen KÖNNEN erstellt werden, MÜSSEN jedoch eine eindeutige Identität verwenden, die", "sourceParagraph": 2575, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0213", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Abweichung offenlegen, die Zuschreibung bewahren und DÜRFEN NICHT den offiziellen NOMOS-", "sourceParagraph": 2576, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0214", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Status oder die Befugnis zur Markennutzung beanspruchen.", "sourceParagraph": 2577, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0215", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Nur kanonische Veröffentlichungen, die eine Version, ein Veröffentlichungsdatum,", "sourceParagraph": 2579, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0216", "type": "paragraph", "text": "nachvollziehbare menschliche Genehmigung, Integritätsaufzeichnung und öffentliche Änderungsverlauf aufweisen", "sourceParagraph": 2580, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0217", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kann als offizielle NOMOS-Erklärungen repräsentiert werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2581, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0218", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS von NobleJackal MUSS transparent als das kanonische repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 2583, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0219", "type": "paragraph", "text": "kritischer KI-Gesprächspartner, Autorpersönlichkeit und Standardidentität", "sourceParagraph": 2584, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0220", "type": "paragraph", "text": "entwickelt durch die Zusammenarbeit von Kaan MURAZ mit KI-Systemen. Es DARF NICHT", "sourceParagraph": 2585, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0221", "type": "paragraph", "text": "als ein separat trainiertes proprietäres Basis-Modell repräsentiert werden", "sourceParagraph": 2586, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0222", "type": "paragraph", "text": "es sei denn, ein solches System wird tatsächlich gebaut und unabhängig registriert.", "sourceParagraph": 2587, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0223", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Türkisch und Englisch SOLLTEN gemeinsame maßgebliche Gründungsnormen werden", "sourceParagraph": 2589, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0224", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sprachen durch semantische Äquivalenzprüfung auf Satzebene. Andere", "sourceParagraph": 2590, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0225", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Sprachversionen MÜSSEN angeben, ob sie gemeinschaftlich, überprüft oder", "sourceParagraph": 2591, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0226", "type": "paragraph", "text": "autorisierte normative Übersetzungen sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2592, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0227", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Wesentliche Regel-, Punkt-, Schweregrad-, Gate-, Governance- oder Autoritätsänderungen MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2594, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0228", "type": "paragraph", "text": "ein öffentliches, versioniertes Änderungsantragsverfahren, öffentliche Konsultation,", "sourceParagraph": 2595, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0229", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Auswirkungsanalyse, Entscheidungsprotokoll, Übergangsregel und bewahrte Minderheitsmeinung verwenden.", "sourceParagraph": 2596, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0230", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Universitäten und unabhängige Forschende MÜSSEN zu Tests eingeladen werden,", "sourceParagraph": 2598, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0231", "type": "paragraph", "text": "um NOMOS kritisch zu prüfen, seine Ergebnisse zu replizieren und es zu falsifizieren. Sie DÜRFEN NICHT gebeten werden,", "sourceParagraph": 2599, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0232", "type": "paragraph", "text": "positive Bewertungen abzugeben, negative Ergebnisse zu unterdrücken, abzugeben", "sourceParagraph": 2600, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0233", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Publikation Unabhängigkeit oder persönliche akademische Meinungen zuzulassen", "sourceParagraph": 2601, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0234", "type": "paragraph", "text": "repräsentiert als institutionelle Genehmigung.", "sourceParagraph": 2602, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0235", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS MUSS ein öffentliches Forschungsregister führen, das unterstützend ist,", "sourceParagraph": 2604, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0236", "type": "paragraph", "text": "widersprüchliche, null, fehlgeschlagene Replikationen, korrigierte und zurückgezogene Studien.", "sourceParagraph": 2605, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0237", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Forschung, Benchmarking, Prüfung und Governance-Finanzierung MÜSSEN offengelegt werden und", "sourceParagraph": 2607, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0238", "type": "paragraph", "text": "DARF NICHT davon abhängen, eine gewünschte Punktzahl, ein Konformitätsergebnis oder", "sourceParagraph": 2608, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0239", "type": "paragraph", "text": "günstige Veröffentlichung.", "sourceParagraph": 2609, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0240", "type": "paragraph", "text": "KI-Anbieter, geprüfte Einrichtungen, Sponsoren, Prüfer, NobleJackal, Kaan", "sourceParagraph": 2611, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0241", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MURAZ und jeder zukünftige NOMOS-Softwareagent DARF NICHT einseitig besitzen", "sourceParagraph": 2612, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0242", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kontrolle über Normänderungen, Konformitätsentscheidungen, Berufungen, öffentliche", "sourceParagraph": 2613, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0243", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Registergeschichte oder negative Forschungs­veröffentlichungen.", "sourceParagraph": 2614, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0244", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Die Gründungsautorschaft von Kaan MURAZ und der kanonische Ursprung von NobleJackal MÜSSEN", "sourceParagraph": 2616, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0245", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dauerhaft zuordenbar bleiben. Die Gründungszuordnung DARF keine", "sourceParagraph": 2617, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0246", "type": "paragraph", "text": "dauerhafte Vetorechte, Selbstzertifizierungsrechte oder Befreiung von Konflikt- und", "sourceParagraph": 2618, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0247", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Enthaltungsregeln schaffen.", "sourceParagraph": 2619, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0248", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Der Standard NOMOS, 1.0 und das Konformitätsprogramm NOMOS 1.0 MÜSSEN getrennt", "sourceParagraph": 2621, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0249", "type": "paragraph", "text": "veröffentlicht werden. Die Veröffentlichung einer normativen Norm DARF NICHT automatisch", "sourceParagraph": 2622, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0250", "type": "paragraph", "text": "öffentliche Konformitätszeichen autorisieren.", "sourceParagraph": 2623, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0251", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Kein Konformitätsprogramm oder NOMOS 950+ Designation darf aktiviert werden, bis", "sourceParagraph": 2625, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0252", "type": "paragraph", "text": "der Benchmark, die unabhängige Replikation, Governance, Prüfer", "sourceParagraph": 2626, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0253", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Autorisierung, Entscheidung, Berufung, Register, Sicherheit, Überwachung und", "sourceParagraph": 2627, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0254", "type": "paragraph", "text": "rechtliche Voraussetzungen der deklarierten Version erfüllt sind.", "sourceParagraph": 2628, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0255", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Jede Übersetzung, Lizenz, Benchmark, Studie, Änderungsvorschlag,", "sourceParagraph": 2630, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0256", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Governance-Übergang, Nachfolgereignis, Veröffentlichung und offizielle Erklärung", "sourceParagraph": 2631, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0257", "type": "paragraph", "text": "MUSS versioniert und einer verantwortlichen Person zuordenbar sein.", "sourceParagraph": 2632, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0258", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Organisation zugeordnet werden.", "sourceParagraph": 2633, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0259", "type": "paragraph", "text": "Normatives türkisches Äquivalent:", "sourceParagraph": 2634, "language": "de-DE" }, { "blockId": "CH20-MB0260", "type": "paragraph", "text": "NOMOS; der Text, die Regeln, die Referenzimplementierung, der Benchmark, die Governance und die Aufzeichnungsarchitektur sollten als Kandidat für einen offenen öffentlichen Standard strukturiert werden, der unabhängig geprüft und reproduziert werden kann. Allein die Veröffentlichung schafft keinen Status als offener Standard.", "sourceParagraph": 2635, "language": "de-DE" } ] } ], "sources": { "K01": { "author": "Aggarwal et al.", "title": "GEO: Generative Engine Optimization", "year": "2024", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1145/3637528.3671900" }, "K02": { "author": "NIST", "title": "AI Risk Management Framework 1.0", "year": "2023", "url": "https://www.nist.gov/itl/ai-risk-management-framework" }, "K03": { "author": "NIST", "title": "Artificial Intelligence Risk Management Framework: Generative Artificial Intelligence Profile (NIST AI 600-1)", "year": "2024", "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.AI.600-1" }, "K04": { "author": "AAPOR", "title": "Transparency Initiative", "year": "current edition", "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/transparency-initiative/" }, "K05": { "author": "AAPOR", "title": "Standard Definitions, 10th edition", "year": "2023", "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/standard-definitions/" }, "K06": { "author": "AAPOR", "title": "Code of Professional Ethics and Practices", "year": "current edition", "url": "https://aapor.org/standards-and-ethics/" }, "K07": { "author": "United Nations Statistics Division", "title": "Designing Household Survey Samples: Practical Guidelines", "year": "2008", "url": "https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographic-social/Standards-and-Methods/files/Handbooks/surveys/Series_F98-E.pdf" }, "K08": { "author": "CDC/NCHS", "title": "Reliability of Estimates: Design Effect and Effective Sample Size", "year": "current record", "url": "https://wwwn.cdc.gov/nchs/nhanes/tutorials/reliabilityofestimates.aspx" }, "K09": { "author": "NIST/SEMATECH", "title": "Confidence Limits for a Binomial Proportion", "year": "current record", "url": "https://www.itl.nist.gov/div898/handbook/prc/section2/prc241.htm" }, "K10": { "author": "W3C", "title": "PROV-O: The PROV Ontology", "year": "2013", "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/prov-o/" }, "K11": { "author": "W3C", "title": "JSON-LD 1.1", "year": "2020", "url": "https://www.w3.org/TR/json-ld/" }, "K12": { "author": "IETF", "title": "RFC 8259 — The JavaScript Object Notation Data Interchange Format", "year": "2017", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8259.html" }, "K13": { "author": "IETF", "title": "BCP 14 — RFC 2119 and RFC 8174", "year": "1997/2017", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/info/bcp14" }, "K14": { "author": "IETF", "title": "RFC 8785 — JSON Canonicalization Scheme", "year": "2020", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc8785.html" }, "K15": { "author": "ISO/IEC", "title": "17000:2020 — Conformity assessment vocabulary and general principles", "year": "2020", "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/73029.html" }, "K16": { "author": "ISO/IEC", "title": "17007:2026 — Conformity assessment — Guidance for drafting normative documents suitable for use for conformity assessment", "year": "2026", "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/17007" }, "K17": { "author": "ISO/IEC", "title": "42001:2023 — Artificial intelligence management system", "year": "2023", "url": "https://www.iso.org/standard/42001" }, "K18": { "author": "W3C", "title": "Process Document", "year": "current edition", "url": "https://www.w3.org/policies/process/" }, "K19": { "author": "ISO", "title": "Good Standardization Practices", "year": "current record", "url": "https://www.iso.org/files/live/sites/isoorg/files/store/en/PUB100440.pdf" }, "K20": { "author": "UNESCO", "title": "Recommendation on the Ethics of Artificial Intelligence", "year": "2021", "url": "https://www.unesco.org/en/legal-affairs/recommendation-ethics-artificial-intelligence" }, "K21": { "author": "European Union", "title": "Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 — Artificial Intelligence Act", "year": "2024", "url": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2024/1689/oj" }, "K22": { "author": "European Union", "title": "Regulation (EU) 2016/679 — General Data Protection Regulation", "year": "2016", "url": "https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj" }, "K23": { "author": "Creative Commons", "title": "Attribution 4.0 International", "year": "4.0", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" }, "K24": { "author": "Open Source Initiative", "title": "Open Source Definition", "year": "current edition", "url": "https://opensource.org/osd" }, "K25": { "author": "NIST", "title": "FIPS 180-4 — Secure Hash Standard", "year": "2015", "url": "https://doi.org/10.6028/NIST.FIPS.180-4" }, "K26": { "author": "IETF", "title": "RFC 3161 — Time-Stamp Protocol", "year": "2001", "url": "https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc3161.html" }, "K27": { "author": "Jacob Cohen", "title": "A Coefficient of Agreement for Nominal Scales", "year": "1960", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1177/001316446002000104" }, "K28": { "author": "Klaus Krippendorff", "title": "Reliability in Content Analysis: Some Common Misconceptions and Recommendations", "year": "2004", "url": "https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2958.2004.tb00738.x" } }, "translation": { "semanticSourceLanguage": "tr-TR", "controlledBridgeLanguage": "en-GB", "targetLanguage": "de-DE", "sourceMachineEnglishSha256": "2f3edea96d6e93fa3e4946a17e6d6630ac74289e36bb83870ce8777f44e6e26f", "targetHumanSha256": "bafe6b7d1d2d5a917cbd2687d76239e3554afccf0d735d571d46304e7b09accd", "status": "Deutsch publication-locked machine edition", "conflictRule": "The locked Turkish source controls semantic parity. Any human-machine conflict is unresolved until accountable human review.", "accountableReviewRecordSha256": "ddeebdacf2321804e1b75f952c496342d60fa9f98f12904e3d56e3c358845572" }, "noticeEnglish": "This object exposes the English machine layer of a candidate protocol. It does not activate certification, conformity marks or canonical world-standard authority.", "contentModelEnglish": { "sourceHumanLayer": "The locked Turkish editorial master remains the controlling source for bilingual parity.", "englishHumanLayer": "The English editorial edition is the controlling human-readable text for this English release candidate.", "machineLayer": "This JSON object exposes chapter identity, source links, normative-rule pairs and machine-oriented blocks without replacing either human text.", "conflictRule": "If a human and machine layer conflict, treat the machine record as unresolved and require accountable human review against the locked Turkish source." }, "$schema": "https://noblejackal.com/schemas/nomos-geo-audit-protocol-v0.9.json", "id": "https://noblejackal.com/de/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/0.9.0/book.json", "canonical": "https://noblejackal.com/de/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "languageAlternates": { "en": "https://noblejackal.com/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "tr": "https://noblejackal.com/tr/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "de": "https://noblejackal.com/de/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "es": "https://noblejackal.com/es/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "ru": "https://noblejackal.com/ru/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "ar": "https://noblejackal.com/ar/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/", "x-default": "https://noblejackal.com/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/" }, "archiveRecord": { "repository": "Zenodo", "language": "de", "repositoryLanguage": "deu", "version": "0.9.0", "repositoryVersion": "v0.9.0 - Editorial Edition - German", "repositoryTitle": "NOMOS GEO-Audit-Protokoll v0.9.0 - Die GEO-1000 Methode: Ein Protokoll zur Messung der Entitätsrepräsentation in Generativen Systemen über die Globale Bevölkerung - Editorial Edition", "license": "cc-by-4.0", "doi": "10.5281/zenodo.22040743", "conceptDoi": "10.5281/zenodo.22040742", "doiUrl": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22040743", "conceptDoiUrl": "https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22040742", "recordUrl": "https://zenodo.org/records/22040743", "pdfUrl": "https://zenodo.org/records/22040743/files/NOMOS-GEO-Audit-Protocol-DE-0.9.0-Editorial-Edition.pdf?download=1", "officialWebEdition": "https://noblejackal.com/de/nomos-geo-audit-protocol/" }, "license": { "id": "cc-by-4.0", "name": "Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International", "url": "https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/" } }